Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Excise Duty

Proportionate CENVAT Credit Reversal Invalidates Rule 6 Demand: CESTAT Mumbai

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2026 taxguru.in 18912
Case Name
Responsive Industries Ltd. Vs Commissioner of Central Excise (CESTAT Mumbai)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Responsive Industries Ltd. Vs Commissioner of Central Excise (CESTAT Mumbai)

Summary: The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), Mumbai, in Responsive Industries Ltd. and Axiom Cordages Ltd. Vs Commissioner of Central Excise, examined whether manufacturers producing both dutiable and exempted goods could be compelled to pay 5% or 6% of the value of exempted clearances under Rule 6(3) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004, despite reversing the credit attributable to exempted products. Responsive Industries manufactured PVC products and coated cotton fabrics, including exempted coated cotton fabrics (deluxe), while Axiom Cordages manufactured HDPE/PP yarn, ropes, twine and exempted Hawser Nets. The Department alleged that both manufacturers had availed CENVAT credit on common inputs and input services without maintaining separate accounts, resulting in substantial demands, interest and penalties.

In the case of Responsive Industries, the Department issued two show-cause notices demanding approximately ₹51.10 crore for November 2010 to March 2013. The company contended that the disputed inputs were used predominantly or exclusively in manufacturing dutiable goods and that it maintained separate records for exempted production. It submitted that ₹17,51,454 out of ₹20,51,421 of input-service credit related exclusively to dutiable goods, while ₹2,99,967 attributable to common services and ₹22,455 relating to Safex equipment had already been reversed. In Axiom Cordages’ case, the Department demanded approximately ₹5.09 crore, alleging irregular availment of common input-service credit. The company maintained that most credit related to dutiable production and that the disputed proportionate credit had been reversed with interest. The Revenue disputed the adequacy of documentary evidence and compliance with Proportionate reversal procedure under Rule 6(3A)” target=”_blank” rel=”noopener”>Rule 6(3A).

The Tribunal examined Rule 6(1), Rule 6(2), Rule 6(3) and Proportionate reversal procedure under Rule 6(3A)” target=”_blank” rel=”noopener”>Rule 6(3A) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004, together with judicial precedents including Mercedes Benz India (P) Ltd., Star Agriwarehousing & Collateral Management Ltd., Reliance Life Insurance Co. Ltd. and Tiara Advertising. It observed that the statutory objective was to prevent manufacturers from retaining credit attributable to exempted goods or services, rather than compel payment of disproportionately large amounts when attributable credit had already been reversed. The Tribunal emphasised that proportionate reversal effectively amounts to non-availment of the corresponding credit and that procedural deficiencies should not automatically deprive an assessee of the substantive benefit of reversal. It also considered the documentary material and the Department’s objections regarding the correctness of the reversals.

Accordingly, CESTAT Mumbai held that reversal of proportionate CENVAT credit attributable to exempted goods amounts to non-availment of such credit and that the Department cannot automatically enforce the 5% or 6% payment option under Rule 6(3) merely because the prescribed procedure was not followed. Both appeals filed by Responsive Industries Ltd. were allowed, setting aside the disputed demands and consequential penalties. In the case of Axiom Cordages Ltd., the appeal was partly allowed by remand for the limited purpose of verifying the correctness of the credit reversal. Any shortfall was required to be paid with applicable interest. The Tribunal directed completion of the verification exercise within four weeks of receipt of its order, thereby distinguishing substantive compliance through proportionate reversal from procedural irregularities.

Cases Discussed

  • Agrawal Metal Works Pvt. Ltd., 2022 (7) TMI 924 (CESTAT) — Cited as following Tiara Advertising on Rule 6 options.
  • Star Agriwarehousing & Collateral Management Ltd., 2021 (44) G.S.T.L. 271 (CESTAT Delhi) — Applied to proportionate reversal and minor procedural lapses.
  • Tiara Advertising, 2019 (30) G.S.T.L. 474 (Telangana High Court) — Cited regarding the assessee’s choice under Rule 6(3).
  • Reliance Life Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs CCE, Mumbai, 2018 (363) E.L.T. 1050 (CESTAT Mumbai) — Relied upon concerning reversal rather than percentage-based demand.
  • The Oberoi Rajvilas Vs Commissioner of Central Excise, Jaipur, 2018 (5) TMI 1715 (CESTAT New Delhi) — Reproduced in a cited precedent on proportionate reversal.
  • Mercedes Benz India (P) Ltd., 2015 (40) S.T.R. 381 (CESTAT Mumbai) — Relied upon for the principle that Revenue cannot compel a particular Rule 6 option.
  • Jost’s Engineering Co. Ltd. Vs CCE, Mumbai-III, 2015 (320) E.L.T. 157 (CESTAT Mumbai) — Cited by the appellants.
  • R.R. Paints Pvt. Ltd. Vs Commissioner of Central Excise, Mumbai, 2013 (288) E.L.T. 289 (CESTAT Mumbai) — Relied upon by Revenue.
  • Chemfab Alkalis Ltd. Vs Commissioner of Central Excise, Pondicherry, 2010 (251) E.L.T. 264 (CESTAT Chennai) — Cited by Revenue on limitation.
  • CCE, Thane-I Vs Nicholas Piramal (India) Ltd., 2009 (244) E.L.T. 321 (Bombay High Court) — Discussed regarding separate accounts.
  • Tilaknagar Industries Ltd., 2008 (225) E.L.T. 51 (Bombay High Court) — Cited by Revenue on Rule 6.
  • CCE, Mumbai-I Vs Bombay Dyeing & Mfg. Co. Ltd., 2007 (215) E.L.T. 3 (Supreme Court) — Cited on reversal of credit.
  • Commissioner of Trade Tax, Lucknow Vs Kanhai Tam Thekedar, 2005 (185) E.L.T. 3 (Supreme Court) — Cited by Revenue on interest.
  • Chandrapur Magnet Wires (P) Ltd. Vs CCE, Nagpur, 1996 (81) E.L.T. 3 (Supreme Court) — Referred to for reversal amounting to non-availment.

FULL TEXT OF THE CESTAT MUMBAI ORDER

Appeals E/88822/13 & E/85676/15 filed by M/s Responsive Industries Ltd and appeal. E/85402/2015 filed by M/s Axiom Cordages Limited is taken together for disposal as the issue involved in these appeals is common.

Brief facts Appeals E/88822/13 & E/85676/15(M/s Responsive Industries Ltd)

2. Brief facts of the case of M/s Responsive Industries Ltd are that the Appellants are that the appellants have a 100% EOU unit as well as a DTA unit located adjacent to each other having separate central excise registrations; they manufacture dutiable goods viz. PVC vinyl floorings, PVC film/sheets, PVC leather cloth etc. classified under Chapter 39 and coated cotton fabrics classified under Chapter 59 of the First Scheduled to the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985; the Appellants also manufactured and cleared coated cotton fabrics (deluxe) falling under Chapter 5903 without payment of Central Excise duty by availing benefit of Notification No. 30/2004 dated 9.7.2004.

2.1. During the course of EA-2000 Audit it was observed that the appellants had availed CENVAT credit of Rs.76, 71,294, on inputs such as Furnace Oil, Lubricating Oil, Kraft paper and Safex Fire Equipment and credit of Rs. 20,51,421 on various common inputs services like management consultancy service, exhibition, tours and travels, fixing vinyl flooring at lavasa, construction services, advertising, courier service, GTA Services, etc, used/ consumed for manufacture of both dutiable as well as exempted goods, during the period from November, 2010 to December, 2011. Vide letter dated 31.01.2012, department raised objections that,

  • the Appellants have not maintained separate accounts for the manufacture of dutiable and exempted goods;
  • they are required to pay an amount which is equal to 5%/6% of the value of exempted goods under Rule 6(3) (i) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004; under sub-rule (5) of Rule 6 of the CCR, 2004, input stage credit of services was allowed, even if the same were used for both dutiable and exempted goods, only in case of those services specified therein till 01.03.2011 as the said sub-rule (5) of Rule 6 of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004, had been omitted vide notification No.03/2011- E(NT);
  • the Appellants had also availed CENVAT credit on services like Transport Charges, Testing Charges, Import Charges, Freight Charges etc;
  • Appellants had not exercised their option to follow the procedure laid down under clause 3A of Rule 6 for determination and payment of amount equivalent to Cenvat credit attributable to inputs and input services used in or in relation to the manufacture of exempted goods.

