Tax Treatment of Dealer Benefits Under Section 194R & Income Tax Act 2025

Tax Treatment of Dealer Scheme Benefits: Comprehensive Analysis under Section 194R of Income Tax Act and Section 393 Table 8(iv) Income Tax Act, 2025

1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

With the enactment of the Income Tax Act, 2025, significant structural changes have been introduced in the taxation framework, particularly affecting TDS provisions. This article provides a comprehensive analysis of the tax treatment of benefits and perquisites received by proprietorship firms under the dealer scheme, focusing on the practical application of the provisions formerly known as Section 194R (now consolidated under Section 393 of the Income Tax Act, 2025).

1.1 Scenario Under Analysis

A proprietorship firm received a dealer scheme tour package valued at ₹1,50,000 from a company. The company deducted and deposited TDS of ₹15,000 under Section 194R (now Section 393). Critically, the TDS amount was not recovered from the proprietor – it was borne entirely by the company.

2. INCOME TAX ACT, 2025: KEY STRUCTURAL CHANGES

The Income Tax Act, 2025, which came into effect from April 1, 2026, has fundamentally restructured the TDS framework while maintaining the underlying tax policy. Understanding these changes is crucial for compliance.

2.1 Consolidation of TDS Provisions

The erstwhile Section 194R (TDS on benefits or perquisites) has been consolidated under Section 393 of the Income Tax Act, 2025. All TDS provisions from Sections 193 to 196D of the 1961 Act have been reorganized into three parent sections:

• Section 392: TDS on salary payments
• Section 393: TDS on all non-salary payments to residents and non-residents (including benefits/perquisites)
• Section 394: All TCS (Tax Collected at Source) provisions

2.2 Terminology Changes

The concept of ‘Assessment Year’ has been discontinued. Income earned during FY 2026-27 (now termed Tax Year 2026-27) will be assessed in TY 2027-28. The term ‘Tax Year’ replaces ‘Previous Year’ from the 1961 Act.

2.3 Form Number Changes

Critical form number changes effective from April 1, 2026:

• Form 16 → Form 130 (Annual TDS certificate for salary)
• Form 16A → Form 131 (TDS certificate for non-salary)
• Form 26Q → Remains Form 26Q (Quarterly TDS return)
• Form 3CD (Tax Audit Report) → Form 26

2.4 Binding Nature of CBDT Guidelines

Section 400(2) of the Income Tax Act, 2025, explicitly restores and makes binding the CBDT guidelines on all deductors. From April 1, 2026, CBDT circulars on TDS matters, including those on perquisites (erstwhile Section 194R), carry mandatory compliance weight. The argument that CBDT circulars are merely advisory no longer holds.

3. TAXABILITY ANALYSIS

3.1 Taxability under Section 28(iv) (erstwhile Section 26)

Section 28(iv) of the Income Tax Act provides that the value of any benefit or perquisite, whether convertible into money or not, arising from business or the exercise of a profession, shall be chargeable to income tax under the head ‘Profits and Gains of Business or Profession’.

In the present case:

• The tour package worth ₹1,50,000 is clearly a benefit arising from the business relationship between the proprietorship and the company
• This benefit is provided as an incentive under the dealer scheme, making it taxable under Section 28(iv)
• The entire value of ₹1,50,000 must be included in the business income of the proprietorship firm

3.2 TDS under Section 393 (erstwhile Section 194R)

Section 393 of the Income Tax Act, 2025 (consolidating the erstwhile Section 194R), mandates:

• TDS Rate: 10% of the value of benefit/perquisite
• Threshold: ₹20,000 per recipient per financial year
• Applicability: Benefits provided to residents in connection with business or profession
• Timing: TDS must be deducted before providing the benefit

The company correctly deducted ₹15,000 (10% of ₹1,50,000) as TDS. However, a critical question arises regarding the treatment when TDS is not recovered from the recipient.

4. GROSSING UP REQUIREMENT: DETAILED ANALYSIS

4.1 The Grossing Up Principle

According to CBDT Circular No. 12/2022 dated June 16, 2022 (which continues to be binding under Section 400(2) of the Income Tax Act, 2025), when the benefit provider bears the TDS cost, the TDS amount itself is considered an additional benefit to the recipient.

Rationale: If the company pays TDS of ₹15,000 on behalf of the proprietor without recovery, the proprietor saves this amount. This saving is itself a benefit that should have been subjected to TDS.

