Dahyabhai Laljibhai Patel Vs ITO (ITAT Ahmedabad)
Facts
- Assessee, engaged in pharmaceutical distribution, filed return for AY 2018-19.
- During scrutiny, AO noticed sales promotion/distribution expenses paid to Welable Pharma at 13.5% of sales, which he held excessive.
- AO restricted it to 5% of sales, disallowing ₹25,88,504/-, terming the excess “beyond market limits.”
- CIT(A)/NFAC confirmed the restriction, leading to the present appeal before ITAT.
Assessee’s Submission
- Assessee furnished comparative data of sales, purchase values & credit-note compensations for preceding years (FYs 2014-15 to 2017-18), demonstrating that:
- The overall gross margins after accounting for compensation remained stable.
- The pattern of compensation had been consistently followed in all years, varying between 20–28% of sales.
- No part of the expenditure was shown to be bogus or for non-business purposes.
Tribunal’s Observations /Decision
- Bench noted that AO failed to produce any evidence of inflation, personal benefit, or non-genuineness.
- It observed that Assessee’s accounting pattern & gross margin trend were consistent year after year.
- When business results are in line with past trends & Department accepted them earlier, arbitrary estimation or restriction without concrete evidence cannot be sustained.
- Tribunal held there was no justification for restricting sales promotion expense from 13.5% to 5%.
- Disallowance of ₹25.88 lakh was deleted & the appeal was allowed in full.
Where the method of accounting & trade practices are consistent, & profits remain stable, the AO cannot substitute his subjective estimate for the businessman’s judgment. Genuine sales promotion & distribution expenses incurred in the ordinary course of trade are fully deductible.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.