2.2. The Appellants vide letter dated 13. 04.2012 replied that inputs like Furnace oil, lube oil, kraft paper and safex equipment are not used for manufacturing coated cotton fabrics (deluxe), but are used for manufacturing dutiable goods; in anyway Appellants have reversed the Cenvat credit of Rs. 22,455/- on safex equipment which was under dispute; they submitted Chartered Engineers certificate and write up of manufacturing process of the both products manufactured; out of Rs. 20,51, 421, amount of Rs. 17,51,454/- pertains to manufacture of dutiable finished goods only; Cenvat credit of Rs.2,99,967/- availed on disputed common input services had already been reversed by them with interest; with effect from April 2012, the Appellant has stopped availing Cenvat credit on the input services on the disputed services.

2.3. Two Show cause Notices dated 29.01.2013 (covering the period November 2010 to October 2012 for Rs 34,99,23,867) and dated 05.12.2013 (covering the period November 2012 to March 2013 for Rs 16,10.58,699) demanding the amounts along with interest and seeking to levy penalties have been issued. The demands and penalties were confirmed by the impugned orders dated 19.6.2013 and 24.12.2014.

Brief facts in Appeal No E/85402/2015(M/s Axiom Cordages Limited)

3. M/s Axiom Cordages Ltd, the Appellants are a DTA unit manufacturing HDPE/PP Yarn, HDPE/PP Rope, Twine, Nylon Rope, HDPE/PP Yarn (Z twisted) and plastic Waste and Scrap cleared after payment of duty and Hawser Net falling under Chapter 56 cleared them without payment of Central Excise duty by availing benefit of Notification No. 30/2004 dated 9.7.2004. Department conducted an audit of the appellants and informed the appellants vide letter dated 13.04.2012 the observation that the appellants availed Cenvat credit on various common inputs services like tours and travels, CHA, Annual Maintenance Contract, GTA Services, Insurance Services, Bank Charges etc; they have taken service tax credit of Rs.1,39,99,363; they did not maintain separate accounts for the manufacture of dutiable and exempted goods; hence, they are required to pay 5%/6% of the value of exempted goods under Rule 6(3) (i) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004;

3.1. The Appellants vide their letter dated 19.05.2012 replied that out of Rs. 1, 39,99,363, credit of Rs. 1,30,62,963/- pertains to manufacture of dutiable finished goods; Cenvat credit of Rs.8,57,324/- availed on common input services had already been reversed by them with interest.; further credit of Rs.79,076 incorrectly availed by them has also been reversed. Subsequently, department raised objection on similar ground that they have incorrectly taken credit of Rs.16,34,144/- on the common inputs services for both dutiable and exempted goods in the month of March 2012.

3.2. Department issued two Show Cause dated 26.3.2013 (demanding Rs 4,78,64,141 for the period November 2010 to February 2012) and dated 1.4.2013 (demanding Rs. 30,05,960 for the period of March 2012). The demands were confirmed vide a common order in original dated 31.10.2014 confirmed the demands with penalties.

Submissions in Appeals E/88822/13 & E/85676/15(M/s Responsive Industries Ltd)

4. Ms Nisha Bineesh, Learned Counsel, appearing on behalf of the appellants submits that from the copies of RG 23 filed before the Audit as well as before Hon’ble Tribunal, it can be seen that the allegation of the department that it is incorrect to say that the Appellant has not maintained separate accounts for the manufacture of dutiable as well as exempted goods; Commissioner is factually incorrect in holding that the part of the coated cotton fabrics have been cleared on payment of duty and part of it have been cleared without payment of duty; in fact the products are different and also the processes undertaken are also entirely different in every way; coated cotton fabrics have been cleared on payment of duty, has not been manufactured by process of heating and embossing coated cotton fabrics; this fact is not in dispute; the raw material for coated cotton fabrics is PVC resin and the raw material for coated cotton fabrics (deluxe) is coated cotton fabrics which the appellant buy from local market; hence, the finding that inputs credit on furnace oil, lube oil, kraft paper has been taken on the manufacturing of coated cotton fabrics (deluxe) is incorrect.

5. Learned Counsel also submits that Rule 6 of Cenvat Credit Rules,2004 is applicable only in the case where the appellants have availed Cenvat credit on the inputs and input services pertaining to the exempted and dutiable goods manufactured in the factory; this is not the fact of the present case; applying Rule 6(3) to the present case is not proper. Refereeing to the copies of documents records submitted by the appellant, she submits that out of Rs. 20,51,421/- the credit of Rs. 17,51,454/- pertains to manufacture of dutiable finished goods only; remaining Rs.2,99,967 availed on disputed common input services had already been reversed by them with interest; appellants have reversed the Cenvat credit of Rs. 22,455/- on safex equipment which was under dispute; Rule 6(3) (ii) has been introduced in the Cenvat Credit Rules to avoid undesired interpretation of the Cenvat Credit Rules; the Commissioner erred in confirming the amount under Rule 6 (3) (ii) of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 instead of invoking Rule 6 (3) (i) of Cenvat Credit Rules. She relies on ratio the following.

(i). CCE, Mumbai-I Vs Bombay Dyeing & Mfg. Co. Ltd., 2007 (215) ELT 3 (SC)

(ii). CCE, Thane-I Vs Nicholas Piramal (India) Ltd., 2009 (244) ELT 321 (Bom.)

(iii). Jost’s Engineering Co. Ltd Vs CCE, Mumbai-III, 2015 (320) ELT 157 (Tri. – Mumbai)

(iv). Reliance Life Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs CCE, Mumbai, 2018 (363) ELT 1050 (Tri. – Mumbai)

(v). Star Agriwarehousing& Collateral Management Ltd. Vs CCE & S.T., jaipur, 2021 GSTL 271 (Tri. – Del.)

6. Learned Counsel submits further that in the view of the above, they have not availed Cenvat credit on the input services which were commonly used in the manufacture of dutiable as well as exempted finished goods as taking credit on inputs/input services and reversing them amounts to not taking of the credit; therefore Rule 6 is not applicable to present case; without prejudice to the above, the demand raised is dis-proportionate to the amount of credit availed on the common input services; out of Rs. 20,51,421/- the credit of Rs. 17,51,454/- pertains to manufacture of dutiable finished goods only; Cenvat credit of Rs. 2,99,967/- availed on common input services and Cenvat credit of Rs. 22,455 vailed on safex equipment had already been reversed by them with interest; in the above factual position, demand of 34,99,23,867 is incorrect and dis- proportionate.

7. Learned Counsel submits also that Demand is beyond reasonable period hence, barred by limitation; the appellant maintained separate records; the same were intimated, made available to the departmental officials on their visits to the factory; respective documents were submitted before Lower Authority along with the reply to the audit objection and reply to the Show Case Notice; the lower authority failed to consider the same. She further submits that no finding of intention to evade the payment of duty is given in the impugned order; hence, proposal of invocation of extended period is not proper and legally unsustainable, so with the imposition of penalty.

