Atanu Mondal Vs Stores and Spares Co. (GSTAT Kolkata)
Summary : The GST Appellate Tribunal, Kolkata Bench, dismissed the Revenue’s appeal against the appellate order granting transitional input tax credit of ₹36,35,704 to Stores and Spares Co. The dispute arose because the taxpayer, a registered dealer under the erstwhile Central Excise regime, had inadvertently reported its transitional credit in Table 5(a) instead of Table 7(a) of Form GST TRAN-1. The Department contended that Table 5(a) applied to credit carried forward under Section 140(1) of the CGST Act, 2017, whereas the taxpayer’s claim was governed by Section 140(3). Consequently, the adjudicating authority ordered recovery of the credit under Section 73. The first appellate authority, however, held that the taxpayer’s substantive entitlement could not be defeated merely because the credit had been entered under the wrong table, particularly when its eligibility under Section 140(3) had not been disputed in the show cause notice or adjudication order.
The Tribunal examined the distinction between substantive eligibility and procedural compliance under Section 140 of the CGST Act and Rule 117 of the CGST Rules. Relying on judicial precedents, including Blue Bird Pure Pvt. Ltd., R.R. Distributors Pvt. Ltd., Calcutta Radio Service Pvt. Ltd. and Adfert Technologies Pvt. Ltd., it observed that inadvertent mistakes in filing TRAN-1 cannot, by themselves, extinguish otherwise admissible transitional credit. The Tribunal also rejected the adjudicating authority’s reasoning that earlier judicial decisions had become inapplicable following CBIC Circular No. 180/12/2022-GST dated 09.09.2022. The underlying judicial principle remained that procedural lapses should not impair substantive rights where the taxpayer is otherwise eligible.
On the Revenue’s additional contention that the taxpayer had failed to establish eligibility under Section 140(3), the Tribunal found that neither the show cause notice nor the original adjudication order had raised that substantive objection. The taxpayer had offered supporting invoices and registers, but the adjudicating authority confined the proceedings to the incorrect TRAN-1 entry without undertaking verification under Rule 121. Applying the principle discussed by the Supreme Court in Shankara Coop. Housing Society Ltd. v. M. Prabhakar, the Tribunal held that the Revenue could not introduce an available but omitted ground at the appellate stage. It further clarified that Section 107(11) empowers the first appellate authority to undertake additional enquiries when necessary but does not mandate such enquiries in every appeal. Finding no infirmity in the first appellate authority’s reasoning, the Tribunal upheld its order and rejected the Revenue’s appeal. The decision reinforces that an incorrect TRAN-1 table entry is not, standing alone, sufficient grounds to deny transitional credit.
Cases Discussed
- Sevoke Motors Vs State of West Bengal; [2022] 142 taxmann.com 374 (Calcutta); 07/07/2022
- Blue Bird Pure Pvt. Ltd. Vs Union of India; [2019] 108 taxmann.com 218 (Delhi); W.P.(C) 3798/2019; 22/07/2019
- Ram Auto Vs Commissioner of Central Taxes & Central Excise; WP(MD) No. 15531 of 2020
- Jakap Metind Pvt. Ltd. Vs Union of India; C/SCA/19951/2018; 04/10/2019
- Union of India Vs Filco Trade Centre Pvt. Ltd.; Supreme Court orders dated 22/07/2022 and 02/09/2022
- R.R. Distributors Pvt. Ltd. Vs Commissioner of Central Tax; [2021] 129 taxmann.com 71 (Delhi); 27/05/2021
- Calcutta Radio Service Pvt. Ltd. (Caltron) Vs Union of India; M.A.T. 283/2024; 27/02/2024
- S.V. Halavagali and Sons Vs Superintendent of Central Excise; (2023) 13 Centax 343 (Karnataka)
- G & C Infra Innovations Vs Union of India; 2022 (65) G.S.T.L. 17 (Kerala)
- Adfert Technologies Pvt. Ltd. Vs Union of India; CWP No. 30949 of 2018 (O&M)
- Siddharth Enterprises Vs The Nodal Officer; 2019-TIOL-2068-HC-AHM-GST
- Shankara Coop. Housing Society Ltd. Vs M. Prabhakar; (2011) 5 SCC 607
FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF GSTAT KOLKATA
Per Anindya Mitra:
1. This appeal has been filed u/s 112(3) by the Revenue assailing the Appellate Order (No.363/CGST/Kol North/2024 dated 31.12.2024) passed by the Additional Commissioner, CGST & CX, Kolkata Appeal-I Commissionerate.
