Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Goods and Services Tax

State Govt cannot deny genuine claim to purchase HSD oil at a concessional rate

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2021 taxguru.in 3033
Case Name
M/s. Tata Steel Ltd. &amp
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Related Assessment Year
W.P.A. No. 5306 of 2021
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

M/s. Tata Steel Ltd. & Anr Vs State of West Bengal & Ors. (Calcutta High Court)

Facts- The main issue raised was whether petitioners/purchasing HSD oil dealers who have been denied a refund of excess tax by the Respondent State Government of West Bengal which was admittedly collected by it from the petitioners through the selling oil dealers/IOCL in West Bengal in excess of concessional rate of tax under Section 8 (1) read with Section 8 (3) and 8 (4) of Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 and which were paid under compelling extraordinary circumstances beyond its control of the petitioners, can be called “person aggrieved” and have locus standi to file the instant Writ Petitions.

Conclusion- Held that neither petitioners nor IOCL is guilty of any latches and when there is no specific prohibition under the statute against such refund petitioners should not get entangled in the cobweb of procedures and the State should do substantial justice by refunding the amount of tax in question collected by it in excess of statutory concessional rate of tax during the relevant period either to the selling oil dealers/IOCL or to the purchasing oil dealers/petitioners and State should not deprive the legitimate claim of the petitioners to purchase the HSD oil at a concessional rate which is their statutory right under Central Sales Tax Act, 1956, in course of inter-State sale since they have fulfilled the conditions under Section 8 (1) read with 8 (3) and 8 (4) of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 by doing what fairness and justice demand of a State and which is the motto of every civilised society.

Impugned order of assessment passed by the Assessing Officer is set aside to the extent of refusal of acceptance of relevant “C” Forms submitted before him during the impugned assessment proceeding by the HSD oil purchasing dealers/petitioners through the oil selling dealers/IOCL relating to the relevant disputed period which was issued by the purchasing respective State Government, in favor of the petitioners on inter-State sales in question and it shall accept the aforesaid relevant “C” Forms and allow the concessional rate of tax to the petitioners on the basis of the said relevant “C” Forms subject to formal verification of the same.

FULL TEXT OF THE JUDGMENT/ORDER OF CALCUTTA HIGH COURT

Heard learned Advocates appearing for the parties.

All these Writ Petitions are heard together and disposed of by this common judgment in view of similarity of facts and questions of law involved in all these Writ Petitions as agreed by the Learned Counsel appearing for the parties. For the sake of convenience I will be dealing and discussing one of such Writ Petitions being W.P.A No. 5306 of 2021.

These Writ Petitions have been filed by the High Speed Diesel Oil (hereinafter called as HSD oil) dealers registered under Central Sales Tax Act, 1956, who purchased the said oil during the relevant disputed period from the seller of HSD oil dealers Indian Oil Corporation Limited (IOCL) in West Bengal in course of Inter-State sale, challenging the action of refusal on the part of Respondent State Government of West Bengal in refunding the differential amount of tax collected by it from the petitioners through IOCL in excess of concessional rate of tax on such purchase and the impugned assessment order to the extent of refusal to accept the “C” Forms submitted before the Assessing Officer relating to the said relevant inter-State sale by IOCL to the petitioners, causing the petitioners deprivation of statutory benefit of concessional rate of tax on the relevant purchase of the HSD oil.

In my considered opinion following factual and legal issues are involved in these Writ Petitions:

(1) Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case petitioners/purchasing HSD oil dealers who have been denied refund of excess tax by the Respondent State Government of West Bengal which were admittedly collected by it from the petitioners through the selling oil dealers/IOCL in West Bengal in excess of concessional rate of tax under Section 8 (1) read with Section 8 (3) and 8 (4) of Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 and which were paid under compelling extra ordinary circumstances beyond its control of the petitioners, can be called “person aggrieved” and have locus standi to file the instant Writ Petitions?

(2) Whether filing of “C” Forms along with return by the selling dealer is mandatory or directory under the relevant provisions of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 and Central Sales Tax Rules, 1956 and whether in view of Rule 12 (7) of the CST Rules, 1956 and under the aforesaid Act and Rules there is any specific or complete statutory bar in filing the “C” Forms belatedly at the stage of assessment proceeding?

(3) Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case impugned assessment order is bad in law to the extent of refusal to accept the “C” Forms relating to relevant disputed period causing denial of concessional rate of tax to the petitioners on purchase of HSD oil during the relevant period in course of Inter-State sale in spite of admitted position and specifically recording by the assessing officer in its impugned assessment order that the “C” Forms in respect of the relevant period were submitted before him and conditions for entitlement of concessional rate of tax are fulfilment of conditions under Section 8 (1) of CST Act, 1956 and though ground for refusal to accept the relevant “C” Forms is that the same were not filed along with return and that the IOCL had not filed revised return in this regard but nowhere it has specifically recorded or held in the impugned assessment order that ground for non acceptance of “C” Forms by him is none fulfilment of any of the conditions under Section 8 (1), 8 (3) or 8 (4) of the CST Act or the same were not fulfilled by the IOCL or the petitioners?

(4) Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case petitioners who have admittedly fulfilled the terms and conditions under Section 8 (1) read with 8 (3) and 8 (4) of the CST Act, 1956 and Rules 12 (7) of the CST Rules, 1956 are entitled to concessional rate of tax on purchase of HSD oil from selling dealers/IOCL in the State of West Bengal in course of inter-State sale during the relevant period?