Submissions in respect of Appeal No. E/85402/2015 (M/S Axiom Cordages Limited)

8. Learned Counsel adopts the above argument on legal points and submits that the appellants did maintain separate accounts for manufacture of dutiable goods as well as exempted goods; the same was submitted at the time of filing reply to the audit objection; she submits copies of RG 23. She submits that raw materials for HDPE/PP Yarn, HDPE/PP Rope, Twine, Nylon Rope, HDPE/PP Yarn (Z twisted) and plastic Waste and Scarp are PP granules and raw material for Hawser Net is fishing net which the appellants buy from local market; hawser net are manufactured manually and no machines are used as alleged by the department. She submits that out of Rs. 1,39,99,363, credit of Rs. 1,30,62,963/- pertains to manufacture of dutiable finished goods; Cenvat credit of Rs.9,36,400 and of Rs.79,076, availed on common input services, had already been reversed by them with interest; Rs.1,02,81,963 pertains to Goods Transport Agency Service of PP Granules procured from Reliance Industries Ltd for manufacturing of dutiable product; the credit on the above and man power services were utilised only for the manufacture of dutiable goods.

9. Sydney D’ Silva, Additional Commissioner, Learned Authorised Representative, appearing for the revenue reiterates the findings of OIO and submits on the appeal E/88822/2013 and E/88676/2015 filed by M/s responsive Industries Ltd that it is not in dispute that the Appellants manufactured dutiable as well as exempted goods.; SCN alleges that the Appellants manufactured Cotton Coated Fabrics, part of which was cleared on payment of duty and part without payment of duty by claiming exemption under notification No.30/2004, dated 09.07.2004; SCN further alleges that inputs such as Furnace Oil, Lube oil, Kraft paper and Safex Fire Equipment on which Cenvat was availed, was used in the manufacture of both dutiable and exempted products mentioned above; no separate accounts were maintained for the receipt, consumption, inventory and use of these inputs with respect to dutiable and exempted final products. He submits that the appellant’s claim of maintaining separate accounts in respect of inputs for dutiable and exempted products is not backed by any evidence; no evidence is produced during the course of audit and during the current proceedings either. He submits that non maintenance of separate records is evidenced by the assertion of the Appellants that they have reversed the credit availed by them on the safex equipment, on being pointed out during the course of audit. He submits that the Appellants on being pointed out by audit, reversed an amount of Rs.2,99,967, for the period from February, 2010 to December, 2011, being Cenvat credit availed in respect of services such as Management Consultancy Services, Exhibition, Tours &Travels, Fixing of Vinyl Flooring at Lavasa, Repair & Maintenance Construction Services Advertising, Courier charges, GTA etc which were consumed in both dutiable as well as exempted goods; similarly, for the period January, 2012 to March, 2012 the Appellants availed Cenvat credit amounting to Rs 66,961

10. Learned Authorised Representative further submits that learned Adjudicating Authority has correctly relied upon R.R. Paints Pvt. Ltd. v/s Commissioner of Central Excise, Mumbai [2013(288) ELT 289 (Tri- Mumbai)];appellants reliance on Bombay Dyeing &Mfg Co Ltd, [2007 (8) SSC 177] and Chandrapur Magnet Wires (P) Ltd 1996 (81) ELT 3 (SC) is misplaced, as the facts of the case are entirely different to the instant case. He submits on the issue of limitation that the Appellants had suppressed the fact of non-maintenance of separate accounts and failed to follow the procedure under Rules 6(3)(i), 6(3)(ii) or Rule 6(3)(iii) of the CCR; mere filing of ER-1 returns, would not provide immunity to the Appellants from such non-adherence of the law; Appellants though had chosen to maintain separate accounts, did not follow and suppressed this fact; the issue was noticed by the department during the course of audit conducted without which the issue could have remained undetected; Tribunal in the case of Chemfab Alkalis Ltd. v/s Commissioner Central Excise, Pondicherry [2010 (251) ELT 264 (Tri-Chennai)] held that even in cases where a unit is audited by the department at regular intervals it cannot be said that extended period will not apply in respect of such unit; interest on delayed payment is inherent in the Act and it is mandatory as held in the case of Commissioner of Trade Tax, Lucknow vs Kanhai Tam Thekedar (2005(185) ELT3 (S.C.)) and SKF Ltd. 2391ELT 385 (SC).

11. On the appeal E/85402/2015 filed by M/s Axiom Cordages, learned Authorised Representative submits that fact of availment of Cenvat credit in input services commonly used for manufacture of dutiable as well as exempted goods has not been denied; it is even sworn in a notarized affidavit; there is no averment either in the written reply dated 13.11.2013 or the affidavit dated 17.05.2014 that the reversal made was as per Rule 6(3A) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004. Rule 6(3) (ii) and Rule 6(3A) of, which provide for substantive monthly and yearly declarations and payments, were not followed; ratio of Bombay Dyeing is not applicable. He submits that the learned Adjudicating Authority has rightly held that a fact, when sought to be averred, needs to be to be proved with circumscribing and definitive facts; in the matter of record based facts, an oath before a notary is no substitute for evidence that flows from records; this is particularly essential when benefit is claimed to an exception, as provided in the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004, and where the onus lies solely on the claimant; letters of the three alleged Manpower suppliers, namely, M/s Jivdani Enterprises, Boisar, M/s Sainath Enterprises, Palghar, and M/s Prathmesh Enterprises, Palghar are ad verbatim to the last word and their credibility is negated from the bills and do not corroborate any facts; no evidence is submitted on the claim that external workforce engaged was not for any machines or work for manufacture of Hawser nets. He submits that similarly, in the case of use of GTA services, no cogent evidence has been tendered to show that the service used was manufacture of only dutiable excisable goods only and not Hawser nets; Hawser nets are also manufactured out of the very same inputs; onus to prove the averment is on Appellants; the appellants have also not proved that there has been no availment of Cenvat credit for the month of March, 2012; as there was a manufacture of 4,10,370 kg of Hawser nets in the month of March, 2012, the claim is not substantiated.

12. Learned Authorised Representative submits also that Bombay High Court held in Nicholas Piramal India Limited. 2009 (244) ELT 321, that if separate inventory is not maintained, then, the manufacturer would have no option, but to pay amounts specified in Rule 6(3)(i) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004; mere reversal of the availed Cenvat credit would not be sufficient; procedure needs to be followed, declarations to be given periodically and reversals need to be made with interest as held in Ind- swift Laboratories, 2011 (265) ELT 3; Bombay High Court, in the case of Tilaknagar Industries Limited, 2008 (225) ELT 51, held that even in the case of manufacture of non-excisable goods, Rule 6(3)(1) would be applicable. He submits that the appellants contention that the demand was not proportional to the availed credits, is not acceptable as the

Appellants did not make proportionate reversal as prescribed by Rule 6(3)(i) & 6(3A) ibid.

13. Making submissions on all the appeals, Learned Authorised Representative submits that the Appellants have declared that they have reversed certain amount of credit towards inputs/input services utilised for manufacture of dutiable and exempted goods, however, no Calculation sheet/ worksheet/ justification has been shown/submitted on as to how they have arrived at this figures; the very claim proves that they were not maintaining separate records; no documentary evidence evidencing either maintenance of separate accounts or calculation of reversal has been produced at any stage including the present proceedings. He further submits that the Appellants filed ER returns but did not disclose relevant facts which were first noticed at the time of audit; therefore, they have suppressed relevant facts; conditions of Rule 14 of the CCR, 2004 read with Section 11A of the Central Excise Act, 1944 satisfied; hence, extended period of limitation was rightly invoked.

14. Heard both sides and perused the records of the case. Brief issues that require our consideration are as to whether the appellants have availed credit of common inputs and input services used in the manufacture of exempted and dutiable goods; the appellants maintained separate accounts of the same in terms of provisions clause (i) of sub- rule (3) of Rule 6 of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004; the appellants incorrectly availed and utilised CENVAT credit; the reversal of credit claimed by the appellants would suffice in the facts and circumstances of the case; the appellants are liable to pay the amounts demanded along with interest and penalty whether the extended period is invokable.

