Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Excise Duty

CESTAT Delhi Quashes Excise Duty Demand: Audit Detection Alone Not Suppression

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2026 taxguru.in 18933
Case Name
Vandana Global Ltd Vs Commissioner (Appeals) Central GST (CESTAT Delhi)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Vandana Global Ltd Vs Commissioner (Appeals) Central GST (CESTAT Delhi)

Summary: The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), New Delhi, in Vandana Global Ltd. Vs Commissioner (Appeals), Central GST, Central Excise & Customs, Raipur, set aside a differential central excise duty demand of Rs. 10,65,505 arising from alleged undervaluation of sponge iron, M.S. billets and silicon manganese sold to Vandana Ispat Ltd. and Shivali Udyog (I) Ltd. The department alleged that these buyers were related parties and that goods were sold to them below the prices charged to independent purchasers. The show cause notice dated 28 October 2015 covered October 2010 to July 2015, invoked the extended period under Section 11A of the Central Excise Act, 1944, and proposed interest and penalty. The original authority confirmed the duty and imposed a penalty equal to 50% of the demand, which the Commissioner (Appeals) upheld.

The Tribunal held that self-assessment and subsequent discovery of an alleged mistake during audit do not, without more, establish suppression of facts with intent to evade duty. Under the Central Excise Rules, officers are required to scrutinise ER-1 returns and may demand records to check valuation. The ER-1 return did not require, or provide a field for, disclosure of relationships with buyers. Consequently, the department could not invoke the extended limitation period merely because the alleged undervaluation came to light during audit. The demand relating to the period up to September 2014 was therefore barred by limitation. For October 2014 to July 2015, the Tribunal noted that the 2013 amendments to the Central Excise Valuation Rules made Rules 9 and 10 applicable to sales made wholly or partly to related persons, whereas the show cause notice relied on Rule 11 read with Rules 4 and 7, without establishing facts warranting those provisions.

On merits, the Tribunal further found no adequate evidence that the appellant and the two purchasers were inter-connected undertakings within Section 4(3)(b) of the Central Excise Act. A financial-statement disclosure that key managerial personnel had significant influence over the purchasers was insufficient, without supporting facts establishing control or the statutory relationship. Even if the entities were inter-connected undertakings, Rule 10(b) would require valuation as though they were unrelated where the additional forms of relationship were absent. The Tribunal also held that the appellate authority could not sustain the demand by invoking valuation provisions not put to the appellant in the show cause notice. By Final Order No. 51135/2022 dated 2 December 2022, the Tribunal set aside the impugned order and allowed the appeal with consequential relief, if any.

FULL TEXT OF THE CESTAT DELHI ORDER

M/s. Vandana Global Ltd1, filed this appeal assailing Order-in-Appeal2 dated 15th February, 2018 passed by the Commissioner of Central Excise & GST (Appeals)3, Raipur whereby he dismissed the appeal of the appellant and upheld Order-in-Original dated 29th November, 2016 passed by the Additional Commissioner.

2. The appellant manufactures excisable goods of iron and steel and is registered with the Central Excise Department. It also avails Cenvat credit on the inputs, inputs services and capital goods. On the basis of an audit report, the department took a view that the appellant was selling sponge iron, M.S. billets and silicon manganese to its related parties (i) Vandana Ispat Ltd.4, Raipur & (ii) Shivali Udyog (I) Ltd.5 at prices lower than the prices at which it sold them to independent buyers. The department also took a view that the goods sold to Vandana and Shivali must be valued as per Section 4 read with Rule 11 read with Rules 4 & 7 of the Central Excise Valuation (Determination of Price of Excisable Goods) Rules, 20006 and issued show cause notice7 dated 28th October, 2015 to the appellant invoking extended period of limitation under Section 11A of the Central Excise Act, 19448 demanding an amount of Rs. 10,65,505/- towards the differential Central Excise duty along with interest. Penalty under Section 11AC read with Rule 25 of the Central Excise Rules9, 2002 was also proposed.

3. The appellant contested the SCN both on merits and on limitation but in his Order-in-Original, the Additional Commissioner confirmed the full demand as proposed along with interest and imposed penalty equal to 50% of the duty demanded. In the impugned order, Commissioner (Appeals) upheld this order and hence this appeal.

4. Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the impugned order is not sustainable on several grounds. Firstly, a large part of the demand is beyond the normal period of limitation and no case has been made out for invoking extended period of limitation. Secondly, the Valuation Rules invoked in the SCN and the Valuation Rules under which the demand was upheld in the impugned order are different. Thirdly, the appellant and Vandana and Shivali are not related persons as per the Section 4 and the mere fact that in terms of Companies Act, they are persons with significant interest, it does not establish that they are related persons. Fourthly, as per Valuation Rules 9 & 10, even if the appellant and the buyer are inter-connected undertakings, value should be determined as if they are not related persons unless they are also related in one of the other ways indicated in section 4 which has not been established. He also reiterated the following grounds of appeal:

(a) The differential duty has been computed as per Annexure-A to the show cause notice on the basis of “greatest aggregate quantity price” but it has nowhere been indicated as to which price was adopted for this purpose. Neither the name of the independent buyers nor any documentary evidence in the form of invoices were produced. Therefore, the demand needs to be dropped.

