RK-BVSR (JV) Vs Superintendent of Central Tax and Customs (Telangana High Court)
Summary: In RK-BVSR (JV) Vs Superintendent of Central Tax and Customs, the Telangana High Court examined the validity of an adjudication order dated 5 June 2023, passed in O.C. No. 132 of 2023, which was challenged by the petitioner under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. The petitioner had received a show-cause notice dated 27 April 2022 and submitted a detailed reply raising various objections. However, the adjudicating authority rejected the defence through a one-line observation that the contentions were general in nature and unsupported by law. The petitioner contended that the authority had failed to consider its submissions and had passed a non-speaking order without recording adequate reasons.
The High Court observed that recording reasons is an essential requirement of judicial, quasi-judicial and administrative decision-making, particularly where an order adversely affects a person’s rights. Relying on the Supreme Court’s decision in Kranti Associates (P) Ltd. v. Masood Ahmed Khan [(2010) 9 SCC 496], the Court reiterated that reasoned orders promote transparency, accountability, fairness and effective judicial review. It also referred to Smt. Lata Goswami v. State of Chhattisgarh (2015:CGHC:9478-DB), which discussed the principles laid down in East Coast Railway v. Mahadev Appa Rao [(2010) 7 SCC 678] and Assistant Commissioner, Commercial Tax Department v. Shukla & Brothers [(2010) 4 SCC 785]. These decisions establish that an order must demonstrate proper application of mind and that the absence of reasons may render administrative or quasi-judicial action arbitrary and legally unsustainable.
Applying these principles, the High Court held that the impugned adjudication order was neither reasoned nor a speaking order, as it failed to address the petitioner’s detailed reply and contained no meaningful justification for rejecting its defence. Consequently, the Court set aside the order dated 5 June 2023 and allowed the writ petition. The matter was remanded to the first respondent with directions to reconsider the petitioner’s reply to the show-cause notice dated 27 April 2022, pass a fresh reasoned and speaking order, and communicate the decision to the petitioner. The Court made no order as to costs and directed closure of pending miscellaneous applications.
Cases Discussed
- Kranti Associates (P) Ltd. v. Masood Ahmed Khan — (2010) 9 SCC 496
- Smt. Lata Goswami v. State of Chhattisgarh — 2015:CGHC:9478-DB
- East Coast Railway v. Mahadev Appa Rao (with K. Surekha v. Mahadeo Appa Rao) — (2010) 7 SCC 678
- Assistant Commissioner, Commercial Tax Department, Works Contract and Leasing, Kota v. Shukla & Brothers — (2010) 4 SCC 785
FULL TEXT OF THE JUDGMENT/ORDER OF TELANGANA HIGH COURT
The instant Writ Petition has been filed by the petitioner under Article 226 of the Constitution of India assailing the order passed by the 1st respondent in O.C.No.132 of 2023, dated 05.06.2023.
2. Heard Mr. Karthik Ramana Puttamreddy, learned counsel for the petitioner; Mr. Dominic Fernandes, learned Senior Standing Counsel for Central Board of Indirect Taxes & Customs, for respondent Nos.1 and 2; Mr. Gadi Praveen Kumar, learned Dy. Solicitor General of India, for respondent No.3; the learned Government Pleader for Commercial Tax, for respondent No.4; and the learned Government Pleader for Revenue, for the 5th respondent.
3. The assessing authority, pursuant to the impugned show-cause notice that was issued to the petitioner and to which the petitioner had also submitted a detailed reply, passed the impugned order without dealing with any of the contentions put forth by the petitioner in its reply and, that too, by passing a one line order holding that the defence taken by the petitioner is of very general nature and not supported by law. Except for those few words, there is no other reason assigned whatsoever.
4. The challenge was primarily on the ground that the order lacks reasons and not a speaking order and therefore, the present writ petition.
5. So far as the order to be passed by a quasi-judicial authority or for that matter by an officer on the administrative side, reasons are the essence of order. In this regard, the law is by now well settled.
6. In the case of Kranti Associates (P) Limited vs. Masood Ahmed Khan1 the Hon’ble Apex Court held at para No.51 as under :
“51. Summarizing the above discussion, this Court holds:
(a) In India the judicial trend has always been to record reasons, even in administrative decisions, if such decisions affect anyone prejudicially.
(b) A quasi-judicial authority must record reasons in support of its conclusions.
(c) Insistence on recording of reasons is meant to serve the wider principle of justice that justice must not only be done it must also appear to be done as well.
(d) Recording of reasons also operates as a valid restraint on any possible arbitrary exercise of judicial and quasi- judicial or even administrative power.