15. In respect of Appeal No. E/88822/2013 and E/88676/2015 it was alleged that the appellant, M/s Responsive Industries Ltd were manufacturing, inter alia, Coated Cotton Fabrics (delux) which they cleared without payment of duty by availing exemption under notification No 30/2004-CE dated 09.07.2004; they had availed Cenvat credit of common inputs such as Furnace Oil, Lubricating Oil, Kraft paper (used for manufacture of paper tubes) and Safex Fire Equipment and thus they had had availed Cenvat credit Rs.76,71,294 during the period from November, 2010 up to December, 2011; during the period from January, 2012 up to October, 2012, they had availed Cenvat credit amounting to Rs.71,18,584/- on such inputs; the Appellants had also availed input service credit on services viz:- Tours & Travels, Fixing Vinyl Flooring at Lavasa, Exhibition / Advertising, etc. up to March 2011; had also availed CENVAT credit on services like Transport Charges, Testing Charges, Import Charges, Freight Charges etc during the period from January, 2012 to October, 2012. In respect of E/85402/2015, it is alleged that the appellants, M/s Axiom Cordages Ltd manufactured dutiable excisable goods, namely, HDPE /PP yarn, HDPE/ PP Rope, Twine, Nylon Ropes, HDPE/ PP yarn (7 twisted), and Plastic waste and scrap etc; they also manufactured Hawser Net, cleared by them duty free;

15.1. Its alleged that both the Appellants had not maintained separate accounts and the said services on which credit was availed were not included in the ‘services specified’ as per Sub-rule (5) of Rule 6 of the CCR; the Appellants was required to pay central excise duty of an amount @ 5% up to 16.03.2012 and thereafter @ 6% on the value of exempted goods as provided in Clause (i) of Sub-rule (3) of Rule 6 of the CCR.

16. M/s Responsive Industries Ltd submit that they had maintained separate accounts for the manufacture of dutiable finished goods and exempted finished goods; the exempted goods were manufactured at separate places in the factory; the entire receipt of the raw material, consumption and finished goods were separately recorded in the books for manufacture of exempted goods; they had taken input service distribution (“ISD”) registration with effect from 01.04.2012 for their head office; their head office distributes credit of service tax to the EOU unit and DTA unit in the proportion of the turnover; thus, credit on the proportion of the Cenvat credit of service tax, attributable to DTA unit, was not availed by them. In respect of inputs, they submitted a write up and a certificate from a Chartered Engineer; they had vide letter dated 13.04.2012 informed the department that Furnace oil, Lube oil, Kraft paper were not used in the manufacture of exempted finished goods i.e., coated cotton fabrics; safex equipment was also used in the manufacture of dutiable final product only; that in any case, they had reversed the Cenvat credit of Rs.22,455/- on safex equipment under dispute; department alleges that the Cenvat credit taken on the common input services was Rs.20,51,421; out of this Rs.17,51,454/- was related to the input service for inward transportation of inputs procured from various suppliers; they have reversed balance credit of Rs.2,99,967; w.e.f. April, 2012, they had stopped availing Cenvat credit on the Input services; there was no evidence to allege that they had not maintained separate accounts.

16.1. M/s Axiom Cordages Ltd submit that they had maintained separate inventories of the input services used for manufacture of dutiable and the exempted goods: from the affidavit dated 17.05.2014 and deposition of Shri AP Jain, their Assistant Manager, it is evident that out of the total Cenvat credit of Rs. 1,39,99,363, during November, 2010 to February, 2012, Rs 1,30,62,963 pertained to manufacture of dutiable excisable goods; they had reversed the balance of credit of Rs. 9,36,400; during January, 2012 to March, 2012, they had availed total input credit of Rs.2,26,696; out of this, they had reversed credit of Rs.66,961, pertaining to common inputs; remaining credit of Rs.1,59,735 was used in the manufacture of dutiable finished goods only; they had not availed credit of service tax paid on common input services; all the input services were used in the manufacture of dutiable finished goods only.

17. Learned adjudicating authority finds in the case of M/s Responsive Industries that

  • The appellants claim that the only raw material required for them to manufacture the exempted product was ‘PVC CCF’, which cannot be used for the manufacture dutiable product and that they have maintained separate accounts is not based on any evidence; they have not produced the same either to the audit or to the adjudicating authority; a mere claim, without supporting Evidence, is not acceptable; reversal of credit availed on the safex equipment, indicates that the appellants used common inputs;
  • the Chartered Engineer’s Certificate submitted to show that they had manufactured exempted coated fabrics using the electrical heater system, though cogent, does not establish that the actual process carried out; certificate would have served as corroborative evidence; as the appellants, the certificate loses muscle and leads to a mere conjecture; coated fabrics can be manufactured by either of the processes.
  • The fact that the appellants reversed Rs.66,961, on ‘Common services’, makes it clear that the assessee failed to maintain separate accounts;
  • Appellants impression that the procedure of reversing Cenvat credit availed by them on common inputs whenever pointed out by the department, is consistent with the legal provisions governing the availment of Cenvat credit by a manufacturer of both dutiable and final products, is mistaken; appellants non availment of credit w.e.f. on services has bearing.
  •  Appellants reliance on Bombay Dyeing & Mfg Co. Ltd 2007 (8) SSC 177 and Chandrapur Magnet Wires (P) Ltd 1996 (81) ELT 3 (SC) is misplaced, as the facts of the cases are entirely different; he relies on the ratio of decision in the case of R.R. Paints Pvt. Ltd. 2013(288)ELT 289 (Tri-Mumbai;

18. Learned adjudicating authority finds in the case of M/s Axiom Cordages that

  • The fact of availment of cenvat credit in respect of input services commonly is not denied; moreover it is even sworn in an affidavit dated 17.05.2004;
  • There is also no averment, either in the written reply dated 13.11.2013 or the affidavit dated 17.05.2014, as to whether the reversal made was equal in quantum to or was determined and reversed in accordance with the formula prescribed Rule 6(3A) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 and as to when it was made;
  • A fact, when sought to be averred, needs to be to be proved with circumscribing and definitive facts; in a record based issue, oath before a notary is no substitute for evidence;
  • Letters by man power suppliers are similar verbatim and thus credibility of the same is negated; the bills do not indicate corroboratory details; in the case of use of GTA services, no cogent evidence has been tendered to show that the allegedly indented and received materials therein were used for manufacture of only dutiable excisable goods and not hawser nets; Hawser nets are also manufactured out of the Very same inputs;
  • He relies on Hon’ble Bombay High Court decision in the case of Nicholas Piramal India Limited, 2009 (244) ELT 321; the decision of the Supreme Court in Ind-swift Laboratories, 2011 (265) ELT 3; Bombay High Court in Tilaknagar Industries Limited, 2008 (225) ELT 51 and finds that mere reversal of the availed cenvat credit would not be sufficient; interest would be payable if cenvat credit is taken, even though, it has not been utilised and that it is not true to say that mere taking of cenvat credit is only a paper credit or transaction.

19. We find that it would be useful to have a look at the provisions of Rules discussed herein in order to have a better appreciation.

“Rule 6. Obligation of manufacturer of dutiable and exempted goods and provider of taxable, and exempted services. –

(1) The Cenvat credit shall not be allowed on such quantity of input or input service which is used in the manufacture of exempted goods or for provision of exempted services, except in the circumstances mentioned in sub-rule (2). Provided that the Cenvat credit on inputs shall not be denied to job worker referred to in Rule 12AA of the Central Excise Rules, 2002, on the ground that the said inputs are used in the manufacture of goods cleared without payment of duty under the provisions of that rule.

