Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Custom Duty

Customs Valuation of Metal Scrap Cannot Be Based Solely on LME Prices: CESTAT Ahmedabad

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2026 taxguru.in 19101
Case Name
Sunland Metal Recycling Industries Vs Commissioner of Customs, Kandla (CESTAT Ahmedabad)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Sunland Metal Recycling Industries Vs Commissioner of Customs, Kandla (CESTAT Ahmedabad)

Summary: The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), Ahmedabad, in Sunland Metal Recycling Industries Vs Commissioner of Customs, Kandla, set aside customs duty demands, confiscation of imported goods and penalties arising from allegations of misdeclaration and undervaluation of zinc ash, zinc dross, zinc scrap and aluminium scrap imported during 2002–2006. The appeals were filed by Sunland Metal Recycling Industries (SMRI), engaged in manufacturing aluminium, zinc, brass and copper ingots, and its partners Sushil Kumar Agarwal, Surendra P. Kachhara and Sanjeev Kumar Agarwal. The dispute arose from a show-cause notice dated 7 May 2007, followed by an adjudication order dated 26 March 2019. The Customs Department alleged that imported metal scrap had been declared at artificially reduced prices and that its assessable value should be enhanced by reference to London Metal Exchange (LME) prices of virgin metals, adjusted according to prescribed discount bands. The Tribunal examined whether such valuation methodology was permissible under the Customs Valuation Rules, whether the allegations were supported by reliable evidence, and whether the Department could reopen or demand differential duty on consignments already provisionally assessed or finally assessed.

The Department’s principal allegation concerning zinc imports was that 32 consignments supplied by U.S. Zinc, USA, had been misdeclared as zinc ash although the goods were allegedly zinc skimmings containing a higher percentage of recoverable zinc. The Department relied on correspondence obtained through the Indian Consulate in the United States, emails exchanged between suppliers and an indenting agent, and statements recorded during investigation. It alleged that the declared invoices did not reflect the actual transaction prices and that differential payments had been made through cash advances, hawala channels or overseas transfers. In respect of other zinc imports, the Department proposed valuation by reference to estimated recoverable metal content, including 35% of LME prices for zinc ash and 75% for zinc dross. Similar allegations were made concerning aluminium scrap imports, where the Department relied on Alert Circular No. 14/2005 dated 16 December 2005 issued by the Directorate General of Valuation. The circular prescribed discount bands for different grades of aluminium scrap relative to LME prices. On that basis, the Department proposed differential duty across multiple consignments imported through Nhava Sheva, Kandla, Mundra and Tuglaqabad, together with confiscation and penalties.

The appellants challenged the allegations of misdeclaration by relying on chemical examination reports prepared at the time of importation. They submitted that the imported zinc ash had been tested by the Customs Chemical Examiner at Nhava Sheva and found to conform to the declared description. The Department, however, relied on a subsequent test report relating to material sampled from the appellant’s factory, which described the material as other than zinc ash without positively identifying it as zinc skimmings. The appellants argued that an inconclusive examination of material subsequently found at the factory could not override the contemporaneous examination of imported consignments. They also disputed the reliance placed on third-party correspondence and requested cross-examination of the chemical examiner. The Tribunal accepted the significance of the original import-stage test reports and observed that the subsequent report did not establish that the goods were zinc skimmings. Since the imported goods had been tested and cleared as zinc ash, and the contrary allegation was not satisfactorily established, the Tribunal held that the charges of misdeclaration and consequential undervaluation were unsustainable.

A separate issue concerned the legality of demands raised under Section 28 of the Customs Act, 1962, in respect of provisionally assessed consignments. The appellants submitted that the zinc ash and zinc dross consignments covered by the relevant annexures to the show-cause notice had been provisionally assessed pending laboratory testing. They produced Bills of Entry containing references to test bonds and electronic assessment records demonstrating the provisional nature of the assessments. Although the adjudicating authority acknowledged the legal distinction between provisional assessment and recovery proceedings under Section 28, it rejected the appellants’ contention on the ground that the relevant provisional assessments had not been adequately identified or supported by evidence of executed bonds. The Tribunal found this reasoning factually incorrect. It noted that the appellants had specifically identified the relevant consignments in their reply and produced documents indicating provisional assessment. Consequently, the Tribunal held that the demands raised in the manner adopted by the Department could not be sustained against those provisionally assessed imports.

On the central issue of customs valuation, the Tribunal rejected the Department’s practice of determining the value of imported aluminium scrap by taking LME prices of virgin metal and deducting standard discount percentages. It observed that the Customs Valuation Rules required the assessing authority to follow the prescribed valuation methods sequentially after establishing legally sustainable grounds for rejecting the declared transaction value. The Department could not directly resort to a residual valuation method merely because LME prices suggested a higher value. The appellants had produced details of contemporaneous imports of identical or comparable scrap at prices similar to their declared values. However, the adjudicating authority had not adequately considered those transactions and had instead relied on LME-based calculations. The Tribunal considered this approach contrary to the statutory valuation framework. It emphasised that contemporaneous import values, where available and relevant, constituted an important basis for valuation and could not be disregarded in favour of a generalised formula derived from the price of virgin metal.

The Tribunal relied on several judicial precedents rejecting the use of LME quotations as the sole basis for enhancing the assessable value of imported scrap. In Commissioner of Customs Vs Prabhu Dayal Prem Chand, the Supreme Court had upheld rejection of an enhancement based on LME prices where the Department had not produced supporting evidence of contemporaneous imports. The Tribunal also considered GKN Sinter Metals Limited Vs Commissioner of Central Excise, Bharati Rubber Lining & Allied Services Pvt. Ltd. and Pushpak Metal Corporation, which supported the proposition that indicative international metal prices could not automatically replace the transaction value of scrap. It further referred to the Department’s own communications recognising that aluminium scrap prices did not necessarily move proportionately with virgin aluminium prices. The Institute of Scrap Recycling Industries had also explained that scrap prices depended on commercial negotiations, market information, quality and other factors, rather than a direct quotation on a metal exchange. The Tribunal therefore concluded that LME prices, even after applying discount bands, could not independently justify rejection of the declared import values.

The Tribunal also examined the effect of earlier assessment proceedings involving the same imports. Certain aluminium scrap consignments imported through Nhava Sheva had initially been assessed provisionally and subsequently subjected to enhancement based on LME prices. That enhancement had been set aside in appellate proceedings, and the Department’s further challenge had been rejected by the Tribunal. Similarly, provisional assessments concerning imports through Kandla and Mundra had been finalised by orders accepting the declared transaction values and rejecting LME-based enhancement. Those orders had attained finality. The Tribunal held that the Department could not disregard these completed proceedings and once again enhance the assessable values through the impugned adjudication. It also noted that values relating to 550 Bills of Entry covered by another annexure had already been enhanced at the original assessment stage and that the resulting assessments had not been challenged through the prescribed appellate or review process. The Tribunal considered a further attempt to reassess those finalised values legally unsustainable.

Another important aspect of the dispute was the evidentiary value of statements recorded from the firm’s partners, indenting agents and other persons during investigation. The Department relied heavily on statements attributed to Sushil Agarwal concerning the relationship between scrap prices and LME quotations. The Tribunal noticed material inconsistencies between statements recorded on different dates. One statement suggested that aluminium scrap prices were generally negotiated at approximately 80% of LME prices, while another referred to different discount bands ranging from 5% to 35%, corresponding to those mentioned in the Directorate General of Valuation’s circular. The appellants disputed the voluntariness and reliability of these statements and sought cross-examination. They also questioned the authenticity of documents allegedly recovered from an indenting agent’s laptop and requested examination of the officers and witnesses involved in the recovery proceedings. The Tribunal found that the adjudicating authority had improperly denied several requests for cross-examination, while the indenting agents whose examination had been permitted were not produced. Relying on Andaman Timber Industries Vs Commissioner of Central Excise, Basudev Garg Vs Commissioner of Customs and Commissioner of Customs Vs Motabhai Iron & Steel Industries, it held that disputed statements could not be relied upon against the appellants without providing a meaningful opportunity to test their credibility.

The Tribunal further considered the Department’s allegation that the difference between declared import prices and allegedly higher actual prices had been settled through hawala transactions or overseas transfers. It found that the investigation had not identified the persons to whom the alleged differential payments were made, established how the appellants generated or possessed the corresponding cash, or produced reliable evidence demonstrating that additional consideration had actually reached the overseas suppliers. Mere suspicion arising from price comparisons, third-party statements or correspondence was insufficient to establish clandestine payments. The Tribunal also examined certain export declarations relating to consignments shipped from New Zealand and Spain. It noted that these declarations had not been authenticated by the relevant foreign customs authorities and that several concerned goods or consignees unrelated to the appellants’ imports. Moreover, the Department had not actually determined the disputed assessable values on the basis of those declarations. The Tribunal therefore declined to treat them as reliable evidence supporting the demands.