[2] The facts of the case in brief.
I. In the show cause -cum-demand Notice No. 10/GST/AC/SASC/BBD Bag-I/2023-24 dated 09.08.2023 it was alleged by Assistant Commissioner, BBD Bag -I Division, Kolkata North Commissionerate that on scrutiny of Form GST TRAN-1 filed by the taxpayer on 10.07.2017, it was found that they have availed ITC of Rs. 36,35,704/-(CGST) in their Electronic Credit Ledger through Table-5(a) of Form GST TRAN-1 against Central Excise Dealer Registration No. AAKFS6823KXD001. The taxpayer was registered as a Dealer. Therefore, they were not liable to file the statutory returns under Central Excise Law and so, they were not entitled to transfer credit under Table-5(a) of TRAN-1( para 3.1)
II. It was stated in the SCN that sub-section (3) of Section 140 of the CGST Act permits a first stage dealer or a second stage dealer or a registered importer or a depot of a manufacturer to take in his Electronic Credit Ledger, credit of eligible duties in respect of inputs held in stock and inputs contained in semi-finished or finished goods held in stock. But Table-5(a) of Form GST TRAN-1 is prescribed for the amount of CENVAT credit carried forward to Electronic Credit Ledger as Central Tax in respect of Section 140(1), Section 140(4)(a) and Section 140(9) only. Hence, a registered Dealer was not entitled to transfer credit under Table-5(a) of TRAN-1.
IIII. The SCN stated that “for the purpose of verification of their eligibility for availing the above-mentioned ITC, the taxpayer was sent a notice dated 09.04.2021 & 01.07.2021, respectively, requesting them to submit necessary documents. But the taxpayer did neither submit any documents in support of their claim of above -mentioned ITC nor did they make any reply to the Department.” ( para 3.4)
So, the taxpayer was asked to show cause as to why CGST credit amounting to Rs. 36,35,704/- should not be demanded and recovered from them in terms of Section 73(1) of CGST Act, read with Rule 121 of CGST Rules, for availing ineligible ITC.
IV. The taxpayer replied to the above SCN cum demand notice. In his reply he stated, inter alia,
“Post introduction of CGST Act with effect from 01.07.2017, we were entitled to avail Input Tax Credit in Form TRAN-1 for the eligible duties and taxes on inputs, semi-finished and finished goods held as stock under section 140 of CGST Act read with rule 117 of CGST Rules. Due to inadvertence, the form was incorrectly uploaded under Table 5(a) of TRAN-1 instead of 7(a). However, Input Tax Credit amounting to Rs. 36,35,704/- was eligible in terms of the provisions of Section 140(3) of the CGST Act 2017.”( para 4 of the O-I-O)
The taxpayer referred to Section 140(3) of the CGST Act, 2017 which states that a person is eligible to avail credit of duties paid on inputs, semi-finished and finished goods held as stock on 30.06.2017 after fulfilling the following conditions: –
A. Such inputs or goods are used or intended to be used for making taxable supplies under this Act.
B. Registered person is eligible for an input tax credit on such inputs under this Act.
C. The registered person is in possession of an invoice or other prescribed documents evidencing payment of duty under the existing law in respect of such inputs.
D. Invoices or other prescribed documents were issued not earlier than twelve months immediately preceding the appointed day; and
E. Supplier of services is not eligible for any abatement under this Act:
The taxpayer claimed that “All the above conditions have been fulfilled by us at the time of availment of the transitional credit.
A. We are duly registered under the existing tax law i.e. GST as Regular taxpayers.
B. We are in possession of all the invoices on which credit had been claimed, evidencing that Excise Duty on the same had been paid by us. Due to the bulkiness of the file, we are submitting a copy of the invoices on a sample basis. However, at the time of the hearing all the copies of the invoices in original will be produced by us. (Copy of the Invoices on a sample basis are enclosed herewith for your kind perusal as Annexure – A).
