Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Excise Duty

CENVAT Credit Demand Based on Presumed Copper Diversion Unsustainable: CESTAT Delhi

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2026 taxguru.in 19183
Case Name
Commissioner of Central Goods and Service Tax Vs Kesri Steels Limited (CESTAT New Delhi)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Commissioner of Central Goods and Service Tax Vs Kesri Steels Limited (CESTAT New Delhi)

Summary: The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), New Delhi, adjudicated cross-appeals filed by Kesri Steels Limited and the Revenue concerning alleged fraudulent availment of CENVAT credit amounting to ₹2,57,94,584 on copper inputs during the period from 31 December 2004 to 25 February 2008. The Department alleged that the assessee had shown excessive consumption of copper in manufacturing stainless steel and alloy ingots and had clandestinely diverted the remaining quantity. Following an earlier remand, the adjudicating authority restricted the demand to ₹12,06,902, which the assessee challenged, while the Revenue sought restoration of the larger demand.

The Tribunal observed that the Department had failed to produce corroborative evidence establishing clandestine removal or diversion of copper inputs. No unaccounted raw materials or finished goods, transportation records, buyer details or evidence of unaccounted sale proceeds were discovered. The Tribunal also noted that the Department relied on test reports involving irregular and non-homogeneous samples while failing to disclose a favourable test report from M/s Nalwa Steels showing 11.9% copper content. Such non-disclosure amounted to a violation of natural justice. Consequently, even the remaining demand relating to 20.636 MT of copper ingots was held unsustainable, as the allegations rested on presumptions rather than tangible evidence.

Regarding limitation, the Tribunal held that the assessee was a registered manufacturer regularly filing statutory returns and that the Department had failed to establish deliberate suppression, misrepresentation or an intention to evade duty. Relying on established judicial principles governing clandestine removal and extended limitation, the Tribunal concluded that invocation of the extended period was unjustified. Accordingly, the show-cause notice dated 12 October 2009 was held time-barred, the assessee’s appeal was allowed and the Revenue’s appeal was dismissed, thereby setting aside the remaining CENVAT credit demand and associated penalty. The order was pronounced on 6 June 2024.

Cases Discussed

  • Century Metal Recycling Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of C.Ex., Delhi-IV — 2016 (333) ELT 483 (Tri.-Del.)
  • Syngenta Crop Protection Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of C.Ex., Chennai-I — 2010 (252) ELT 280 (Tri.-Chennai)
  • Mittal Steel Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of C.Ex., Bangalore — 2002 (150) ELT 437 (Tri.-Bang.), upheld in 2008 (231) ELT A102 (SC)
  • Commissioner of C.Ex., Ahmedabad-II Vs. Chhajusingh S. Kanwal — 2011 (272) ELT 202 (Guj.)
  • Uniworth Textiles Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of Central Excise, Raipur — 2013 (288) ELT 161 (SC)
  • Commissioner of Customs, Central Excise & Service Tax Vs. Monsanto Manufactures Pvt. Ltd. — 2014 (35) STR 177 (All.)
  • Pearl Drinks Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of Central Excise, Delhi — 2005 (186) ELT 117 (Tri.-Del.)
  • Suzuki Synthetics Pvt. Ltd. — 2015 (318) ELT 487 (Tri.-Ahmd.)
  • Arya Fibers Pvt. Ltd. — 2014 (311) ELT 529 (Tri.-Ahmd.)
  • Siddh Industries — 2013 (293) ELT 556 (Tri.-Ahmd.)
  • Bansal Wires Pvt. Ltd. — 2010 (261) ELT 1165 (Tri.-Del.)
  • Arsh Casting Pvt. Ltd. — 2010 (252) ELT 191 (HP)
  • Pan Parag India Ltd. — 2013 (291) ELT 81 (Tri.-Del.)
  • Jasmine Paints — 2013 (287) ELT 239 (Tri.-Del.)
  • Castrol India Ltd. — 2012 (283) ELT 399 (Tri.-Chennai)
  • Jaidev Alloys Pvt. Ltd. — 2012 (279) ELT 283 (Tri.-Ahmd.)
  • Anand Nishikawa Co. Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of Central Excise, Meerut — 2005 (7) SCC 749 (SC)