(b) The department has not established that the two buyers M/s Vandana Ispat Ltd. & M/s Shivali Udyog (I) were related persons of the appellant as per Section 4(3)(b) of the Act.

(c) Department has issued the show cause notice based on the Annual Report of the appellant in which under the heading “Enterprises over which key managerial person or their relatives have significant influence” the names of Vandana. and Shivali find mention. This declaration was done as per the requirement of the Companies Act, 1956 and the department has not been able to establish that the two units were related persons of the appellant as per Section 4(3) (b) of the Central Excise Act.

(d) Since Vandana and Shivali were neither relatives of the appellant nor were they appellant’s distributors, as per Section 4 and (3) (b), the department had to establish that the appellants and the two buyers had interest directly or indirectly in the business of each other. This onus has not been discharged by the department.

(e) As per para 2.6.3 of the show cause notice, valuation was proposed in terms of Valuation Rule 11 read with Valuation Rules 4 & 7. It is therefore not clear as to which valuation rules were applied.

(f) As the appellant’s final products were raw materials to Vandana and Shivali the entire exercise is revenue neutral.

(g) The show cause notice covered the period October, 2010 to July 2015 of which the demand up to September 2014, is time barred and no case has been made out of for invoking extended period as per Section 11A.

(h) The demand does not survive and therefore the interest and penalty also need to be set aside.

5. Learned Authorised Representative for Revenue supports the impugned order and submits that the impugned order is fair and proper and calls for no interference.

6. We have considered the submissions on both sides and perused the records. Since the Valuation Rules had undergone significant changes in 2013 during the period of dispute, we proceed to address the question of extended period of limitation first so that the appeal can be examined as per the Valuation Rules applicable during the relevant period.

Limitation

7. It is not in dispute that Section 11A provides for a limitation of one year for issuing the SCN. This period can be extended to five years in case the duty is not paid, short paid, not levied, short levied or erroneously refunded on account of fraud or collusion or willful statement or suppression of facts or violation of the provisions of Act or Rules with an intent to evade the payment of duty. In this case, the SCN alleges that the appellant had deliberately suppressed facts with intent to evade payment of duty and therefore, invoked extended period of limitation. The relevant paragraph of the show cause notice is as follows:

“3.2 This fact of deliberate undervaluation the goods sold by the Noticee to their inter-connected undertakings/related units by resorting to under valuation of excisable goods and without observing the provisions of the Central Excise Valuation (Determination of price of Excisable goods) Rules, 2000 with intent to evade the payment of Cenvat duty of Rs. 10,65,505/- (including cess) (Rupees Ten lakh Sixty five Thousand Five Hundred and Five Only) as detailed above came to the notice of the department during the course of audit. This therefore leads to the apparent conclusion that the Noticee has suppressed the fact of such under valuation of their sales to related parties, to the department and has failed to discharge the burden caste upon them under Rule 8 of the Central Excise Rules, 2002. Since the Noticee have suppressed the material facts from the department with intent to evade payment of Central Excise duty, the same is recoverable from them invoking the extended period of five years as stipulated under section 11A(4) (in terms of Finance act, 2015) [(erstwhile Section 11A and 11A(5)] of the Central Excise Act’1944 along with penalty under Section 11Ac (1)(c) (in terms of Finance Act,2015) [erstwhile Section 11AC(1)(b)] of the Central Excise Act, 1944 for having resorted to deliberate suppression of facts with an intent to evade payment of Central Excise Duties and for the contravention of the provisions of Rules 4,5,6 & 8 of the Central Excise Rules, 2002 and Rules 4,7,8,9,10 & 11 of the Valuation Rules, 2000 read with Section 4 of the Central Excise Act, 1944.”