C. Credit availed by us on inputs and finished goods were not purchased prior to 01.07.2016 i.e. 12 months prior to appointed date. (Copy of the Invoice-wise and quantity-wise register is enclosed herewith for your kind perusal as Annexure – B).”
(Para 4 of Order-in-Original (O-1-O) No. 19/AC/CGST&CX/BBD BAG-1/GST/2023-24 Date: 10.11.2023)
A personal hearing was held where the authorised representative of the taxpayer reiterated their written reply submitted on 18.09.2023. The Adjudicating Authority mentioned in the O-I-O that the taxpayer had submitted copies of sample invoices and produced hard copies of the related invoices.
VI. Paragraph 6 of the O-I-O contains the discussion and the findings of the O-I-O. The reasoning adopted by the Adjudicating Authority for rejection of the claim of the taxpayer are as follows:
“6.2.1………… the noticee stated that due to inadvertence the form was incorrectly uploaded under Table-5(a) of Form GST TRAN-1 instead of Table-7(a) of the same though, the ITC amounting to Rs.36,35,704/- was eligible in terms of the provisions of Section 140(3) of the CGST Act.”
6.2.2 in support of their plea, the noticee relied upon following judgments wherein Hon’ble Courts held that transitional credit could not be denied on procedural grounds such as recording details in the wrong table in Form GST TRAN-1, etc.: ‘
a. M/s Sevoke Motors versus State of West Bengal, [2022] 142 com 374 (Calcutta), decided on 07.07.2022;
b. M/S Blue Bird Pure Pvt. Ltd. versus Union of India & Ors. on 22 July, 2019, W.P.(C) 3798/2019;
c. M/s Ram Auto versus Commissioner of Central Taxes & Central Excise, WP(MD) No. 15531 of 2020;
d. M/s Jakap Metind Pvt Ltd vs Union of India Through The Secretary & 6 other(s) on 4 October 2019, C/SCA/ 19951/2018; and many more.
6.3.1 in view of above, I find that the noticee have admitted that they have availed the above said ITC through Table-5(a) of Form GST TRAN-1 instead of Table-7(a)(A). But they have tried to justify their mistake by relying upon several judgments with the intention that the mistake on technical grounds may be condoned.
6.3.2 in this regard, I also find that in terms of order dated 22.07.2022 & 02.09.2022 of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Uol versus Filco Trade Centre Pvt. Ltd. and subsequent Circular No.180/12/2022-GST dated 09.09.2022 issued by the CBIC wherein opportunity was given to the taxpayers those who were committed mistake in filing Form GST TRAN-1 to file revised TRAN-1. But in the instant case, the noticee did not avail such opportunity of filing revised TRAN-1 though the Department has pointed out their mistake vide letter dated 09.04.2021 & 01.07.2021.
6.3.3 Further, I find that all judgments, as relied upon by the noticee, were decided before issuance of the Circular No.180/12/2022-GST dated 09.09.2022. After issuance of the Circular No.180/12/2022-GST scenario in respect of transitional credit has been changed. Therefore, those judgments, decided before the Circular No.180/12/2022-GST, are not applicable in this case.
6.3.4 it is, therefore, evident that the noticee have availed the ITC under wrong category which has also been admitted by them and hence, I am of the opinion that the ITC to the tune of Rs. 36,35,704/- (CGST) was wrongly availed by them and thus, such ITC is recoverable from them under Section 73(9) of the CGST Act.”
VII. Aggrieved by the appellate order, the Revenue is before us by way of this appeal in terms of sub-section (3) of Section 112 of CGST Act,2017.
[3] IMPUGNED ORDER-IN APPEAL OF THE FIRST APPELLATE AUTHORITY
I. The Appellate Authority noted that the appellant had entered transitional credit in Table 5(a) of Form GST TRAN-1 instead of Table 7(a), which is the correct table prescribed for recording transitional credit under Section 140(3) of the CGST Act, 2017 by a registered dealer. But he also noted that neither the SCN nor the O-I-O disputed the taxpayer’s entitlement under Section 140(3). His observation is reproduced below:
“7.5. On going through the SCN and impugned O-I-O, I find that the respondent has nowhere disputed the legitimacy of the said transitional credit. The eligibility of ITC under Section 140(3) of the CGST Act, 2017 was not brought into the question by the respondent. Moreover, there is no implication of excess transitional credit taken nor has it been availed of under any other head (SGST/IGST). The respondent’s only concern was that the appellant had availed transitional credit under Table 7(A) in place of Table 5(a) of TRAN-1. Therefore, the issue involved in the present case for consideration is:
Whether transitional credit of Rs. 36,35,704/- (CGST) as availed by the appellant under Table 5(a) in place of Table 7(a)7(A) of TRAN-l is admissible or not.”
