Sunil Kumar Agarwal Vs ACIT (ITAT Kolkata)
ITAT Kolkata: Retraction Accepted – No Incriminating Material, Penalty u/s 271(1)(c) Deleted- Forced Disclosure Without Evidence Can’t Sustain Penalty – ITAT Kolkata
Kolkata Tribunal deleted penalty levied u/s 271(1)(c), holding that Explanation 5A was wrongly invoked when no incriminating material was found during search and disclosure stood retracted.
A search u/s 132 was conducted on 05.02.2021 against Healthcare/ESKAG group. Assessee, being a key person, was covered. He originally filed ROI for AY 2015-16 declaring income of ₹21.03 lakh. Pursuant to notice u/s 153A, he filed ROI declaring ₹1.61 crore including additional income of ₹1.40 crore disclosed during search u/s 132(4). However, assessee retracted by affidavit dated 18.02.2021, stating disclosure was forced on behalf of group. AO accepted retraction but still initiated penalty u/s 271(1)(c), levying ₹47.90 lakh on “concealment,” by applying Explanation 5A. CIT(A) upheld penalty.
Tribunal’s Observations
- Additional disclosure of ₹1.40 crore was not based on any incriminating document, seized asset, or unrecorded entry during search.
- Explanation 5A applies only where undisclosed assets/income are found during search & not disclosed in earlier returns. Here, nothing of that sort was seized.
- Disclosure under coercion, later retracted, cannot by itself justify penalty. A retracted statement, without corroborative evidence, is unsafe to rely upon.
- CBDT Circular No. 286/2/2003 itself cautions officers not to obtain confession during search without evidence.
- Tribunal relied on CIT vs. Raj Pal Bhatia (333 ITR 315 Delhi HC) & Beni Prasad Lahoti vs. DCIT (2022 Kol-Trib) that additions/penalties cannot rest solely on retracted statements.
Tribunal held Explanation 5A to s.271(1)(c) inapplicable; penalty imposed on voluntary disclosure without seized material was unsustainable. Orders of CIT(A) were set aside, penalty deleted. Both appeals allowed.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.




