Section 143(2) Income Tax Notice Explained: Assessment Process, Timelines and How to Handle Scrutiny Safely
Introduction
Many taxpayers are currently receiving notices under section 143(2), and there is confusion about what these notices mean, why they are issued, and what needs to be done next. A large number of cases have already moved into scrutiny for returns filed for recent financial years, including original, revised, and updated returns. This article explains, in practical CA-style language, what a 143(2) notice is, how to check whether your case is selected, what type of scrutiny applies, and how the assessment process moves forward in a faceless system.
Main Discussion
A notice under section 143(2) means that the Income Tax Department has selected your return for scrutiny assessment. This selection can happen even if you have already filed your return correctly, revised it, or filed an updated return. The selection window for issuing such notices follows statutory timelines, and once that window closes, no new 143(2) notice can be issued for that year.
If you want to check whether your case is selected, log in to the income tax portal and go to the e-Proceedings section. If you do not see a notice under section 143(2), it means your case is not under scrutiny. If scrutiny has not been initiated within the permitted time, either no further action will be taken or, in certain cases, proceedings may move under a different section.
Once a 143(2) notice is issued, the case moves forward to assessment under section 143(3). The Assessing Officer must pass the final order within the prescribed deadline. In practice, most orders are completed well before the final statutory date, as officers close cases in batches.
Scrutiny can broadly be of three types. Limited scrutiny means the notice clearly mentions the specific issue for which the case is selected, and the officer is restricted to that issue only. Complete scrutiny means there is no issue mentioned, and the officer can examine all aspects of the return. Manual scrutiny usually arises from information, surveys, or inputs and is also generally issue-specific.
Common reasons for selection include mismatch or abnormal reporting of income, high cash deposits and withdrawals, unusual refund claims, low profit ratio compared to earlier years, large agricultural income disclosures, and cases where the return form selected does not match the nature of income. Incorrect form selection is a frequent mistake and can easily trigger scrutiny.
Practical Impact / Expert View
After selection, taxpayers usually receive two notices together: section 143(2) and section 144B. Section 144B confirms that the assessment will be conducted in a faceless manner. This means there is no physical interaction with the Assessing Officer, and all communication must be done online through the portal.
Initially, the 143(2) notice may show a reply date. In most cases, no detailed reply is required at this stage. The actual process begins when a detailed questionnaire is issued. This questionnaire typically asks for computation of income, return details, bank statements, deduction proofs, form disclosures, and supporting documents for claims made.
All replies must be submitted only through the e-Proceedings tab. Replies sent by email, physical visits, or informal communication have no legal value. Proper documentation, clear explanations, and structured submissions are critical.
If the officer is not satisfied with the reply, a show cause notice is issued proposing additions. If no satisfactory response is provided, or no response is filed at all, the officer may proceed with a best judgment assessment under section 144 and pass an order accordingly.
Experience shows that most cases become problematic not because the taxpayer is wrong, but because replies are not presented in a manner that the officer can easily understand. Accounting records, bank explanations, reconciliations, and documentary evidence must speak clearly. Over-explaining or giving irrelevant information often creates confusion instead of clarity.
Before replying, it is advisable to do a full internal simulation—review the return, AIS, TIS, bank statements, capital market statements, and computation as if the return is being filed again from scratch. This preparation helps anticipate questions and avoid mistakes.
Conclusion – key takeaways –
- A 143(2) notice means your return is selected for scrutiny assessment.
- Always check e-Proceedings on the income tax portal for notice status.
- Understand whether scrutiny is limited, complete, or manual.
- Faceless assessment applies; all replies must be filed online only.
- Questionnaires require structured, document-based replies.
- Poor or no reply can lead to best judgment assessment and demand.
- Professional handling and advance preparation significantly reduce risk.
*****
For professional support and advisory, you may reach out at casgpj@gmail.com or WhatsApp +91 81715 82583.
Author Bio