II. The grounds on which the First Appellate Authority allowed the appeal of the taxpayer are as follows
(i) Several Hon’ble High Courts have decided in favour of
taxpayers on similar issue. He relied on M/s Blue Bird Pure Pvt Ltd vs Union of India [2019] 108 taxmann.com 218/75 GST 59 (Delhi) and M/s Jakap Metind Pvt Ltd vs Union of India (R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 19951 OF 2018), Gujarat High Court.
(ii) “Substantive rights cannot be denied on account of procedural matters.” and relied on various judgements of the Hon’ble Supreme Court and the High Courts in support of this proposition.
[4] GROUNDS OF APPEAL IN GSTAT
The Revenue has assailed the impugned order and has urged this Tribunal to set aside the same. We reproduce the grounds of appeal.
i. The Appellate Authority, while allowing the appeal filed by the taxpayer, has accepted at Para 7.4 of the impugned O-I-A that the appellant had incorrectly availed transitional credit through Table 5(a) of Form GST TRAN-1 instead of Table 7(a), which is the correct table prescribed for availing transitional credit under Section 140(3) of the CGST Act, 2017 by a registered dealer. However, the Appellate Authority has proceeded to allow the credit solely on the ground that input tax credit (ITC) is a vested right and that it cannot be denied merely on procedural grounds.
ii. In terms of Section 107(11) of the CGST Act, 2017, the Appellate Authority was required to make further enquiry as may be necessary before passing the order. In the instant case, the Appellate Authority has failed to conduct any enquiry, as required under Section 107(11), in regard to eligibility of the taxpayer for availing the transitional credit as held inadmissible by the Adjudicating Authority. The failure of the Appellate Authority to conduct an independent scrutiny of such requisite conditions has rendered the order nonspeaking and legally deficient. Even if the eligibility was not challenged specifically by the department, the Appellate Authority was under a statutory obligation to apply judicial mind and record a finding on the fulfilment of statutory preconditions before granting relief.
(iii) The Appellate Authority has failed to appreciate that the taxpayer was well aware of the mistake committed by them in filing TRAN-1 declaration as the same was brought to their notice twice by the Department on 09.04.2021 and 01.07.2021. Yet, the taxpayer did not take any corrective measure although opportunity was provided to them in terms of Circular No. 180/12/2022-GST dated 09.09.2022 in the light of Hon’ble Supreme Court of India’s orders dated 22.07.2022 and 02.09.2022 in the case of Union of India vs. Filco Trade Centre Pvt. Ltd. It is evident that such inaction on the part of the taxpayer was intentional only to cover up their ineligibility for availing transitional credit in terms of Section 140(1) or 140(3) of the CGST Act, 2017. While there is no dispute that the taxpayer was not eligible to avail transitional credit under Section 140(1), they have not produced or submitted any documentary evidence to support their eligibility of availing credit under Section 140(3) except producing hard copies of the purported invoices to the Adjudicating Authority. Incidentally, the Appellate Authority has not even verified the said invoices, let alone raise any question over non-submission of any other documentary evidence for fulfilling the conditions as laid down in Section 140(3) of the Act. This renders the impugned Order non-speaking and bad in law.”
[5] ANALYSIS AND DECISION
I. We have heard the learned representative for the Revenue and the `Counsel for the taxpayer and perused the records.
II. Section 140 of CGST Act,2017 provides for transitional arrangements for input tax credit. Sub-section (1) to sub-subsection (4) of section 140 specify the eligibility conditions for different categories of registered persons to take, in his Electronic Credit Ledger, transitional credit. Accordingly, Rule 117(1) of CGST Rules, 2017 requires submission of a declaration electronically in FORM GST TRAN- 1 on the common portal. A registered person entitled to take credit of input tax under Section 140 is required to specify in FORM GST TRAN- 1, separately, the amount of input tax credit of eligible taxes and duties to which he is entitled.