The appellants additionally argued that countervailing duty, described in the proceedings as additional customs duty, was not payable on imported zinc ash, zinc dross, skimmings and scrap where the corresponding goods did not arise from a manufacturing process and were consequently not liable to central excise duty. They relied on the principles laid down in Hyderabad Industries Ltd. and subsequent judicial decisions and departmental circulars concerning the excisability of waste and scrap. The adjudicating authority had rejected this contention partly because the appellants had not raised it during the original assessments. The Tribunal disagreed, observing that the nature of the imported scrap and the applicable judicial precedents supported the appellants’ position. It also held that an assessee defending recovery proceedings under Section 28 could raise relevant grounds demonstrating that duty was not legally payable, even if those grounds had not been advanced during the original assessment. The Tribunal accordingly rejected the adjudicating authority’s reasoning for denying consideration of the additional-duty objection.

Finally, the Tribunal held that the Department had failed to establish the essential factual and legal foundation for the disputed duty demands. The alleged misdeclaration of zinc ash was contradicted by the import-stage chemical examination reports; the LME-based valuation methodology disregarded the prescribed valuation rules and available contemporaneous imports; several assessments had already attained finality; and the evidence relied upon to establish undervaluation and differential payments was insufficient or procedurally unreliable. Since the underlying allegations of undervaluation and misdeclaration were not sustained, the confiscation of goods, including consignments seized at ports and the appellant’s factory, also lacked justification. The penalties imposed on Sunland Metal Recycling Industries and its partners consequently could not survive. By Final Order Nos. A/11871–11874/2019 dated 1 October 2019, the CESTAT Ahmedabad set aside the Commissioner’s order dated 26 March 2019 and allowed all four appeals with consequential relief to the appellants. The decision reinforces the requirement that customs valuation must rest on legally admissible evidence and the prescribed valuation methodology, rather than uncorroborated international commodity prices or unsupported allegations of additional payments.

Cases Discussed

1. Lili Foam Industries (P) Ltd. Vs Commissioner of Central Excise (CESTAT); 1990 (46) ELT 462. Cited for the principle that an assessee may challenge the legality of duty liability when defending recovery proceedings, including on grounds not raised during the original assessment.

2. Bakeman Home Products Pvt. Ltd. Vs Commissioner of Customs (CESTAT); 1997 (95) ELT 278. Relied upon concerning the availability of additional grounds for contesting a demand under Section 28 of the Customs Act.

3. Decora Ceramics Pvt. Ltd. Vs Commissioner of Central Excise (CESTAT); 1998 (100) ELT 279. Cited on the right to contest duty liability in recovery proceedings. The principal order also records the citation as 1998 (100) ELT 297 in paragraph 12.

4. Hyderabad Industries Ltd. (Supreme Court); 1999 (108) ELT 321. Relied upon for the principle that additional customs duty cannot be imposed by reference to excise duty where the corresponding goods are not manufactured products.

5. Drunkey Exports (P) Ltd. Vs Commissioner of Customs (Port), Kolkata-I (CESTAT Kolkata); 2004 (165) ELT 417. Cited in the reproduced precedent concerning the insufficiency of LME quotations alone to justify enhancement of imported scrap values.

6. Commissioner of Customs, Kandla Vs Meera Impex (CESTAT Mumbai); 2004 (167) ELT 446. Cited for requiring corroborative evidence of higher import values before enhancing declared prices on the basis of international metal quotations.

7. Commissioner of Customs Vs Tata Iron & Steel Co. Ltd. (Supreme Court); 2004 (165) ELT 386. Cited concerning the levy of additional customs duty on imported scrap.

8. Commissioner of Customs Vs Lord Shiva Overseas (CESTAT); 2005 (181) ELT 213. Relied upon concerning the finality of completed customs assessments.

9. Karnataka Chemical Industries Corporation Ltd. Vs Commissioner of Customs (CESTAT); 2005 (183) ELT 207. Cited in connection with the excisability of imported scrap and additional customs duty.

10. Malhotra Impex Vs Commissioner of Customs (CESTAT); 2006 (203) ELT 561. Relied upon against subsequent enhancement of values already determined in finalised assessments.

11. Commissioner of Customs, Kolkata Vs South India Television (P) Ltd. (Supreme Court); 2007 (214) ELT 3. Held that suspicion concerning invoice prices is insufficient to reject declared transaction values without cogent supporting evidence.

12. GKN Sinter Metals Limited Vs Commissioner of Central Excise, Pune (CESTAT Mumbai); 2008 (232) ELT 692. Held that LME quotations for prime metals cannot independently justify enhancement of the declared value of imported scrap.

13. Commissioner of Customs, Mumbai Vs H.D. Orgochem Ltd. (Supreme Court); 2008 (226) ELT 9. Referred to in the CBEC communication reproduced in the order concerning rejection of declared customs transaction values.

14. Shri Ram Agro Chemicals (P) Ltd. Vs Union of India (Punjab and Haryana High Court); 2009 (234) ELT 218. Cited regarding additional customs duty and the treatment of goods not arising from manufacture.

15. Commissioner of Customs Vs Paras Electronics (CESTAT); 2009 (246) ELT 231. Relied upon concerning the finality of assessments and restrictions on subsequent reassessment.

16. Commissioner of Customs, New Delhi Vs Prabhu Dayal Prem Chand (Supreme Court); 2010 (253) ELT 353. Upheld rejection of additional customs duty demanded on the basis of LME prices without supporting evidence of contemporaneous imports.

17. Commissioner Vs GKN Sinter Metals Limited (Supreme Court); 2010 (254) ELT A43. The principal order records that the Supreme Court upheld the Tribunal’s decision rejecting unsupported LME-based enhancement of scrap values.

18. Commissioner of Customs Vs L. Madanlal (Aluminium) Ltd. (CESTAT); 2010 (258) ELT 107. Cited concerning additional customs duty and the excisability of scrap.

19. Bhushan Steel Ltd. Vs Commissioner of Central Excise (CESTAT); 2012 (284) ELT 713. Cited on the treatment of scrap for excise duty purposes.

20. Bharati Rubber Lining & Allied Services Pvt. Ltd. (CESTAT); 2013 (287) ELT 124. Relied upon for the principle that departmental valuation circulars cannot override the Customs Valuation Rules and that statutory valuation methods must be followed.

21. Basudev Garg Vs Commissioner of Customs (Delhi High Court); 2013 (294) ELT 353. Cited for the requirement to provide an opportunity for cross-examination where disputed witness statements are relied upon in adjudication.

22. Bothra Metal & Alloys (CESTAT); 2013 (9) TMI 546. Referred to in support of rejecting valuation enhancement based solely on LME quotations and standard discount bands.

23. Pushpak Metal Corporation (CESTAT); 2014 (312) ELT 381. Relied upon because comparable contemporaneous scrap imports supported acceptance of transaction values rather than LME-based enhancement.

24. Commissioner of Customs Vs Motabhai Iron & Steel Industries (Gujarat High Court); 2015 (316) ELT 374. Held that statements of witnesses who were not made available for cross-examination could not be relied upon against the affected party.

25. Hindalco Industries Ltd. Vs Union of India (Bombay High Court); 2015 (315) ELT 10. Cited concerning the excisability of metal waste and scrap and the consequential levy of additional customs duty.

26. Andaman Timber Industries Vs Commissioner of Central Excise, Kolkata-II (Supreme Court); 2015 (324) ELT 641. Held that denial of cross-examination of witnesses whose statements form the basis of an adverse adjudication order constitutes a serious violation of natural justice.

Other precedents cited without complete reported citations:
27. Varsha Plastics (Supreme Court). Cited concerning the application of the Customs Valuation Rules, contemporaneous import evidence and the circumstances in which international price publications may be considered.

28. FSP (India) Pvt. Ltd. (CESTAT). Cited for the principle that uniform enhancement of customs values based on general valuation criteria is impermissible.

29. Slugs India Ltd. Vs Commissioner of Central Excise (CESTAT); (278) ELT 611. Cited regarding excisability of scrap. The year in the original citation is incomplete.

FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF CESTAT AHMEDABAD

The present appeals have been filed by M/s Sunland Metal Recycling Industries (SMRI) and its partners Shri Sushil Kumar Agrawal, Shri Surendra P. Kachhara and Shri Sanjeev Kumar Agrawal against OIO No. KMD-COSTM-000-COM-18-18-19 dated 26.03.2019 passed by the Commissioner of Customs, Kandla. The brief facts of the case are that M/s SMRI are engaged in the manufacture of Aluminum Ingots, Zinc Ingots, Brass ingots and Copper Ingots. The Appellants M/s Sunland during the impugned period of 2002 – 2006, had imported consignments of Zinc Ash, Zinc dross, Zinc scrap and Aluminum scrap of different grades through Ports of Nhava Sheva, Mumbai, Kandla, Mundra and Tuglaqabad.