8. The original authority had not directly dealt with this issue while confirming the demand for extended period of limitation but dealt with this issue while imposing penalty under Section 11AC which also requires the same elements of fraud, collusion, etc. He held that the appellant had knowingly opted for undervaluation of the goods sold to related buyers to evade Central Excise duty and also deliberately suppressed facts. The relevant extract of this order is as follows:

“21.10. The Noticee cited a number of decisions in their defense to support their arguments but none of it is relevant to the facts and circumstances discussed as above. The fact of deliberate undervaluation of goods sold to the related buyers being lower in price than the ‘normal transaction value’ of the same goods sold to the independent buyers at the same date or nearest date of greatest aggregate quantity of the same goods sold to the independent buyers. The mala fide intention of the Noticee cannot be ruled out. This is not a case of procedural lapses to be ignored on technical grounds. It is a case of authenticity of duty that has to paid on the ‘normal transaction value’ of the goods sold to the related buyers like that of the goods sold to the independent buyers. The Noticee knowingly opted for undervaluation of the goods sold to the related buyers to evade the payment of Central Excise duty. The deeds of the Noticee leads to short payment of Central Excise duty on the goods sold to the related buyers during the relevant period. It is therefore, they have rendered themselves liable for penalty proposed under Section 11AC of the Act for having resorted to deliberate suppression of facts with intent to evade payment of the Central Excise duty.”

9. The Commissioner (Appeals) has also, in the impugned order, not dealt with this issue while invoking the extended period of limitation.

10. Learned Authorised Representative for Revenue submits that the extended period of limitation has been correctly invoked in this case as the appellant is operating in a regime of self assessment and as such is responsible for assessing the duty correctly and reflecting the same in its ER-1 returns. He submits that had the audit not pointed out that the appellant and Vandana and Shivali were related persons, the fact would not have been discovered. The appellant had not disclosed this relationship in its ER-1 Returns. Therefore, extended period of limitation was correctly invoked.

11. We have considered submissions of both sides on the issue of limitation.

12. Revenue’s submission that since the appellant is working under self assessment, any deficiency in payment of duty would amount to suppression of facts and extended period of limitation can be invoked is not correct because as per Excise Rules, all assessees work under self assessment but Section 11A still provides for normal period of limitation and extended period of limitation. If the argument of the learned authorised representative is accepted, there cannot be any normal period of limitation in any case because everyone is operating under self assessment and the provision for normal period of limitation would be rendered otiose.

13. The second submission on behalf of the Revenue is that had the audit not discovered, the alleged undervaluation would not have been detected and therefore it can be inferred that the appellant had suppressed facts.

14. This submission cannot be accepted. There could be two or more views on the same issue and the assessee self- assesses duty as per its view and understanding. It cannot be expected to foresee what view the audit team may take sometime in the future and assess duty accordingly. The Excise Rules provide not only for self-assessment of duty and filing of returns by the assessee in ER-1, but also provide for scrutiny of the returns by the officers. Duty of excise is charged on excisable goods manufactured or produced in India (Section 3) but the duty becomes payable on removal (Excise Rule 4). The assessee has to self- assess (Excise Rule 6) the duty and pay it by the fifth day or sixth day (in case of electronic payment) of the following month (Excise Rule 8) and file Returns (Excise Rule 12) as per the form. The officers have to scrutinize the returns [Excise Rule 12(3)] and can, for the purpose call for documents and records which the assessee is bound to produce [Excise Rule 12(4)]. The relevant extracts of these Rules are reproduced below:

Rule 4. Duty payable on removal.-

(1) Every person who produces or manufactures any excisable goods, or who stores such goods in a warehouse, shall pay the duty leviable on such goods in the manner provided in rule 8 or under any other law, and no excisable goods, on which any duty is payable, shall be removed without payment of duty from any place, where they are produced or manufactured, or from a warehouse, unless otherwise provided

Xxxxxxx

Rule 6. Assessment of duty.-

The assessee shall himself assess the duty payable on any excisable goods:

Provided that in case of cigarettes, the Superintendent or Inspector of Central Excise shall assess the duty payable before removal by the assessee.

Rule 8. Manner of payment. –

The duty on the goods removed from the factory or the warehouse during a month shall be paid by the 6th day of the following month, if the duty is paid electronically through internet banking and by the 5th day of the following month, in any other case:

Provided that in case of goods removed during the month of March, the duty shall be paid by the 31st day of March:

Xxxxxx

Rule 12 Filing of return.-

(1) Every assessee shall submit to the Superintendent of Central Excise a monthly return in the form specified by notification by the Board, of production and removal of goods and other relevant particulars, within ten days after the close of the month to which the return relates

Xxxxxxx

(3) The proper officer may on the basis of information contained in the return filed by the assessee under sub-rule (1), and after such further enquiry as he may consider necessary, scrutinize the correctness of the duty assessed by the assessee on the goods removed, in the manner to e prescribed by the Board.

