Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Income Tax

Unsigned Third-Party Excel Sheet Cannot Support On-Money Addition: ITAT Rajkot

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2026 taxguru.in 19038
Case Name
Chatrabhuj Narandas Vithlani Vs ITO (ITAT Rajkot)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Related Assessment Year
2019-20
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Chatrabhuj Narandas Vithlani Vs ITO (ITAT Rajkot)

Summary: The Rajkot SMC Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal allowed three connected appeals involving Chatrabhuj Narandas Vithlani and Sharad Chatrabhujbhai Vithlani for assessment years 2019-20 and 2020-21. The Assessing Officer had relied on an unsigned third-party Excel file named “Trinity”, allegedly recording on-money relating to flats in the Trinity Towers project. The assessees argued that the disputed entry referred to Flat C-402, whereas the relevant purchaser acquired Flat C-401, and that the spreadsheet had neither been recovered from nor authenticated by the assessees. They also challenged the absence of corroborative evidence and cross-examination. The Revenue supported the assessment findings. The Tribunal followed its Division Bench decision in R C Heights Pvt. Ltd., dated 13 April 2026, which had relied on the Gujarat High Court judgment in PCIT v. Kaushik Nanubhai Majithia, dated 6 March 2024. The earlier rulings rejected additions founded solely on unsigned third-party spreadsheets without reliable evidence connecting the entries to actual transactions. Finding no distinguishing change in facts or law and no material from the Revenue to displace those precedents, the Tribunal allowed all three appeals on 12 June 2026.

The Rajkot Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal allowed three appeals filed by Chatrabhuj Narandas Vithlani and Sharad Chatrabhujbhai Vithlani, holding that income-tax additions based on unsigned Excel sheets recovered from a third party could not be sustained without independent corroborative evidence. The appeals concerned Assessment Years 2019-20 and 2020-21 and arose from reassessment orders passed under Section 143(3) read with Section 147 of the Income-tax Act, 1961. Since the issues involved were common, the Tribunal heard the appeals together and disposed of them through a consolidated order. The controversy arose from an Excel file named “Trinity”, allegedly recovered from a third party and containing details of flats sold in the Trinity Towers project. The Assessing Officer treated the spreadsheet as incriminating material indicating undisclosed on-money transactions. The assessees challenged the additions, contending that the spreadsheet had neither been recovered from their possession nor signed or approved by them. They specifically submitted that the alleged on-money entry related to Flat No. C-402, whereas the relevant assessee had purchased Flat No. C-401. They further argued that the Revenue had produced no independent evidence establishing the alleged cash payment and had not afforded an opportunity for cross-examination.

Before the Tribunal, the assessees relied upon the Gujarat High Court’s decision in PCIT v. Kaushik Nanubhai Majithia, Tax Appeal No. 20 of 2024, decided on 6 March 2024, and the Rajkot Tribunal’s decision in R C Heights Pvt. Ltd., ITA Nos. 3 and 4/RJT/2025, decided on 13 April 2026. These decisions addressed additions founded on unsigned third-party Excel records without adequate corroboration. The Tribunal reproduced the relevant findings from R C Heights, including its discussion of Pankaj Dahyabhai Patel (HUF) v. ACIT and Addl. CIT v. Miss Lata Mangeshkar, concerning the evidentiary limitations of third-party records and uncorroborated notings. The Tribunal observed that the issue was squarely covered in favour of the assessees by the earlier Rajkot Bench decision, which had followed the jurisdictional Gujarat High Court. It noted that the Revenue had not produced material controverting those findings or demonstrating any relevant change in facts or law. Respectfully following the coordinate-bench decision and the Gujarat High Court judgment, the Tribunal held that the additions could not be sustained merely on the basis of the disputed third-party Excel sheet. Accordingly, all three appeals were allowed, reinforcing the principle that unsigned third-party electronic records, unsupported by reliable corroborative material, cannot by themselves establish undisclosed income.

Cases Discussed

FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF ITAT Rajkot

Captioned three appeals filed by the different assessees, pertaining to Assessment Years (AY) 2019-20 and 2020-21, are directed against the separate orders passed under section 250 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 [hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’], by the National Faceless Appeal Center, Delhi/ Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) [hereinafter referred to as ‘Ld.CIT(A)/NFAC’], which in turn arise out of separate assessment orders passed by the Assessing Officer [hereinafter referred to as ‘AO”] u/s. 143(3) r.w.s. 147 of the Act.