(2) Where a manufacturer or provider of output service avails of Cenvat credit in respect of any inputs or input services, and manufactures such final products or provides such output service which are chargeable to duty or tax as well as exempted goods or services, then, the manufacturer or provider of output service shall maintain separate accounts for receipt, consumption and inventory of input and input service meant for use in the manufacture of dutiable final products or in providing output service and the quantity of input meant for use in the manufacture of exempted goods or services and take Cenvat credit only on that quantity of input or input service which is intended for use in the manufacture of dutiable goods or in providing output service on which service tax is payable.

(3) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-rules (1) and (2), the manufacturer of goods or the provider of output service, opting not to maintain, separate accounts, shall follow either of the following options, as applicable to him, namely:-

(i) the manufacturer of goods shall pay an amount equal to five per cent of value of the exempted goods and the provider of output service shall pay an amount equal to six per cent of value of the exempted services; or

(ii) the manufacturer of goods or the provider of output service shall pay an amount equivalent to the Cenvat credit attributable to inputs and input services used in, or in relation to, the manufacture of exempted goods or for provision of exempted services subject to the conditions and procedure specified in sub-rule (3A).

Explanation I. – If the manufacturer of goods or the provider of output service, avails any of the option under this sub-rule, he shall exercise such option for all exempted goods manufactured by him or, as the case may be, all exempted services provided by him, and such option shall not be withdrawn during the remaining part of the financial year.

Explanation II. – For removal of doubt, it is hereby clarified that the credit shall not be allowed on inputs and input services used exclusively for the manufacture of exempted goods or provision of exempted service. (3A) For determination and payment of amount payable under clause (ii) of sub-rule (3), the manufacturer of goods or the provider of output service shall follow the following procedure and conditions.”

20. As per above, we find that Rule 6 of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 deals with the obligations of a provider of taxable and exempted services. A plain reading of the above provisions indicate that while Rule 6(1) provides that the manufacturer or provider of output service is not entitled for the credit of such quantity of input or input services which are used in the manufacture of exempted goods or exempted service except in the circumstances mentioned in the sub-rule (2) of the said Rules. Sub-rule (2) of Rule 6 provides for maintenance of separate records in respect of inputs, input services substantiating use of input and input services for taxable and exempted goods or services. Sub-rule (3) of Rule 6 provides that in case separate accounts are not maintained, the manufacturer or provider of services shall follow either of the conditions stipulated in sub-rule (3) of Rule 6. It is pertinent to note that after the amendment the only change that could be seen in respect of sub-rule (3) is to the extent of payment in respect of exempted goods produced or exempted services provided Rule 6(1) states that Cenvat Credit shall not be allowed on inputs/input services exclusively used for providing exempted services. Rule 6(2) provides that if inputs or input services are used for provision of output services which are chargeable to duty or tax as well as exempted services, then separate accounts are to be maintained for receipt, consumption and inventory of inputs and receipt and use of input services and the provider shall take credit only on inputs used for dutiable output services. Rule 6(3) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 is relevant for the purpose of this case and states to the effect that a provider of output services who opts not to maintain separate accounts, as required under Rule 6(2), should follow any one of the options provided under Clauses (i) to (iii) there under, as applicable to him. Clause (i) provides for the option of paying an amount equal to 5% of the value of the exempted services.

21. We find that the tribunal has gone in to issue of the admissibility of credit in cases where the inputs and/or input services are used in manufacture/provision of dutiable as well as exempted products/services. This Bench has gone in to the issue involved, while dealing with an appeal in the case of Mercedes Benz India (P) Ltd 2015 (40) S.T.R. 381 (Tri. – Mumbai). This Bench observed that Adjudicating Authority demanded 5% of the total sale of the trading turnover of goods on the ground that option provided under Rule 6(3)(i) is applicable on the ground that claim of the appellant on the option provided under Rule 6(3)(ii) is not available for the reason that appellant has not complied with condition provided under sub Rule (3A) of Rule 6 which provides that manufacturers of the goods shall follow certain procedure and conditions as provided under sub-rule (3A) (a)(i) to (iv) inasmuch as the appellant have not given said information in writing to the Jurisdictional Superintendent of Central Excise. Secondly the appellant, as provided under Claus (b) of sub-rule (3A) have not paid the amount of Cenvat on monthly basis and paid after almost 11 months.

5.1 We have observed that in Rule 6(3) prevalent at the relevant time, two options have been provided:-

(i) Payment of 5% on value of exempted services.

(ii) Payment of an amount equal to the Cenvat Credit amount attributed to input services used in or in relation to manufacture of exempted goods or provision of exempted services as provided under sub rule (3A)(b).

It is observed that the appellant has availed the option provided under sub-rule (3)(ii) of Rule 6 and paid an amount as per sub-rule (3A) along with interest and intimated the same to the jurisdictional superintendent in writing vide letter dated 14-3-2012. From the perusal of the said letter, we observed that the appellant categorically stated in the said letter that payment of Cenvat Credit, which they have made along with interest is in accordance with Rule 6 (3A) of Cenvat Credit Rules. With this act of the appellant, it is clear that the appellant opted for the option as provided under Rule 6(3)(ii) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004, in accordance to which, the appellant are supposed to an amount equivalent to Cenvat Credit on input service attributed to the exempted service in terms of Rue 6(3A). In the present case, the appellant has availed Cenvat credit in respect of common input services, which has been used in relation to the manufacture of the final product as well as for trading of bought out cars. Therefore they are supposed to pay an amount equivalent to Cenvat credit which is attributed to the input service used for exempted service i.e. sale of car. In our view, three options have been provided under Rule 6(3) and it is up to the assessee that which option has to be availed. Revenue could not insist the appellant to avail a particular option. In the present case the appellant have admittedly availed option as provided under Rule 6(3)(ii) and paid an amount as required under sub-rule (3A) of Rule 6. As regard the compliance of the procedure and conditions as laid down for availing option as provided under sub-rule (3)(ii), we find that foremost condition is that the appellant is required to pay an amount as per the formula provided under sub-rule (3A) on monthly basis. However, we find that as per the provision, payment on monthly basis is provisional basis, therefore it is not mandatory that whole amount or part of the amount was required to be paid on every month. The appellant though belatedly calculated the amount required to be paid in terms provided under sub-rule (3A) of Rule 6, therefore to fulfill the condition, assessee should pay the said amount, which has been complied by the appellant.

5.2 As regard the delay in payment, if any, the appellant have discharged the interest liability on such delay. Regarding the compliance as provided under Clause (a) of sub-rule (3A) of Rule 6 the appellant while exercising this option is required to intimate in writing to the Jurisdictional Superintendent, Central Excise, the following particulars namely:

(i) Name, address and registration No. of the manufacturer of goods or provider of output service;

(ii) Date from which the option under this clause is exercised or proposed to be exercised;

(iii) Description of dutiable goods or taxable services;

(iv) Description of exempted goods or exempted services;

(v) Cenvat credit of inputs and input services lying in balance as on the date of exercising the option under this condition. As per the submission of the appellant and perusal of their letter along with enclosed details, it is found that more or less all these particulars were intimated to the Jurisdictional Superintendent. The appellant has been filing their returns regularly on monthly basis to the department. On perusal of the copies of the such return submitted along with appeal papers, it is observed that the particulars, as required under clause (a) of sub-rule (3A) of Rule 6 has been produced to the range superintendent. Therefore all the particulars which are required to be intimated to the Jurisdictional superintendent while exercising option stand produced. Though these particulars have not been submitted specifically under a particular letter, but since these particulars otherwise by way of return and some of the information under their letters has admittedly been submitted, we are of the view, as regard this compliance of Rule 6(3A), it stood made.