(4) Every assessee shall make available to the proper officer all the documents and records for verification as and when required by such officer.

xxxxxx

15. Thus, the scheme under the law is that although the duty is levied on manufacture of goods, it becomes payable only when they are removed and it must be paid based on self-assessment by the fifth or sixth of the following month. The assessee also has to file returns. Needless to say that the assessee may make mistakes in self-assessment and the check against this has been provided in the form of scrutiny of the returns by the officers and the officer scrutinising the returns can call for any documents and records from the assessee which it is bound to provide. In other words, the officer is mandated under the Rules to do what the audit has done much later. Had the officer scrutinised the returns as was mandated and called for any records, the alleged mistakes which were pointed out by the audit would have come to light and a SCN could have been issued under section 11A within the normal period of limitation. It also needs to be pointed out that the relevant date to calculate the limitation is the date on which the Return is filed by the assessee or if it is not filed, the last date by which it was required to be filed because only when the return is filed, the officer can scrutinise it and raise demands for any short paid duty and if no return is filed by due date, the officer is expected to initiate steps to call for records and determine if the duty has been paid. From this date, the officer can issue an SCN within one year.

16. Lastly, the ER-1Return is filed online and it has certain columns which do not include any declaration if there was any sale to related parties nor was there any requirement of declaration of the nature of relationship. Thus, the assessee was not only NOT REQUIRED to disclose the relationship but it was also not possible for it to disclose the relationship in ER1.

17. To sum up, while the assessee was required to self–assess duty and file ER-1 return, a check against such self-assessment was the scrutiny which the officers were mandated to do by Rules. Audit is the next level of check against the scrutiny. If the audit points out some wrong assessment which was not pointed out by the officer scrutinising the ER-1 return, the fault lies at the doorstep of the officer. It does not, by itself, establish that the assessee had suppressed any facts.

Merits of the case

18. Since we have found that the extended period of limitation was incorrectly invoked only for a portion of the demand in the matter, we proceed to decide the matter on merits as per Section 4 and the Valuation Rules applicable for the normal period of limitation (October 2014 to July 2015).

19. Central excise duties are levied under Section 3 of the Central Excise Act, 1944 as per the Schedule to the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985. These can be levied based on quantity (specific rate of duty) or value (ad valorem rate of duty) or in some cases maximum retail sale price (under section 4A). In most cases, including in this case, the duty is levied based on value which must be determined as per Section 4 read with Valuation Rules.

20. As per Section 4 the assessable value for each removal of the goods is the transaction value if four conditions are met:

(a) there is a sale ;

(b) the sale is for delivery is at the time and place of removal;

(c) the assessee and the buyer of the goods are not related; and

(d) the price is the sole consideration of sale.

21. If any of these four conditions is not met, the value has to be determined as per the Valuation Rules. Of the above, what is relevant to this appeal is whether or not the appellant and its two buyers were related persons. The buyer and seller are ‘related persons’ according to clause (b) of sub-section (3) of section 4 if one more of the following conditions are met:

(i) they are inter-connected undertakings;

(ii) they are relatives;

(iii) amongst them the buyer is a relative and a distributor of the assessee, or a sub-distributor of such distributor; or

(iv) they are so associated that they have interest, directly or indirectly, in the business of each other.

22. The exceptions to Section 4 have been dealt with in the Valuation Rules as follows:

(a) Rules 1 and 2 are the preliminary provisions.

(b) Rule 3 mandates that valuation should be done as per the rules.

(c) Rule 4 deals with situations where goods are sold but not at the time of removal.

(d) Rule 5 deals with situations where goods are sold, but not at the place of removal.

(e) Rule 6 deals with situations where there is an additional consideration for sale.

(f) Rule 7 deals with situations where there is no sale and the goods are transferred to the assessee’s own depot not at the premises of the consignment agent.

(g) Rule 8 deals with situations whether goods are captively consumed by the assessee or on its behalf in which case, the valuation has to be done at 115% of the cost of production.

(h) Rule 9 deals with the situations where the assessee and the buyer are related persons as per sub-Clauses (ii) (iii) or (iv) of Clause (b) of sub- Section (iii) of Section 4.

(i) Rule 10 (a) deals with situations related persons as per sub-Clause (i) of Clause (b) of sub- Section (iii) of Section 4 also known as

‘interconnected undertakings’ where the assessee and the buyer are, in addition also related persons as per sub-Clause (ii) or (iii) or (iv) or the buyer is the holding company or a subsidiary company.

(j) Rule 10 (b) deals with situations where the assessee and the buyer are interconnected undertakings as per sub-Clause (i), but they are not also related persons in terms of sub-Clauses

(ii) (iii) or (iv) nor is the buyer holding for a subsidiary company of the assessee.

(k) Rule 11 deals with situations which are not covered by any of the above rules.