1.1 M/s SMRI after investigation on the allegation of mis-declaration and under valuation of Zinc and Aluminum scrap were issued Show Cause Notice dt. 07.05.2007. It was contended that M/s SMRI had imported consignments of Zinc Ash and Aluminium Scrap from many parties. In case of 32 consignments of Zinc Ash imported from U.S. Zinc, U.S.A and detailed in Annexure – ‘A-II’ of show cause notice it was alleged that the documents received from the Consulate General of India, USA shows that M/s US Zinc Ltd entered into the agreement for payment of higher rate and the formal contracts were prepared at under-valued rates through indentor, Shri Tarun Jhingon of M/s Trendene India Pvt Ltd, New Delhi. The email correspondence dated 5.4.2003 between Shri Tarun Jhingon and the officials of M/s US Zinc Ltd, USA and emails between the persons of M/s U.S. Zinc were relied upon to allege that the goods were Zinc skimming and not zinc ash containing higher zinc content. Also the test report dated 31.07.2006 of the Chemical Examiner, Vadodara was relied upon that the sample drawn from the factory of M/s SMRI showed the sample to be other than Zinc Ash. It was alleged that the invoice issued by exporter were indicating lower value and the balance amount was paid as cash advance to M/s U.S. Zinc through third parties by Hawala or Telegraphic Transfer outside India. Reliance was placed upon statement of Shri Tarun Jhingon, Indenter of Trendene India Pvt. Ltd. and Shri Sushil Agarwal, Partner of M/s SMRI.

1.2 In case of other varieties of Zinc Scrap namely Zinc Die cast scrap “Saves” and Zinc Dross, the Show Cause Notice relied upon the report dt. 10.01.2007 of Second Secretary (Trade), High Commission of India, U.K wherein it was reported that 11 consignments of Aluminium and Zinc scrap loaded at Barcelona Port, Spain and imported by SMRI consigned by M/s Sunberg Ltd., U.K were undervalued. It also relied upon three emails between M/s Aboura Trading and Commission and Shri Tarun Jhingon to allege undervaluation. Reliance was placed upon Report dated 3.11.2006 of the High Commission of India, Singapore wherein it was reported that in respect of 2 consignments the value declared by the exporter at the port of exports in case of supply from M/s P.W.T. Australia were on higher side as compared to that declared by the Appellant. Reliance was also placed upon report dt. 17.04.2007 of High Commission of India that two consignments loaded from ports in Greece were undervalued. The show cause notice alleged that Shri Sushil Agarwal in his statement has stated that the prevailing LME prices formed the basis of negotiations and normally the price negotiated at 80% of the LME as the Aluminium scrap imported by them. Shri Sushil Agarwal was shown abstract of LME for the period 2006 to April’ 2006 and 80% of the High and low price and on showing comparison of the same with the import price, he stated that the aspect of undervaluation was apparent and almost in all the cases the price declared in respective invoice was on lower side than 80% of the LME which is normally negotiated. Statement of Indentor Shri Tarun Jhingon was also recorded on 25.04.2006 wherein he stated that M/s Trendene India Pvt. Ltd is indenting agent for the firms namely M/s FBM Metals U.K & Germany, M/s Mount Star Metal UK, M/s Aboura Trading, Jordan, M/s Euro Gulf, Jordan, M/s Arsh Metal, UAE, M/s N. Raydan Comm. Org., Saudi Arabia, M/s U.S. Zinc, USA & M/s Indra Recycling, Germany. Statement of Shri Rajeshwar Prasad Dubey, CHA was also recorded on 22.06.2006 wherein he stated that the sample of Aluminium scrap were not drawn but in case of Zinc Dross/Ash, the samples were drawn and sent to Deputy Chemist at Nhava Sheva/Mumbai and the test reports were received of the same were directly received by the Customs Authorities and based on test reports the consignments assessed provisionally were finalised. During investigation against M/s SMRI the imported scrap of Zinc and Aluminium lying at different ports and factory of M/s SMRI were seized on grounds of undervaluation. Statement dt. 16.01.2007 of Shri Mihir Bhatt, Prop. of M/s Metal Resources, Mumbai, who was dealing in import & export of non-ferrous metal & scrap was relied upon wherein he stated that the minimum metal content in the Aluminium Scrap was 70% to 80% and considering impurities content in the respective lot, the prices of the metal content therein could be the purchase price. He also stated that his business with M/s SMRI was only of around 300 MT, which is negligible quantity. Statement of Shri Haji Amin Gadawala, Chairman of Bibi Group of companies was recorded 17.1.2006 wherein he stated that he was acting as a follow-up agent of M/s Ala International Trading, Sharjah. The Indian buyers were importing Aluminium Scrap from M/s Shar Metals, Sharjah, M/s Aboura Trading, Jordan, M/s Namma Trading, Saudi Arabia, M/s Al-Sharif Metals, UAE and M/s Eta, Dubai. All the Indian buyers negotiated with M/s Ala International Trading, who in turn negotiated and arranged the consignments from the above-said entities and accordingly invoices were raised by the respective exporters and payment was directly made to them. He also submitted that the invoices raised against the respective contracts were not the actual prices/values negotiated. He was shown the comparison of imported invoices and LME prices, to which he stated, there has been under-invoicing. The show cause notice also placed reliance upon the search made in another case against M/s Agravanshi Aluminium Ltd and where the CPU was seized. It was alleged that said M/s Agravanshi Aluminium Ltd resorted to under-valuation in imports of Aluminum Scrap during the period 01.01.2005 to 30.04.2005 through indentors, M/s Nehan Ispat, Mumbai in imports made from M/s Al-Sharief, Dubai and same modus operandi was adopted by the Appellant unit for import from the same supplier in six consignment. Statements of Shri Surendra Kachhara, Partner of M/s SMRI, was also recorded wherein he agreed with the statement of Shri Sushil Agrawal. He also stated that they were purchasing Aluminium scrap in various forms, which were classified on the basis of their form, source and quality. He also stated that the import price of Aluminium scrap before Customs authority was much lower than the corresponding LME prices of Aluminium Scrap while effecting imports. Statement of Shri Sanjeev Kumar Agrawal, another partner, was also recorded, who had agreed with the statements given by other Partners.

1.3 Based on above, it was also alleged that M/s SMRI had imported 1699 consignments of Aluminium scrap of various grades as defined in ISRI. That on scrutiny of declared value of imported goods vis-a-vis the prevailing LME of the respective imports, the imports were found to be undervalued. The show cause notice relied upon the LME Prices for Aluminium metal for the impugned period and Circular No. 14/2005 issued from F. No. VAL/TECH/37/2005 dt. 16.12.2005 by Director of Valuation wherein the directorate had allowed discounts in the LME Prices considering the metal content of Aluminium in the various grades of Aluminium Scrap. It was alleged that on comparison of the declared import value in consignments with the discount bands provided in said circular it revealed that M/s SMRI has under-declared the value of Aluminium Scrap. The show cause notice also relied upon the report dt. 10.01.2007 of Consulate General of India of U.K. and alleged that in case of supplier M/s Sunberg Ltd. U.K, the value declared by the said exporter are on the higher side as compared to that declared by SMRI at the time of clearance in India. Based upon above contention/allegation the show cause notice proposed duty demands as under:

(i) A demand of Rs. 4,31,00,86/- as detailed in Annexure – ‘A-II’ to show cause notice was proposed on the ground that M/s SMRI has imported Zinc Skimming from M/s U.S. Zinc by mis-declaring the same as Zinc Ash. That the Zinc content in Zinc Ash is only 35%, whereas the recovery of the pure metal in Zinc Skimming ranges from 60 to 65%. In trade parlance, the presence of pure metal is guiding factor for fixation of prices of scrap. It was, thus, proposed to reject the declared value under Rule 10A and to determine the value under Rule 3 (i) read with Rule – 9 (1)(e) of Customs Valuation Rules, 1988.

(ii) A demand of duty of Rs. 43,71,891/- was proposed on Zinc Ash as detailed in Annexure A-III of the SCN, on the ground that the pure metal in the scrap is guiding factor for negotiating the price and that in case of Zinc Ash as per ISRI Norms the metal content is about 35%. It was proposed to determine the value of Zinc Ash on the basis of 35% of the LME price of virgin metal.

(iii) A demand of Rs. 74,83,970/- on Zinc Dross detailed in Annexure A-IV of Show Cause Notice was proposed on the ground that recovery of pure metal in terms of ISRI Norms is 75%. Hence it was proposed to value the same at 75% of the prevailing LME rate.

(iv) A demand of duty as detailed in Annexure – A-V to the show cause notice was made on Zinc Scrap (Scope/Saves/Score etc.) by contending that ISRI norms do not specify the actual metal content in this variety. However as per disclosure of Shri Sushil Agarwal in his statement dt. 23.04.2007, the prices of Zinc Scarp is 65% to 70% of the prevailing LME. The said consignments including 3 consignments from Aboura Trading, M/s Metal Interest Ltd. and M/s Sunberg, UK were proposed to be valued on the basis that it contained 65% metal content.

(v) Demand of Rs. 1,91,22,810/- was also proposed in respect of seized Aluminium and Zinc Scrap and the goods contained in finished goods seized at factory of M/s SMRI as detailed in Annexure – RM-I. The basis of valuation was by applying discount as per ISRI Norms in case of Zinc Scrap and discount band as per Director General of Valuation Alert Circular No. 14/2005 dt. 16.12.2005 to LME price of Aluminium in case of Aluminium scrap.