(5) Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case Respondent State Government of West Bengal is legally justified in refusing to refund the amount of tax in excess of concessional rate of tax collected by it from the purchasing dealers/petitioners through the selling HSD oil dealer/IOCL in West Bengal during the relevant period in spite of admitted position of facts as appear from record that relevant “C” Forms relating to the relevant period were submitted to it by IOCL admittedly before the assessing officer during the impugned assessment proceeding though belatedly, on the plea that the petitioners/purchasing HSD oil dealers cannot claim refund from it directly since the same have not been received by it directly from the petitioners so they should claim the said refund from the selling dealers of HSD Oil company/IOCL in West Bengal and on the plea that since selling dealer has not filed revised returns for such claim in spite of being fully aware of the extra ordinary circumstances of wrongful action of non-issuance of “C” Forms by the purchasing State Government of Jharkhand and Orissa within due time and which is matter of record that the time to file revise return under the statute had already been expired when the “C” Forms were issued by the purchasing State Governments in favour of the petitioners and further by disregarding the fact that petitioners have no control over filing of revised return by the HSD oil selling dealer/IOCL and further on the plea that since the petitioners have already paid the full rate of tax and not at concessional rate of tax now petitioners cannot claim refund of the said amount of tax paid in excess of concessional rate of tax?

(6) Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case Respondent State Government of West Bengal is legally justified in not refunding the tax collected by it from the petitioners through IOCL in excess of concessional rate by ignoring and disregarding that the excess amount of tax/full rate of tax which were paid by the petitioners was due to compelling extra ordinary circumstances of non-issuance of “C” Forms by the purchasing State Governments during the relevant period on the basis of relevant notification issued by them and “C” Forms for the relevant period were issued in favour of the petitioners by the purchasing State Government belatedly only after the said notification was quashed by the Hon’ble High Court of Jharkhand with further order giving liberty to the petitioners to recover the tax paid in question in excess of concessional rate of tax during the relevant period either from the selling dealer/IOCL in West Bengal or from the State Government of West Bengal and it is matter of record that after the SLP of the State Government of Jharkhand was dismissed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court against the said order of the Hon’ble Jharkhand High Court, the “C” Forms in question were issued and by the time “C” Forms were issued by the respective purchasing State Governments time to submit “C” Forms along with return as well as time to file revised return had already expired and delay in submitting the relevant “C” Forms due to this compelling extraordinary circumstances were beyond the control of the petitioners purchasing company?

(7) Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case the Respondent State Government of West Bengal is justified in denying the petitioners the aforesaid refund and the petitioners should make claim of refund of such excess amount of tax in question from IOCL and not directly from it while it is matter of record that such excess amount of tax is not lying with the IOCL and admittedly it has already been deposited with the exchequer of State Government of West Bengal and even if IOCL wants to refund the said excess amount of tax to the petitioners, it is impossible and impracticable for it to do so in such circumstances unless the State Government of West Bengal refunds back the said excess tax to IOCL if not directly to the petitioners?

(8) Whether on the facts and in circumstances of the case action of the Respondent State Government of West Bengal in refusing to refund the amount of tax to the petitioners which have been collected by it in excess of concessional rate of tax for the relevant period through the IOCL is legally justified by taking the stand of consent and acquiescence by disregarding the admitted fact that the Respondent State Government of West Bengal itself had been allowing the petitioners to purchase the HSD oil at a concessional rate of tax before the disputed relevant period and has been allowing them to purchase at a concessional rate of tax even after the disputed relevant period and is still continuing with the same practice?

(9) Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case action of Respondent State Government of West Bengal in non-refunding the excess tax in question to the petitioners and withholding the same is contrary to instruction issued by the Government of India, Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue, State Taxes Section dated 1st November, 2018, to the State Governments on the basis of the judgment of the Hon’ble Punjab and Haryana High Court dated 28.03.2018 and order of the Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 13.08.2018

Common facts which emerge on perusal of the instant Writ Petitions and affidavits filed by the parties in these Writ Petitions are as follows:

Writ Petitioners are purchasing dealers of HSD oil and are registered under the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 (hereinafter referred to as “CST Act”) and their Certificate of Registration in Form B under the Central Sales (Registration and Turnover) Rules, 1957 (hereinafter referred to as “CST Rules”) provide for the purchase of High Speed Diesel Oil (hereinafter referred to as “HSD Oil”) against “C” Forms at a concessional rate of tax which were belatedly submitted during the course of impugned assessment proceeding though not along with return by IOCL due to compelling exceptional circumstances beyond the control of the petitioners.

According to the petitioners prior to 01.07.2017 petitioners were purchasing HSD Oil (for the purpose of use in manufacturing and/or processing of goods for sale and/or use in mining) from IOCL in the State of West Bengal for their Units situated in the State of Jharkhand at a concessional rate of tax under the CST Act, 1956, in course of inter-State sale, from the State of West Bengal at concessional rates of tax under Section 8(1) read with 8 (3) and 8(4) of the CST Act, 1956, against the issue of “C” Forms to IOCL prior to 1.7.2017 and from 29.10.2018 onwards and currently the same modus operandi is being followed and the Respondent State of West Bengal is regularly accepting the said “C” Forms from the petitioner relating to such Inter-State sale.

