Texo The Builders Vs ACIT (ITAT Bangalore)
VAT Bills Don’t Save Cash Payments – ITAT Upholds 40A(3) Despite Genuine Purchases- Cash Payments on Working Days Hit by 40A(3),
Assessee is a real-estate developer. Survey u/s 133A led to detection of substantial cash payments toward materials, labour & other project expenses. AO held that several payments exceeded the monetary limit prescribed u/s 40A(3), made on working days, & not covered by Rule 6DD exceptions. AO completed reassessment u/s 147 with major disallowances. CIT(A) partly allowed relief, directing AO to verify payments category-wise, particularly those claimed to be made on Sundays/bank-holidays, labour payments & material purchases with VAT-paid bills. AO passed OGE, granting partial relief but confirming violations of 40A(3).
Before Tribunal, Assessee argued that construction activity runs through weekends, cash payments were business-expedient, many invoices were < Rs.20,000, labourers were paid individually, & several payments were on non-banking days attracting Rule 6DD(j). Revenue contended that Assessee failed to prove any bank-holiday payments & could not justify cash payments.
Tribunal noted that for AY 2013-14, payments totalling Rs.3,41,850/- were made on regular banking days & not protected by Rule 6DD. Only one item-labour development cess of Rs.99,000/–was remitted back for limited verification to confirm whether it was paid to a Government department, in which event it would not attract 40A(3). Remaining Rs.2,42,850/- was confirmed. Tribunal also upheld disallowance of Rs.6,72,380/- claimed as bank-holiday/Sunday payments since AO’s verification showed all such payments were on working days.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.