4.2 Grossing Up Calculation

When TDS is borne by the payer, the correct approach is to gross up:

Formula: Grossed-up Value = Benefit Value / (1 – TDS Rate) Grossed-up Value = ₹1,50,000 / (1 – 0.10) Grossed-up Value = ₹1,50,000 / 0.90 Grossed-up Value = ₹1,66,667

Therefore: • Total Benefit Value (including TDS borne): ₹1,66,667 • TDS @ 10%: ₹16,667 • Net Benefit Received: ₹1,50,000

4.3 Impact on Taxable Income

The proprietorship must recognize as business income:

• Tour package value: ₹1,50,000
• TDS borne by company (additional benefit): ₹15,000
• Total Taxable Benefit: ₹1,65,000

Note: While theoretically the grossed-up amount should be ₹1,66,667, in practice, for the TDS already deducted at ₹15,000, the total taxable benefit is recognized as ₹1,65,000 (₹1,50,000 + ₹15,000). This approach is administratively simpler and is accepted in practice.

5. ACCOUNTING TREATMENT IN PROPRIETORSHIP BOOKS

5.1 Journal Entries

Entry 1: At the time of receiving the tour package benefit

(Being tour package benefit received from XYZ Company Ltd. under dealer scheme)

Entry 2: Recording TDS borne by company (additional benefit)

(Being TDS borne by XYZ Company Ltd. on behalf of proprietorship – treated as additional benefit)

5.2 Ledger Accounts Summary

After posting the above entries:

• Dealer Benefit / Perquisite Income A/c: ₹1,65,000 (Credit) – This will be included in business income
• Tour Expenses A/c: ₹1,50,000 (Debit) – This may be claimed as business expense if tour is business-related
• TDS Receivable A/c: ₹15,000 (Debit) – To be claimed as tax credit in ITR

6. INCOME TAX RETURN DISCLOSURE

6.1 Applicable ITR Form

For a proprietorship firm, ITR-3 (For individuals and HUFs having income from profits and gains of business or profession) or ITR-4 (For individuals, HUFs and Firms being a partner of a firm having presumptive income) should be filed, depending on the nature of business and whether presumptive taxation scheme is opted.

6.2 Disclosure of Benefit as Income

Under ‘Profits and Gains of Business or Profession’ (Schedule BP):

• Gross Receipts / Turnover: Include ₹1,65,000 as part of business receipts
• Alternatively, disclose under ‘Any other income’ within business income schedule with proper description: ‘Dealer scheme benefit/perquisite received – ₹1,65,000’

6.3 Claiming TDS Credit

In the TDS schedule of ITR (Schedule TDS):

• Enter details from Form 26AS / Annual Information Statement (AIS)
• TAN of deductor: [Company’s TAN]
• Name of deductor: XYZ Company Ltd.
• Section under which TDS deducted: 393 (erstwhile 194R)
• TDS amount: ₹15,000
• Note: Verify from Form 26AS that TDS has been correctly deposited by the company

6.4 Expense Deduction (If Applicable)

If the tour was undertaken for business purposes (attending trade fairs, dealer meets, business conferences), the ₹1,50,000 may be claimed as a legitimate business expense. However, if the tour was purely recreational, the deduction may be disallowed under Section 37 (business expenditure not wholly and exclusively for business).

7. GST IMPLICATIONS

7.1 GST Applicability on Dealer Incentives

Under GST law, when a manufacturer/company provides benefits or perquisites to its dealers/distributors as incentives for achieving sales targets, it may constitute a ‘supply of service’ under Section 7 of the CGST Act, 2017.

7.2 Reverse Charge Mechanism

Analysis from GST perspective:

• The dealer is considered to be providing a service to the company (agreeing to do an act – achieving sales targets)
• In return, the company provides the tour package as consideration
• Valuation: As per Rule 27 of CGST Rules, the value shall be the open market value of ₹1,50,000
• GST Rate: 18% (standard rate for services)

7.3 Who Pays GST?

Since the dealer (proprietorship) is the supplier of service, the dealer is liable to pay GST on ₹1,50,000. However, there are practical challenges:

• The ₹1,50,000 value may be considered as ‘inclusive of GST’
• Reverse calculation: Value = ₹1,50,000 / 1.18 = ₹1,27,119
• GST @ 18%: ₹22,881

7.4 Input Tax Credit (ITC) Availability

If the dealer issues a proper GST invoice to the company:

• The company can claim ITC of ₹22,881 if the service is in the course of business and not blocked under Section 17(5) of CGST Act
• The twin conditions (i) in the course or furtherance of business, and (ii) no blockage under Section 17(5)) must be satisfied

7.5 Practical Recommendation

Given the complexity and lack of clear judicial guidance, it is advisable to:

1. Obtain clarification from the GST department or seek an advance ruling

2. Maintain proper documentation showing the business relationship and sales achievement

3. Issue a proper GST invoice if GST is determined to be applicable, clearly mentioning the nature of supply

8. ICAI GUIDANCE AND JUDICIAL PRECEDENTS

8.1 ICAI Treatise on Section 194R

The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) has published a comprehensive ‘Treatise on Section 194-R under the Income-tax Act, 1961’ in February 2023. This publication provides detailed guidance on:

• Identification of benefits and perquisites covered under Section 194R
• Valuation methodology for non-monetary benefits
• Practical compliance aspects and reporting requirements
• Grossing up mechanism when TDS is borne by the payer

8.2 CBDT Circular No. 12/2022

CBDT Circular No. 12 of 2022 dated June 16, 2022, provides clarifications on several critical aspects:

• The deductor is not required to check whether the benefit is taxable in the hands of the recipient
• Section 194R applies to benefits in cash, kind, or partly in both
• Sales discounts, cash discounts, and rebates are excluded from Section 194R
• When the benefit provider deducts and pays TDS, the tax amount should be computed after grossing up, as the TDS itself is considered a benefit
• Valuation: Purchase price if purchased by provider; selling price to customers if manufactured by provider

8.3 Key Judicial Principles (Pre-Section 194R)

While specific case law on Section 194R (introduced in 2022) is still evolving, established principles from earlier cases on perquisite taxation include:

• Benefits arising from business relationships are taxable under Section 28(iv)
• Monetary value can be assigned to non-monetary benefits based on market value
• TDS paid by the payer on behalf of the payee constitutes additional income to the payee

9. TAX TREATMENT SUMMARY TABLE

10. PRACTICAL COMPLIANCE TIPS

10.1 Documentation Requirements

1. Maintain copy of dealer scheme agreement or circular

2. Obtain TDS certificate (Form 131, erstwhile Form 16A) from the company

3. Verify TDS credit in Form 26AS / Annual Information Statement (AIS)

4. Keep invoice/receipt for the tour package showing value of ₹1,50,000

5. Document the sales achievement that qualified for the dealer scheme benefit

10.2 Reconciliation Checklist

1. Match TDS amount in books (₹15,000) with Form 26AS entry

2. Ensure benefit income (₹1,65,000) is included in total business income

3. Verify that TDS credit is correctly claimed in ITR computation

10.3 Common Pitfalls to Avoid

• Do NOT ignore the ₹15,000 TDS borne by company – this is additional taxable income
• Do NOT claim TDS credit without including corresponding income
• Do NOT treat the benefit as exempt or outside the scope of taxation
• Do NOT forget to assess potential GST liability and ITC implications

10.4 Year-End Compliance Actions

1. Review all dealer benefits received during the year

2. Ensure all benefits exceeding ₹20,000 threshold have proper TDS certificates

3. Include all benefits and TDS borne amounts in tax computation

4. File ITR before due date to avoid interest under Section 234A

11. CONCLUSION

The taxation of dealer scheme benefits under Section 393 of the Income Tax Act, 2025 (erstwhile Section 194R) requires careful analysis, particularly when TDS is borne by the payer. The grossing up mechanism ensures that the tax benefit received by the proprietorship is also brought to tax, maintaining equity in the tax system.

Key takeaways:

1. Total taxable benefit: ₹1,65,000 (₹1,50,000 tour + ₹15,000 TDS borne)

2. TDS credit available: ₹15,000

3. Proper accounting entries are essential for accurate ITR filing

4. GST implications require separate evaluation based on facts

5. CBDT guidelines and ICAI guidance provide authoritative framework for compliance

With the binding nature of CBDT guidelines under Section 400(2) of the Income Tax Act, 2025, taxpayers must ensure strict compliance with the grossing up methodology and reporting requirements. Professional advice should be sought in complex scenarios involving multiple benefits or cross-border transactions.

*****

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute professional tax or legal advice. Readers should consult qualified professionals for their specific circumstances. The provisions discussed are based on the Income Tax Act, 2025, and applicable circulars/guidelines as of the date of publication. Tax laws are subject to amendments and judicial interpretations.