III. Sub-section (1) and sub-section (3) of section 140 which are relevant to the present appeal are reproduced below-
“(1) A registered person, other than a person opting to pay tax under section 10, shall be entitled to take, in his electronic credit ledger, the amount of CENVAT credit of eligible duties carried forward in the return relating to the period ending with the day immediately preceding the appointed day, furnished by him under the existing law within such time and in such manner as may be prescribed:
Provided that the registered person shall not be allowed to take credit in the following circumstances, namely: –
A. where the said amount of credit is not admissible as input tax credit under this Act; or
B. where he has not furnished all the returns required under the existing law for the period of six months immediately preceding the appointed date; or
C. where the said amount of credit relates to goods manufactured and cleared under such exemption notifications as are notified by the Government.
“(3)A registered person, who was not liable to be registered under the existing law, or who was engaged in the manufacture of exempted goods or provision of exempted services, or who was providing works contract service and was availing of the benefit of notification No. 26/2012-Service Tax, dated the 20th June, 2012 or a first stage dealer or a second stage dealer or a registered importer or a depot of a manufacturer, shall be entitled to take, in his electronic credit ledger, credit of eligible duties in respect of inputs held in stock and inputs contained in semi-finished or finished goods held in stock on the appointed day, within such time and in such manner as may be prescribed, subject to the following conditions, namely:-
a. such inputs or goods are used or intended to be used for making taxable supplies under this Act;
b. the said registered person is eligible for input tax credit on such inputs under this Act;
c. the said registered person is in possession of invoice or other prescribed documents evidencing payment of duty under the existing law in respect of such inputs;
d. such invoices or other prescribed documents were issued not earlier than twelve months immediately preceding the appointed day; and
e. the supplier of services is not eligible for any abatement under this Act:
Provided that where a registered person, other than a manufacturer or a supplier of services, is not in possession of an invoice or any other documents evidencing payment of duty in respect of inputs, then, such registered person shall, subject to such conditions, limitations and safeguards as may be prescribed, including that the said taxable person shall pass on the benefit of such credit by way of reduced prices to the recipient, be allowed to take credit at such rate and in such manner as may be prescribed.”
1. Registered persons claiming transitional credit under section 140(1) are required to enter the information in Table 5(a) of Form GST TRAN-1. Registered persons claiming transitional credit under section 140(3) are required to enter the information in Table 7(a) of GST TRAN-1.
V. Rule 121 provides for verification of the transitioned credit and if any credit has been wrongly availed, proceedings under section 73 or section 74 shall be initiated.
VI. As per the taxpayer, due to inadvertence, the Form was incorrectly uploaded under Table 5(a) of TRAN-1 instead of 7(a). However, Input Tax Credit amounting to Rs. 36,35,704/- was eligible in terms of the provisions of Section 140(3) of the CGST Act 2017.
VII. First, we shall discuss a few leading case laws on this subject.
VIII. In M/s Blue Bird Pure Pvt. Ltd vs Union of India (2019) 108 com 218 (Del.), a division bench of the Hon’ble Delhi High Court dealt with a case where the petitioner committed an inadvertent error in showing the available stock of goods as on 30th June, 2017 in column 7(d) of TRAN 1 instead of column 7(a). The Court held:
“12. In the present case, the Court is satisfied that, although the failure was on the part of the Petitioner to fill up the data concerning its stock in Column 7(d) of Form TRAN- 1instead of Column 7(a), the error was inadvertent. The Respondents ought to have provided in the system itself a facility for rectification of such errors which are clearly bona fide.”
IX. In R.R. DISTRIBUTORS PVT. LTD vs COMMISSIONER OF CENTRAL TAX, GST, DELHI NORTH [2021] 129 com 71 (Delhi) a division bench of the Hon’ble Delhi High Court observed in its judgement dated 27th May,2021
“Situation similar to the one faced by the present Petitioner has already been considered by this Court in the case of Blue Bird Pure Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India and Ors. In the said case as well, the Petitioner had committed an inadvertent error in showing available stock of goods as on 30th June, 2017 in Column 7(d) instead of 7(a) of the TRAN-1 Form. Noting and relying upon the judgments of this Court in Bhargava Motors v. Union of India and Ors , and Kusum Enterprises Pvt. Ltd. and Ors. v. Union of India and Ors. the Court had directed the Respondents to enable the Petitioner to rectify TRAN-1 Form.