5.3 As regard the contention of the adjudicating authority that this option should be given in beginning and before exercising such option, we are of the view that though there is no such time limit provided for exercising such option in the rules but it is a common sense that intention of any option should be expressed before exercising the option, however the delay can be taken as procedural lapse. We also note that trading of goods was considered as exempted service from 2011 only, thus it was initial period. We are also of the view that there is no condition provided in the rule that if a particular option, out of three options are not opted, then only option of payment of 5% provided under Rule 6(3)(i) shall be compulsorily made applicable, therefore we are of the view that Revenue could not insist the appellant to avail a particular option. In the present case admittedly it is appellant who have on their own opted for option provided under Rule 6(3)(ii). The meaning of the option as argued by the Ld. Sr. Counsel is that “option of right of choosing, something that may be or is chosen, choice, and the act of choosing”. From the said meaning of the term ‘option’, it is clear that it is the appellant who have liberty to decide which option to be exercised and not the Revenue to decide the same.

5.4 We find that the appellant admittedly paid an amount of Rs. 4, 06,785/- plus interest, this is not under dispute. Therefore in our view, the appellant have complied with the condition prescribed under Rule 6(3)(ii) read with sub-rule (3A) of Rule 6 of Cenvat Credit Rules, therefore demand of huge amount of Rs. 24,71,93,529/- of the total value of the vehicle amounting to. Rs. 494, 38, 70,577/- sold in the market cannot be demanded. We are also of the view that Rule 6 of the Cenvat Credit Rules is not enacted to extract illegal amount from the assessee. The main objective of the Rule 6 is to ensure that the assessee should not avail the Cenvat Credit in respect of input or input services which are used in or in relation to the manufacture of the exempted goods or for exempted services. If this is the objective then at the most amount which is to be recovered shall not be in any case more than Cenvat Credit attributed to the input or input services used in the exempted goods. It is also observed that in either of the three options given in sub-rule (3) of Rule 6, there is no provisions that if the assessee does not opt any of the option at a particular time, then option of payment of 5% will automatically be applied. Therefore we do not understand that when the appellant have categorically by way of their intimation opted for option provided under sub-rule (3)(ii), how Revenue can insist that option (3)(i) under Rule 6 should be followed by the assessee.

5.5 As discussed above and in the facts of the case that actual Cenvat credit attributed to the exempted services used towards sale of the bought out cars in terms of Rule 6(3A) comes to Rs. 4,06,785/- where as adjudicating authority demanded an amount of Rs. 24,71,93,529/-. In our view, any amount, over and above Rs. 4,06,785/- is not the part of the Cenvat Credit, which required to be reversed. The legislator has not enacted any provision by which Cenvat credit, which is other than the credit attributed to input services used in exempted goods or services; can be recovered from the assessee.

5.6 We have gone through judgments relied upon by the Ld. A.R. In the arguments, we found that as regards the judgments on the issue of availment of Cenvat credit on the input or input services used in dutiable and exempted goods, the provision involved in the present case i.e. Rule 6(3) (i) (ii) (3A) has not been considered in the relied upon judgments, therefore the same are not applicable. As regard the other judgments, all these judgments having different facts and dealing with other provisions such as SSI exemption, exemption notification, etc., which are not identical to the fact of the present case, Moreover, in the present case the substantive provisions under Rule 6(3)(ii) and sub rule (3A) i.e. payment of equivalent to the Cenvat credit, which the appellant have complied with and if at all there is delay, the required interest has also been paid, therefore in the present case, there is no case of noncompliance of procedure and condition. Therefore the judgments cited by the ld. A.R. are not applicable.

22. We find that Principal Bench in the case of Star Agri-warehousing & Collateral Management Ltd 2021 (44) G.S.T.L. 271 (Tri. – Del.) held that

8. We have heard the rival contentions and are of the view that it is a matter of record that the appellant have been providing both taxable and exempted output services in respect of which they have been availing credit of common input services. It is also a matter of record that the appellant have fulfilled the requirement of Rule 6(3)(ii) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 read with Rule 6(3A) and have been reversing the amount of common Cenvat credits, proportionate to value of exempted output services. In this regard we take note of the fact that appellant have furnished Cenvat credit register for the period April, 2009 to June, 2012 which indicate that they have regularly been reversing the proportionate amount of the Cenvat credit taken on the common inputs which have gone into exempted output services. In this regard, we are of the view once the appropriate reversal have been made under Rule 6(3A) of the Cenvat Credit Rules any procedural violations of minor nature would be of in-consequential nature and will not disentitle the assessee from availing the Cenvat credit of the common inputs for which they have already been making a regular reversal of proportionate credits. We also take note of the fact that the Department has nowhere mentioned in entire proceedings that the amount of Cenvat credit reversed is not proportionate to the value of exempted services or not proper otherwise. The only ground that the appellant have not followed the laid down procedure of availing the option of Rule 6(3A) like not declaring value of turnover of exempted services in their periodic service tax return, etc., can be minor procedural lapses, but same cannot become ground for denying a substantial benefit to the appellant.

9. We are also of the view that once the proportionate reversal of the Cenvat credit has taken place, that tantamount to not availing of the input services credit of the common inputs which are going into the exempted services. While holding this view we take shelter of the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Chandrapur Magnet Wires (P) Ltd. v. Collector of Central Excise, Nagpur – 1996 (81) E.L.T. 3 (S.C.).

10.We also take note of this Tribunal’s decision on the same issue in case of M/s. The Oberoi Rajvilas v. Commissioner of Central Excise, Jaipur reported under 2018 (5) TMI 1715 – CESTAT New Delhi, the relevant extract of same are reproduced here below:-

From the above, we note that the appellant “9. has followed the proportionate method for availment of credit on common input services. It cannot be said that the appellant has availed any credit on input services used in providing exempted service. The reversal of credit as above satisfies the requirement of non-availment of credit laid down in the Notification No. 1/2006-S.T. ibid.

It is a settled position of law that 10. proportionate reversal at a later date will satisfy the requirement of non-availment of Cenvat credit. This view is supported by various decisions of the Supreme Court/High Courts and Tribunal, some of which have been cited by the appellant.

The procedure prescribed in Rule 6(3A) of 11. the [Cenvat] Credit Rules is only to make the provisions of Rule 3 workable. By means of proportionate reversal the requirement of Rule 6(3) has been substantially satisfied. This is also provided in Rule 6(3D) of the Cenvat Credit Rules which was introduced at a later date”.