From 01.07.2017 with the operationalization of the Goods and Services Tax regime (hereinafter referred to as “GST”) the State of Jharkhand and certain other State Governments took a view that the registration of dealers such as the Petitioners herein under the CST Act, 1956 as well as under the local VAT (Value Added Tax)/Sales tax laws stood automatically lapsed and since the final products being manufactured/produced by the dealers, such as the Petitioners herein, would not fall within the definition of the term “goods” under Section 2 (d) of the CST Act as amended by Act No. 18 of 2017 w.e.f. 01.07.2017 and Petitioners would become disentitled to the issue of “C” Forms. Consequently, the sale of HSD Oil by IOCL from State of West Bengal was taxed at the full rate of tax. Accordingly, State of Jharkhand issued a Circular dated 11.10.2017 one of such annexure is Annex. P-2/Pages 83-84 of the Writ Petition being WPA No. 5306 of 2021 and on the basis of such notification IOCL stopped selling HSD to the Petitioner No. 1 at a concessional rate and IOCL recovered full rate of tax from the petitioners and admittedly the said full rate of tax were deposited with the Respondent State Government of West Bengal by the IOCL.

The aforesaid Circular dated 11.10.2017 was accordingly challenged by the Petitioner No. 1, in W.P. (T) No. 6048 of 2017, WP (T) No. 6892 of 2017, W.P. (T) No. 6893 of 2017 and W.P. (T) No. 6897 of 2017, before the Hon’ble High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi.

The Hon’ble High Court of Jharkhand by its interim order dated 17.05.2018 stayed the implementation and execution of the aforesaid Circular dated 11.10.2017 and directed the State of Jharkhand to issue necessary ‘C’ Forms to the Petitioner No. 1. Against the said interim order, Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 26844 of 2018 was filed by the State of Jharkhand which was dismissed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court by order dated 29.10.2018.

The Hon’ble High Court of Jharkhand finally allowed the aforesaid Writ Petitions by its judgment and order dated 28.08.2019 quashing the aforesaid Circular dated 11.10.2017 and consequently directed the State Government of Jharkhand/purchasing State for issuance of “C” Forms in favour of purchasing dealers/petitioners and further holding that the petitioners would be entitled to claim refund of the excess tax collected either by the Oil selling Companies/IOCL or from the State Government concerned, as would appear on perusal of Paragraph 27 of the said judgment against which Respondent State Government of West Bengal could have filed Appeal before the Hon’ble Supreme Court if so aggrieved though it was not a party to the said proceeding before the Hon’ble Jharkhand High Court but it did not file. Special Leave Petition (Civil) Diary No. 7966 of 2020 filed by the State of Jharkhand against the aforesaid final judgment and order of Hon’ble High Court of Jharkhand was also dismissed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court by order dated 13.09.2021. The Hon’ble High Court of Orissa in W.P. (Civil) No. 23585 of 2017, by its final judgment and order dated 12.12.2018 also passed a similar order in favour of the Petitioner No. 1 with respect to the similar Circular dated 17.08.2017 issued by the State of Orissa.

IOCL filed Review Petition before the Hon’ble High Court of Jharkhand primarily contending that it is only the petitioners herein who should be directed to seek a refund from the State Government of West Bengal and that IOCL should not be saddled with the responsibility of refunding the excess tax to the petitioners since the said excess tax had already been deposited with the Respondent/State Government of West Bengal and it is not lying with it. The aforesaid Review Petition filed by IOCL was dismissed by the Hon’ble High Court of Jharkhand by order dated 17.10.2020. While dismissing the said Review Petitions the Hon’ble High Court of Jharkhand granted liberty to the petitioners as well as to IOCL to approach the appropriate forum in the State of West Bengal for the required refund in question as appears from Paragraphs 9 and 11 of the aforesaid order of the Hon’ble Jharkhand High Court, dated 17.10.2020.

Pursuant to the aforesaid order passed by the Hon’ble High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi, the petitioners obtained statutory Form ‘C’ from the purchasing state, i.e. State of Jharkhand for the entire relevant period for which it was compelled to purchase HSD Oil at full rate of tax instead of at concessional rate of tax and submitted the same to IOCL for onward submission to the State Government of West Bengal. Admittedly, IOCL has deposited the aforesaid “C” Forms to the authorities concerned of the State Government of West Bengal during the course of assessment proceeding yet the Respondent/State Government of West Bengal has not refunded the said excess tax which were collected by it from the petitioners through IOCL even after making representation which is a part of annexure to the Writ Petitions.

In these Writ Petitions, petitioners have challenged the impugned assessment orders passed in the assessments of IOCL to the extent of causing the petitioners deprivation of refund of excess amount of tax paid by them to the State Government of West Bengal through IOCL and non-consideration of their representations for refund of the said tax collected by the Respondents/State Government of West Bengal in excess of concessional rate of tax mainly on the following grounds:

“(i) For that the impugned Assessment Order dated 30th June, 2020 is neither sustainable in law nor on facts and the same is liable to be quashed/set aside.

(ii) For that the petitioner is directly aggrieved by the Assessment Order passed in the case of Respondent-IOCL, as due to non-acceptance of statutory Form ‘C’ by the authority of the State of West Bengal, claim of refund of differential tax due to the petitioner no. 1 has incorrectly and illegally denied to the petitioner no. 1, for no fault of the petitioner no. 1.

(iii) For that it is submitted that the reasoning regarding non issuance of Invoice at the concessional rate of tax by IOCL to petitioner as given in the Assessment Order is untenable in the eyes of law inasmuch as the same fails to take into consideration the effect of the Provisional Credit Notes issued by the IOCL to petitioner no. 1. As such, this reason has no legs to stand in the eyes of law and ought to be rejected as without any substance or merit.

