Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Service Tax

No service tax for brand endorsement during IPL as the same was not “business support service”

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2023 taxguru.in 622
Case Name
Yusuf Khan M Pathan Vs C.C.E. & S.T. (CESTAT Ahmedabad)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Yusuf Khan M Pathan Vs C.C.E. & S.T. (CESTAT Ahmedabad)

Conclusion: Service tax demand against famous cricketers and brothers, Irfan Pathan and Yusuf Pathan was not justified as they were not providing any service as an independent individual worker therefore, they were not liable to service tax under the “Business Support Service” for brand endorsement during IPL.

Held: Assessees were international cricket players and they had entered into contract with the cricket team owners (known as franchisee) whereby they were employed/ engaged to play cricket for the respective teams in terms of the contracts for IPL seasons. The fees paid to assessees  had been held to be liable to service tax under the service category of “Business Support Service”. This view had been taken on the ground that assessees wore the team clothing which bear the brands/ marks of various sponsors and they were also required to participate in promotional /public events of the franchisee thus they were providing Business Support Service. Based on such reasoning show cause notices were issued to assessees for demand of service tax. After considering the reply, Adjudicating Authority confirmed the service tax demand along with interest and imposed the penalties on Appellant. Being aggrieved, an appeal was filed before the Commissioner (Appeals) who rejected the appeal of appellant and upheld the order of the adjudicating authority. It was held that from the contract entered into by assessees with the IPL franchisee that assessees were engaged as a professional cricketer for which the franchisee was to provide fee to assessees. They were under full control of the franchisee and had to act in the manner instructed by the franchisee. The apparel that they had to wear were team clothing and the same could not exhibit any badge, logo, mark, trade name, etc. Assessees were not providing any service as an independent individual worker. It could not be said that assessee was rendering any service which could be classified as business support service. He was simply a purchased member of a team serving and performing under KKR and was not providing any service to KKR as an individual. It was held that no service was provided by the player, nor requiring him to discharge any service tax. Thus, assessees were not liable to service tax under the “Business Support Service”.

FULL TEXT OF THE CESTAT AHMEDAB) ORDER

These appeals are filed against the Orders-In-Appeal No. 10/VDR-II/S.T./OA/Irfan khan Pathan /ADJ/COMMR/2011-12 dated 14.12.2011 and 11/VDR-II/S.T./OA/Y M. Pathan/ADJ/COMMR/2011-12 dated 14.12.2011. The issue involved in both the appeal is same and therefore are considered together and common order is being passed.

02. Briefly the facts of the present case are that both the appellants are international cricket players and they had entered into contract with the cricket team owners (known as franchisee) whereby they were employed/ engaged to play cricket for the respective teams in terms of the contracts for IPL seasons. The fees paid to the Appellants has been held to be liable to service tax under the service category of “Business Support Service”. This view has been taken on the ground that Appellant wear the team clothing which bears the brands/ marks of various sponsors and they are also required to participate in promotional /public events of the franchisee thus they are providing Business Support Service. Based on such reasoning show cause notices were issued to the appellant for demand of service tax. After considering the reply, the adjudicating authority confirmed the service tax demand along with interest and imposed the penalties on Appellant. Being aggrieved, an appeal was filed before the Commissioner (Appeals) who vide impugned order-in-appeal rejected the appeal of appellant and upheld the order of the adjudicating authority. Hence, the present appeals before us.

03. On behalf of the appellants, Learned Advocate Shri Saurabh Dixit appeared and argued the matter. He submits that the agreement between the Appellant and franchisee is an agreement of “employment” as can be seen from the clause 2.2 and clause 8.1(b) read with other clauses of the agreement, and the same actually creates the relationship of “employer – employee”. Since, Appellant employed by the franchisee and the Appellant agreed upon the remuneration and benefit as mentioned in schedule -1 of the agreement. In addition to this, wearing the franchisee’s colour’s and design of cricket clothing, including marks and logos, it is also part of employment agreement and it cannot be construed as promotional activities.

3.1 He further submits that after referring clause 4 and 5 of the franchise agreement, Revenue authority wrongly interpreted and submitted that payment received against such contract agreement and against the promotional activities of the franchises/ sponsors by wearing franchisee’s officials cricket clothing, displaying franchisee’s sponsor’s marks/ logo etc. also were liable to pay service tax under the taxable service “Business Support Service”. However in terms of agreement, stipulated wearing of cloths as provided by the franchisee. This hardly amount to “ marketing or promoting” the goods and services provided by such sponsors, whose names are mentioned on such cloths/ gear. The Appellant was obliged to undertake any “promotional activities” in terms of the agreement. After carefully reading of clause 4.1. and 4.2 of the agreement, it clear that the Appellant undertakes to grant franchisee all rights to use the identity of the appellant including his photographs. Films and TV appearances and his identification and these right is given by a player to the franchisee during the tenure of the contract and thereafter, the appellant will not claim endorsement of any products or goods or services of any sponsors in his name.

3.2 He further submits that clause 4.1. is also otherwise quite explicit inasmuch as the same clearly state that the right granted by the player to the franchisee shall not be so as to imply any individual endorsement by the player of any person, product or service and in such circumstance, player of any person, product or service and in such circumstance, player identification will normally be used with not less than two other player from the champions tournament. As such it is clear that the Appellant was not the one endorsing/promoting any person/product/ service, but it was only the franchisee who was doing so, with clear understanding that the same shall not amount to endorsement being made by the player himself. Further, reading of the entire agreement established the facts that playing cricket is the primary reason for which IPL was formed and promotional activities are ancillary to the main purpose that of playing cricket. The main activities of the Appellant, as per contact, is to play cricket as they spent 95% time for it, the other rights i.e. photography, film, television otherwise recording and performance during contract period including training and press conference granted to IPL and its franchisee are ancillary or incidental thereto, to make it commercially viable.

3.3 He argued that Appellant was in employment of the respective teams and was not an independent service provider. It is settled legal position that services provided by an employee, for the activities undertaken by the employer, for and under the instruction of the employer, cannot be termed as service provided by the employee. That by now plethora of decisions are available, wherein ad verbatim identical agreement clauses were interpreted and it was held that no service tax is leviable on player fees received for participating in IPL and the promotional events were merely incidental to the main activity of playing as a Cricketer in IPL. He placed reliance on the following decisions:-

Want to Read the Complete Judgment?

You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.

Read on with Premium
Goes straight to payment. GST invoice included.

One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.

Advertisement

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.