23. This Bench in the case of Reliance Life Insurance Co. Ltd 2018 (363) ELT 1050 (Tri. – Mumbai) held that

5. We have carefully considered the rivals submissions and perused the records. We find that the controversy in the case has evolved as the appellant were availing credit on input services. The Revenue’s case is that the appellant was not entitled for the credit of services which has been exclusively used in providing the Life Insurance services under the Traditional Golden Plan which is not taxable simultaneously they have availed credit of common input service used in taxable policies as well as policies which had no risk portion and hence not liable to tax. However we are of the view that in terms of explanation to Rule 2(e) of CCR, 2004 the services on which no service tax is payable is to be considered as “exempted service” and the credit of input or input services is not available to the service provider. The Traditional Golden Plan which does not have any risk cover and thus being not liable to tax falls under the category of “exempted service” at the relevant time. The appellant at the relevant time on the basis of interpretation of the provisions of the Finance Act and Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 considered their service as not exempted and availed Cenvat of input service which were commonly used. The appellant though litigating the show cause notice and demand on merits had also prayed for reversal of credit instead of demand of 6% value of the exempted goods contending that the substantial benefit of reversing the credit should not be denied to them. Before us also it is their submission that they have been given option to reverse the proportionate credit and they cannot be forced to reverse 6% of the value of exempted goods in terms of Rule 6(3) of CCR, 2004. In our considered view the assessee cannot be forced to pay 6% of the value of exempted goods in case where they have availed the credit of input services used in exempted output services. The Rule 6(3A) of CC Rules, 2004 only contemplates procedure for application of Rule 6(3) and does not mandates that on failure to intimate in writing for availing option the manufacturer or the service provider shall lose their choice to avail option under Rule 6(3)(ii) for reversing proportionate credit. The procedure given therein and the conditions in said Rule 6(3A) is intended to make Rule 6(3) workable. It nowhere mandates to take away options exercisable available to the assessee. Rule 6(3)(i) cannot be made automatically applicable on failure to intimate in writing about option to be availed by the assessee. The assessee has the option either to reverse the proportionate credit pertaining to such exempted service or to pay 6%. It has been consistently held by this Tribunal that there is no bar on the assessee for reversal of credit said to have been accrued while providing exempted services. This analogy has been accepted by the Tribunal in case of Mercedez Benz India (P) Ltd. v. CCE – 2015 (40) S.T.R. 381 (Tri.-Mum.), Tata Technologies Ltd. v. CCE – 2016 (42) S.T.R. 290 and by the Hon’ble High Courts in case of Maize Products – 2009 (234) E.L.T. 431 (Guj), Hello Minerals Water (P) Ltd. v. UOI – 2004 (174) E.L.T. 422 (All.), AshimaDyecot Ltd. – 2008 (232) E.L.T. 580 (Guj.-H.C.). Further we find that in case of M/s. Commissioner of Central Excise, New Delhi v. Max New York Life Insurance Company Ltd. reported in 2017-TIOL-2385-CESTAT-DEL the Tribunal held that assessee is entitled for reversal of credit. The Tribunal held as under: “6. The proceedings against the respondent is to recover an amount equivalent to 6% of the value of the exempted service. The Original Authority held that the respondent is liable to follow one of the two options in terms of Rule 6(3) of CCR, 2004. The respondent followed second option and reversed the proportionate credit attributable to the exempted service, along with interest for delayed reversal of such credit. We find that the only objection of the Revenue is to the effect that the respondent failed to exercise the option for reversal at the time of availing credit. We note that the annuity products are considered as exempted service as held by the impugned order. It is also held that the appellant has to follow the consequences of such finding. We note that upon the direction of the impugned order, the respondent did exercise the second option and reversed the credit along with interest. In such factual background, we find that there is no reason to insist that the respondent should necessarily follow the first option of paying 6% of the value of exempted service. We find no merit in the appeal by Revenue. Accordingly, we dismiss the same.”

5.1 We are in agreement with the aforesaid order of the Tribunal and the other judgments and hold that the appellant is entitled for reversal of credit attributable to the exempted service and the demand of 6% is not sustainable against them. The appellant has also argued that there reversal of Cenvat credit ought to be computed by taking the entire Cenvat credit of the services of Insurance Auxiliary Service as the same fall in ambit of Rule 6(5) of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 in line with Tribunal’s decision in case of TATA AIG Life Insurance Company Ltd. reported in 2014-TIOL-487 = 2015 (37) S.T.R. 570 (Tribunal). We find that in terms of Rule 6(5) of CCR, 2004 the credit of tax paid on Insurance Auxiliary Service cannot be denied if the person availing such credit is engaged in both categories of services i.e. taxable as well as exempted. In the present case it is not disputed that the appellant is engaged in providing both categories of services and therefore there is no reason to demand Cenvat reversal in respect of credit of Insurance Auxiliary services. However, input services which are exclusively used for providing exempted service the Cenvat credit on such services is not admissible in terms of Rule 6(5) of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004.

24. We find that Hon’ble High Court of Telangana in the case of Tiara Advertising 2019 (30) G.S.T.L. 474 held similarly. The decision was followed by the principal Bench in the case of M/S Agrawal Metal Works Pvt Ltd 2022 (7) TMI 924 – CESTAT. Hon’ble Telangana High Court Held that

7. Rule 6 of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 deals with the obligations of a provider of taxable and exempted services. Rule 6(1) states that Cenvat Credit shall not be allowed on inputs/input services exclusively used for providing exempted services. Rule 6(2) provides that if inputs or input services are used for provision of output services which are chargeable to duty or tax as well as exempted services, then separate accounts are to be maintained for receipt, consumption and inventory of inputs and receipt and use of input services and the provider shall take credit only on inputs used for dutiable output services. Rule 6(3) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 is relevant for the purpose of this case and states to the effect that a provider of output services who opts not to maintain separate accounts, as required under Rule 6(2), should follow any one of the options provided under Clauses (i) to (iii) thereunder, as applicable to him. Clause (i) provides for the option of paying an amount equal to 5% of the value of the exempted services. Pursuant to Notification No. 18/2012, dated 17- 3-2012, the amount to be paid under Clause (i) was increased to 6% with effect from 1-4-2012.

8. It is an admitted fact that the petitioner did not maintain separate accounts of the inputs/input services utilized for providing certain taxable and exempted output services. It also did not choose to opt for one of the procedures stipulated in Rule 6(3) set out supra. The petitioner however availed and utilised Cenvat Credit on such inputs/input services which were common to both taxable and exempted output services and the same amounted to Rs. 17,15,489/-.

9. It may be noted that there is no controversy with regard to the entitlement of the petitioner to avail Cenvat Credit but for this disputed amount of Rs. 17,15,489/- out of the total extent of Rs. 1,41,51,903/-. While so, the second respondent issued show cause notice dated 19-4-2016 to the petitioner proposing to choose the option under the aforestated Rule 6(3)(i) on its behalf and calling upon it to explain as to why it should not be directed to pay an amount of 5%, upto 31-3-2012, and 6%, from 1-4-2012, of the value of the exempted services, aggregating to Rs. 3,52,65,241/-. In its reply dated 16-5- 2016, the petitioner contended that it was wholly unreasonable on the part of the authorities to expect it to pay over Rs. 3.50 Crore when the total Cenvat Credit availed by it was less than Rs. 1.50 Crore and the actual dispute boiled down to a mere Rs. 17,15,489/-. It relied on case law to support its contention that such an unreasonable result could not be allowed to follow by application of the law. The impugned Order-in-Original however reflects that the second respondent did not even advert to the case law cited before him

………………………

14. Further, we may reiterate that Rule 6(3) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004, merely offers options to an output service provider who does not maintain separate accounts in relation to receipt, consumption and inventory of inputs/input services used for provision of output services which are chargeable to duty/tax as well as exempted services. If such options are not exercised by the service provider, the provision does not contemplate that the Service Tax authorities can choose one of the options on behalf of the service provider. As rightly pointed out by Sri S. Ravi, Learned Senior Counsel, if the petitioner did not abide by the provisions of Rule 6(3) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004, it was open to the authorities to reject its claim as regards the disputed Cenvat Credit of Rs. 17,15,489/-.

15. We may also note that in the event the petitioner was found to have availed Cenvat Credit wrongly, Rule 14 of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 empowered the authorities to recover such credit which had been taken or utilised wrongly along with interest. However, the second respondent did not choose to exercise power under this Rule but relied upon Rule 6(3)(i) and made the choice of the option thereunder for the petitioner, viz., to pay 5%/6% of the value of the exempted services. The statutory scheme did not vest the second respondent with the power of making such a choice on behalf of the petitioner. The Order-in-Original, to the extent that it proceeded on these lines, therefore cannot be countenanced.