(iv) For that it is submitted that the other and further reasoning given in the Assessment Order regarding non filling of revised returns by IOCL is also not sustainable in the eyes of law. This is so as non submission of revised returns cannot jeopardize the legitimate substantive claim of another party, which is going to be directly affected by the action/non-action of another party, on which it has no control. Further, in any case, such technical plea cannot defeat the substantive right of the petitioners. Still further, even in the hands of IOCL, the said ground has no merit and ought to be overruled. As such, looked at from any angle, it is very clear that the reasoning employed in the Assessment Order cannot affect the substantive and legitimate right of petitioner to have the matter considered in accordance with law, more so, when the petitioner has done, all it could have done in the facts and circumstances of the present case.

(v) For that, it is submitted that it would be travesty of justice, if the legitimate right and claim of the petitioners are allowed to be rejected, in the manner it is rejected by the Assessment Order, for no fault of the petitioner.

(vi) For that, it is submitted that the age old legal maxim ubi jus ibi remedium that where there is a right there is a remedy is fully applicable in the present case to set at naught the illegality committed in the Assessment Order which has a prejudicial bearing on the present petitioner, independent of the conduct of IOCL.

(vii) For that the petitioner was, admittedly, entitled to purchase H.S.D at concessional rate in terms of Section 8 (3) read with Section 8 (4) of the CST Act and, thus, the excess amount realized from the petitioner at full rate of tax by Respondent-IOCL in the compelling circumstances and deposited with the State of West Bengal, is liable to be refunded to the petitioner no. 1 as consequential relief, upon acceptance of the already submitted From ‘C’ and setting aside of the Assessment Order pro tanto.

(viii) For that Assessing Officer, while passing the impugned order, failed to take into consideration that the Hon’ble High Court of Orissa, in its judgment and order dated 28.08.2019 passed in W.P (Civil) No. 23585 of 2017, has categorically recognized the right of the petitioner no. 1 to claim refund of differential tax and it was specifically ordered that the petitioner no. 1 shall be refunded the differential tax which was realized due to issuance of Circular dated 17.08.2017 issued by the State of Orissa, the said circular stands quashed as on date.

(ix) For that Assessing Officer failed to appreciate that it is an undisputed fact that the goods were sold by Respondent-IOCL to the petitioner no. 1 by way of inter-State movement of goods and the petitioner no. 1, being registered dealer, was entitled to purchase said goods at concessional rate and even in terms of Section 8 (3) read with Section 8 (4) of the CST Act, Declaration Form ‘C’ has been duly furnished by the petitioner no. 1 to Respondent-IOCL, which was, in turn, deposited by IOCL with the authority of the State of West Bengal. Thus, the petitioner no. 1 and/or Respondent-IOCL have fulfilled all conditions pertaining to concessional sale or purchase and merely because, at the time of raising of Invoices, under compelling circumstances, tax was charged at full rate, cannot be considered as a valid ground for denying the benefit of refund to the petitioner no. 1 of the differential tax, as, admittedly, the petitioner no. 1 was entitled to purchase H.S.D oil at concessional rate.

(x) For that Assessing Officer failed to appreciate that the issue as to whether the petitioners/petitioner is/are entitled to claim refund of the differential tax, which was realized and deposited by Respondent-IOCL to the State of West Bengal, is no longer res integra, as the Hon’ble Orissa High Court has held that the petitioner no.1/petitioner is/are entitled for refund of the amount, which was collected from the Petitioner no.1 in the circumstances narrated above, without any fault of petitioner.

(xi) For that Assessing Officer failed to take into consideration that the present issue has been decided by several Hon’ble High Courts including the High Court of Punjab and Haryana in the case of Carpo Power Limited Vs. State of Haryana and Others and in the said case, while adjudicating the issue, the Hon’ble High Court of Punjab and Haryana further ordered for refund of the differential tax which has been realized by the Oil Companies from the purchasers of HSD oil.

(xii) For that Assessing Officer also failed to take into consideration, that, similarly, the Hon’ble Rajasthan High Court vide its judgment and order dated 18.05.2018, quashed the similar circular issued by the State of Rajasthan and, while quashing the said circular, further ordered for refund of the differential tax which was realized on account of purchase of HSD at full rate of tax.

(xiii) For that pursuant to the judgment and order passed by Hon’ble Rajasthan High Court, one J.K. Cement Ltd. being the purchaser of HSD oil approached the Hon’ble High Court of Gujarat by filing writ application claiming refund of tax which was collected from it by its seller Reliance Industries Ltd. and deposited with the authorities of the State of Gujarat. In the said writ petition it was primarily contended, inter alia, that said company – J.K. Cement Ltd. was entitled under law to purchase HSD at concessional rate, but, under compelling circumstances, it was forced to purchase HSD oil by paying full rate of tax and, thereafter, subsequently, issued Declaration Form ‘C’ to the seller which led supplied HSD at full rate of tax. It was, thus, contended inter alia that since, subsequently, Form ‘C’ was obtained by said J.K. Cement Ltd. it is entitled under law to claim refund from the authorities of the State of Gujarat as the seller – Reliance Industries Ltd. had already deposited the tax with the State of Gujarat. The Hon’ble High Court of Gujarat, vide order dated 18.12.2019, was pleased to allow the said writ application and directed the authorities of the State of Gujarat to grant refund to the purchaser as the seller has already deposited the tax with the State authorities.”