(vi) Duty was also proposed in Annexure – RM-II on Aluminium and Zinc scrap seized from Nhava Sheva/JNPT on the basis that the imported price when compared with LME price of virgin material in case of Zinc Scrap as per ISRI Norms and LME minus discount band as per DGOV Circular No. 14/2005 dt. 16.12.2005 in case of Aluminium Scrap shows difference.

(vii) In case of Aluminium Scrap detailed in Annexure – ‘C’ of Show Cause Notice, demand of differential duty was made on consignments imported through Nhava Sheva Port on the ground that the value declared by the exporters is on higher side as compared to that declared by SMRI and the exporters have issued invoices at undervalued rates. It was proposed to reassess the same by adopting LME price to which discount band was applied in terms of Circular issued by Director General of Valuation Circular No. 14/2005 dt. 16.12.2005.

(viii) In case of Annexure – D to show cause notice the duty of Rs. 95,168/- was proposed to be made in respect of Aluminium scrap (Telic/Taint/Tabor) by adopting the LME price for virgin Aluminium to which discount band was applied in terms of DGOV Circular No. 14/2005 dt. 16.12.2005.

(ix) In Annexure E to the show cause notice demand of duty in respect of Aluminium scrap imported from Kandla port was made. The basis adopted for valuation is LME price for virgin raw material to which a discount band was applied in terms of DGOV Circular supra on valuation.

(x) In Annexure F to show cause notice duty demand of Rs. 31,02,341/- was proposed in respect of Aluminium and Zinc Scarp imported through Tuglaqabad port. The basis adopted for valuation was LME Price for virgin material to which discount band was applied in terms of DGOV Circular supra.

1.4 The show cause notice also proposed the confiscation of seized goods and in respect of goods which not be seized, it was proposed to Impose redemption fine. Penalty under section 114A/112 of the Customs Act was proposed upon M/s SMRI and u/s 112 (b) upon co-appellants.

1.5 The differential duty demands as proposed in the show cause notice were confirmed except the repetition of demand on same consignments by rejecting the declared values vide impugned order dated 26.03.2019 and penalties were also imposed upon M/s SMRI and all the partners. The seized goods lying at factory and Port which were released provisionally were also ordered to be confiscated. In respect of goods which could not be seized, the redemption fine was not imposed. Aggrieved the present Appellants has filed the present appeals.

2. Shri Jaideep. C. Patel, Ld. Counsel appearing for the Appellants submits that the impugned order has been passed without any reasoning. The confirmation of demand on the ground of mis declaration and on the basis of LME price does not have any base. In case of Zinc Ash imported from U.S. Zinc the goods at the time of import were tested by the Chemical Examiner, Nhava-Sheva and were found to be of declared description. He takes us through the sample test reports to support his contention. He submits that when the examination of goods showed them as Zinc Ash, in such case the same cannot be alleged to be Zinc Skimming on the basis of correspondence between supplier and indenter or the supplier documents. The allegation is not supported by any evidence but only on third party documents. The test report of chemical examiner in case of sample drawn from factory cannot be relied upon to support allegation of misdeclaration of zinc skimming as zinc ash as the report only states that the goods are other than Zinc Ash. The cross examination of chemical examiner was not allowed and hence in view of above fact the report given by him cannot be relied upon. He submit that on the basis of documents and report of the Consulate of India, U.S.A or the correspondence between the employees of supplier or the email between indentor and supplier it cannot be alleged that the goods were Zinc Skimming as the chemical examination at the time of import clearly shows that the goods are Zinc Ash.

2.1 He also submits that during impugned period the imports of Zinc Ash and Zinc Dross were provisionally assessed and hence the demand under section 28 of the Customs Act is not tenable. In respect of Zinc Ash and Zinc dross, covered by Annexures A-II to A-IV to the SCN, the assessments were provisional and therefore the demands could not have been made under Section-28 of the Customs Act. The adjudicating authority though accepted the proposition that in respect of provisionally assessed Bills of entries the demand under section 28 is not maintainable, but confirmed the demand by holding that the Appellants had not specifically mentioned which bills of entry are provisional and that there was no evidence of provisional assessment in the form of execution of bond. This contention of the adjudicating authority is erroneous and he has overlooked the material facts. He points out from the submissions of reply to SCN dated 29.12.2018 that the Appellants had specifically shown that the bills of entry in Annexure A-II, A-III and A-IV were provisionally assessed pending test. He submits that the findings of the adjudicating authority that there is no evidence of execution of bond is also incorrect since the provisionally assessed bills of entry were clearly had inscription/mention as Test Bonds. He list out the Bills of entry and print-outs taken from EDI systems which clearly shows the assessment to be provisional.

2.2 He submits that in case of Aluminium Scrap even if the declared value is to be rejected, than too the demand has to be re-determined sequentially under Rule 5 and 6 based upon contemporary imports. The show cause notice itself states that wherever contemporary imports of similar goods were found, value is redetermined under Rule 6 and in rest of cases value is redetermined under Rule 8 of the Customs Valuation Rules 1988 by adopting the LME Prices of Virgin metal and applying discount bands to them. However not a single instance of contemporary imports at a higher price is disclosed. The Appellant gave a list of contemporary imports. He draws our attention to the details of contemporary imports of identical goods imported at or about the same prices at which the Appellants had imported the impugned goods. He submits that the aforesaid evidence of contemporary import of identical goods were ignored by the adjudicating authority and the demands were upheld in terms of Rule 8 by adopting the LME prices of virgin material and applying discount bands which on the face are illegal as the prices of contemporaneous import were available. He submits that identical goods were imported in case of Pushpak Metal Corporation 2014 (312) ELT 381 during the same period and the Appellant’s imports at prices comparable to the Appellant import price. The said prices were upheld by the Tribunal by holding that value cannot be determined on the basis of LME Prices. The said order was accepted by the CBEC Board. He also provides the comparison of the import prices with Baheti Metal case decided by Tribunal and reported under same Pushpak Metal case supra with the prices of imported goods involved in present case.

2.3 In respect of several imports made in year 2006 at Nhava Sheva included in Annexure – C to show cause notice, he submits that the assessments were provisional which were finalized by the Order No. 2958/09 AM (I) dt. 18.05.2009 enhancing the value by relying on LME. The order was set aside by Commissioner (Appeals) vide Order-in-appeal dt. 09.09.2010 and the appeal against the same before Tribunal filed by the revenue was rejected by decision reported as CC Vs. Bharati Rubber Lining & Allied Services 2013 (287) ELT 124. That in case of imports made in year 2006 made at Kandla and Mundra Port included in Annexure – ‘E’ of SCN, the assessments were provisional which were finalized by Order-in-Original dt. 21.02.2011 and 03.07.2012 accepting the transaction value and holding that value cannot be determined under Rule 8 on the basis of LME less discount band. The order attained finality.

2.4 Ld. Counsel submits that adopting LME price of Virgin metal and applying discount bands as a principle of valuation of scrap has been outrightly rejected in decisions of Tribunal which stands accepted by the CBEC and Apex Court. He relies upon judgments in case of Pushpak Metal Corporation 2014 (312) ELT 381, Bharati Rubber Lining & Allied Services Pvt. Ltd. 2013 (287) ELT 124. He submits that in view of aforesaid two judgments, the demand cannot be re-determined under Rule 8 by adopting LME price of prime raw material and applying the discount bands. He also draws our attention to the communication of CBEC to the effect that while accepting the aforesaid decision of Pushpak Metal, the CBEC has categorically taken a view that recourse to LME price cannot be taken to substantiate the charge of undervaluation when contemporaneous import of almost same prices was available during the material time. He also submits that the adjudicating authority has erred in relying upon statement of Shri Sunil Agarwal for justifying recourse to LME prices. He point out that there is contradiction in statement dt. 29.05.2006 and 23.04.2007 of Shri Sushil Agarwal that Shri Sushil Agarwal, Partner of M/s SMRI in course of recording of his statement dt. 29.05.2006 was shown an alleged abstract of LME price of Aluminium Scrap as per which the Aluminium scrap was 80% of the LME price of Aluminium and his statement was obtained that the prevailing LME price formed the basis of negotiations and that normally the price of Aluminium scrap was negotiated at 80% of the LME. Another statement of Shri Sushil Kumar Agrawal was recorded on 23.4.2007 in which the statement was obtained that the import price of Aluminum Scrap was negotiated by applying different discount bands ranging from 5% to 35% to the LME prices for various grades such as Trump, Tense, Taldon, Throb etc., which corresponded to the discount bands provided in Alert Circular No. 14/2005 dated 16.12.2005 of the Director General of Valuation. The statements clearly shows that initially the investigating officers were attempting to apply 80% of the LME but later realizing that even the Directorate General of Valuation was not recommending 80% of LME, they conveniently abstracted the statement of Shri Sushil Kumar Agrawal to match the discount band, as per DGOV circular. He submits that such statements cannot be relied upon as in numerous judgments of the Tribunal and the High Court as well as the CBEC itself has out-rightly rejected the principal of adopting LME less discount band. It is inconceivable that Shri Sushsil Kumar Agrawal, who is in the business of import and re-cycling of non-ferrous scrap for so many years would agree to the proposition that the price of scrap would be equal to the price of material content in the scrap. Any person in business of import and re-cycling of such scrap would know that it is impossible to recover the entire material content; there would be process loss, there is a cost to be incurred for conversion of scrap to material and further prices of recovered material would not be equal to the price of prime virgin material. Hence it is impossible to believe the statement of Shri Agrawal to the effect that the price of scrap is equal to the virgin metal price of metal content in the scrap. He also points out that in the statement dated 19.4.2007, Shri Agrawal is said to have submitted year-wise charts for the period 2002 to 2006 depicting the quantum of imports of Zinc Ash / Dross / Scrap and Aluminum scarp covering 2200 import consignments running into 120 pages, which was not possible since all the import documents such as bills of entry etc. were seized by the DRI in May 2006 itself. This clearly shows that his statements were not true or voluntary and he has merely signed the statement prepared by the DRI.

