Steel Authority of India Ltd. Vs Principal Commissioner (CESTAT Delhi)
The case of Steel Authority of India Ltd. Vs Principal Commissioner (CESTAT Delhi) revolves around whether service tax could be levied on liquidated damages, penalties, and forfeiture of security deposits in case of non-fulfilment of contractual obligations.
Analysis: In the original order dated November 22, 2017, the Principal Commissioner affirmed the demand for service tax along with interest and penalty from the Steel Authority of India Ltd. The service tax was demanded on the basis of amounts collected by the appellant in terms of liquidated damages, penalties, and forfeiture of security deposits under section 65B(44) and section 66E of the Finance Act, 19941.
However, the appellant argued that these charges were not taxable services but safeguards included in their contracts to ensure timely and quality delivery of services. The Principal Commissioner, despite these arguments, confirmed the service tax demand.
The CESTAT Delhi, referencing prior tribunal rulings, observed that service tax could only be levied when there is a flow of consideration for a specific activity. In this case, penalties, liquidated damages, and forfeitures are not considered ‘services’ but are compensatory mechanisms triggered due to non-compliance with the contract. The tribunal also cited Circular No. 214/1/2023-Service Tax dated: 28th February, 2023 which stated that service tax could not be levied on amounts collected as liquidated damages.
Conclusion: The CESTAT Delhi concluded that the amounts collected as penalties, liquidated damages, and forfeiture of security deposits could not be subjected to service tax. The ruling underscores the principle that service tax applies to activities conducted for consideration, not penalties imposed due to contract breaches. This landmark ruling helps to clarify the scope of service tax in contract law, particularly in the context of non-compliance penalties.
FULL TEXT OF THE CESTAT DELHI ORDER
1. The order dated November 22, 2017 passed by the Principal Commissioner confirming the demand of service tax with interest and penalty for the reason that the amount collected by the appellant on account of liquidated damages, penalty and forfeiture of security deposits would be leviable to service tax under section 65B(44) and section 66E of the Finance Act, 19941, has been assailed in this appeal.
2. The appellant, which is engaged in the manufacture of Blooms, Slabs, TMT Bars, Plates, Angles, Joists, Channels and Rails, entered into supply contracts and works contracts with suppliers/service providers for supply of goods as well as rendering of services to the appellant. The appellant claims that to ensure smooth operations of the business of the appellant and timely execution of the said contracts, clauses relating to liquidated damages, penalty, forfeiture of earnest money/ security deposits were included as part of the terms of such Agreements/Purchase orders and situations in which such charges were collected by appellant have also been stated by the appellant in the following manner:
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.