FULL TEXT OF THE ORIGINAL JUDGMENT/ORDER OF CESTAT NEW DELHI

The present order disposes of two cross appeals arising out of the same Order-in-Original bearing No. 17/18-19 dated 13.08.2018. One of these appeals is filed by the assessee and another is filed by the department. The facts in brief culminating into these appeals are as follows:

1.1 Assessee are engaged in manufacture of S.S. Ingots and Alloy Ingots. They had diverted, as such, the Cenvatable inputs i.e copper ingots/scrap on which Cenvat credit had been availed under Cenvat credit Rules, 2004. The officer of Anti-evasion (Hqrs.), Central Excise Commissionerate, Jaipur-I had visited the factory premises of M/s. Kesri Steel Ltd., Bhiwadi on 25.02.2008. It was observed that S.S. Ingots and Alloys Ingots were being manufactured mainly by way of remelting of S.S. scrap already containing ingredients like magnesium, carbon, silicon, chromium, aluminum, cobalt, copper, nickel, sulphur etc. As per the various standards of manufacturing like Bureau of Indian standards (BIS), the percentage of copper for manufacturing of stainless steels/alloy steels should range between 0.0094 to 1.94%. However, quality inspection at the time of visit revealed that the acceptance criteria of copper was mentioned as 1.2 to 2%. Some test reports of the samples were also recovered from the laboratory of the manufacturers/Kesri Steels themselves wherein percentage of copper was shown as 0.12 to 1.24. The visiting team also observed that the manufacturer purchased 622.474 MT of copper during the period from 31.12.2004 to 25.02.2008, however, has shown to have consumed 616.211 MT during the period from 01.01.2005 to 25.02.2008. Thus, the ratio of consumption of copper against the production of S.S. Ingots and Alloy Steel Ingots during the period was observed to be 12.31% i.e. much more than norms of manufacturing standards as well as the quality inspection plan. Thus, department formed an opinion that the manufacturer has taken credit of duty paid on copper ingots which accounts for about 12% of the weight of products manufactured by them whereas for manufacturing stainless steel, copper is needed to the maximum extent of 2% or so. Accordingly, an opinion was formed that the appellants have taken fraudulent Cenvat credit amounting to Rs.2,57,94,584/- during the period 31.12.2004 to 25.02.2008. Accordingly, vide Show Cause Notice No. 2429 dated 12.10.2009, the said amount of Cenvat credit was proposed to be recovered along with the interest and proportionate penalties. While adjudicating the said proposal, the adjudicating authority below vide the Order-in-Original as mentioned above has passed the following order:

(i) I confirm the demand of amount equal to CENVAT credit of Rs.12,06,902/- (BED Rs.9,95,178 + CVD Rs.1,81,870/- Ed. Cess Rs19,903/- + Hr. Ed. Cess Rs.9,951/-) and order its recovery along with interest under Rule 14 of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 read with proviso to Section 11A(1) of Central Excise Act, 1944 and Section 11AB from M/s Kesri Steel Ltd, A-350, RIICO Industrial Area, Bhiwadi.

(ii) Since the assessee has already debited an amount of Rs.18 Lakh, I order appropriation of Rs.12,06,902/- to Govt. Account towards the aforementioned confirmed demand and amount of Rs.5,93,098/- is refundable to the assessee by way of CENVAT credit in their CENVAT Credit Account.

(iii) I impose a penalty of Rs. 12,06,902/-on M/s Kesri Steel Ltd., A-350, RIICO dustrial Area, Bhiwadi, under Rule 15(2) of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 read with Section 11AC of Central Excise Act, 1944 on M/s Kesri Steel Ltd, A-350, RIICO Industrial Area, Bhiwadi.

(iv) However benefit of reduced penalty of 25% as per proviso to Section 11AC of Central Excise Act, 1944, is available to the assessee subject to the condition that the interest payable on demand of CENVAT credit of Rs. 12,06,902/- as in (i) above under Section 11AB ibid, is paid within thirty days from the date of communication of this order and further subject to the condition that the benefit of reduced penalty 25% of Rs. 12,06,902/- shall be available if the amount of penalty so determined has also been paid within the period of thirty days from the date of communication this order.

1.2 The manufacturer has challenged the order for the demand as confirmed, however, department simultaneously has challenged the order with respect to the demand over and above Rs.12,06,902/- which has been dropped.