Petitioners have made the following prayers/reliefs in the instant writ petitions:

“(a) For issuance of an appropriate writ/order/direction, including Writ of Certiorari for quashing/setting aside the assessment order dated 30.06.20210 passed by Respondent No. 2 in the case of IOCL pertaining to the Assessment Year 2017-18, to the extent submission of Additional Form ‘C’ by Respondent-IOCL pertaining to the petitioner no. 1 has been denied in having consequential effect of denying the benefit of refund of the excess differential tax to the petitioners and borne by it and stands paid to the Respondent/State of West Bengal; and

(b) For issuance of appropriate writ/order/direction, including a Writ, in the nature of Mandamus, directing the Respondent-State of West Bengal to consequentially refund the amount of Rs.13,85,00,494.21/- being the amount of excess differential tax realized from the petitioners by IOCL and deposited with the State of West Bengal in respect of purchase of HSD oil, which the petitioners are entitled under law without any controversy and,

(c) Rule Nisi in terms of prayer (a) and (b) above, and;

(d) Such further and/or other order or orders be passed and/or direction or directions be given as to this Hon’ble Court may deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the present case.”

Common case according to the Respondent/State Government of West Bengal in all the Writ Petitions herein are as follows:

In the assessment for the relevant assessment year 2017-18 of IOCL, the Assessing Officer, by its order dated 30.06.2020 (Annx. P-9/Pages 146-150 of the Writ Petition being WPA No. 5306 of 2021), has rejected the claim in question made by IOCL on inter-State sale of HSD Oil to the petitioners against relevant “C” Forms, on the following grounds:

(i) IOCL has not filed revised returns claiming sale at a concessional rate of tax, in spite of all the necessary “C” Forms being made available to the State of West Bengal by the petitioners through IOCL.

(ii) IOCL has not revised its selling invoices charging CST.

(iii) IOCL has not issued credit note for differential CST.

Respondent/State of West Bengal, in its Affidavit-in-Opposition to the Writ Petition, in substance has raised an issue of the locus standi of the petitioners in filing these Writ Petitions against denial of their claim of refund in question directly from the Respondent/State of West Bengal and further for the reasons stated in the assessment order which were reiterated by it in its affidavit-in-opposition.

During the course of arguments, the Learned Government Pleader for the State Government of West Bengal also resisted the claim of refund in question on the ground that in view of paragraph 27 of the judgment dated 28.08.2019 of the Hon’ble High Court of Jharkhand (supra) that since IOCL had issued Provisional Credit Notes, the refund could only be claimed by the Petitioners not directly from the State Government of West Bengal but only through IOCL. In support of its aforesaid contention reliance was also placed by him on the Representation dated 29.12.2020 being Annxure P-17 to the Writ Petition and more specifically on the prayer clause where request was made to the State Government of West Bengal to refund the amount of excess tax collected through IOCL.

The State of West Bengal/Respondents authorities, relating to petitioners’ claim of concessional rate of tax, submitted that the claim of the petitioners by invocation of Section 8 (1) read with Section 8 (3) and 8(4) of the CST Act is not a claim for refund of any tax, it is for concession to be allowed in specific manner under the Act. IOCL has itself admitted that the taxation for such transaction has been done at the full rate of tax under Section 8 (2) of the CST Act. Accordingly, the taxing authority has accepted such sale being sales under Section 8 (2) of the CST Act and as such there has been no payment for excess tax or illegal tax which has been imposed by the State. The only way to claim concession on the rate of tax according to State Respondent is under the Provision of the CST Act and the Rules. There is completely discrepancy between the return, the invoices in support of the return and “C” Form. The writ petitioner is attempting to create a cloud on the said transaction. Any concession which IOCL was required to make is a contractual obligation of the IOCL and the writ petitioner. The State of West Bengal cannot be a party to the same. Rule 8(2A) of the CST (West Bengal) Rules, 1958 which provides that every dealer registered under the Act, other than those referred to in sub-rule (1) and sub-rule (2) shall, in accordance with the West Bengal Sales Tax Act, 1994 and/or the Value Added Tax Act, 2003, and Rules made thereunder shall furnish a return quarterly in Form-1 in respect of his turnover as referred to in Rule 11 of the Central Sales Tax (Registration and Turnover) Rules, 1957. Hence, the Form-1 (the Return) is a statutory form in which a dealer has to declare its turnover, break-up of his turnover, deductions claimed, if any, and different rates of tax chargeable on the break-up of turnover. In serial no.8 (b) of the form, he has to declare the turnover of sales of goods under Section 8(1) of the CST Act to registered dealers against prescribed declaration forms, here in this case Form-C. In view of this, it is clear that furnishing of return and his declaration of sale at concessional rate of tax in the said return is sine qua non for claiming concessional rate of tax.

The stand of the Respondent/State of West Bengal in paragraphs 4(1) and 9 of its Affidavit-in-Opposition to the Writ Petition being WPA No. 5306 is to the effect that there is no provision under law to make a refund to a non­party to the assessment, and since the Petitioners are not “dealer” within the meaning of Section 2(b) of the CST Act.

