Introduction
The indirect tax regime in India, changed after July 1, 2017 with the introduction of Goods and Services Tax (GST), which subsumed multiple taxes at both state and central level into a single system. The education sector, which is talismanic for national development and future prospects of a society stands to be affected drastically because this reform religiously cultivates mediocrity by taking away merit. The GST regime provides special exemptions for educational services by way of making it exempt or nil rated to ensure that the education remains affordable though certain compliance requirements are imposed under GST rules.
The effects of GST on the education sector are far-reaching and this post looks into all that it entails for educational institutions, students, as well as government officials. Educational Institutions must understand these features to allow a hassle-free operation in the GST framework.
Educational Landscape Before GST
To have a complete picture of the broad-based impacts that GST will bring to educational sector, one must first of all reflect on how this unorganized system had been governed hitherto. Its scope is wide from a historic perspective and to understand such sweeping changes being brought in through the implementation of GST, we need an analysis on what was there before introducing into it pre-GST scenario.
Learning was overshadowed by a labyrinth of indirect taxes and exemptions related to different aspects of educational services and goods having an intricate multi levied tax structure strewn across many multiple variations with in the ambit under pre-GST era.
1. Value-Added Tax: it is levied on goods and materials used for educational purpose, as well stationeries like text books, equipment etc.
2. Central Excise Duty, however Charged on any goods at educational institution if the same are manufactured by institutions or sold to students (printed material/educational software)
3. Octroi and Entry Tax: These are local taxes imposed on the entry of goods into a specific state or municipality
The result has been a similarly cascading impact, driving up costs and compliance headaches. Another problem was that these tax rates and exemptions were different for every state, leading to disparity and problems with inter-state operations as well. Not only that, the lack of ITCs and a uniformity in tax rates added to the complexity. The result of having such a tax structure raised additional costs for transfer to the students, making education more expensive and hence less accessible.
Advent of GST
The introduction of GST has brought a drastic change in the taxation structure of educational organizations right from its complex system and has brought several changes in an organized manner. Before going through the various impacts of the GST on the educational sector, it is imperative to undertake an analysis of the specification of changes brought about by the introduction of the GST. This preliminary investigation will create the basis to better understand how GST is contributing to change the context of the education, and thus will be possible to achieve a better perspective on its impacts on organisations and actors.
> GST Exemptions
Among the exclusion of the detailing of GST, there are some that will assist in ensuring that the cost of education remains low hence affordable. Such exceptions are helpful in order to make education an effective expenditure to be offered for all the social and economic groups. In other words, as per Entry 66 of the notification 12/2017-Central Tax (Rate) some of the services covered by the educational institution are as follows:
1. Core Educational Services Exemptions:
- Pre-School and School Education: The services provided by a pre-school or any school that offers education till higher secondary or equivalent level are completely GST-exempted.
- Recognized Degree/Diploma Programs: The services connected with formal education needed to get a recognized qualification (degree, diploma etc.) are also excluded.
Entry No. 67 of Nnotification 12/2017-Central Tax (Rate) specifies that the Indian Institutes of Management (IIMs) are exempt from GST on the following educational services, which are provided free of charge as per Central Government guidelines:
– Full time master’s Degree Programmes in Management for the duration of two years
– Fellow Programmes in Management
– Integrated Five-year Programmes for Management
But, this exclusion does not exclude the programs that are of Executive Development Programme and Short duration programmes, which are below one year and which provide participation certificates these are taxable under GST.
- Vocational Courses: All courses recognized by way of vocational education are GST safe. Such courses consist of the courses or trainings being authorized by the National or State Council for Vocational Training. {section 2(h) (As per Notification No. 12/2017-Central Tax (Rate)}.
2. Ancillary Services Exemptions:
- Transportation: Transportation services of students, faculty, and staff of an educational institution come under the negative list and are therefore, GST free.
- Catering Services: Some of the expressly excluded services are the catering services such as mid-day meals provided by the educational institutions.
- Housekeeping and Security: Cleaners, maids, security and other related services offered to the institution such as schools are zero-rated.
- Admission and Examination: Services in relation to admission to any educational establishment or the holding of examinations is excluded.
(All of these services are excluded only if rendered to Faculty, students and staff of an Institution and not to any third person or party much less any third person and that too only up to pre-school or higher secondary school level).
