SEBI’s New Framework on Financial Penalties for Surveillance Lapses at MIIs: The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) has issued a new circular establishing a framework for imposing financial penalties on Market Infrastructure Institutions (MIIs) for surveillance-related lapses. This initiative, detailed in circular SEBI/HO/ISD/ISD-PoD-1/P/CIR/2024/73 dated June 6, 2024, aims to bolster the integrity and safety of the securities market. The framework will come into effect from July 1, 2024.
Introduction: Market Infrastructure Institutions, including stock exchanges, clearing corporations, and depositories, play a pivotal role in the development and functioning of the securities market. Given the substantial increase in trading activity and the adoption of sophisticated trading strategies, the role of MIIs in surveillance has become even more critical. SEBI’s latest directive emphasizes the importance of these institutions in detecting and preventing market abuses, ensuring investor confidence and market integrity.
Detailed Analysis
Role and Responsibilities of MIIs: MIIs serve as the frontline regulators of the securities market, equipped with the mandate to monitor and oversee trading activities and the behavior of market participants. According to the SEBI Act of 1992 and subsequent regulations, MIIs are entrusted with the responsibility to detect and report any manipulative or abusive trading activities.
The new framework specifies that surveillance activities should include:
- Monitoring daily market activities such as trading, margining, settlement, demat transactions, and holdings.
- Keeping an eye on market intermediaries through alert generation, trading rationale requests, and preliminary to detailed examinations.
- Reporting abnormal or suspicious activities to SEBI.
- Implementing decisions from surveillance meetings promptly and accurately.
- Taking pre-emptive measures as guided by SEBI.
Financial Disincentives for Lapses: The framework introduces financial penalties for MIIs based on the severity and frequency of surveillance lapses. These penalties are structured according to the total annual revenue of the MII and the number of lapses detected within a financial year:
| Total Annual Revenue (INR) | First Instance | Second Instance | Third Instance Onwards |
| > 1000 crore | 25 Lakhs | 50 Lakhs | 1 Crore |
| 1000 crore – 300 crore | 5 Lakhs | 10 Lakhs | 20 Lakhs |
| < 300 crore | 1 Lakh | 2 Lakhs | 4 Lakhs |
Implementation and Compliance: Upon identifying a surveillance lapse, SEBI will allow the concerned MII to present its case. If financial disincentives are imposed, the MII must credit the specified amount to the Investor Protection and Education Fund (SEBI–IPEF) within 15 working days. MIIs are also required to disclose these penalties on their websites and in their annual reports, ensuring transparency and accountability.
Exceptions and Administrative Procedures: The framework excludes certain minor procedural lapses from financial penalties, treating them instead with administrative actions such as warnings. These minor lapses include small delays in information submission, minor errors corrected promptly, and delays due to uncontrollable factors.
*****
Securities and Exchange Board of India
Circular No. SEBI/HO/ISD/ISD-PoD-1/P/CIR/2024/73 Dated: June 6, 2024
To,
All Recognized Stock Exchanges,
All Clearing Corporations,
All Depositories,
Madam/Sir,
Sub.: Framework of “Financial Disincentives for Surveillance Related Lapses” at Market Infrastructure Institutions.
1. Market infrastructure Institutions (i.e. Stock Exchanges, Clearing Corporations and Depositories) are systemically important institutions for the development of the securities market. The role of surveillance at Market Infrastructure Institutions (“MIIs”) has become crucial in ensuring the safety and integrity of securities market in view of the significant increase in trading activity during the past few years, increased participation by retail individual investors, increased trading activity in the derivatives segment and deployment of new trading techniques and strategies by market participants.
2. MIIs, being the first-level regulators, are expected to be in the know of the ground realities of the securities market and their constituents and updations thereof. The MIIs, supervise their members in terms of the respective bye-laws framed under the Securities Contracts (Regulation) Act, 1956 (“SCRA”) / Depositories Act, 1996. They need to be well equipped to detect market abuse, including new modus-operandi that could be adopted by unscrupulous elements and take suitable, prompt, effective and preventive action against such activities.
3. The Securities and Exchange Board of India Act, 1992 (“SEBI Act, 1992”) inter alia requires the Securities and Exchange Board of India (“SEBI”) to protect the interest of investors in securities and to regulate the market through measures that may provide for regulating the business in the stock exchanges and the working of the depositories.
4. Regulation 49 (2) of the Securities Contracts (Regulation) (Stock Exchanges and Clearing Corporations) Regulations, 2018 (“SECC Regulations, 2018”) empowers SEBI to take action against a recognised stock exchange or recognised clearing corporation for any contravention of the SCRA, the SEBI Act, 1992, any rules or regulations framed thereunder and any circulars or directions issued by SEBI. Similarly, Regulation 91A (2) of the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Depositories and Participants) Regulations, 2018 (“DP Regulations, 2018”) empowers SEBI to take action against a depository for any contravention of the SEBI Act, 1992, the Depositories Act, 1996, any rules or regulations framed thereunder and any circulars or directions issued by SEBI.
5. As per Regulation 28 (2) read with Part–C of Schedule II of the SECC Regulations, 2018, the surveillance function of a Stock Exchange is considered as a core function. Similarly, Regulation 2 (k) (iii) read with Fourth Schedule of the DP Regulations, 2018 classifies surveillance as part of the core functions of the Depository.