Case and stand of the Respondent/IOCL as appears from its Affidavit-in-Opposition dated 18.08.2021 to the Writ Petition is that it has supported the claim of the petitioners and it has been specifically admitted by IOCL in paragraph 4 that IOCL had produced and placed on record “C” Forms issued by the Petitioners before the Assessing Officer. In paragraph 11 of the said Affidavit-in-Opposition it has also been stated by the IOCL that it will not be able to get the refund in question from the State Government of West Bengal since the excess tax which it has collected from the Petitioners has already deposited the same with the Respondent/the State of West Bengal and it is not lying with it and it can’t claim for the refund on the principles of unjust enrichment and it is only the Petitioners who would be lawfully entitled to such refund from the State Government of West Bengal.

Respondent No. 4/Indian Oil Corporation Limited supporting the contention and claim of the petitioners has made the following additional common submission and taken the stand in all the aforesaid Writ Petitions:

(i) If the State Respondents decide to refund the aforesaid amount of differential tax, IOCL has no objection provided !OCL is exonerated by the State Respondents from all claims arising from non-entertainment of relevant declaration forms issued by the petitioners now under challenge in pending appeal of IOCL. Also, the petitioners should indemnify IOCL against all future liability arising from refund to them in the peculiar exceptional circumstances of these cases and no adverse effect should fall upon IOCL for any refund so made.

(ii) The refund to the petitioners, by the State Respondents, in the circumstances of these cases, would mean unconditional acceptance of the claim for concessional rate of tax supported by the declaration forms furnished by the petitioners. Such acceptance would result in excess payment by IOCL which may be refunded directly to the petitioners and in such case IOCL shall have no claim over such refund. In case refund is made to IOCL, IOCL would be obliged to and shall make the said refund to the petitioners.

(iii) While making the refund, the actual amount refundable to each of the petitioners has to be carefully ascertained by the State Respondents, preferably after hearing both the petitioners and IOCL. The amounts of refund claimed in these writ petitions, which relate only to the relevant assessment year 2017-18, are excessive. The major reason for the difference in claim for 2017-18 is, perhaps, that the petitioners have mingled the figures of 2018-19 whereto the instant dispute spills over. Adjustments in some cases may also be necessary to arrive at the correct amount.

(iv) The view canvassed by the State Respondents is vitiated. It does not take into consideration the statutory scheme. Return is periodic self assessment of tax payable by the assessee. Non-filing or late filing of return is visited by imposition of late fee and interest. Initiation of prosecution proceeding is permissible for intentional non-filing or wrong filing of returns.

(v) It is nowhere provided in law that claims of the assessee shall not be entertained if not made in returns or wrongly made in returns.

(vi) Assessment is governed by altogether separate provisions applying equally to those who file returns or who fail to file returns. The entertainment and allowance of claims does not depend upon what is declared in the returns. The purpose of the assessment proceeding before the authorities is to assess correctly the tax liability of an assessee in accordance with the law. Such purpose can be achieved only if all aspects, including claims, independent of returns are considered. The assessment is an exercise in finding the actual tax liability.

(vii) The judgment of Hon’ble Mysore High Court at Bangalore in the case of Giridharlal Parasmal, reported at 20 STC 64, is a good exposition of the law. In paragraph 6 of the judgment, it has been observed that “…………………. the duty of the assessing officer is not merely to impose tax that is lawfully exigible but also to give to the assesses the benefit of any reduction or exemption that may become due to them upon facts actually found to be true by the assessing authorities, whether or not the assessee, out of ignorance or by mistake, make a claim thereto.” The Hon’ble Supreme Court, in the case of National Thermal Power Co. Ltd., (1997) 7 SCC 489 at page 491, has expressed similar view.

Some of the provisions of law which in my view are relevant to this case are referred hereinbelow:

Central Sales Tax Act, 1956:

“(6). Liability to tax on inter-State sales.—

(1) Subject to the other provisions contained in this Act, every dealer shall, with effect from such date as the Central Government may, by notification in the Official Gazette, appoint, not being earlier than thirty days from the date of such notification, be liable to pay tax under this Act on all sales [of goods other than electrical energy] effected by him in the course of inter-State trade or commerce during any year on and from the date so notified:

[Provided that a dealer shall not be liable to pay tax under this Act on any sale of goods which, in accordance with the provisions of sub-section (3) of section 5 is a sale in the course of export of those goods out of the territory of India.]

(1A) A dealer shall be liable to pay tax under this Act on a sale of any goods effected by him in the course of inter-State trade or commerce notwithstanding that no tax would have been leviable (whether on the seller or the purchaser) under the sales tax law of the appropriate State if that sale had taken place inside that State.

(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (1) or sub-section (1A), where a sale of any goods in the course of inter-State trade or commerce has either occasioned the movement of such goods from one State to another or has been effected by a transfer of documents of title to such goods during their movement from one State to another, any subsequent sale during such movement effected by a transfer of documents of title to such goods to a registered dealer, if the goods are of the description referred to in sub-section (3) of section 8, shall be exempt from tax under this Act:

Provided that no such subsequent sale shall be exempt from tax under this subsection unless the dealer effecting the sale furnishes to the prescribed authority in the prescribed manner and within the prescribed time or within such further time as that authority may, for sufficient cause, permit,—

(a) a certificate duly filled and signed by the registered dealer from whom the goods were purchased containing the prescribed particulars in a prescribed form obtained from the prescribed authority; and

(b) if the subsequent sale is made to a registered dealer, a declaration referred to in subsection (4) of section 8:

Provided further that it shall not be necessary to furnish the declaration referred to in clause (b) of the preceding proviso in respect of a subsequent sale of goods if,—

(a) the sale or purchase of such goods is, under the sales tax law of the appropriate State exempt from tax generally or is subject to tax generally at a rate which is lower than three percent, or such reduced rate as may be notified by the Central Government, by notification in the Official Gazette, under sub­section (1) of section 8 (whether called a tax or fee or by any other name); and

(b) the dealer effecting such subsequent sale proves to the satisfaction of the authority referred to in the preceding proviso that such sale is of the nature referred to in this subsection.