10. As can be seen from the aforesaid decisions, this Court has held that inadvertent and genuine mistakes in filling up the correct details of credit in TRAN-1 Form should not preclude taxpayers from having claims examined by the authorities in accordance with law. This Court has consistently been issuing directions to the Respondents and granting relief to such taxpayers. When the Petitioner attempted to upload TRAN-2 Form, it was prevented to do so because of the error committed by him while making the declaration in the TRAN-1 Form, however, the system did not enable the Petitioner to revise
TRAN-1 Form on the system………………..
11. Further, this Court, in the case of Aadinath Industries & Ors. v. Union of India and Ors. Lease Plan India Private Limited v. Government of National Capital Territory of Delhi and Ors. , Godrej & Boyce Co. Ltd. v. Union of India and……… , Arora & Co v. Union of India & Ors., and M/s Blue Bird (supra), has taken a similar view. In our view, the non-filing of part 7B of table 7(a) and table 7(d) of TRAN-1 Form cannot impair the rights of the petitioner to claim transitional ITC, if he is otherwise eligible. This Court has observed in numerous decisions that the GST system was in a trial-and-error phase as far as its implementation was concerned and ever since GSTN network became operational, taxpayers genuinely faced difficulties in filing the returns and input tax credit in the GST portal. Acknowledging the procedure and difficulties in claiming input tax credit, this Court and several other High Courts have granted relief to such taxpayers. Failure on the part of the Petitioner to give relevant details in TRAN-1 Form can only be taken as a procedural lapse which should not cause any impediment to its right to claim transitional ITC.” (emphasis added by us).
X. In CALCUTTA RADIO SERVICE PRIVATE LIMITED (CALTRON) AND ANR vs UNION OF INDIA (M.A.T 283/2024) the division bench of the Hon’ble Calcutta High Court dealt with a similar situation. The consistent case of the appellants was that they would fall under Entry 7B and inadvertently the TRAN-1 was filed under Entry 7A and the appellants explained that since they are not registered under the Central Excise Act, they are required to file TRAN-1 under Entry 7B. The Hon’ble Court observed in the judgement dated 27.02.2024 :
“ 10. The question would be as to whether on account of such a technical error which undoubtedly is an inadvertent error can the appellants be denied the transitional credit. This issue is no longer res integra and has been considered by several courts as well as this court in a batch of cases in MAT 552 of 2020. More or less an identical issue arose for consideration and the court considered the various orders passed by the other High Courts and disposed of the appeals by permitting the writ petitioners therein to file individual tax credit in GSTR-3B Forms for the relevant months and the assessing officer was at liberty to verify the genuineness of the claim. We are informed that the judgment and order dated 14.12.2021 in MAT 552 of 2020 etc. batch has been given effect to. More recently in the case of S.V. Halavagali and Sons v. Superintendent of Central Excise reported in (2023) 13 Centax 343 (Karnataka) an identical issue arose for consideration before the court. In the said case also there was an inadvertent error and the credit was filed under wrong head i.e. 7(d) instead of 7(b). The court after taking into consideration the various orders passed by the other High Courts directed the authorities to consider the claim of the petitioners therein under Column 7(b) of the CGST Rules, 2017 and if there are supporting documents to make the claim and the claim is established, then consequential relief should be allowed. Earlier similar issue was considered in the case of G & C Infra Innovations v. Union of India reported in 2022 (65) G.S.T.L. 17 (Kerala) wherein the court took note of the fact that after the GST regime came into force the period between 2017 and 2020 ought to be regarded as the nascent period of legislation and admittedly several glitches occurred even from the part of the department. Further, it was pointed out that the courts have repeatedly held that the said period as a trial-and-error phase as far as implementation of the statute was concerned and the taxpayers were also in a state of confusion, during the relevant period………………….