2.5 As regards reliance placed in the show cause notice and impugned order upon the statement of indentors, he submits that those statements cannot be relied upon for the reason that they did not appear for cross examination. Similarly, no reliance can be placed on the alleged recovery of e-mails from the laptop of the indentor as no cross examination was given of panch witness and the officers who conducted the Panchnama. It is inconceivable that the activities alleged to have been undertaken, as recorded in the panchnama, could have been undertaken within a short term period during which the Panchnama is alleged to have been conducted. He relies upon the judgments in case of Motabhai Iron & Steel Industries 2015 (316) ELT 374 (GUJ), Basudev Garg Vs. CC 2013 (294) ELT 353 (DEL), Andaman Timber Industries Vs. CCE 2015 (324) ELT 641 (SC) to submit that in absence of cross examination, the statements cannot be relied upon.

2.6 He also submits that no additional duty (CVD) is payable in respect of Zinc Ash, Dross, skimmings, Scrap and Aluminium Scrap as it is a settled law laid down by the Apex Court in case of Hyderabad Industries Ltd. 1999 (108) ELT 321 (SC) that if an article is not liable to excise duty since it is not a manufactured product, no additional duty of customs can be levied on the import of such article. He relies upon following Circulars and judgments:

(i) Circular No. 904/24/2009 – CX dated 28.10.2009

(ii) Hindalco Industries Ltd vs UOI – 2015 (315) ELT 10 (Bom)

(iii) Circular No. 1027/15/2016-CX dated 25.04.2016

(iv) Slugs India Ltd vs CCE – 202 (278) ELT 611

(v) CC vs Tata Iron & Steel Co. Ltd – 20

(vi) 04 (165) ELT 386 (SC)(vii) Bhushan Steel Ltd vs CCE – 2012 (284) ELT 713

(viii) Shri Ram Agro Chemicals (P) Ltd vs UOI – 2009 (234) ELT 218 (P & H)

(ix) CC vs L. Madanlal (Aluminium) Ltd – 2010 (258) ELT 107

(x) Karnataka Chemical IndusCorpn Ltd vs CC – 2005 (183) ELT 207.

2.7 He submits that the Ld. adjudicating authority has held that the appellants have not produced evidence to show that the imported goods are not manufactured products. The said finding is totally un-tenable as the decisions and Board circulars themselves establish that the said goods are not manufactured products. The definitions of various scrap imported as per ISRI along with photographs clearly indicate that these scraps are not result of any manufacturing process. The adjudicating authority has so erred in holding that the issue of no additional duty of customs is payable cannot be raised in reply to Notice under Section 28 when the same was not raised at the time of assessment. The Ld. Counsel submits that the contention of the Adjudicating authority is absolutely erroneous as it is a settled law that when notice u/s 28 is issued, it opens up the entire assessment and it is, therefore open to the importer to raise the issue that duty is not payable even for the reason not taken at the time of original assessment. He relies upon the judgments in cases of Decora Ceramics Pvt Ltd vs CCE – 1998 (100) ELT 279, Lili Foam Industries (P) Ltd vs CCE – 1990 (46) ELT 462 and Bakeman Home Products Pvt Ltd vs CC – 1997 (95) ELT 278.

2.8 The Ld. Counsel also points out that in respect of 550 Bills of entries covered under Annexure – C, value was already enhanced at the time of assessment and hence there cannot be any reassessment of the said values, which had become final for want of appeal against the same. He places reliance on judgments in the case of CC vs Lord Shiva Overseas – 2005 (181) ELT 213, Malhotra Impex vs CC – 2006 (203) ELT 561 and CC vs Paras Electronics – 2009 (246) ELT 231. As regard export declaration in respect of one consignment shipped from New Zealand and 11 consignments shipped from Spain, he submits that the declarations have no relevance as the same were not authenticated by the News Zealand Customs and Spanish Customs. Most of them are in respect of goods other than those imported by the Appellants and they are not consignees. He points out that in some declarations, the goods are Iron & Steel scrap which are not imported by them. He submits that in any event, the values not been re-determined on the basis of these declarations and hence they have no relevance.

3. Shri T.G Rathod, Ld. Joint Commissioner (AR) appearing for the revenue reiterates the findings of the impugned order. He further submits that as apparent from the report from Consulate General of India, USA, the appellant had imported Zinc Skimming from M/s U.S. Zinc but misdeclared and undervalued the same as Zinc Ash. The sales detail form as well as mail retrieved from the laptop of indenter Shri Tarun Jhingon shows that the goods were having high metal content and were zinc skimming. He also submits that the impugned consignments including the Aluminium scrap were undervalued as may be found from the statement of indentors and statement of Partner Shri Sushil Agarwal and others. That in case of scrap imported from M/s Sunberg U.K and PWT Australia, the consulates has informed that the process were undervalued. He supports and reiterates the findings of the impugned order and submits that the valuation of imported goods resorted to in terms of Rule 8 of Customs Valuation Rules by taking LME price less discount band is correct. Written Submission dated 27.09.2019 along with compilation of judgment which was taken on record.

4. Heard both the sides and proposed the case records. The demand of duty in Annexure – II to show cause notice in case of 32 consignments imported by M/s SMRI from M/s US Zinc, USA through indentor Shri Tarun Jhingon of M/s Trendene Pvt Ltd is on the ground that the goods were mis-declared as Zinc Ash whereas the same was Zinc Skimming. The show cause notice has relied upon the documents received from the Consulate General of India, USA, three e-mails retrieved from the laptop of Shri Tarun Jhingon and the correspondence between the officials of US Zinc concerning the valuation of goods. Also the test report of goods found at factory whose samples were tested by the Chemical Examiner, Central Excise & Customs Laboratory, Vadodara has been relied upon wherein the examiner reported that the goods are other than zinc ash. Against these emails and documents and the report of chemical examiner, we find that the goods on their importation were sent to laboratory for testing to the Chemical Examiner at the Nhava Sheva Port. From the test report annexed to the Appeal, we find that the Chemical Examiner reported that the goods are zinc ash. Such test reports has not been disputed. Contrary to the same we find that the revenue has relied upon the test report of samples drawn from the Appellant’s factory. The Chemical Examiner in his report has reported that the goods are other than Zinc Ash. However it is nowhere appearing that the goods are skimmings. The Appellant had requested cross examination of chemical examiner which was also not allowed. In our view when the goods on importation were found to be zinc ash and permitted to be cleared after testing and also that the chemical examination report of goods seized from factory is inconclusive, the goods would merit classification as Zinc Ash only. Even though there is communication from the Indian Consulate or the emails between the indentor and supplier, but in the light of the fact that the goods were found to be Zinc Ash during imports, we are inclined to hold that the charges of mis-declaration are not sustainable and hence no duty demand can be made. There is no evidence found at the end of the Appellant and the documents relied upon to support the allegation were of third party. Hence in such circumstances, we are of the view that the charges of misdeclaration and undervaluation does not sustain.

4.1 Further coming to the demands made in above Annexure – II, Annexure A-III on Zinc Ash and in Annexure A-IV on Zinc Dross, we find that the demand has been made in respect of Zinc Ash by determining the value on the basis of 35% of the LME prices and in case of Zinc Dross 75% of the LME. The Appellant has contended that since the assessment were provisional, hence the demand under section 28 cannot be made. We find that though the Ld. Adjudicating authority in Para 291 of the impugned order has accepted the ratio that in case of provisional assessment demand under section 28 cannot be made, but proceeded to confirm demand on the ground that Appellants have not specifically mentioned as to which Bills of Entry are provisional and there is no evidence in the form of execution of Bond. We find the aforesaid findings to be erroneous and contrary to facts. The Appellant had clearly stated in their reply to the SCN that all the goods covered by Annexure-II, III and IV are provisionally assessed and also produced copy of Bills of Entry which clearly show the mention of Test Bond. The printouts taken from EDI system also shows that the assessment were provisional. In such case when the imported goods were provisionally assessed by execution of test bond and is fact apparent, in that case, there is no ground to demand duty.

