Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Income Tax

Ex-Parte Income Tax Appeal Order Set Aside for Fresh Adjudication: ITAT Indore

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2026 taxguru.in 19155
Case Name
Laxminaryan Patidar Vs ITO (ITAT Indore)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Related Assessment Year
2012-13
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Laxminaryan Patidar Vs ITO (ITAT Indore)

Summary: The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Indore Bench, set aside an ex-parte order of the CIT(A) and restored the matter for fresh adjudication. For Assessment Year 2012-13, the assessee returned income of Rs.6,040, whereas the assessment order dated 03.12.2019 determined income at Rs.95,78,165, including additions of Rs.3,23,750 from undisclosed sources, Rs.84,00,000 as unexplained money and Rs.8,48,375 as unexplained expenditure. The CIT(A) dismissed the appeal following non-compliance with notices. The assessee challenged the additions under Sections 69A and 69C, reassessment jurisdiction, notice under Section 148, compliance with CBDT Circular No. 19/2019 and initiation of penalty under Section 271(1)(c).

The authorised representative submitted that the assessee, a senior citizen and rural agriculturist unfamiliar with computers and income tax laws, had expressly opted against email communications in the appeal form. Notices were allegedly sent to an email address different from that of his former tax preparer, despite his request for physical notices. He learnt of the appellate order when recovery proceedings commenced on 19.12.2025 and filed the Tribunal appeal on 27.01.2026 after engaging a new chartered accountant. The submissions were supported by an affidavit dated 15.10.2026. The registry recorded a delay of 149 days, while the submissions also referred to 151 days. The departmental representative left condonation to the Tribunal.

The Tribunal noted that the assessment order was bipartite whereas the appellate order was ex-parte. It condoned the delay, admitted the appeal and remanded the matter to the CIT(A) for de novo adjudication. The assessee was directed to provide updated email addresses for himself and his counsel, cooperate and avoid adjournments on flimsy grounds. The CIT(A) was directed to pass an expeditious, reasoned and speaking order on merits. The appeal was allowed for statistical purposes; the substantive additions and jurisdictional objections were not decided.

Cases Discussed

  • B.N. Bhattacharjee and Another (Supreme Court); 118 ITR 461 – Cited by CIT(A) on pursuing an appeal effectively.
  • M/s Chemipol Vs Union of India (Bombay High Court); Excise Appeal No. 62 of 2009 – Cited by CIT(A) regarding dismissal for non-prosecution.
  • Sunderlal Mannalal Vs Nandramdas Dwarkadas; AIR 1958 MP 260 – Cited in the reproduced appellate order regarding inherent power of dismissal.

Assessee was Represented by: Sh. Milind Wadwani, CA & Ms.Shradha Piplodia, Adv

FULL TEXT OF THE ORIGINAL JUDGMENT/ORDER

This is an Appeal filed by the Assessee under section 253 of the Income Tax Act 1961, [ herein after referred to as the Act for the sake of brevity] before this tribunal as & by way of a second Appeal. The Assessee is aggrieved by the order bearing Number:- ITBA / NFAC / S / 250 / 2025-26 / 1076837382(1) dated 09.06.2026 passed by the Ld. CIT(A) U/S 250 of the Act, which is herein after referred to as the “Impugned Order”. The Relevant Assessment Year is 2012-13 and the corresponding previous year period is from 01.04.2011 to 31.03.2012.

2. FACTUAL MATRIX

2.1 That as and by way of an Assessment Order made u/s 143(3) of the Act, the total Income of the Assessee was computed and Assessed at Rs 95,78,165/-. The total income as returned was at Rs.6040/-. The Ld Assessing Officer made an addition of Rs. 3,23,750/- as income from the undisclosed sources by virtue of para 4.3, added unexplained money by virtue of para 7 of Rs.84,00,000/- & so also added unexplained expenditure of Rs.8,48,375/- by virtue of para 8.4. That the aforesaid assessment order is dated 03.12.2019 which is hereinafter referred to as the “Impugned Assessment Order”.

2.2 That the Assessee being Aggrieved by the aforesaid “Impugned Assessment Order” prefers the first appeal u/s 246A of the Act before the Ld CIT(A) who by the “Impugned Order” has dismissed the 1st appeal of the Assessee on the grounds & the reasons stated therein. The core grounds & the reasons for the dismissal of the 1st appeal was as under: –

5.0 Decision:

5.1 The grounds of appeal, copy of assessment order, submissions of the appellant, statement of facts and Form 35 have been carefully considered and adjudicated as under:

5.2 The appeal was filed by appellant on 08/01/2020 against the order u/s. 147 of the IT Act, 1961. In connection to the appeal, opportunities were provided to the appellant to substantiate his grounds of appeal on following dates:

S.No. Date of Notice Date for compliance Remarks
1 06/03/2020 11/03/2020 No response
2 28/07/2023 09/08/2023 No response
3 08/02/2024 23/02/2024 Adjournment 12/02/2024 to 05/03/2024
4 06/03/2024 08/04/2024 No response
6 08/05/2024 23/05/2024 Adjournment 30/08/2024
7 10/09/2024 25/09/2024 No response
8 28/05/2025 04/06/2025 No response

As can be seen from the above table, as many as Eight opportunities have been granted. On verification of the ITBA portal, it is observed that all the above-mentioned hearing notices got delivered to email: [email protected] successfully. It is evident that the appellant is neither filing any details during the appellate proceedings under the principle of natural justice.