11. Thus, taking note of the law and the subject as well as the facts of the case, it is a fit case where directions should be issued to the authorities to enable the appellants to rectify the mistake and submit GST TRAN-1 under heading 7B of Table 7(a) of Form GST TRAN-1 and the appellants are directed to comply with the same within three weeks from the date of receipt of the server copy of this order after which the adjudicating authority is directed to verify the same and if admissible, extend the transitional credit to the appellants.”
XI. So, it is abundantly clear that filing credit claim in wrong head or Table of Form GST TRAN-1 has been viewed by the Hon’ble High Courts as ‘inadvertent error’ or as “a procedural lapse which should not cause any impediment to its right to claim transitional ITC”. As the Hon’ble Delhi High Court has held in R.R. DISTRIBUTORS PVT. LTD vs COMMISSIONER OF CENTRAL TAX, GST, DELHI NORTH (W.P.(C) 4143/2020,” the non -filing of part 7B of table 7(a) and table 7(d) of TRAN-1 Form cannot impair the rights of the petitioner to claim transitional ITC, if he is otherwise eligible.”
XII. In Adfert Technologies Pvt. Ltd. vs Union of India (CWP No.30949 of 2018 (O&M)), the Hon’ble Punjab & Haryana High Court observed:
“10. During the course of arguments, counsel for the Petitioners submitted various judgments and we find that a Division Bench of Gujrat High Court in the case of Siddharth Enterprises Vs The Nodal Officer 2019-TIOL-2068-HC-AHM-GST has dealt with issue involved at length. It has been held that denial of credit of tax/duty paid under existing Acts would amount to violation of Article 14 and 300A of Constitution of India. Unutilized credit has been recognized as vested right and property in terms of Article 300A of the Constitution of India……. and held
“Accordingly, we direct Respondents to permit the Petitioners to file or revise where already filed incorrect TRAN-1 either electronically or manually statutory Form(s) TRAN-1 on or before 30th November 2019. The Respondents are at liberty to verify genuineness of claim of Petitioners but nobody shall be denied to carry forward legitimate claim of CENVAT / ITC on the ground of non-filing of TRAN-I by 27.12.2017.”
Special leave Petition ( Special Leave to Appeal (C) No.4408/2020) by the Union of India against the judgement in Adfert Technologies Pvt. Ltd was rejected by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
XIII. We are surprised by the observation of the Adjudicating Authority that “I find that all judgments, as relied upon by the noticee, were decided before issuance of the Circular No.180/12/2022-GST dated 09.09.2022. After issuance of the Circular No.180/12/2022-GST scenario in respect of transitional credit has been changed. Therefore, those judgments, decided before the Circular No.180/12/2022-GST, are not applicable in this case.”
The judgements not only permit filing a corrected TRAN-1 but more importantly, reiterate a cardinal principle of law that procedural lapses or technical errors cannot impair the substantive rights of a petitioner if he is otherwise eligible. So, we shall now deal with the matter of eligibility.
XIV. In the Grounds of Appeal, the Revenue has stated “While there is no dispute that the taxpayer was not eligible to avail transitional credit under Section 140(1), they have not produced or submitted any documentary evidence to support their eligibility of availing credit under Section 140(3) except producing hard copies of the purported invoices to the Adjudicating Authority”.
However, the SCN (Show Cause-cum-Demand Notice No. 10/GST/AC/SASC/BBD Bag-I/2023-24 Date: 09.08.2023) or the subsequent O-I-O is completely silent about the taxpayer’s alleged inability to fulfil the conditions laid down in section 140(3). They are based solely on the ground of entry in wrong column of TRAN 1. We reproduce the allegation against the taxpayer in the SCN.
“Whereas it appears from the brief facts of the case narrated here-in-below that M/s Stores & Spares Co., having its principal place of business at 26/1, Strand Road, 3rd Floor, Burrabazar, Kolkata700001, holding GSTIN: 19AAKFS6823K1ZL ………………………. have violated the provision of Section 140 of CGST Act 2017 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the CGST Act’), as amended, inasmuch as they have availed and utilized ineligible transitional credit of CGST of Rs.36,35,704/-………… ….through Table 5(a) of Form GST TRAN-1, as carried forward balance of CENVAT credit as on 30.06.2017 in respect of their legacy Central Excise Registration No. AAKFS6823KXD001, though they are not entitled to transfer credit through Table-5(a) of TRAN-1. Thereby, the said tax amount of Rs.36,35,704/- (CGST) appears to be recoverable from them under Section 73(1) of the CGST Act….” (emphasis added by us ).