23. The Valuation Rules were amended in 2013. Before this amendment, only when the goods were not sold except to or through a related person, Valuation Rules 9 and 10 were to be applied to determine the value. After 2013, if either whole or part of the sales were to related persons, Valuation Rules 9 &10 apply. The changes brought about in the Valuation Rules in 2013 are summarized below:

S.No. Rule and the situation it deals with Before 2013 From 2013
1 Rules 1, 2 and 3- Preliminary No change
2 Rule 4- Goods are sold but not at the time of removal. Based on the value of such goods sold by the assessee for delivery at any other time nearest to the time of the removal of goods under assessment, subject, if necessary, to such adjustment on account of the difference in the dates of delivery of such goods No change
3 Rule 5- Goods are sold but for delivery not at the place of removal but elsewhere. Transaction value minus the cost of transportation from the factory to the buyer’s premises No change
4 Rule 6- Goods are sold but price is not the sole consideration for sale Value shall be the aggregate of such transaction value and the amount of money value of any additional consideration flowing directly or indirectly from the buyer to the assessee No change
5 Rule 7- Goods are not sold by the assessee at the time and place of removal but are transferred to a depot, premises of a consignment agent or any other place or premises (hereinafter referred to as “such other place”) from where the excisable goods are to be sold after their clearance from the place of removal and where the assessee and the buyer of the said goods are not related and the price is the sole consideration for the sale. The value shall be normal transaction value of such goods sold from such other place at or about the same time and, where such goods are not sold at or about the same time, at the time nearest to the time of removal of goods under assessment No change
6 Rule 8- Goods are not sold by the assessee but are used for consumption by him or on his behalf in the production or manufacture of other articles The value shall be one hundred and fifteen per cent of the cost of production or manufacture of such goods. The value shall be one hundred and ten per cent of the cost of production or manufacture of such goods.
7 Rule 9- Goods sold to a ‘related person’ as per sub-clauses (ii), (iii) or (iv) of clause (b) of sub-section (3) of section 4 of the Act Only when goods are not sold except to or through a related person as per sub-clauses (ii), (iii) or (iv). The price shall be the price at which the related person sells to other non-related persons. If the related person consumes the goods, valuation should be done as per Rule 8. Where whole or part of the excisable goods are sold by the assessee to or through a related person as per sub- clauses (ii), (iii) or (iv). Rest is the same.
8. Rule 10(a)- Goods sold to an ‘inter- connected undertaking’ , as per sub-clause (i) of clause (b) of sub- section 3 of section 4 of the Act who are also related persons in terms of sub- clauses (ii) or (iii) or (iv) or the buyer is a holding company or a subsidiary company of the assessee Only when the assessee so arranges that the excisable goods are not sold by him except to or through an inter- connected undertaking. Valuation should be as per Rule 9. Where whole or part of the excisable goods are sold by the assessee to or through an inter-connected undertaking. Valuation should be as per Rule 9.
9 Rule 10(b)- Goods are sold to inter- connected undertaking, as per sub-clause (i) of sub- section 3 of section 4 of the Act but is not related as per sub- clauses (ii) to (iv) Value shall be determined as if they are not related persons for the purpose of sub-section (1) of section 4 Value shall be determined as if they are not related persons for the purpose of sub-section (1) of section 4
10 Rule 11- value of any excisable goods cannot be determined under the foregoing rules. The value shall be determined using reasonable means consistent with the principles and general provisions of these rules and sub-section (1) of section 4 of the Act No change

24. The period of dispute in the present case is October 2010 to July 2015 (i.e., before and after 2013 amendment to the Valuation Rules) but only the pre-2013 Valuation Rules were invoked in the SCN, in the order-in-original and in the impugned order. The case of the Revenue is that the appellant sold goods partly to Vandana and Shivali and partly to other independent buyers and therefore, Valuation Rules 9 and 10 do not apply and hence the residual provision – Valuation Rule 11 applies. The Valuation Rules as applicable for the period post-2013 were neither invoked nor discussed. As summarized in the table above, after 2013 amendment, even if part of the goods are cleared to related buyers, Valuation Rules 9 & 10 apply and Rule 11 cannot be resorted to. The relevant paragraphs in the SCN are reproduced below:

2.6.2. Therefore, in cases where the goods are sold partially to the related buyers and partially to independent buyers in terms of the stipulations contained in the relevant provisions, the valuation of the goods sold to related buyers have to be determined in terms of the Rule 11 of the Valuation Rules, 1000 read with Rule 9 or Rule 10 of “the Rules”.

2.8. From the above and Annexure A to the show cause notice, it is clear that in the instant case, when the sale is made to related persons and the price of the goods is not the sole consideration for sale, the excise duty is liable to be charged from the Noticees, at the value arrived at in terms of Rule 4, Rule 7 of the Central Excise Valuation Rules, 2000 read with the Rule 11 of the said Rules at the value at which the aggregate value of identical excisable goods were sold by them to other independent buyers as detailed in the Annexure A to the Show Cause Notice.

25. The allegation in the SCN is that the appellant and Vandana and Shivali were related persons. It is also the allegation that price was not the sole consideration for sale. It is further the contention that Valuation Rules 9 & 10 do not apply to this case and value should be determined as per Rule 11 read with Rules 4 & 7.