- Taxable Services and Goods {Exceptions}
Although core educational services provided by the institutions are exempted but this too has some exceptions as discussed below-
1. Commercial Activity: Educational institutions involved in commercial activities like renting out spaces for commercial purpose or conducting short term programmes like diplomas etc are all taxable under GST.
2. Sale of Goods: Educational institutions buying or selling stationery, books or uniform etc to any third party is taxable under GST.
Since they do not fit under the category of supplementary services that are free from GST, these are taxable as per Notification No. 12/2017- CTR
3. Higher Education Institutions: While services provided by educational institutions are normally free from the goods and services tax (GST), many services—particularly those provided by institutes of higher learning—are not. As a result, the colleges ability to pay the GST on purchases is severely limited, which drastically reduces their operational budgets.
Domino Effect of GST
The domino effect of advent of GST in this sector has led to surge of both positive and negative outcomes, discussed as below-
Positive Implications:
1. Streamlined: The implementation of GST has integrated a number of indirect taxes under one tax therefore, simplifying the tax system. This has helped the educational institutions to improve the way they handle their cash resources and meet their future aspects relating to taxes.
2. Cost Efficient: By eradicating a number of complex taxes, the cost of compliance has come down for the long run. Thus, improving the availability of more resources in fulfilling the enhancement of the educational structure.
3. Improved Financial Planning: School authorities can now be able to make sound financial forecasts since they can now determine their tax responsibilities effectively therefore improving on the financial planning.
Negative Implications:
1. Increased Costs: The implementation of GST on some of the rather basic services like tuition, tutoring, and educational material has caused its prices to rise, and therefore translated to increased charges to the students and parents thereby causing disadvantage to students coming from low-income families.
2. Administrative Burden: GST compliance may be a concern for many educational institutions, especially the small ones due to the following reasons. The requirement for record keeping and filing of taxes becomes demanding, hence raises concern as to how they manage the tasks.
3. Impact on Ancillary Services: Transport charges and hostel facilities are some of the additional services that attract GST and in turn this brings about increased overhead cost to the institutions fuelling the cost of education.
Therefore, the introduction of GST has enhanced organization of better and easy to understand tax system in the educational sector but together with the losses, two major finance and administrative issues have emerged to limit cost of education.
Path Forward
Consequently, the educational institutions need to implement a complex strategy that encompasses requirements fulfilment, creativity, as well as a focus on students. This requires compliance with the GST policies, accepting creativity in dealing with its effects, and putting students in the frontline to make decisions. Another important conclusion is the occasional assessment of GST’s consequences, the adaptation to new requirements, and polices are needed to ensure that GST fosters the strategic vision of quality education and students’ achievements.
Adherence is a must to avert fines and other detrimental effects the institution’s image. To achieve the suitable level of GST compliance, institutions have to ensure employees are sufficiently trained on GST, records are properly kept, and regular audits are conducted. It is for this reason that innovation is critical in helping organisations minimize the impact of GST for instance through identifying new sources of income, improving resource utilisation, and leveraging technology in improving organisational efficiency. Thus, GST does not demean the learning experience or quality of a degree programme while at the same time making the prices high or the processes complicated. The management must also ensure they get to talk to students, parents and faculty to hear them out and work on the issues raised.
Thus, the study focuses on assessment of GST on adaptation where institutions must be flexible to address issues arising from change and undertake initiatives expected of them due to change. Some changes required in policies and can include lobbying for relief in the current sector, engage with other sectors or policy makers, and enlightening the policy makers on the effects of GST on education.
Conclusion
Therefore, the arrival of GST has set off a chain reaction in the educational sector in India and now has brought a huge change in strategies of functioning, including how institutions have to cope and transform. Since the actions unfold in this situation, it is crucial for the sector to be innovative, knowledgeable, and timely to address the implications, prospects as well as the GST’s complexities and consequences toward educational institutions. In this way, they can unlock and realise the opportunities offered by GST in order to increase the efficiency of their work, improve financial viability, and play a role in the strengthening of quality and access to education. The GST ripple effect is still being felt in the education sector to this date, and according to the existing evidence the future of education in India is going to be determined by these stakeholders’ ability to adopt, explore and excel within this new tax environment.
Author Bio