We find from the O-I-O that the Department was aware of the error in filling up TRAN-1 by the taxpayer at least since April 2021 and Department informed the taxpayer vide letter dated 09.04.2021 & 01.07.2021. In the Grounds of Appeal before this Tribunal, it has even stated “they have not produced or submitted any documentary evidence to support their eligibility of availing credit under Section 140(3) except producing hard copies of the purported invoices to the Adjudicating Authority”. But the Revenue decided to initiate proceedings u/s 73(1) of CGST Act,2017 and pass the O-I-O , not on the ground of the taxpayer’s alleged ineligibility under section 140(3) of CGST Act,2017 but on a completely different ground, i.e. the taxpayer is not entitled to transfer credit through Table-5(a) of TRAN-1. It is also surprising that although empowered in terms of rule 121 of CGST Rules, 2017, the Revenue never considered it necessary to undertake an enquiry to verify whether the taxpayer fulfilled the conditions for availing transitional credit under section 140(3) of CGST Act,2017.
XV. We have already reproduced in para 2.IV of this order, the contents of the taxpayer’s reply to the SCN. The taxpayer offered to produce the prescribed documents and registers in support of his claim of fulfilment of the conditions under section 140(3) of CGST Act. However the Adjudicating Authority did not deem it necessary to scrutinise the documents or call for additional records. It is amply clear from paragraph no. 6 of the O-I-O that the Adjudicating Authority confined himself only to the issue of availment of transitional credit under the wrong head. Since the adjudicating authority omitted to take the ground of eligibility under section 140(3) of CGST Act,2017 in the O-I-O, it shall be deemed to have been taken by him.
Once the officer while passing the O-I-O has himself constructively held that the omitted ground is not a ground for disallowing the transitional credit , he cannot be allowed to say in appeal that it is so . He cannot be allowed to take such inconsistent stand .It is approbating and reprobating on the same issue .
XVI. In Shankara Coop. Housing Society Ltd. v. M. Prabhakar, reported in (2011) 5 SCC 607, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that the ground of non-compliance of statutory provision which was very much available to the parties to raise but did not raise it as one of the grounds, cannot be raised later on and would be hit by the principles analogous to constructive res judicata. The relevant observations read as under: –
“89. In the present case, it is admitted fact that when the contesting respondents filed WP No. 1051 of 1966, the ground of non-compliance with statutory provision was very much available to them, but for the reasons best known to them, they did not raise it as one of the grounds while challenging the Notification dated 11-12-1952 issued under the Evacuee Property Act. In the subsequent writ petition filed in the year 1990, initially, they had not questioned the legality of the notification, but raised it by filing an application, which is no doubt true, allowed by the High Court. In our view, the High Court was not justified in permitting the petitioners therein to raise that ground and answer the same since the same is hit by the principles analogous to constructive res judicata.”
XVII. The above ratio is squarely applicable to the instant appeal by the Revenue.
XVIII. The Revenue also pleaded in the present appeal that in terms of sub-section (11) of section 107, the First Appellate Authority was obliged to verify the entitlement of the taxpayer to avail of transitional credit under section 140(3) of CGST Act,2017 and his failure to do so renders the impugned order invalid.
Section 107(11) of CGST Act,2017 reads as under
“(11) The Appellate Authority shall, after making such further inquiry as may be necessary, pass such order, as it thinks just and proper, confirming, modifying or annulling the decision or order appealed against but shall not refer the case back to the adjudicating authority that passed the said decision or order.”
”
The expression “ as may be necessary” indicates that Appellate Authority is not to undertake enquiry in each and every appeal as a matter of routine. The sub-section (11) confers a discretionary power on him which he is to exercise when the facts of a case demand. Therefore there is no merit in the contention of the Revenue.
We have reproduced the observations of the First Appellate Authority under the heading “IMPUGNED O-I-A of this order. We are unable to see any infirmity in the above reasoning of the First Appellate Authority.
We therefore uphold the impugned order and reject the appeal filed by the Revenue.
Communicate this order to the appellant as well as the respondent by delivering certified copy of the same immediately. No order as to costs. Pronounced in open court.