22. We find, on-going through the records of the case and rival contentions, that the appellants claim that they have maintained separate records; they have not availed credit on common inputs or services; Rule 6 is applicable only in the case where the Appellants had availed Cenvat credit on the inputs and input services pertaining to the exempted and dutiable goods/services; Rule 6(3) is not applicable to the present case; demand of duty at the rate of 5% or 6% was incorrect; they had made reversal of this availed Cenvat credit of the common inputs and/or services, used in the manufacture of both dutiable and the exempted excisable goods; reversal of Cenvat credit would mean non- availment of such credit in the ratio of the decision of the Supreme Court in Bombay Dyeing & Manufacturing Company, 2007 (8) SCC 177 and the decision of the Bombay High Court in Steelco Gujarat Limited, 2012 (285) ELT 161. These decisions enunciated the proposition that reversal, made prior to its utilization, would mean non-availment of such credit; Rule 6(3)(1) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 would come into play only when a manufacturer did not wish to comply with Rule 6(1) thereof by not making reversal of the availed Cenvat credit.

23. Ongoing through the averments of the appellants and the case law cited and paraphrased as above, we find, in the light of judicial pronouncements it is clear that

(i). Rule 6 lays down the obligations of the manufacturer of dutiable and exempted goods and provider of taxable, and exempted services; Rule 6 (1) and (2) Provide for different situations;

(ii). Rule (3) starts with a non estate clause; it begins with the words ‘notwithstanding’ and refers to Sub-Rules (1) and (2) of Rule 6 of CCR, 2004; once the conditions stipulated in Sub-Rule (3) are complied with, the provisions of Sub-Rule (1) and (2) will not be applicable; sub-Rule (3) clearly provides that if the provider of output service does not opt to maintain separate accounts, he should comply with the provision of Rule 6(3)(c) of the said Rules;

(iii). Reversal amounts to non availment of credit

(iv). It is not open for the revenue to thrust upon the assessee the choices available under Sub-Rule (3)

(v). It is not the intention of the legislature to demand huge amounts of credit disproportionate to the credit availed on exempted goods.

We find that the department has heavily relied upon the judgment of Mumbai High Court in the case of Nicholas Piramal (Supra). It can be seen that the judgments cited above are subsequent to this judgment and are of recent period. The decision of Principal Bench in the case of M/S Agrawal Metal Works Pvt Ltd ( supra), flowing the decision of Hon’ble High Court of Telangana in the case of Tiara Advertising (supra), being the latest. It appears that Courts and Tribunals were consistent in following the principles listed above. Therefore, we are of the considered opinion that these judgments are to be followed and we do so.

24. In addition to the above legal issue, we find, in the factual matrix of the case, that the appellants have submitted to the Audit party as well as the adjudicating authority that process involved in the manufacture of goods respectively i.e. coated cotton fabrics (deluxe) by M/s Responsive Industries and Hawser Fishing Net by M/s Axiom Cordages Ltd did not involve the raw material which is disputed to have been a common input by the Department. We find that the appellants have given a detailed submission on the process of manufacture of the impugned goods. We find that the learned adjudicating authority has not gone into the submissions and has simply brushed aside the arguments of the appellant saying that understandably, the raw material used is common. We find that the Department has not taken any steps to negate the claims of the respective appellants. No Panchnama indicating the process of manufacture has been drawn, in the least, leave alone obtaining any technical opinion to support or to contradict the submissions of the appellants. The only averment of the learned adjudicating authority appears to be that the input services are understandably, used in the manufacture of dutiable as well as exempted goods. However, we find that no basis for such understanding has been given with cogent reasons. We find that it is not open to the Department to brush aside the submissions of the appellants without a proper enquiry and reason. In the absence of a systematic study and negation of the appellant’s submissions, the findings of the learned adjudicating authority are not legally tenable.

25. Moreover, we find that the appellants have submitted Chartered Accountant’s certificates. The learned adjudicating authority held that the Chartered Accountant’s certificates are not acceptable without giving any reasons thereof. On the contrary, the claim of the appellants and the reversal thereof, as mentioned in the certificates, was taken to be ample proof that the appellants have availed cenvat credit of common inputs. It is not a case of the Department that the said Chartered Accountant has been examined. Learned Commissioner was within his rights to call the said Chartered Accountants and examine him to find out and establish the veracity or otherwise of the certificates issued by them. Interestingly, one more argument taken by the learned adjudicating authority is that the certificates given by the Manpower Recruitment Agency in respect of Axiom Cordages Ltd are verbatim to the end and do not disclose any details. In this context also, the learned adjudicating authority has not thought it fit to call upon the persons issuing certificates and to record the submission before proceeding to adjudicate the case. We find that in the absence of any enquiry, verification or examination of the persons concerned, the conclusion drawn by the learned adjudicating authority do not sustain the scrutiny of law. For the reasons discussed above, we find that impugned orders are not sustainable.

26. Moreover, the judgments cited above, held that reversal of credit availed on inputs and services used exclusively in the manufacture of exempted goods or provision of exempted services, would tantamount to not availing credit. Learned adjudicating authority has recorded the fact of reversal of proportionate credit by the appellants. However, in the case of M/s Axiom Cordages Ltd., he gave the finding that it is not clear from submissions of the appellant as to when such reversal was made and also as to whether the same was in accordance with the provisions of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004. It was held in the above cited judgments that it was not the intention of the legislature to burden the assessee with demand of duty disproportionate to the actual credit availed on the said common inputs used in the manufacture of exempted goods. In the instant case too, the appellants submitted that demands are disproportional to the credit availed. In the present case fact of reversal is not denied by the adjudicating authority. In view of the case laws cited and discussed above, we find that reversal of credit amounts to not availing credit and as the appellants reversed the credit demands do not survive.

27. We further find that the learned adjudicating authority mainly relies on the averments that the appellants did not disprove the allegation made in the show-cause notice. As discussed above, it is a matter of record that the appellants have given elaborate submissions in response to Audit reports and also during the adjudication proceedings, it is apparent that the learned adjudicating authority has not gone into the submissions in detail and has not negated the assertions made by the appellant in a reasoned manner. It is to be noted that it is the Department who are alleging certain non-observance, of procedures by the appellants and availment of CENVAT Credit in a proper manner, on the part of the appellants. Therefore, it was incumbent upon the Department to prove the same with cogent evidence, reasoned argument and on a legal basis. Having not discharged their onus, the Department cannot simply brush aside the submissions of the appellants. We find that on this count too the show-cause notices and the adjudication orders are not sustainable. Accordingly, we find that the demands raised therein are not sustainable and once the demands are held to be not sustainable, penalties imposed are also not sustainable. The same need to be set aside along with demand. We find that the appellants have reversed the credit attributable to the inputs or inputs services alleged to have been used in the manufacture of exempted goods. In view of the settled position of law, we find that reversal of CENVAT Credit amounts to non-availment of CENVAT Credit and therefore, demands would not sustain.

28. We find that in case of M/s Responsive Industries Ltd. (Appeal No. E/88822/2013), the Department not contested the method or quantum of reversal of CENVAT Credit and in respect of M/s Axiom Cordages Ltd. (Appeal No. E/85402/2015) have disputed the conclusion. We find that in the interest of justice, the matter needs go back to the adjudicating authority for the limited purpose of verifying the correctness of the reversal.

29. In the result –

(i) Appeal No. E/88822/2013 and E/85676/2015 filed by the M/s Responsive Industries Ltd are allowed.

(ii) Appeal No. E/85402/2015 filed by M/s Axiom Cordages Ltd. is partly allowed by way of remand to the adjudicating authority for a limited purpose of verifying the conclusion of reversal. In case the amount reversed by the appellant falls short of the requisite amount, the appellants shall pay the difference along with interest. We direct that the entire exercise should be completed within four weeks of the receipt of this order; the appellants are directed to co- operate with the authorities.

(Order pronounced in the open court on 12.08.2022)

Advertisement

Author Info

CA Sandeep Kanoi
Qualification: Graduate, CA in Job / Business, DD
Company: Taxguru Consultancy
Location: Mumbai, Maharashtra
Articles Published: 24,572

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.