2. Since, the issues involved in all these appeals are common and identical; therefore, these appeals have been heard together and are being disposed of by this consolidated order.

3. When these three appeals were called out for hearing, learned Counsel for the assessee invited my attention to the order dated 13.04.2026 passed by the Division Bench of this Tribunal in the case of M/s R C Heights Pvt. Ltd. (ITA No. 3 & 4/Rjt/2025), whereby the issue relating to addition made by the assessing officer based on the excel sheet, which were not signed by any parties, have been discussed and adjudicated in favour of assessee. Learned counsel for the assessee submitted that the present appeal is squarely covered by the aforesaid order of the Tribunal, a copy of which was also placed before the Bench. The ld. Counsel explained the facts that from the possession, of third party certain Excel file was found, named “Trinity” which allegedly contained the details of flats sold by M/s Buildcon LLP of their project “Trinity Towers”. Thus, the Excel File “Trinity” was the incriminating seized material, as per assessing officer. The ld. Counsel submitted that assessing officer completely ignored the specific submission of the assessee wherein it was clearly explained that the alleged amount of “on-money” was mentioned against Flat No. C-402, whereas, the assessee had purchased only Flat No. C-401. The ld.Counsel also submitted that the addition made by the assessing officer by relying upon the unsigned and unilaterally created Excel Sheet (“Trinity”) cannot be sustained even on legal grounds. The Excel Sheet, which is the basis of making the addition, has neither been found from the possession of the assessee nor does it contain any signature/approval of the assessee. It has been found from the possession of a different third party. Hence, such data/material cannot be directly thrust upon the assessee, more particularly, when there is no other independent/corroborating evidence in support of the veracity of its content and also when no cross-examination is allowed. In respect of the unsigned Excel Sheet found from the possession of a third party, ld.Counsel relied upon a direct judgment of Jurisdictional Gujarat High Court in the case of PCIT v. Kaushik Nanubhai Majithia (Judgment dated 06.03.2024 in Tax Appeal No. 20 of 2024) wherein the Hon’ble Court disapproved the reliance placed on unsigned Excel Sheet by the assessing officer and affirmed the deletion of the addition by the Tribunal (ITAT). Following the above judgment of the Hon’ble Gujarat High Court, the Hon’ble Rajkot Tribunal (ITAT) in case of M/s. RC Heights Pvt Ltd. (ITA No. 3 & 4 / Rjt/2025), on similar facts, relying on the above Gujarat High Court decision, has deleted the addition. Therefore, ld. Counsel contended that addition made by the assessing officer may be deleted.

4. On the other hand, the Ld. DR for the revenue relied on the findings of the assessing officer.

5. I have heard both the parties and carefully gone through the submission put forth on behalf of the assessee along with the documents furnished and the case laws relied upon, and perused the fact of the case including the findings of the ld CIT(A) and other materials brought on record. I see no reasons to take any other view of the matter than the view so taken by the Division Bench of this Tribunal in the case of M/s. R C Heights Pvt. LTd. (ITA No. 3 & 4/Rjt/2025), vide order dated 13.04.2026, wherein the Tribunal relied on the judgement of Hon’ble Jurisdictional High Court of Gujarat, in the case of PCIT v. Kaushik Nanubhai Majithia, (supra).In this order, the Tribunal has inter alia observed as follows:

“20. We note that apart from excel sheet, no evidence has been found to suggest that the assessee had actually received the said amount. In the absence of any documentary evidence to suggest the same, it could not be presumed that the amounts reflected in the excel sheet were the income of the assessee, received from RK Group. The Assessing Officer has not brought on record any evidence to suggest that RK Group has admitted that the amounts were paid to the assessee-company. Hence, simply rough noting on the excel file, which is not signed by any party, does not mean that the addition could be made in the hands of the assessee-company. Since no evidence was found relating to the existence of any transaction between the assessee- company and R K Group and in the absence of any corroborative evidence to suggest that the assessee- company had actually received the said amount, no addition could be made merely on the basis of noting excel file found during the search proceedings from third party.