5. In case of imported Aluminium scrap as detailed in Annexure – ‘C’, ‘D’, ‘E’ and ‘F’ of the show cause notice, the demands have been made under Rule 8 of the Customs Valuation Rules, 1988 by applying price bands to LME prices as per Alert Circular No. 14/2005 dt. 16.12.2005 issued by the Director General of Valuation. The show cause notice has relied upon the statements of the Partners of M/s SMRI and indentors to allege undervaluation. The show cause notice has proposed demand by rejecting declared value. Even though the show cause notice states that wherever the contemporaneous values were found the same has been applied by re-determining the value under Rule 6 and in rest of the cases Rule 8 has been applied, but we find that all demands have been made by applying LME prices and nowhere such contemporaneous values has been cited in show cause notice. The demands have thus been made by adopting the LME prices of Virgin metal and applying discounts inspite of the fact that the Apepllant had produced details of contemporaneous imports. The adjudicating authority if was to redetermine the value, he should have sequentially applied Rule 5 and 6 of the Customs Valuation Rules i.e Transaction value of similar goods or determination under rule 6 by determining under provisions of Rule 7. The Appellant in their reply to show cause notice had provided list of contemporaneous import of identical goods at the same price and we have perused the same. This has been overlooked by the adjudicating authority. We are of the view that if the declared value is to be rejected in that case the CVR, 2008 has to be applied sequentially i.e Rule 5 and 6 is to be applied. If the value of the contemporaneous goods are available, the same shall be basis for re-determining the prices. Whereas in the case of instant demands the prices of contemporaneous imports were same as that of Appellant and hence the LME Prices reduced by discount band could not have been basis for re-determining the prices and rejecting the declared value. The Appellant has pointed out that identical goods were imported in case of Pushpak Metal Corporation 2014 (312) ELT 381 which were imported during the same period and comparable with Appellant’s import price. The said prices were upheld by the Tribunal and it was held that value cannot be determined on the basis of LME prices. Also that the said decision was accepted by the CBEC. The Appellant has annexed comparison sheet showing the prices in their case and in case of Baheti Metal which was reported as Puspak metal case supra. We find that when the prices in case of Pushpak metal case supra has been accepted by the revenue and the same are contemporary prices to the Appellant’s import, in that case the value redetermined vide the impugned order by taking LME Prices as basis is not sustainable. Hence we do not find any reason to uphold the demand confirmed against Appellant as above.

6. In case of demands made under Annexure-‘C’ on Aluminium Scrap, it is observed that several imports were made through Nhava Sheva Port and the assessments were provisional. The Order No. 2958/09 AM (I) was passed for finalization of assessment and the prices were enhanced by applying LME. The Appellant approached Commissioner (Appeal) who vide Order-in-Appeal dt. 09.09.2010 set aside the enhancement. The revenue’s appeal against said order-in-appeal also stands dismissed as reported in Bharathi Rubber Lining & Allied Services P. Ltd. 2013 (287) ELT 124. In such case there is no ground to redetermine the value as the redetermination on basis of LME price already stands decided by the Tribunal. Similarly in respect of imports made through Kandla and Mudra Port included in Annexure – ‘E’ to SCN the assessments were provisional but were finalized vide Orders-in-Original dt. 21.02.2011 and 03.07.2012 accepting the transaction value. It was also held that value cannot be re-determined under Rule 8 on the basis of LME minus discount band. Such orders stands accepted by the revenue. In such case we do not find any reason to reject the declared value. We also find that the issue of determining the value by adopting the price of virgin metal and applying discount bands has been rejected in catena of judgments. In case of Bharathi Rubber Lining & Allied Services P. Ltd. 2013 (287) ELT 124, the tribunal held as under:

5.4 The lower appellate authority has rejected the reliance place on the DGOV Circular on the ground that in terms of the Hon’ble Apex Court judgment in the case of Varsha Plastics (cited supra), the assessment under the provisions of Customs Valuation Rules cannot be given a go-by and the Valuation Rules will prevail over the departmental instructions on the subject matter. The Hon’ble Apex Court in the said case held as follows:

“The valuation of the imported goods where the transaction value in the opinion of Assessing Authority is liable to be rejected because of invoice manipulation or under-invoicing or un-realistic price or misdeclaration in respect of valuation of goods or description or where transaction value of the goods declared is ridiculously low, which of course the Assessing Authority has to justify, he must proceed to determine valuation of goods by following Customs Valuation Rules. The availability of evidence of contemporaneous import of the same goods obviously provides the best guide for determination of value of the import of goods but in the absence of evidence of contemporaneous import, reference to foreign journal for finding out correct international price of imported goods may not be irrelevant.”

5.5 In the instant case, the proposition in the show cause notice is that the value of the contemporaneous imports indicated a higher price. If that be so, that should have been the starting point for determination of value of the imported goods and not some other basis. Further even when we take the values of the contemporaneous imports, the lowest of such value has to be adopted as provided for in Rule 6 and not the highest. In the instant case no such thing has been done by the assessing officer.

5.6 In view of the above, we do not find any infirmity in the observation of the Commissioner (Appeals) that the DGOV Circular cannot override the provisions of Valuation Rules. The Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Commissioner of Customs, Calcutta v. South India Television – 2007 (214) E.L.T. 3 (S.C.) had held that casting suspicion on invoice produced by the importer is not sufficient to reject it as evidence of value. The invoice price is not sacrosanct but before rejecting the invoice price, the department has to give cogent reasons for such rejection. The assessing authority has to examine each and every case on merits for deciding its validity and he cannot form a view to reject all transaction values on

the basis of some general criteria based on DGOV Circular and on that basis load the value of imports uniformly across board. This Tribunal in the case of FSP (India) Pvt. Ltd. (cited supra) held that uniform loading based on general criteria is not permissible.

In case of CCU, NEW DELHI Vs. PRABHU DAYAL PREM CHAND 2010 (253) ELT 353 (SC), the Apex Court held as under:

“2. The respondent assesee filed two Bills of Entry dated 16th September, 1988 and 17th December, 1998 for clearance of Brass Scrap and Copper Scrap as per ISRI grade “Honey” and Birth/Cliff” respectively. The Bills of Entry were assessed at the declared invoice value, viz., CIF US $ 1100 and US $ 1300 PMT respectively. After inspection, the goods were cleared on payment of customs duty assessed.

3. Subsequently, on the basis of the information received from the London Metal Exchange, (for short, “the LME”) to the effect that the price of the said metals in the LME as on the date of import was more than the price declared by the respondent, an additional duty amounting to Rs. 90,248/- and 1,94,035/- respectively was demanded from the assessee on the said two Bills of Entry. The additional demand having been confirmed by the Deputy Commissioner of Customs, the assessee preferred appeal to the Commissioner (Appeals) but without any success.

4. Aggrieved, the assessee carried the matter in further appeal to the Customs, Excise and Gold (Control) Appellate Tribunal, New Delhi, (for short “the Tribunal”) as it then existed. By the impugned order, the Tribunal has allowed the appeal and quashed the additional amount of duty demanded from the respondent. While accepting the plea of the assessee that they were not confronted with any contemporaneous material relied upon by the revenue for enhancing the price declared by them in the bills of entry, the Tribunal has observed thus:

“In the present case as mentioned above, even though there is a reference to contemporaneous import in the order passed by the Deputy commissioner no material regarding such import has been placed before us or made available by the appellant at any point of time. Therefore, assessment in this case has to be taken as having been made purely on the basis of LME Bulletin without any corroborative evidence of imports at or near that price which is not permissible under law. We, therefore, set aside the impugned order and allowed the appeal.”

5. Not being satisfied with the said order, the revenue is before us in this appeal.

6. We have heard Mr. Biswajit Bhattacharya, learned Additional Solicitor General on behalf of the revenue. The assessee remains unrepresented.

7. Learned counsel submits that since the LME bulletin is a true indicator of current international prices of metals, the adjudicating authority was justified in adopting the price of the said two metals as notified by the LME, and therefore, the Tribunal was not justified in quashing the additional customs duty determined to be payable on the imports in question.

8. We are unable to persuade ourselves to agree with the learned counsel. It is manifest from the afore-extracted order of the Tribunal that no details of any contemporaneous imports or any other material indicating the price notified by the LME had either been referred to by the adjudicating Officer in the adjudication order or such material was placed before the Tribunal at the time of hearing of the appeal. Learned counsel for the Revenue has not been able to controvert the said observations by the Tribunal. In that view of the matter no fault can be found with the order passed by the Tribunal setting aside the additional demand created against the assessee.”

In case of GKN SINTER METALS LIMITED Vs. CCE, Pune 2008 (232) E.L.T. 692 (Tri. – Mumbai), the tribunal held as under:

“2. We have heard both sides. We find that the prices in the LME bulletin for prime metal are only indicative and cannot be the sole basis for enhancing the value of copper scrap, particularly when the goods imported are copper scrap and not copper. Further there is no basis for holding that refining charges for refining scrap and conversion of the same to copper bar/rod will be US$ 150 per MT. As per Rule 4(2)(b) of the Valuation Rules transaction value of the imported goods shall be accepted provided that (a)- – – – (b) the sale does not involve any abnormal discount or reduction from the ordinary competitive price. It is clause (b) which is highlighted by the Commissioner (Appeals). However, there is no material on record to establish that the suppliers offered any abnormal discount or reduction from the ordinary competitive price for copper scraps which were imported by the appellants. Further, it is brought to our notice that the price declared is only marginally lower than the price as loaded.