5.3 In this regard, the reliance is place on the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of B.N. Bhattacharjee and Another (118 ITR 461) wherein it has been held that appeal does not mean merely filing of memo of appeal but also pursuing it effectively. In cases where the appellant does not want to pursue the appeal, appellate authorities have inherent power to dismiss the appeal for non-prosecution as held by the Hon’ble Bombay High Court in the case of M/s Chemipol vs. Union of India in Excise Appeal No. 62 of 2009. While deciding the issue, the Hon’ble High Court of Bombay has referred to the observations of Hidayatullah, Chief Justice (as His Lordship then was) in Sunderlal Mannalal Vs. Nandramdas Dwarkadas AIR 1958 MP 260 wherein it has been observed: –

“Now the Act does not give any power of dismissal. But it is axiomatic that no court or tribunal is supposed to continue a proceeding before it when the party who has moved it has not appeared nor cared to remain present. The dismissal, therefore, is an inherent power which every tribunal possesses….”

5.4 This appeal has been filed by the appellant claiming that the action of the Assessing Officer is not supported by facts and laws and that it is unjust. In such a situation, it is for the appellant to furnish submissions with relevant evidence(s), case laws, if any, to support the claim. The ‘burden of proof’ is always on the person who makes the claim. In this case, it is the appellant who has made the claim by filing the appeal. Thus, in cases where a particular receipt is sought to be taxed as income, the initial onus is on the Assessing Officer to prove that it is taxable. Since, an appeal is nothing but the claim of the appellant that he has been unduly unjustifiably taxed, it is for the appellant to prove its case. The appellant has not availed any opportunity to do so.

5.5 From the conduct of the appellant as per the facts noted above, it is clear that the appellant does not wish to pursue the appeal. Further, Though the appellant filed appeal but remained non-compliant during the appellate proceedings also and not furnished any evidences to satisfy the appellate authority. Even otherwise, on the merits of it also, I do not see any reason to differ with the findings of the AO. No attempt has been made by the appellant to discharge its onus.

5.6 During the A.Y. 2012-13, the appellant has received the unsecured loan of Rs.84,00,000/- from three parties and identity, creditworthiness and genuineness of the transaction of the creditors are not proved therefore, the Assessing Officer added Rs.84,00,000/- as unexplained money. The appellant has not explained the source of expenditure of Rs. 8,48,375/- and evidence for agriculture income of Rs. 3,23,750/- was not furnished, hence, the Assessing Officer has added Rs.8,40,375/- as unexplained expenditure and Rs Rs. 3,23,750/- as income from other sources. During the course of Appellate proceedings, the appellant has neither responded nor filed any details for disproving the facts brought out by the Assessing Officer, hence, the undersigned could not deviate from the Assessment Order. Hence, respectfully following the above-mentioned judicial pronouncements and in view of the facts of the case, the appeal is hereby dismissed.

6.0 In effect, the appeal filed by the appellant is dismissed.

2.3 That the Assessee being aggrieved by the “Impugned Order” has preferred the Instant Appeal before this Tribunal & has raised the following grounds of Appeal in the Form No: -36 against the “Impugned Order” which are as under: –

“1. On the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, The Ld. NFAC erred in upholding the action of Ld. AO in making an addition of Rs. 3,23,750/- made to the income of the appellant.

2. On the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the Ld. NFAC erred in upholding the addition of Rs. 84,00,000/- as unexplained money u/s. 69A.

3. On the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the Ld. NFAC erred in upholding the addition of Rs. 8,48,375/- as unexplained expenditure u/s. 69C.

4. On the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the provisions of Section 69A cannot be invoked.

5. On the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the provisions of Section 69C cannot be invoked.

6. On the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the assessment order dated 03.12.2019 is bad in law, without jurisdiction, and liable to be quashed.

7. On the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the assessment order dated 03.12.2019 is passed in contravention of circular no. 19/2019 hence the order is invalid, and deemed to never have been issued, and hence liable to be quashed.

8. On the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the additions are made on mere conjectures, surmises and suspicions.

9. On the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the assessment was completed without complying with the statutory requirements of law.

10. On the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the assessment order dated 03.12.2019 is contrary to law, facts and circumstances of the case and in any case is opposed to the principles of equity, natural justice and fair play.

11. On the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the notice u/s. 148 is erroneous, void and illegal and liable to be quashed.

12. That the Assessing Officer could not have reason to believe that the income had escaped assessment in the hands of the appellant.

13. That the reassessment is vitiated by mechanical action and borrowed satisfaction, lacking independent application of mind.