26. Valuation Rule 4 deals with cases where goods are sold but not the time of removal. Valuation Rule 7 deals with cases where the goods are sold but not at the place of removal. It is neither alleged nor established that the goods were not sold at the time of removal or at the place of removal in this case. We are at a loss to understand as to why these Rules were invoked in the SCN because there is no dispute regarding the place of removal or time of removal.

27. It is further interesting that in paragraph 2.8 of the SCN it is alleged that price was not the sole consideration for sale. Valuation Rule 6 deals with additional consideration for sale and requires such consideration to be added to the sale price. There is no discussion or even any indication of the nature or quantum of additional consideration for sale nor has Rule 6 been invoked either alone or in conjunction with Rule 11.

28. Thus, the SCN has not only NOT invoked the Valuation Rules relevant to the period post 2013, but does not also explain why Valuation Rules 11 read with Rules 4 &7 were invoked even for the period pre-2013.

29. The original authority determined the value as per Rule 11 read with Rules 4 and 7 invoked in the SCN. Paragraph 21.7 of this order is reproduced below:

21.7. In the instant case, the goods are sold partially to the related buyers and partially to the independent buyers, the valuation of the goods sold to the related buyers have to be determined in terms of Rule 11 read with rule 9 and 10 of the Central Excise Valuation (Determination of Price of Excisable goods) Rules, 2000. However, Rules 9 and 10 of the Rules ibid do not cover the facts of the instant case. It covers only those cases where are the sales are to related buyers only. It is therefore, concomitant of the Rule 4 read with Rule 7 is applicable in terms of the provisions of the rule 11 of the Rules, ibid. in the case since the value as mentioned in rule 4 i.e., value of goods sold by the assessee for delivery at any time which applies to valuation of goods sold to an independent buyers is available in the case and the principles of rule 7 of the Rules is applicable to the goods sold by the Noticee to their related persons.

30. Thus, the finding of the original authority is that since Rules 9 & 10 do not apply to the case, Rule 11 has to be applied with Rules 4 and 7. It needs to be noted that neither there is any allegation in the SCN nor is there any finding in the order in original that the goods were not sold at the time of delivery (which Valuation Rule 4 deals with) nor is any allegation that the goods were not sold at the place of delivery (which Valuation Rule 7 deals with).

31. Commissioner (Appeals) has, in the impugned order, held that Valuation Rules 11 (read with Valuation Rules 9 & 10) apply to this case. However, these were not invoked in the SCN or in the order-in-original and the appellant was not put to notice on these Rules. Paragraph 6.1 of the impugned order is reproduced below:

6.1 I find that in the instant case the question to be answered is whether the goods cleared by the appellant during the period from 2010-11 (from 10/2010) to 2015-16( upto Jul’15) to M/s. Vandana Ispat Ltd. Raipur and M/s. Shivali Udyog (for brevity hereinafter called the concerned units) are to be assessed to Central Excise duty on the basis of the cost of production in terms of Rule 11 (read with Rule 8,9 and 10) of the Central Excise Valuation (Determination of Price of Excisable goods) Rules, 2000 (hereinafter referred to as the Valuation Rules) especially when the goods are sold to the independent buyers. (emphasis supplied)

32. We have already found that extended period of limitation cannot be applied in the facts of this case and therefore, the demand up to September 2014 cannot be sustained. For the period October 2014 to July 2015, even if the goods are sold partly to related buyers and partly to independent buyers, Valuation Rules 9 and 10 of the Valuation Rules apply which have not been invoked and a demand cannot be confirmed under Valuation Rule 11 which has been invoked. No demand has been made or confirmed under Valuation Rules 9 and 10.

33. Although we have found that the demand is time-barred and also that the Valuation Rules 11 read with Valuation Rules 4 and 7 invoked in the SCN apply to sales to related persons either during the normal period of limitation or during the extended period of limitation, for the sake of completeness, we also proceed to examine, based on the assertions and evidence adduced in the SCN whether the appellant and Vandana and Shivali are related persons.

34. The buyer and seller are ‘related persons’ according to clause (b) of sub-section (3) of section 4 if one more of the following conditions are met:

(i) they are inter-connected undertakings;

(ii) they are relatives;

(iii) amongst them the buyer is a relative and a distributor of the assessee, or a sub-distributor of such distributor; or

(iv) they are so associated that they have interest, directly or indirectly, in the business of each other.

35. The appellant, Vandana and Shivali are all companies. Therefore, the question of they being ‘relatives’ or being a relative and a distributor does not arise. We do not find any evidence in the SCN that the appellant and Vandana and Shivali have interest in the business of each other. Thus, of the four sub-clauses of clause (b) of sub-section 3 of section 4, (ii), (iii) and (iv) are not relevant.