2. We have heard Shri G.K. Sarkar and Shri Prashant Srivastava, learned Advocates for the assessee and Shri Rakesh Agarwal, learned Authorized Representative for the department.

3. Learned counsel for the assessee has mentioned that the department has taken the percentage of copper content in the S.S. Ingots manufactured by the respondent to be average of 1.2% to 2.0% and has alleged that the consumption of copper to the tune of 616.211 MT shown as consumed for manufacturing of 5004.835 MT of S.S. Ingots and Alloy Steel Ingots showing 12.31% of copper content by the respondent during the period of dispute is incorrect as the actual consumption of copper could be only 80.077 MT. Hence, the allegations of clandestinely removing the remaining quantity of 536.134 MT of copper and availment of irregular Cenvat credit on the aforesaid quantity are absolutely baseless. The Original Adjudicating Authority pursuant to the directions of remand in the final order of this Tribunal dated 06.01.2012 has already concluded that the percentage of copper in S.S. and Alloy Ingots manufactured by assessee is 11.9%. It is mentioned that despite these observations 20.636 MT of Ingots had been held unaccounted for and held not eligible for Cenvat credit thereby confirming a demand of Rs.12,06,902/- out of the proposed demand of Rs.2,57,94,584/-. Learned counsel has mentioned that there was no unaccounted stock of any raw material was found at the time of search.

3.1 Learned counsel while objecting the said confirmed demand of Rs.12,06,902/- has mentioned that there is no evidence produced by the department of alleged clandestine removal and the diversion of inputs even in respect to said 20.636 MT. In the absence of any cogent and corroborative material establishing the fact of actual clandestine clearance even the said demand has been wrongly confirmed. Learned counsel has relied upon the following decisions:

(i) Century Metal Recycling Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of C.Ex., Delhi – IV reported in 2016 (333) ELT 483 (Tri-Del)

(ii) Syngenta Crop Protection Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of C.Ex., Chennai-I reported in 2010 (252) ELT 280 (Tribunal – Chennai)

(iii) Mittal Steel Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of C.Ex., Bangalore reported in 2002 (150) ELT 437 (Tri-Bang.) upheld by the Hon’ble Supreme Court reported as 2008 (231) ELT A102 (S.C.)

(iv) Commissioner of C.Ex., Ahmedabad –II Vs. Chhajusingh S. Kanwal reported in 2011 (272) ELT 202 (Guj.)

3.2 It is further submitted that the demand is otherwise barred by time as the demand for the period w.e.f. 31.12.2004 to 25.02.2008 has been proposed vide the Show Cause Notice dated 12.10.2009. The appellant is duly registered and has been regularly filing the returns. No mis-declaration in his returns was ever noticed. The extended period has wrongly been invoked. Learned counsel has relied upon the following decisions:

(i) Uniworth Textiles Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of Central Excise, Raipur reported as 2013 (288) ELT 161 (SC)

(ii) Commissioner of Customs, Central Excise & Service Tax Vs. Monsanto Manufactures Pvt. Ltd. reported in 2014 (35) STR 177 (All.) Accordingly, the assessee’s appeal is prayed to be allowed by setting aside the demand even of Rs.12,06,902/- and by setting aside the order of imposition of penalty. The appeal filed by the department is accordingly prayed to be dismissed.

4. While rebutting these submissions, learned Departmental Representative has mentioned that as per BIS norms, S.S. Steel/ Alloy Steel ranges between 0.0094 to 1.94%. However, from the test reports of sample recovered from assessee’s laboratory, the percentage of copper was shown as 0.12 to 1.24%. The department had picked up three samples from the assessee’s manufacturing unit and got those tested from CRCL, New Delhi. The test result showed the copper percentage from 0.95 to 1.01% except that one inspection report about sample from M/s. Nalwa Steels Udyog manufactured by assessee showed the percentage of 0.66%. It is impressed upon that the adjudicating authority below has wrongly considered the said one report as contrary to three reports supporting the department’s case. The major demand is alleged to have wrongly been dropped.

