Goswami Bhagwan Lal Education Society Vs ITO (ITAT Delhi)
10(23C) / 11 Exemption Cannot Be Denied in 143(1)- CPC Cannot Tax Gross Receipts of a School -Failure to File Form 10B is Curable; 139(9) Opportunity Mandatory
Assessee, an educational society, filed ITR on 19.09.2015 declaring NIL income after claiming exemption u/s 10(23C)(via). Audit report was uploaded in Form 10BB (meant for institutions claiming exemption under clauses of s.10(23C)), whereas the ITR reflected claim u/s 11. CPC processed the return u/s 143(1), held the claim u/s 10(23C)(via) ineligible, also denied alternate claim u/s 11 for want of Form 10B, & taxed the entire gross receipts of Rs.1,18,22,502 instead of surplus of Rs.23,47,095.
CIT(A) upheld CPC’s action, holding that inconsistency between Form 10BB & ITR justified 143(1)(a)(ii) adjustment & that if exemption under 10(23C) or 11 fails, entire receipts, not income, become taxable.
Before Tribunal, Assessee argued:
- At most CPC could have treated the return as defective u/s 139(9) & given opportunity to upload Form 10B.
- Filing of Form 10B is directory & a curable defect, supported by CBDT Circular 10/2019 (22.05.2019) & judgments (Rai Bahadur Bissesswarlal Trust, Sankulp Welfare Society, National Horticulture Board, Sahja Nand Charity Trust).
- Even if exemption fails, CPC cannot tax gross receipts; only income embedded can be taxed.
- Disallowance of all expenditure under 143(1) is not a prima facie adjustment & is legally impermissible.
Tribunal accepted the arguments & held:
- Non-filing of Form 10B is a curable defect, reinforced by CBDT Circular 10/2019 & cited case law.
- Denial of exemption u/s 11 without giving 139(9) opportunity is a debatable issue, hence not permissible u/s.143(1).
- Disallowance of entire expenses in 143(1) is contrary to law; if exemption fails, income has to be computed under “Income from Other Sources” allowing deductions u/s 57.
- Only income embedded in receipts can be taxed, not the entire gross receipts.
Accordingly, ITAT set aside the CIT(A)’s order & restored the matter to AO to:
(i) give opportunity u/s 139(9);
(ii) allow assessee to file Form 10B & seek condonation;
(iii) re-examine eligibility u/s 11/10(23C);
(iv) compute only income, not receipts, if exemption is denied.
FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF ITAT DELHI
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.