36. The only allegation is that as per the declaration made in the balance sheet by the appellants, key personnel of the appellant have significant influence over Vandana and Shivali which is not disputed by the appellant before us. The question which remains to be answered is whether this would make them inter-connected undertakings as per sub-clause(i) of clause (b) of sub-section 3 of section 4. As per the Explanation in Section 4, “inter-connected undertakings” means two or more undertakings which are inter-connected with each other in any of the following manner, namely :-

(A) if one owns or controls the other;

(B) where the undertakings are owned by firms, if such firms have one or more common partners;

(C) where the undertakings are owned by bodies corporate,-

(I) if one body corporate manages the other body corporate; or

(II) if one body corporate is a subsidiary of the other body corporate; or

(III) if the bodies corporate are under the same management; or

(IV) if one body corporate exercises control over the other body corporate in any other manner;

(D) where one undertaking is owned by a body corporate and the other is owned by a firm, if one or more partners of the firm, –

(I) hold, directly or indirectly, not less than fifty per cent. of the shares, whether preference or equity, of the body corporate; or

(II) exercise control, directly or indirectly, whether as director or otherwise, over the body corporate;

(E) if one is owned by a body corporate and the other is owned by a firm having bodies corporate as its partners, if such bodies corporate are under the same management;

(F) if the undertakings are owned or controlled by the same person or by the same group;

(G) if one is connected with the other either directly or through any number of undertakings which are inter-connected undertakings within the meaning of one or more of the foregoing sub-clauses.

Explanation 1. – For the purposes of this clause, two bodies corporate shall be deemed to be under the same management, –

(i) if one such body corporate exercises control over the other or both are under the control of the same group or any of the constituents of the same group; or

(ii) if the managing director or manager of one such body corporate is the managing director or manager of the other; or

(iii) if one such body corporate holds not less than one-fourth of the equity shares in the other or controls the composition of not less than one-fourth of the total membership of the Board of directors of the other; or

(iv) if one or more directors of one such body corporate constitute, or at any time within a period of six months immediately preceding the day when the question arises as to whether such bodies corporate are under the same management, constituted (whether independently or together with relatives of such directors or employees of the first mentioned body corporate) one-fourth of the directors of the other; or

(v) if the same individual or individuals belonging to a group, while holding (whether by themselves or together with their relatives) not less than one-fourth of the equity shares in one such body corporate also hold (whether by themselves or together with their relatives) not less than one-fourth of the equity shares in the other; or

(vi) if the same body corporate or bodies corporate belonging to a group, holding, whether independently or along with its or their subsidiary or subsidiaries, not less than one-fourth of the equity shares in one body corporate, also hold not less than one-fourth of the equity shares in the other; or

(vii) if not less than one-fourth of the total voting power in relation to each of the two bodies corporate is exercised or controlled by the same individual (whether independently or together with his relatives) or the same body corporate (whether independently or together with its subsidiaries); or

(viii) if not less than one-fourth of the total voting power in relation to each of the two bodies corporate is exercised or controlled by the same individuals belonging to a group or by the same bodies corporate belonging to a group, or jointly by such individual or individuals and one or more of such bodies corporate; or

(ix) if the directors of one such body corporate are accustomed to act in accordance with the directions or instructions of one or more of the directors of the other, or if the directors of both the bodies corporate are accustomed to act in accordance with the directions or instructions of an individual, whether belonging to a group or not.

Explanation II. – If a group exercises control over a body corporate, that body corporate and every other body corporate, which is a constituent of, or controlled by, the group shall be deemed to be under the same management.

Explanation III. – If two or more bodies corporate under the same management hold, in the aggregate, not less than one-fourth equity share capital in any other body corporate, such other body corporate shall be deemed to be under the same management as the first mentioned bodies corporate.

Explanation IV. – In determining whether or not two or more bodies corporate are under the same management, the shares held by financial institutions in such bodies corporate shall not be taken into account.

Illustration Undertaking B is inter-connected with undertaking A and undertaking C is inter-connected with undertaking B. Undertaking C is inter- connected with undertaking A; if undertaking D is inter-connected with undertaking C, undertaking D will be inter-connected with undertaking B and consequently with undertaking A; and so on.

Explanation V. – For the purposes of this clause, “group” means a group of-

(i) two or more individuals, associations of individuals, firms, trusts, trustees or bodies corporate (excluding financial institutions), or any combination thereof, which exercises, or is established to be in a position to exercise, control, directly or indirectly, over anybody corporate, firm or trust; or

(ii) associated persons.