(e) Reasons reassure that discretion has been exercised by the decision maker on relevant grounds and by disregarding extraneous considerations.
(f) Reasons have virtually become as indispensable a component of a decision making process as observing principles of natural justice by judicial, quasi-judicial and even by administrative bodies.
(g) Reasons facilitate the process of judicial review by superior Courts.
(h) The ongoing judicial trend in all countries committed to rule of law and constitutional governance is in favour of reasoned decisions based on relevant facts. This is virtually the life blood of judicial decision making justifying the principle that reason is the soul of justice.
(i) Judicial or even quasi-judicial opinions these days can be as different as the judges and authorities who deliver them. All these decisions serve one common purpose which is to demonstrate by reason that the relevant factors have been objectively considered. This is important for sustaining the litigants’ faith in the justice delivery system.
(j) Insistence on reason is a requirement for both judicial accountability and transparency.
(k) If a Judge or a quasi-judicial authority is not candid enough about his/her decision making process then it is impossible to know whether the person deciding is faithful to the doctrine of precedent or to principles of incrementalism.
(l) Reasons in support of decisions must be cogent, clear and succinct. A pretence of reasons or `rubber-stamp reasons’ is not to be equated with a valid decision making process.
(m) It cannot be doubted that transparency is the sine qua non of restraint on abuse of judicial powers. Transparency in decision making not only makes the judges and decision makers less prone to errors but also makes them subject to broader scrutiny. (See David Shapiro in Defence of Judicial Candor (1987) 100 Harward Law Review 731-737).
(n) Since the requirement to record reasons emanates from the broad doctrine of fairness in decision making, the said requirement is now virtually a component of human rights and was considered part of Strasbourg Jurisprudence. See (1994) 19 EHRR 553, at 562 para 29 and Anya vs. University of Oxford, 2001 EWCA Civ 405, wherein the Court referred to Article 6 of European Convention of Human Rights which requires, “adequate and intelligent reasons must be given for judicial decisions”.
(o) In all common law jurisdictions judgments play a vital role in setting up precedents for the future. Therefore, for development of law, requirement of giving reasons for the decision is of the essence and is virtually a part of “Due Process”.
7. Similar view has been taken by a Division Bench of the High Court of Chattisgarh in Smt. Lata Goswami vs. State of Chhattisgarh2, wherein the Court held at paragraph Nos.8 and 9 as under:
“8. In the case of East Coast Railway vs. Mahadev Appa Rao with K. Surekha Vs. Mahadeo Appa Rao [reported in 2010 (7) SCC 678], the Supreme Court in a very categorical terms has held that “arbitrariness” in making of an order by an authority can manifest itself in different forms. Every order passed by a public authority must disclose due and proper application of mind by the person making the order. Application of mind is best demonstrated by disclosure of mind by the authority making the order and disclosure is best done by recording the reasons that led the authority to pass the order in question. Absence of reasons either in the order passed by the authority or in the record contemporaneously maintained is clearly suggestive of the order being arbitrary hence legally unsustainable. In the absence of reasons in support of the order it is difficult to assume that the authority had properly applied its mind before passing of the order.
9. Likewise, again in case of Assistant Commissioner, Commercial Tax Department, Works Contract and Leasing, Kota vs. Shukla and Brothers [reported in 2010 (4) SCC 785], the Supreme Court has held that “recording of reasons is an essential feature of dispensation of justice. Reasons are the soul of orders. Non-recording of reasons could lead to dual infirmities; firstly, it may cause prejudice to the affected party and secondly, more particularly, hamper the proper administration of justice. A judgment without reasons causes prejudice to the person against whom it is pronounced, as that litigant is unable to know the ground which weighted with the authority in rejecting him claim and also causes impediments in his taking adequate and appropriate grounds before the higher court in the event of challenge to that order.”
8. In view of the aforesaid legal pronouncements, as has been reflected in the preceding paragraphs, we have no hesitation in reaching to the conclusion that the impugned order passed by the 1st respondent in O.C.No.132 of 2023, dated 05.06.2023 is not a reasoned and speaking order. Therefore, the same is unsustainable and deserves to be set aside. Accordingly, the same is set aside and the Writ Petition is allowed.
9. The matter is remanded to the 1st respondent with a direction to pass a reasoned and speaking order duly taking into account the reply submitted by the petitioner to the show-cause notice dated 27.04.2022 and communicate the same to the petitioner. No costs.
10. As a sequel, miscellaneous applications pending if any in this petition, shall stand closed.
Notes:
1 (2010) 9 SCC 496
2 2015:CGHC:9478-DB