(3) Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act, no tax under this Act shall be payable by any dealer in respect of sale of any goods made by such dealer, in the course of inter-State trade or commerce, to any official, personnel, consular or diplomatic agent of—

(i) any foreign diplomatic mission or consulate in India; or

(ii) the United Nations or any other similar international body,

entitled to privileges under any convention or agreement to which India is a party or under any law for the time being in force, if such official, personnel, consular or diplomatic agent, as the case may be, has purchased such goods for himself or for the purposes of such mission, consulate, United Nations or other body.

(4) The provisions of sub-section (3) shall not apply to the sale of goods made in the course of inter-State trade or commerce unless the dealer selling such goods furnishes to the prescribed authority a certificate in the prescribed manner on the prescribed form duly filled and signed by the official, personnel, consular or diplomatic agent, as the case may be.

(8) Rates of tax on sales in the course of inter-State trade or commerce. –

(1) Every dealer, who in the course of inter-State trade or commerce, sells to a registered dealer goods of the description referred to in sub-section (3), shall be liable to pay tax under this Act, which shall be [two per cent] of his turnover or at the rate applicable to the sale or purchase of such goods inside the appropriate State under the sales tax law of that State, whichever is lower:

Provided that the Central Government may, by notification in the Official Gazette, reduce the rate of tax under this sub-section.

(2) The tax payable by any dealer on his turnover in so far as the turnover or any part thereof relates to the sale of goods in the course of inter-State trade or commerce not falling within subsection (1), shall be at the rate applicable to the sale or purchase of such goods inside the appropriate State under the sales tax law of that State.

(3) The goods referred to in sub-section (1)—

(a) *************

(b) are goods of the class or classes specified in the certificate of registration of the registered dealer purchasing the goods as being intended for re-sale by him or subject to any rules made by the Central Government in this behalf, for use by him in the manufacture or processing of goods for sale or in the telecommunications network or in mining or in the generation or distribution of electricity or any other form of power;

(c) are containers or other materials specified in the certificate of registration of the registered dealer purchasing the goods, being containers or materials intended for being used for the packing of goods for sale;

(d) are containers or other materials used for the packing of any goods or classes of goods specified in the certificate of registration referred to in clause (b) or for the packing of any containers or other materials specified in the certificate of registration referred to in clause (c).

(4) The provisions of sub-section (1) shall not apply to any sale in the course of inter-State trade or commerce unless the dealer selling the goods furnishes to the prescribed authority in the prescribed manner a declaration duly filled and signed by the registered dealer to whom the goods are sold containing the prescribed particulars in a prescribed form obtained from the prescribed authority:

Provided that the declaration is furnished within the prescribed time or within such further time as that authority may, for sufficient cause, permit.

“(9) (1) ……………..

(2) Subject to the other provisions of this Act and the rules made thereunder, the authorities for the time being empowered to assess, re-assess, collect and enforce payment of any tax under general sales tax law of the appropriate State shall, on behalf of the Government of India, assess re-assess, collect and enforce payment of tax, including any [interest or penalty,] payable by a dealer under this Act as if the tax or [interest or penalty] payable by such a dealer under this Act is a tax or [interest or penalty] payable under the general sales tax law of the State; and for this purpose they may exercise all or any of the powers they have under the general sales tax law of the State; and the provisions of such law, including provisions relating to returns, provisional assessment, advance payment of tax, registration of the transferee of any business, imposition of the tax liability of a person carrying on business on the transferee of, or successor to, such business, transfer of liability of any firm or Hindu undivided family to pay tax in the event of the dissolution of such firm or partition of such family, recovery of tax from third parties, appeals, reviews, revisions, references, [refunds, rebates, penalties,] [charging or payment of interest,] compounding of offences and treatment of documents furnished by a dealer as confidential, shall apply accordingly:

Provided that if in any State or part thereof there is no general sales tax law in force, the Central Government may, be rules made in this behalf make necessary provision for all or any of the matter specified in this sub-section.

(3) The proceeds in any financial year of any tax, [including any interest or penalty] levied and collected under this Act in any State (other than a Union Territory) on behalf of the Government of India shall be assigned to the State and shall be retained by it; and the proceeds attributable to Union territories shall form part of the Consolidated Fund of India.

West Bengal Sales Tax (WBST) Act, 1994:

(2) (1) …………………………….

(2) ……………………………

(3) ……………………………

(4) …………………………..

(10) “dealer” means any person who carries on the business of selling or purchasing goods in West Bengal or any person making sales under section 15, and includes—

(a) an occupier of a jute-mill or shipper of jute;

(b) Government, a local authority, a statutory body, a trust or other body corporate which, or a liquidator or a receiver appointed by a court in respect of a person, being a dealer as defined in this clause, who, whether or not in the course of business, sells, supplies or distributes directly or otherwise goods for cash or for deferred payment or for commission, remuneration or other valuable consideration;

(c) a person who has set up a business of selling or purchasing goods in West Bengal.

Explanation 1.— A co-operative society or a club or any association which sells goods to its members is a dealer.

