In a setback to telecom service provider Vodafone, the Income Tax Department on Monday said it has the jurisdiction to tax the $11.1-billion Vodafone- Hutchison Essar deal of February 2007. “We have jurisdiction over taxing Vodafone. Jurisdiction order has been issued … We will send the tax demand to them within few days,” Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) chairman S S N Moorthy told media.
Though Moorthy has not mentioned the tax liability of Vodafone, it is estimated to be around $2 billion.
Vodafone confirmed that it has received an order from the tax department today on the preliminary issue of jurisdiction.
“Vodafone remains fully confident that no tax is payable by Hutchison in this transaction and that Vodafone has no liability in any event, and all the taxation and legal advice received continues to be consistent with this view,” Vodafone Group said in a statement.
The dispute concerns Vodafone Group Plc’s acquisition of a 67 per cent stake in Hutchison Essar from Hong Kong’s Hutchison Telecommunications International Ltd. The I-T department is of the opinion that the transaction is taxable in the country.
Earlier, Vodafone had also approached the Supreme Court, which had refused to intervene in the tax dispute between the telecom firm and the I-T department and had asked the department to check whether it has the jurisdiction to proceed further in the tax case.
Vodafone had paid $11.1 billion for a 67 per cent stake of Hutchison in Hutchison-Essar (since renamed Vodafone Essar) in 2007.
The government approved the deal in May, 2007, itself. After regulatory clearances were given, the tax department issued a show-cause notice to Vodafone saying the company did not deduct tax, estimated at around $2 billion.
In 2007, Vodafone received a show-cause notice asking it why it had not done this. Following this, the company approached the Bombay High Court. After the high court dismissed Vodafone’s petition challenging the I-T department’s notice, the company moved the Supreme Court in January, 2009.
The primary question that Vodafone requested the apex court to answer was whether Indian authorities have the jurisdiction to tax a transaction that occurred outside India between two global players.
Till October the tax department studied the documents of Vodafone. In October 30, 2009, it had issued another showcause notice to Vodafone asking the company why they think that the IT department has no jurisdiction over them.
Vodafone was given time to file their detailed response by November, 16, 2009.
The company had sought extension till January this year. On January 29, Vodafone had filed their detailed response to the notice. After studying its response, the IT department issued another show cause notice to Vodafone today.
“Vodafone will be reviewing the documents in detail. The Supreme Court granted Vodafone the right of appeal to the Bombay High Court if we disagree with the tax authorities determination,” the company said.