14. That the assessment was not reopened based on any new tangible material.

15. That there was no live link between material available on record and reasons to believe.

16. On the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the initiation of penalty proceedings u/s. 271(1)(c) is bad in law.

17. For that the appellant craves leave to add, amend, alter vary and or withdraw any or all the above grounds of appeal.”

3 Record of Hearing

3.1 The hearing in the matter took place before this Tribunal on 02.11.2026 when the Ld AR for & on behalf of the Assessee appeared before us & interalia contended that the “Impugned Order” is bad in law, illegal & not proper. It is in violation of the principles of Natural Justice. It therefore deserves to be set aside.

3.2 The Ld AR has placed on the record of this tribunal a appeal memo containing Pages 1 to 51. In continuation there of PAPER BOOK pages 52 to 58. An affidavit of the Assessee dated 15.10.2026 is too placed on record.

3.3 The Ld AR contended that registry of this tribunal has pointed out a delay of 149 days in filling the Instant appeal. It was submitted that “Impugned Order” is dated 09.06.2025. The date of receipt of the “Impugned Order” is dated 09.06.2025 (Form 36). The Instant Second appeal is filed on 27.01.2026 abeit delay of 149 days. The Ld AR then invited our attention to Appeal Memo Page 18 wherein respect of Column “Whether Notices/Communication may be sent on email?” The Assessee had expressly stated as “NO” as an Answer. The Assessee thus had requested for the physical Notices from the Ld CIT(A) & not electronic Notice(s). Our attention was next invited to appeal memo Pages 15 wherein Notice(s) about seven in Number were issued to the Assessee by the Ld CIT(A) which are all tabulated in Para 5.2 of the “Impugned Order”. It was submitted by the Ld AR basis PAPER BOOK Pages 52 to 58 that all the 7 Notice(s) were served on email address [email protected] which were totally contrary to his request for the physical copy of the Notice(s) as the Assessee was a Senior Citizen & a Rural Agriculturist & was not at all conversant with computer, technical, internet & Income Tax Laws etc. Further the above email ID is a totally different email ID as the Assessee email was [email protected] which was of his Previous “Tax Preparer”. The LD AR further submitted that when the Dept started recovery proceedings on 19.12.2025 he learnt about passing of the “Impugned Order” against him & upon making Inquiry with the previous “Tax Filer” / “Tax Preparer” No proper answer was given to him. Then the new CA was contacted & present appeal was filed on 27.01.2026 & therefore there is a delay of 151 days. It was therefore finally stated that the delay is unintentional & unfortunate. It was prayed that the Assessee be pardoned for this delay & his appeal be admitted for Adjudication after condoning the delay. Per contra the LD DR appearing for the Revenue contended that on the Issue of delay he leaves it to this tribunal to take an appropriate call basis law. In rejoinder argument the Ld AR submitted that all facts narrated by him are affirmed in the affidavit dt 15.10.2026 of the Assessee & in ultimate analysis of facts it will be noticed that “Impugned Order” is passed without hearing the Assessee which is in the breaches of the Principle of Natural Justice. Hence the “Impugned Order” should be set aside & matter be remanded back to the Ld CIT(A) on Denovo Basis. The hearing was then over & closed.

4. Observations, Finding and Conclusions

4.1 We how have to decide the legality, validity and proprietary of the “Impugned Order” basis records of the case & the rival submission canvassed before us.

4.2 We have carefully perused the records of the case and have heard the submissions.

4.3 We basis records of the case & after hearing & upon examining the rival contentions of the Ld. AR & the Ld. DR canvassed before us, are of the considered opinion that though the “Impugned Assessment Order” is an Biparte Order whereas the “Impugned Order” is an Exparte one. Under these facts & circumstances we do not have anything on merits in so far as the “Impugned Order” is concerned. Therefore, we set aside the “Impugned Order” & remand the case back to the Ld CIT(A) on denovo basis. The delay however is condoned too & appeal is admitted. We direct the Assessee to give his latest email Id & of his counsel where the Notice(s) etc. could be served by the Dept. We direct the Assessee & his counsel to Cooperate with the Ld CIT(A) in such a manner that at least first Appeal of the Assessee is disposed off effectively on the merits. The Assessee & his counsel are directed not to taken any adjournments on any flimsy grounds. The Ld CIT(A) is directed to pass a reasoned & a speaking order on merits as expeditiously as possible.

4.4 In view of the above, we set aside the “Impugned Order” & remand the case back to file of the Ld CIT(A) on the denovo basis, who shall now pass a speaking & a well-reasoned order.

5 Order

5.1 In result the Impugned Order is set aside as and by way of remand back to the file of the Ld CIT(A).

5.2 In result, appeal is allowed for statistical purpose.

Pronounced in open court on 13.11.2026.

Advertisement

Author Info

CA Sandeep Kanoi
Qualification: Graduate, CA in Job / Business, DD
Company: Taxguru Consultancy
Location: Mumbai, Maharashtra
Articles Published: 24,807

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.