4.1 It is further submitted that act of the assessee about not following the BIS norms while manufacturing S.S. and Alloy Ingots clearly establishes the fact that percentage of copper actually used in manufacture was very low. This amounts to concealment/mis- representation on part of the assessee. The extended period has rightly been invoked. Learned Departmental Representative has accordingly prayed for department’s appeal to be allowed by confirming the entire demand as was proposed in show cause notice and for the assessee’s appeal to be dismissed. Learned Departmental Representative has relied upon the decision of this Tribunal in the case of Pearl Drinks Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of Central Excise, Delhi reported as 2005 (186) ELT 117 (Tri.- Del.)

5. Having heard the rival contentions and perusing the records of both the impugned appeals, we observe and hold as follows: 5.1 This is a second round of litigation arising out of the show cause notice dated 12.10.2009. The assessee was alleged to have clandestinely removed some quantity of manufactured ingots and was alleged to have thereby availed fraudulent Cenvat credit amounting to Rs.2,57,94,584/- during the period 31.12.2004 to 25.02.2008. The said show cause notice was adjudicated vide Order-in-Original No. 23/2011 dated 25.02.2011. This Tribunal vide Final Order No. 6/2012 dated 09.12.2011 had remanded the matter for de novo adjudication directing the adjudicating authority to provide copies of all relied upon documents to be furnished to the appellant including all the test reports even such reports which were not mentioned as relied upon documents. Pursuant to those directions that the impugned Order-in-Original No. 17/18-19 dated 13.08.2018 has been passed vide which the earlier Order-in- Original has been modified to the extent of confirming demand only for Rs.12,06,902/- instead of 2,57,94,584/-. We observe that the show cause notice was issued observing that the Cenvat credit has been availed on such inputs which were not consumed in terms of the test report of consumption of raw material in manufacture of final product.

5.2 To adjudicate further, we observe following to be the admitted facts:

(i) During the course of search no unaccounted stock of raw material or finished goods or any cash etc. were found.

(ii) No allegations of receipt of any unaccounted sale proceeds on part of the respondent-assessee.

(iii) There is no investigation with respect to the buyers who would have purchased the clandestinely cleared copper from the assessee.

(iv) There is no investigation with respect to the transportation of such clandestinely cleared input material/copper from the assessee’s factories.

(v) All the payments have been received and made by the assessee through proper banking channel.

5.3 These observed admitted facts are sufficient for us to hold that the allegations of clandestine removal of the final product of assessee are merely presumptive allegations. This Tribunal in Century Metal Recycling Pvt. Ltd. (supra) has held that when there is no documentary evidence of clandestine removal of raw material i.e. transport details, buyer details, financial transactions etc. adduced, in the absence of the corroborative evidence, statutory records cannot be discarded merely on the basis of wrong interpretation and the presumption alleging the Cenvat credit as inadmissible is held unsustainable in that circumstance. In Suzuki Synthetics Pvt. Ltd. reported as 2015 (318) ELT. 487 (Tri- Ahmd.), the Tribunal observed that if the case of clandestine removal is to be sustained based on private records then the same is required to be supported by corroborative evidence with regard to purchase of raw material, manufacture of final goods, flow-back of money or identification of the buyers and their statement, etc. In Arya Fibers Pvt. Ltd. reported as 2014 (311) EL.T. 529 (Tri.-Ahmd.) the Tribunal laid down certain principles, after detailed analysis of large number of case laws, to establish the case for clandestine manufacture/clearance. The Tribunal observed that there should be tangible evidence of clandestine manufacture and clearance and not merely inferences or unwarranted assumptions. Similar ratio was followed in large number decisions by the High Courts and Tribunal -Siddh Industries reported as 2013 (293) ELT 556 (Tri-Ahmd.); Bansal Wires Pvt. Ltd. reported as 2010 (261) ELT 1165 (Tri-Del.); Arsh Casting Pvt. Ltd. reported as 2010 (252) ELT 191 (HP), Pan Parag India Ltd. reported as 2013 (291) ELT 81 (Tri-Del.), Jasmine Paints reported as 2013 (287) ELT 239 (Tri-Del.); Castrol India Ltd. reported as 2012 (283) ELT 399 (Tri. Chennai), Jaidev Alloys Pvt. Ltd. reported as 2012 (279) ΕLT 283 (Tri.- Ahmd.). The ratio laid down in the above mentioned judgments is squarely applicable to the present case also as there is no corroborative and tangible evidence adduced by the department establishing clandestine clearance/diversion of input material by the assessee except the presumption about the same.