3. In the light of the Tribunal’s decision in the case of Drunkey Exports (P) Ltd. v. Commissioner of Customs (Port), Kolkata-I – 2004 (165) E.L.T. 417 (Tri.- Kolkata) and Commissioner of Customs, Kandla v. Meera Impex – 2004 (167) E.L.T. 446 (Tri.-Mumbai) holding that LME prices are indicative and cannot be the basis for enhancing the value in the absence of corroborative evidence of contemporaneous imports at higher price, we hold that enhancement of the value is not justified in the present case and accordingly set aside the impugned order and allow the appeal.

The above Tribunal judgment stands upheld by the Apex Court as reported in Commissioner Vs. GKN Sinter Metals Limited – 2010 (254) E.L.T. A43 (S.C.)]”

Same analogy has been taken by the Tribunal in case of Bothra Metal & Alloys 2013 (9) TMI 546. It is therefore absolutely clear that the redetermination of value based upon LME prices less discount band as per DGOV Alert Circular supra is not sustainable.

7. From the above judgments it is absolutely clear that applying the LME price minus discount band as per SMRI bulletin or DGIV Circular No. 14/2005 dt. 16.12.2005 is absolutely wrong. The Appellant has also relied upon the letter F. No. S/26 – Misc-1040/2005 GrIV dt. 13.02.2006 of the Commissioner of Customs, Nhava Sheva wherein the Commissioner in reference to Valuation of Aluminium Scrap under Alert Circular No. 14/2005 issued under F. No. VAL/TECH/37/2005 dt. 16.12.2005 has stated that there is no linear correlation between the prices of Aluminium Metal and prices of Aluminium Scrap quoted in Metal Bulletin. The main excerpts of the above communication of the Commissioner Nhava Sheva clearly mentions as under:

2.

A.

B. ……………………. the enquiries with the trade reveal that in case the difference between the prime metal and scrap is indeed so small, it does not make economic sense to go in for purchase of scrap. Inquiries from the trade have revealed that the Aluminium Scrap is used for melting purpose and re-melted Aluminium Ingots produced out of it has a sale price of 8 to 10% lower than the virgin metal. This also includes manufacturing cost and the recovery of the metal from scrap is never 100%.

3. ………………………………..

4. It may also be mentioned that there is no linear correlation between the prices of Aluminium Metal and the prices of Aluminium Scrap quoted in the Metal Bulletin.

…………………..

5. It can be seen that the prices of Aluminium Scrap has not changed in spite of surge in the prices of Aluminium Metal as mentioned in the Metal Bulletin.

From the above communication it is absolutely clear that even the revenue authorities did not consider the valuation of Aluminium scrap to be made as per Alert Circular or based upon LME Prices.

Even the CBEC Board while accepting the decision of the PushpakAluminium case vide letter F. No. 387/w/9/2013-JC dt. 25th June 2013 F No. 387/W/9/2013-JC dated 25 June, 2013 has clarified as under:-

“Recourse to LME prices can’t be taken to substantiate the charge of undervaluation when contemporaneous import of almost same prices was available during the material time. It is a settled law that transaction value can’t be rejected unless there is contemporaneous evidence to reject the invoice value as being held by the Apex Court in case laws like Commissioner of Customs, New Delhi vs. M/s. Prabhu Dayal Prem Chand reported in 2010 (253) ELT 353 (S.C.), Commissioner of Customs, Kolkata vs. M/s. South India Television (P) Ltd. reported in 2007 (214) ELT 3 (S.C.), Commissioner of Customs, Mumbai vs. H.D. Orgochem Ltd. reported in 2008 (226) ELT 9 (S.C.).

The case laws relied upon by the Department will not help our cause because these decisions were applicable in respect of prime metals only and not w.r.t. scrap except in the case of Varsha Plastics. In Varsha Plastic also, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that the availability of evidence of contemporaneous import of the same goods obviously periods the best guide for determination of value of the import of goods. But in the absence of evidence of contemporaneous import, reference to foreign journals for finding out the correct international prices for the purpose of Section 14 of the Customs Act is not irrelevant. Since contemporaneous import prices were available in the present case as being noted but not accepted by the Commissioner in the Order—in-Original, departmental case for undervaluation become weak and appeal in Supreme Court is not merited”

We find from the communication dated 29.10.2008 of the Institute of Scrap Re-cycling Industries, INC (ISRI), wherein they have stated as under:

“We have been asked to explain how aluminum scrap prices are determined. Please be advised that ISRI, as a trade association, does not become involved in scrap pricing. However, our understanding of the market is that scrap prices are determined through negotiations between buyers and sellers, based upon then current market information derived from a variety of sources, including trade press such as the American Metal Market and the Metal Bulletin, as well as future markets. These information sources are utilized as a general market trend basis for negotiation. It should be noted that scrap metal is not traded directly on the futures exchanges – rather it is alloy ingots derived from scrap material that are traded on some of the exchanges such as the London Metal Exchange (LME).”

8. In view of above communication of ISRI it is absolutely clear that the scrap price would depend on many factors and the LME based price cannot be applied blindly to imports of scrap for the purpose of valuation.

9. Most pertinently we find that the whole case is also based upon allegation that the differential amount was paid by the Appellant through Hawala Channels or transfer. However we find that in the show cause notice not a single person was identified or investigations were made as whom the differential value amount was handed over. Except naming Chaganlal no person has been named. There is no evidence as to how the Appellant came into possession of cash alleged to be differential amount towards scrap import neither there is any evidence of any cash being handed over to any person representing suppliers. In absence of same the allegation of undervaluation cannot be supported.

10. The Adjudicating authority in order to justify the LME based valuation has relied upon the statement of Shri Sushil Agarwal, Partner of M/s SMRI and indentors. The Appellant has objected to reliance on such statements that the statement dt. 29.05.2006 and 23.04.2007 of Shri Sushil Agarwal are contradictory as different pricing method was stated by him which are not applicable in the facts of the case. That the cross examination of Shri Sushil Agarwal was also not allowed. Further that even though the cross examination of indentors were allowed but they did not appear for the cross examination. The Appellant has pleaded that in such circumstances, the statement of Shri Sushil Agarwal and indentors cannot be relied upon. We find that the adjudicating authority ought to have allowed cross examination of Shri Sushil Agarwal as the same was necessarily required in view of his statements dated 29.5.2006 and 23.04.2007 which were contradictory in respect of value of imported goods. In his statement dated 29.5.2006 on being shown an alleged abstract of LME prices of Aluminium Scrap, which showed price of Aluminium scrap as 80% of the LME price he had stated that the prevailing LME prices formed the basis of negotiation and that normally, the prices of Aluminium scrap were negotiated at 80% of the LME. However in his statement dated 23.04.2007, he has stated that the import price of Aluminium Scrap was negotiated by applying different discount bands ranging from 5% to 35% to the LME price of various grades, viz. Trump, Tense, Taldon, Trob etc., which corresponded to the discount band provided in Alert Circular No. 14/2005 dated 16.12.2005 of the Director General of Valuation. In such a case, we are inclined to accept the submission of the Appellant that initially the investigating officers were attempting to apply 80% of the LME, but later on realizing that even the Director General of Valuation was not recommending valuation of 80% of the LME, the statement of Shri Sushil Agarwal was recorded to match the discount band, as per DGOV Circular. In such view of the facts, we do not find any reason to rely upon the statement of Shri Agarwal to support the allegation of under-valuation on the part of the Appellant. The Appellant has pleaded that it is incomprehensible that Shri Sushil Agarwal, who was in business of imports of Aluminium Scraps and Zinc Scrap since last many years would state that the prices of Scrap would be equal to the prices of metal content. It is a known fact that re-cycling of scrap would not result into recovery of entire metal content as there would be a process loss, cost to be incurred for conversion of scrap to metal. Such metal produced from Scrap cannot command same price as that of virgin metal. We find that the Appellant had sought cross examination of Shri Sushil Agarwal under Rule 138B of the Customs Act. The allegation of undervaluation are based upon the letters of Indian Consulates and statements of indentors namely Shri Anil Parolia of Nihon Ispat, Shri Tarun Jhingon, Shri Ehsan Amin Gadawala and Shri Mihir Bhat as well as letters from Indian Consulate at U.S.A in reference to import of 32 consignments of Zinc Ash, Indian Consulate at UK in respect of 11 Consignment imported from Sunberg and Indian Consulate at Singapore in respect of 2 consignments imported from PWT Australia. The Appellant had sought cross examination of Indentors. The Appellant has also sought cross-examination of the officials and panchas, who were present during drawal of Panchnama on 26.04.2006 for examination of seized laptop of Shri Tarun Jhingon on the ground that it was not possible to complete the proceedings in 2 hours, as stated in the show cause notice. The cross examination of the officials, who had recorded the statement of Shri Sushil Agarwal on 9.4.2007 was also sought since it was recorded in his statement that he had submitted in tabular form running into 120 pages the particulars of all imports made in 5 years by the Appellant, which are involved in the impugned appeal. The Appellant in their reply had contended that the cross examination of officials was sought as all the import related documents of the Appellant were lying seized with the investigating officers and there was no occasion for Shri Sushil Agarwal to compile such information in absence of any import documents. However except indentors no cross examination of any of the above persons was allowed. The cross examination of Shri Sushil Agarwal was denied by the adjudicating authority on the ground that no new facts are likely to come out at such examination and cross-examination. This reasoning of the adjudicating authority is highly erroneous since it cannot be assumed that the cross examination of a person would not bring any material not already available. Our views are based upon the judgment of the Hon’ble apex court in case of Andaman Timber Industries – 2015 (324) ELT 641 (SC), wherein the apex court held as under:

“6. According to us, not allowing the assessee to cross-examine the witnesses by the Adjudicating Authority though the statements of those witnesses were made the basis of the impugned order is a serious flaw which makes the order nullity inasmuch as it amounted to violation of principles of natural justice because of which the assessee was adversely affected. It is to be borne in mind that the order of the Commissioner was based upon the statements given by the aforesaid two witnesses. Even when the assessee disputed the correctness of the statements and wanted to cross-examine, the Adjudicating Authority did not grant this opportunity to the assessee. It would be pertinent to note that in the impugned order passed by the Adjudicating Authority he has specifically mentioned that such an opportunity was sought by the assessee. However, no such opportunity was granted and the aforesaid plea is not even dealt with by the Adjudicating Authority. As far as the Tribunal is concerned, we find that rejection of this plea is totally untenable. The Tribunal has simply stated that cross-examination of the said dealers could not have brought out any material which would not be in possession of the appellant themselves to explain as to why their ex-factory prices remain static. It was not for the Tribunal to have guess work as to for what purposes the appellant wanted to cross-examine those dealers and what extraction the appellant wanted from them.

7. As mentioned above, the appellant had contested the truthfulness of the statements of these two witnesses and wanted to discredit their testimony for which purpose it wanted to avail the opportunity of cross-examination. That apart, the Adjudicating Authority simply relied upon the price list as maintained at the depot to determine the price for the purpose of levy of excise duty. Whether the goods were, in fact, sold to the said dealers/witnesses at the price which is mentioned in the price list itself could be the subject matter of cross-examination. Therefore, it was not for the Adjudicating Authority to presuppose as to what could be the subject matter of the cross-examination and make the remarks as mentioned above. We may also point out that on an earlier occasion when the matter came before this Court in Civil Appeal No. 2216 of 2000, order dated 17-3-2005 [2005 (187) E.L.T. A33 (S.C.)] was passed remitting the case back to the Tribunal with the directions to decide the appeal on merits giving its reasons for accepting or rejecting the submissions.

8. In view the above, we are of the opinion that if the testimony of these two witnesses is discredited, there was no material with the Department on the basis of which it could justify its action, as the statement of the aforesaid two witnesses was the only basis of issuing the show cause notice.

9. We, thus, set aside the impugned order as passed by the Tribunal and allow this appeal.”

11. Similarly, in case of Vasudev Garg – 2013 (294) ELT 353 (Dl), it was held that it was mandatory to give cross examination. It was held that the statement against the assessee cannot be used without giving them opportunity of cross examining the witness as it is valuable right of accused/ noticee in quasi judicial proceedings which can have adverse consequence for them. The Adjudicating authority had allowed cross examination of indentors and even they were also issued notice, none of the indentor was made available for cross examination. In such circumstances when these persons could not be produced for cross examination, their statements could not have been relied upon. Especially in case of Mihir Bhatt, Ehsan Amin Gadawala where the only evidence was their own statements stating undervaluation. In case of other persons also in the light of above facts, the adjudicating authority should have allowed the cross examination. In absence of the opportunity to cross examine the above persons, we are of the view that no reliance can be placed upon their statements. Our views are supported by the judgment of Hon’ble High Court of Gujarat in case of CC Vs. Motabhai Iron & Steel Industries 2015 (316) ELT 374 (GUJ) wherein the Hon’ble High Court has held that “no reliance can be placed on the statement of such witness who has not subjected himself to cross-examination by the affected party”. Similarly we are of the view that no reliance can be placed on the alleged recovery of email from indentor Shri Tarun Jhingon as no opportunity of cross examination of panch witness and officers was given to Appellant. We further find that during the visit to the factory of M/s SMRI, the officers had questioned the employee of M/s SMRI namely Shri Rajesh Kumar Trivedi, C. Haridas and Nikhil Jain on the basis of documents called “Abstract of LME Price of Aluminium Scrap and Zinc Scrap’ to which said employees had stated that the Appellant’s declared price was less. This document was handed over to the Appellant on 20.02.2018 and it contained Pages 1 to 8 lowest & Highest Zinc prices of a day and the next 10 pages tiled MP Prices & Archive containing low price of the day alongwith 80% of said price. However we find that nowhere the said papers contain prices of Aluminium or Zinc Scrap. Also no prices of Aluminium Scrap is issued by the LME as it is not concerned with scrap pricing. Hence the allegation that the Appellant’s declared price was less than the mentioned in said document does not hold any substance. We also find that the Appellant had sought cross examination of the officers for the source and authenticity of such document and 80% formula derived by officers. They had also sought cross examination of panch witness who had witnessed such proceedings. However the same was not allowed. In absence of authenticity of such document and refusal of cross examination we find that the charges of undervaluation are not sustainable.

12. Coming to the issue raised by the Appellants that no additional duty of Customs is payable in respect of Zinc Ash, skimmings and scrap as these are not manufactured product, we observe that adjudicating authority has denied relief to Appellant on ground that they have not produced evidence to show that goods are not manufactured products. We find from the definition of various scrap imported as per ISRI and the photographs annexed to appeal papers that it clearly shows that the scrap was not arising as a result of process of manufacture. The ratio of law on such scarp being non excisable is absolutely settled by the judgments and Circulars viz. Hindalco Industries Ltd. 2015 (315) ELT 10 (Bom), Circular No. 904/24/2009 – CX dated 28.10.2009, Circular No. 1027/15/2016-CX dated 25.04.2016, Slugs India Ltd Vs. CCE – 202 (278) ELT 611, CC vs Tata Iron & Steel Co. Ltd – 2004 (165) ELT 386 (SC), Bhushan Steel Ltd vs CCE – 2012 (284) ELT 713, Shri Ram Agro Chemicals (P) Ltd vs UOI – 2009 (234) ELT 218 (P & H), CC vs L. Madanlal (Aluminium) Ltd – 2010 (258) ELT 107, Karnataka Chemical IndusCorpn. Ltd vs CC – 2005 (183) ELT 207. The adjudicating authority also held that since the issue of non-payment of Additional duty was not raised at the time of assessment, hence cannot be raised in reply to show cause notice under section 28. The contention of adjudicating authority is not sustainable as when notice under section 28 is issued to an assessee, he can contest the whole assessment to say that duty is not payable for a reason not taken up at the time of original assessment. He is entitled for all reliefs/ exemption associated with the assessment. The issues is well settled by the Tribunal’s order in case of Decora Ceramics P. Ltd. 1998 (100) ELT 297, Lili Foam Indus. P. Ltd. 1990 (46) ELT 462, Bakeman Home Products P. Ltd. 1997 (95) ELT 278.

13. Further, we also find that in respect of 550 Bills of entries covered under Annexure – C, value was already enhanced at the time of assessment and hence further proposal to re-enhance the value when the earlier assessment order has attained finality since no appeal/review was filed against such order, is not sustainable. There cannot be any reassessment of the said values, which had become final for want of appeal against the same. Our views are supported by judgments in case CC vs Lord Shiva Overseas – 2005 (181) ELT 213, Malhotra Impex vs CC – 2006 (203) ELT 561 and CC vs Paras Electronics – 2009 (246) ELT 231.

14. In respect of export declaration in respect of one consignment shipped from New Zealand and 11 consignments shipped from Spain, we are in agreement with the submission of the Appellant that such declarations have no relevance as the same were not authenticated by the News Zealand Customs and Spanish Customs. Even otherwise also most of these declarations are in respect of goods viz. Iron and Steel i.e other than those imported by the Appellants and the Appellant are not consignees. Even in some declarations, the goods are Iron & Steel scrap which were not imported by Appellant. Even the values has not been re-determined on the basis of such declarations and hence the same are not relevant in the instant case.

15. In respect of demands made in Annexure – RM-I and II, we find that the demands was raised on same ground as in case of demand made in other annexures. We have elaborately discussed the grounds for non sustainability of demand and the same ratio would apply in respect of seized goods also. Also since the charges of undervaluation of declared price is not sustainable, hence the confiscation of goods is also not sustainable.

16. In view of our above observations and findings, we are of the view that the demands confirmed against M/s SMRI, confiscation of goods and penalties imposed upon M/s SMRI is not sustainable. For the same reason the penalty imposed upon co-appellants namely Shri Sushil Kumar Agarwal, Shri Surendra P. Kachhara and Shri Sanjeev Kumar Agarwal is also not sustainable. We thus set aside the impugned order and allow all the appeals before us with consequential reliefs to the Appellants.

Advertisement

Author Info

CA Sandeep Kanoi
Qualification: Graduate, CA in Job / Business, DD
Company: Taxguru Consultancy
Location: Mumbai, Maharashtra
Articles Published: 24,756

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.