Explanation VI. – For the purposes of this clause,-

(I) a group of persons who are able, directly or indirectly, to control the policy of a body corporate, firm or trust, without having a controlling interest in that body corporate, firm or trust, shall also be deemed to be in a position to exercise control over it;

(II) “associated persons” –

(a) in relation to a director of a body corporate, means –

(i) a relative of such director, and includes a firm in which such director or his relative is a partner;

(ii) any trust of which any such director or his relative is a trustee;

(iii) any company of which such director, whether independently or together with his relatives, constitutes one-fourth of its Board of directors;

(iv) any other body corporate, at any general meeting of which not less than one-fourth of the total number of directors of such other body corporate are appointed or controlled by the director of the first mentioned body corporate or his relative, whether acting singly or jointly;

(b) in relation to the partner of a firm, means a relative of such partner and includes any other partner of such firm; and

(c) in relation to the trustee of a trust, means any other trustee of such trust;

(III) where any person is an associated person in relation to another, the latter shall also be deemed to be an associated person in relation to the former;

37. It is undisputed that key personnel of the appellant have significant influence over Vandana and Shivali. This would indicate the possibility of the same persons controlling both the appellant and also Vandana and Shivali and if true, it will make them ‘inter-connected undertakings’ as per clause (F) above and if the appellant and Vandana and Shivali are also under the same management it will also make them ‘inter- connected undertakings’ as per clause C (III) above. This possibility could have been examined to see the kind of relationship which makes them inter-connected undertakings. However, we do not find sufficient details, let alone, supporting evidence in the SCN to hold that the appellant and Vandana and Shivali are interconnected undertakings.

38. Even if they are inter-connected undertakings but are not related persons in any of the other ways indicated in section 4, valuation must be done as if they are not related persons [Valuation Rule 10(b)] and so the demand will not sustain on merits.

39. To sum up:

a) The demand for the period prior to September 2014 is time barred.

b) The fact that the appellant was working under self- assessment is not a ground on which extended period of limitation can be invoked as per Section 11A and such an interpretation of Section 11A renders the provision related to the normal period of limitation under section 11A otiose.

c) The assessee can make mistakes in self-assessment but the Rules mandate the officers to scrutinize the returns and call for documents and records from the assessee.

d) Scrutiny by the officers is a check provided under the Rules against any mistakes in self-assessment. If any duty escapes assessment, a demand can be issued within the normal period of limitation.

e) The period of limitation under section 11A is to be reckoned from the date of filing of the Return or the last date for filing the Return. If the Return is filed, the officer gets sufficient time to scrutinize it and raise a demand. If the Return is not filed by the date when it is due, it is for the officer to call for records, scrutinize them to check if duty has been correctly paid. If the period lapses without the officers scrutinizing the returns and raising a demand, it is on account of the officers not scrutinizing the returns properly and taking timely action. The fact that the officer has not scrutinized the returns properly and timely cannot be a ground to invoke extended period of limitation.

f) The appellant cannot be faulted for not disclosing any information (such as its relationship with Vandana and Shivali in this case) in the ER-1 return because it is not required to do so. The Rules empower the officer to call for any information or records and the officer scrutinizing the returns could have called for any information which he felt was necessary to check the valuation.

g) It is not correct to say that had the audit not been conducted, the alleged errors in assessment would not have come to light because they would have come to light if the officers had scrutinized the Returns and called for any data or records which they needed. The fact that audit has pointed out the alleged mistakes only shows that the officers have not scrutinized the returns properly.

h) The SCN is vague as to why Valuation Rule 11 read with Valuation Rules 4 & 7 was being invoked when there is no dispute regarding the place of removal or time of removal;

i) The Commissioner (Appeals) upheld the demand invoking Valuation Rules 11 read with Rules 9 & 10 which were not invoked in the SCN;

j) For the normal period of limitation after 2013, the Valuation Rules as amended, would apply. They were neither discussed nor invoked and the demand was confirmed as per the un-amended Valuation Rules.

k) Evidence in the case is insufficient to hold that the appellant and its buyers Vandana and Shivali are inter- connected undertakings and there is no allegation or evidence that they are related in any other manner. Even if they are inter-connected undertakings but are not related in any other manner, valuation has to be done as per Valuation Rule 10(b) as if they are not related persons and the demand would not sustain.

40. For all the above reasons, the impugned order cannot be sustained. The impugned order dated February 15, 2018 is set aside and the appeal is allowed with consequential relief, if any, to the appellant.

(order pronounced in the open court on 02.12.2022)

Notes:

1 Appellant

2 Impugned order

3 Commissioner (Appeals)

4 Vandana

5 Shivali

6 Valuation Rules

7 SCN

8 Act

9 Excise Rules

Advertisement

Author Info

CA Sandeep Kanoi
Qualification: Graduate, CA in Job / Business, DD
Company: Taxguru Consultancy
Location: Mumbai, Maharashtra
Articles Published: 24,592

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.