21. We find that no tangible documents, any loose papers found during the courses of search, which contains the signature of the assessee as well as authorized partner of M/s Titanium Buildcon LLP. In Pankaj Dahyabhai Patel (HUF) Vs. ACIT (1999) 63 TT) (Ahm) 790-where papers were not seized from house of the assessee nor was in his handwriting, of the assessee, the inference of on-money receipt based on such paper was not justified. Additions based on loose papers without corroborative evidence, it was held, by Tribunal, to be not sustainable. Neither evidence to link the seized documents found in the premises of third party, that is, R K Group during the course of search, then the presumption u/s 132(4A) of the Act not applicable. The action of the Assessing Officer in making addition based on the searched person`s excel -sheet data, recording of third party, that the same belongs to the assessee, is incorrect, as the same would be clearly impermissible, as the seized data, admittedly, had no nexus with the assessee and there is no signature of assessee or third-party, on such excel sheet. In the case of Addl. CIT v. Miss Lata Mangeshkar [1974] 97 ITR 696 (Bom), the addition was made in the hands of the assessee on the basis of the entries in the books of third persons. Hon’ble Bombay High Court held that such addition could not be made only on the basis of the notings in the books of third persons. The entire addition revolving to the excel sheet found and seized from the third- party which is “dump documents” which has no legality in the eyes of the law and the addition exclusively based on such documents needs to be deleted.

22. We note that assessee’s issue under consideration is also covered by the judgement of the Hon’ble High Court of Gujarat in the case of PCIT vs. Kaushik Nanubhai Majithia R/Tax Appeal No. 20 of 2024 order dated 06.03.2024, while passing the order the Hon’ble Gujarat High Court has made the following observations:

“1. Having noted the findings of the facts returned by the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) (‘CITA’, in brief) and the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (‘ITAT’, herein after), we may record that, essentially, the proceedings under Section 153C of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (in short, ‘IT Act of 1961’) were initiated against the Respondent- assessee on the basis of an excel sheet found from the computer of a person, associated with the Company, namely Navratna Organizers and Developers Private Limited (in short as “the Developer’), in the premises of whom the search was conducted.

2. The excel sheet, according to the learned Counsel for the Revenue, contained the details of payment made by the assessee to the developer, with respect to which tax had been paid by the developer before the Settlement Commissioner. The findings returned by the CITA and ITAT on the issue is sought to be assailed on the ground that the payment of tax by the developer, in whose premises search was conducted, before the Settlement Commissioner, with respect to the amount entered in the excel sheet found from the possession of the assistant working with the developer, is sufficient proof of the transaction between the assessee and the developer.

3. We find Inherent fallacy in this submission, inasmuch as, there is no basis for conducting proceedings against the assessee merely for the fact that the developer had paid tax on the amount shown in the excel-sheet There is no adjudication with regard to the payment, which was shown in the excel-sheet to the effect that the same was actually paid by the assessee to the developer. Even otherwise, the concurrent findings written by the CITA and ITAT are that the document found from the premises of the third party namely excel-sheet, which is the basis the proceedings was without any signature and there is no corroborative material to substantia the said document. The nature of the document has not been explained by the Assessing Officer while proceeding against the assessee. The statements of the persons recorded during search with reference to the alleged, seized material, was not provided to the assessee and hence, the entire proceedings under Section 153C of the IT Act of 1961 stood vitiated.

4. Learned Counsel for the petitioner could not successfully demolish the facts, which ai recorded concurrently by the CITA and ITAT.

5. No question of law much less any substantial question of law arises to entertain this appeal. The same is accordingly, dismissed.

6. As the issue is squarely covered in favour of the assessee by the decision of the Hon’ble Rajkot Bench in the case of M/s. R C Heights Pvt. Ltd. (ITA No. 3 & 4/Rjt/2025) (supra), wherein the Tribunal relied on the judgement of Hon’ble Jurisdictional High Court of Gujarat, in the case of PCIT v. Kaushik Nanubhai Majithia (supra) and deleted the addition made by the assessing officer based on the excel sheet.

7. As the issue is squarely covered in favour of the assessee by the decision of the Coordinate Bench (supra) and judgement of jurisdictional High Court of Gujarat (supra) and there is no change in facts and law and the Revenue is unable to produce any material to controvert the aforesaid findings of the Coordinate Bench (supra) and judgement of jurisdictional High Court of Gujarat (supra). Therefore, respectfully following the binding judgments of the Coordinate Bench(supra) and judgement of jurisdictional High Court of Gujarat (supra), I allow these three appeals of different assessees.

8. In the result, these three appeals of the assessees ( in ITA Nos. 113/RJT/2026, ITA No. 824 & 825/RJT/2025) are allowed.

Order is pronounced in the open court on 12/06/2026.

Advertisement

Author Info

CA Sandeep Kanoi
Qualification: Graduate, CA in Job / Business, DD
Company: Taxguru Consultancy
Location: Mumbai, Maharashtra
Articles Published: 24,690

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.