6. The general objective of surveillance by MIIs is thus to monitor the market to detect and deter manipulation or abusive trading that affects the integrity of the market, and to provide information that supports the Regulator’s enforcement actions. In this backdrop, market surveillance by MIIs may be said to include, but not limited to the following broad activities as may be applicable from time to time:
6.1. Monitoring the day-to-day activities in the markets including trading / margining / settlement / demat transactions / holdings;
6.2. Monitoring the conduct of market intermediaries through generation and processing of alerts, seeking trading rationale, carrying out snap analysis / preliminary examination and if required, detailed analysis / examination and timely submission of Report to SEBI.
6.3. Reporting of abnormal / suspicious activities as per the framework that is to be communicated by SEBI.
6.4. Promptly implementing the decisions taken in the surveillance meetings.
6.5. Endeavouring to take pre-emptive surveillance measures as per any framework that may be communicated by SEBI.
7. Since any lapse in monitoring to detect and deter manipulative or abusive trading would show lacking adequate actions for surveillance related activity on the part of MIIs that may have an adverse effect on the investors’ trust and confidence in the securities market, it has been decided by SEBI, after consultation with MIIs, for MIIs to implement a framework for Surveillance Related Lapses at MIIs as stated at para 8.1 below that shall be applicable to Surveillance Related Lapses emanating from non-adherence to the requisite surveillance activities / decisions taken in the surveillance meetings, which does not involve any subjective discretionary deviations or discretionary value judgments.
8. Framework of Financial Disincentives for Surveillance Related Lapses at MIIs:
8.1. Surveillance Related Lapses:
8.1.1. Surveillance Related Lapse (“SRL”), shall mean and include the following:
8.1.1.1. Any lapse observed in the implementation of decisions taken during the Surveillance Meetings including any non-implementation or partial implementation or delayed implementation of any decision or communication of SEBI relating to surveillance as per agreed scope and timelines;
8.1.1.2. Any lapse observed in discharge of surveillance activities as per agreed scope and timelines; and
8.1.1.3. Any inadequate reporting or non-reporting of surveillance related activity as per agreed timelines.
8.2. Amount of Financial Disincentives
8.2.1. The amount of financial disincentives as per the framework of financial disincentives for Surveillance Related Lapses (“FDSRL”) at MIIs, as detailed below, shall be determined on the basis of total annual revenue of the MII, as an indicator of the size and impact of the MII on the market ecosystem, during the previous Financial Year as per the latest audited consolidated annual financial statement and the number of instances of Surveillance Related Lapses during the Financial Year.
| Financial Disincentive (INR) | |||
| Total Annual Revenue (INR) of MII
No. of Instances of SRL in FY |
>1000cr | 1000cr – 300cr | < 300cr |
| FIRST instance | 25 Lakhs | 5 Lakhs | 1 Lakh |
| SECOND instance | 50 Lakhs | 10 Lakhs | 2 Lakhs |
| THIRD instance onwards – for each instance during the FY. | 1 Crore | 20 Lakhs | 4 Lakhs |
8.3. Procedure upon identification of SRL:
8.3.1. Upon identification of SRL at MIIs, as indicated in para 8.1 above or upon receipt of information of any such instances, SEBI shall provide an opportunity to the concerned MII to make its submissions, in respect of the SRL.
8.3.2. The submissions made by the concerned MII shall be considered by SEBI before imposing any “Financial Disincentive” on the concerned MII as per the framework.
8.3.3. The “Financial Disincentive(s)” under the framework of FDSRL, if imposed, shall be credited by the MII concerned within 15 working days, to the Investor Protection and Education Fund (“SEBI–IPEF”) established under the SEBI Act, 1992 and a confirmation of payment in this regard shall be forwarded to SEBI.
8.4. Disclosure:
8.4.1. MIIs shall disclose on their websites (and in their respective annual reports) the details pertaining to financial disincentive(s) if any, credited to the SEBI–IPEF under the framework for FDSRL at MIIs as specified in this circular. Further, listed MIIs make appropriate disclosures required in terms of the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2015, regarding any financial disincentive(s) imposed by SEBI under this circular.
8.5. Applicability:
8.5.1. The framework of FDSRL at MIIs shall not be applicable to matters/instances wherein it:
8.5.1.1. has market wide impact, or
8.5.1.2. caused losses to a large number of investors, or
8.5.1.3. affected the integrity of the market, and any such matter shall be subject to appropriate proceedings under the SCRA/ SEBI Act, 1992/ Depositories Act, 1996.
8.5.2. The framework of FDSRL at MIIs shall not be applicable for matters/instances that are procedural in nature, including the following:
8.5.2.1. Minor delays like 1-2 working days in providing information sought by SEBI, or
8.5.2.2. Minor errors in the information provided which is corrected in a short span of time, or
8.5.2.3. Minor errors in the submissions which are corrected on their own, or
8.5.2.4. Minor extension sought for submissions, or
8.5.2.5. Extension sought due to factors beyond the control of the MII, and any delay/ error/ lapse that is considered as minor by SEBI may be subject to administrative proceedings like warnings etc.
8.5.3. This circular shall come into effect from July 1, 2024 and the framework of FDSRL at MIIs shall be applicable for any surveillance related lapse occurring on or after the said date.
9. The framework for FDSRL at MIIs shall be without prejudice to the right of SEBI to initiate any other action(s) as deemed appropriate under the provisions of the SCRA, the SEBI Act, 1992, the Depositories Act, 1996 and the rules and regulations framed thereunder.
10. This circular is being issued in exercise of powers conferred under Section 11 (1) of the Securities and Exchange Board of India Act, 1992, to protect the interests of investors in securities and to promote the development of, and to regulate the securities market.
11. This circular is available on SEBI website at sebi.gov.in under the category “Legal ⇒ Circulars”.
Yours faithfully,
Versha Agarwal
General Manager
Integrated Surveillance Department
+91-22-26449728
[email protected]