Explanation 2.— A factor, a broker, a commission agent, a del credere agent, an auctioneer, an agent for handling or transporting of goods or handling of document of title to goods or any other mercantile agent, by whatever name called, and whether of the same description as hereinbefore mentioned or not, who carries on the business of selling goods and who has, in the customary course of business, authority to sell goods belonging to principals, is a dealer;

(37) (1) …………………………….

(2) ………………………

“(3) The Commissioner shall, on application made by the buyer in respect of sales of goods to him referred to in sub-section (1) and on such terms and conditions as he may deem fit and proper, refund to such buyer the tax or the excess tax, as the case may be, collected from such buyer and deposited by the dealer in the manner referred to in sub-section (2):

Provided that no application from any buyer shall be entertained unless the same is made within twelve months from the date on which the tax or excess tax, as the case may be, is paid and supported by relevant cash memo or bill issued by the dealer.”

(60) Refunds— (1) The Commissioner shall, in the prescribed manner, refund to a dealer any amount of tax, penalty or interest paid by such dealer in excess of the amount due from him under this Act, either by cash payment or by deduction or adjustment of such excess from the amount of tax, penalty or interest due in respect of other period.

(2) Nothing in sub-section (1) shall be deemed to empower the Commissioner to amend, vary or rescind any assessment, or to amend, vary or rescind any order passed on appeal, revision or review under section 79, section 80, section 81, section 82 or section 83, or to confer on a dealer any relief in addition to what he is entitled under the provisions of this Act.

(61) Reimbursement of tax levied under the Act in respect of……. Or inter-State sales of declared goods.— (1) Where a tax has been levied under this Act in respect of the sale or purchase of any goods referred to in section 14 of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956, and such goods are subsequently sold in the course of inter-State trade or commerce, and tax has been paid under that Act in respect of sale of such goods in the course of inter-State trade or commerce, the tax levied or paid under this Act shall be reimbursed to the dealer making such sale in the course of inter-State trade or commerce in the manner and subject to the conditions hereinafter provided.

(2) The dealer making the sale of such goods in the course of inter-State trade or commerce referred to in sub-section (1) shall, in the prescribed manner, make an application to the Commissioner for reimbursement of the tax levied under this Act on sale to, or purchase by, him of such goods within one year from the date of such inter-State sale.

(3) On receipt of an application from a dealer under sub-section (2), the Commissioner shall, after giving such dealer an opportunity of being heard and after recording reasons for so doing, make an order either granting or rejecting the application wholly or in part.

(4) When an application for reimbursement of tax is granted under sub-section (3) the amount of tax levied under this Act shall be reimbursed to the dealer in the manner referred to in section 60 as if it were a tax refundable under this Act to the dealer.

West Bengal Value Added Tax (WBVAT) Act, 2003:

(2) (1) ………………………….

(2) ………………………

(3) ……………………..

“(11) “dealer” means any person who carries on the business of selling or purchasing goods in West Bengal or any person making sales under Section 14, and includes –

(a) An occupier of a jute-mill or shipper of jute,

(b) Government, a local authority, a statutory body, a trust or other body corporate which, or a liquidator or receiver appointed by a court in respect of a person, being a dealer as defined in this clause, who, whether or not in the course of business, sells, supplies or distributes directly or otherwise goods for cash or for deferred payment or for commission, remuneration or other valuable consideration,

(c) a society including a co-operative society, club or any association which sells goods to its members or others for cash, or for deferred payment, or for commission, or for remuneration, or for other valuable consideration,

(d) a factor, a broker, a commission agent, a del credre agent an auctioneer, an agent for handling of document of title to goods, or any other mercantile agent, by whatever name called, and whether of the same description as hereinbefore mentioned or not, who carries on the business of selling goods and who has, in the customary course of business, authority to sell goods belonging to principles;

CST Rules, 1956

(12). (1) The declaration and the certificate referred to in sub-section (4) of section 8 shall be in Forms C and D respectively:

……………………….

………………………

(7) The declaration in Form “C” or Form “F” or the certificate in Form E-I or Form E-II shall be furnished to the prescribed authority within three months after the end of the period to which the declaration or the certificate relates:

Provided that if the prescribed authority is satisfied that the person concerned was prevented by sufficient cause from furnishing such declaration or certificate within the aforesaid time, that authority may allow such declaration or certificate to be furnished within such further time as that authority may permit.

Now I would like to make little discussion on the ambit and scope of the aforesaid relevant provisions of law:

Under Section 6 of CST Act the liability, in the case of an inter-State sale, liability to pay tax is that of the seller (i.e. IOCL herein). This tax is imposed by the Central Government. However, in view of Section 9(2) of the CST Act the authorities of the selling State (i.e. State Government of West Bengal) have been delegated the powers of assessment, re-assessment, collection and refund of tax under the respective State legislations on behalf of the Union of India. Even though the tax is collected by the State Government on behalf of the Union of India, the proceeds so collected are assigned to the State Government and retained by it in view of Section 9(3) of the CST Act.

Section 8 of the CST Act provides for the rate of tax. Sections 8(1), 8(3) and 8(4) of the CST Act read with Rule 12 of the CST Rules provide for a concessional rate of tax, when goods are purchased to be used either for the purposes of resale or for the purposes of manufacture or for use in mining. Such a concessional rate of tax is available provided that:

Want to Read the Complete Judgment?

You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.

Read on with Premium
Goes straight to payment. GST invoice included.

One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.

Advertisement

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.