Case Law Details
ESSA Exports Vs Commissioner of Customs (CESTAT Chennai)
Introduction: In a notable decision, the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT) Chennai provided substantial relief to ESSA Exports in a case concerning the import of goods declared as “Heavy Melting Iron Scrap.” The dispute arose when the Department contested the nature of certain goods, leading to confiscation and penalties. The CESTAT Chennai, after careful consideration, deemed the seized goods to be ‘scrap,’ altering the original order.
Detailed Analysis: ESSA Exports filed a Bill of Entry for the import of goods declared as “Heavy Melting Iron Scrap of 46.47 MTs.” Upon examination, the Department found an excess quantity of 3.862 MTs and identified 22 MTs as secondary quality rusted pipes. Disputes ensued regarding the classification of these pipes as ‘scrap.’ The original authority enhanced the value of the goods, ordered confiscation, and imposed penalties. The Commissioner (Appeals) reduced the redemption fine and penalty but did not provide absolute relief.
The pivotal point of contention was the nature of the 22 MTs of goods. The Department claimed these were serviceable pipes, not ‘scrap,’ based on visual examination. However, the Commissioner (Appeals) noted the absence of expert opinion supporting this conclusion and emphasized that pipes could be part of scrap.
ESSA Exports had, in good faith, requested mutilation of the goods before clearance to establish their intent to import only scrap. This request went unconsidered by the authorities.
Please become a Premium member. If you are already a Premium member, login here to access the full content.
Author Bio