5.4 Though the department has taken the plea that there are three test reports which supports the department’s contention but we observe that there is no apparent denial to the fact that the three of the samples picked up by the department were of irregular shape and were not homogenous at all and as is mentioned in CRCL Report itself. The sample as was picked up from the M/s. Nalwa Steel premises, the buyer of the assessee, the sample being absolutely homogenous and showing the result of 11.9% of copper content in the Ingot. Hence the said report dominates the three of the reports produced by the department. It is also very much apparent on record that the report of M/s. Nalwa Steels sample was not given to the assessee. It was not even made the relied upon document. This fact became the basis of remand. The adjudicating authority has duly considered the said report and accepted its contention. Department has failed to show any cogent reason of concealing the M/s. Nalwa steels sample report. The adjudicating authority itself has held that not informing the assessee about M/s. Nalws Steels sample test report clearly shows that show cause notice has relied upon the test reports which did not favour the assessee. Non disclosing the vital fact of the report which supports assessee is held to be the violation of principal of natural justice.

5.5 Despite accepting that the S.S. and Alloy ingots manufactured by assessee have 11.9% of copper, the original adjudicating authority has still confirmed the demand/reversal of Cenvat credit availed on 20.636 MT of copper ingots. The findings that the said amount of copper ingots have been diverted clandestinely without payment of duty have not discussed any evidence to this effect. As already observed above, that to prove the allegations of clandestine production and removal thereof, there has to be a cogent evidence on various criteria and parameters as discussed above. There has been found no supporting or corroborative evidence to sustain the allegations of clandestine removal as no raw material was found unaccounted nor even the final product. There is no evidence about transportation of 20.636 MT of ingots from the appellant to anybody else without payment of duty. No shortcomings have been noticed in the accounts maintained by the assessee. Thus, there is no iota of evidence or investigation made by the department to prove that the raw material of the assessee as shown to be consumed is an excess as compared to its consumption in the final products. There is no evidence even to show that the final products were clandestinely cleared by the assessee. In view thereof, the confirmation of the recovery of Cenvat credit alleging the same to be irregular for 20.636 MT of ingots to have been clandestinely removed is also not sustainable. We accordingly hold that demand/reversal of availed Cenvat credit has wrongly been confirmed despite accepting the M/s. Nalwa Steels sample report.

5.6 Coming to the aspect of invoking the extended period, we observe that from the entire above discussion, it is clear that department has produced no evidence about any evasion of duty by the appellant. The allegations of clandestine removal are held to have no supportive evidence. Admittedly, the assessee is a registered manufacturer. Returns were being regularly filed. Accordingly, we hold that suppression of facts to evade duty has wrongly been raised against the appellant. Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Anand Nishikawa Co. Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of Central Excise, Meerut reported as 2005 (7) SCC 749 has held that in taxation, “suppression of facts” can have only one meaning that the correct information was not disclosed deliberately to escape payment of duty where the facts are known to both the parties the omission by one to do what he might have done and not that he must have done, does not render it suppression. In an earlier decision in the case of Pushpam Pharmaceuticals Co. Vs. Collector of Central Excise, Bombay, Hon’ble Apex Court has held that there must be some positive act from the side of assessee to find the willful suppression. Once there is no deliberate intention on part of the assessee not to disclose the correct information or to evade payment of duty, it was not open to central excise officer to precede recovered duties in the manner indicated in the proviso to Section 11A of the Act. In the above discussion, we have already held that the department has intentionally and wrongly concealed the correct test reports. In fact, the departmental adjudicating authority itself has appreciated the same while dropping the major part of demand. We have also concluded that the demand, whatsoever has wrongly been confirmed on the assessee. Clearly the present is not the case of suppression of facts or mis- representation as is alleged. Accordingly, we hold that the extended period of limitation has wrongly been invoked.

6. As the result of entire above discussion, the order under challenge is though modified in terms of findings in Para 5.4 above. However, we hold that show cause notice itself is barred by time. Consequent thereto, the appeal filed by assessee is hereby allowed, however, the one filed by the department is hereby dismissed.

[Order pronounced in the open court on 06.06.2024]

Advertisement

Author Info

CA Sandeep Kanoi
Qualification: Graduate, CA in Job / Business, DD
Company: Taxguru Consultancy
Location: Mumbai, Maharashtra
Articles Published: 24,828

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.