Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Income Tax

Commercial Dairy Farm Not Second Residential House for Section 54F: ITAT Dehradun

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2026 taxguru.in 19169
Case Name
DCIT Vs Rajesh Jain (ITAT Dehradun)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Related Assessment Year
2017-18
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

DCIT Vs Rajesh Jain (ITAT Dehradun)

Section 54F Relief Cannot Be Denied by Counting a Property Used as a Dairy Farm as a Second Residential House: ITAT Dehradun

The Dehradun Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal held that a property let out and used as a commercial dairy farm could not be counted as a second residential house for denying Section 54F relief. The Tribunal also upheld the assessee’s claim under Section 54B for reinvestment in agricultural land and deleted the 20% ad hoc disallowance of land development expenditure. It remanded a separate addition relating to an alleged land sale for verification.

Facts of the Case

Rajesh Jain, an individual engaged in real estate and hotel businesses, declared income of ₹32,75,400 for AY 2017–18. He reported long-term capital gains of ₹3,58,94,559 from the sale of property at Mauza Adhoiwala for ₹3,95,94,465. The assessment involved claims under Section 54B for purchase of agricultural land and Section 54F for purchase of a residential flat.

The Assessing Officer (AO) restricted the Section 54B deduction to ₹13,32,874, citing the failure to deposit unutilised funds in the specified account and questioning the agricultural character of part of the replacement land. The AO denied Section 54F relief on the ground that the assessee owned two residential properties. After making a further addition relating to allegedly undisclosed property sales, the AO assessed total income at ₹4,52,47,965.

The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) [CIT(A)] granted relief under both sections but sustained a 20% disallowance of land development expenditure and directed verification of the disputed sales. Both parties appealed to the Tribunal.

Commercial Use of Dairy Premises Supported Section 54F Claim

The assessee owned a house in Vasant Vihar, New Delhi, and a property at Jakhan, Rajpur Road, Dehradun. The latter had been let to Narendra Gauseva Society for running a dairy farm. The Revenue argued that the premises were in a residential area and that the assessee had disclosed the rent under the head Income from House Property. It therefore sought to count the dairy premises as another residential house under Section 54F.

The CIT(A) examined photographs of the dairy farm, the tenant’s income-tax returns and audited financial statements evidencing rent payments. The AO did not offer comments on the Section 54F issue despite reminders during the remand proceedings. The Tribunal found that the Revenue had failed to rebut the finding that the premises were used commercially. On those facts, the actual use of the property supported its exclusion from the residential house count. The Tribunal accordingly upheld the Section 54F relief of ₹66,91,200.

Section 54B Relief Upheld Following Assessee’s Own Earlier Case

The Revenue argued that the assessee had failed to deposit unutilised funds in the Capital Gains Account Scheme by the return filing due date. It also challenged relief on the entire 73.24-acre parcel purchased in Tuticorin, relying on an inspection report indicating that roughly 27 acres were under cultivation. The assessee submitted that the report did not establish that the remaining land was unsuitable for agricultural use and argued that the purpose for which the land was purchased was relevant under Section 54B.

The Tribunal followed the coordinate bench decision in the assessee’s own case for AY 2016–17, in ITA No. 1/DDN/2026. In that year, relief had been upheld where the assessee substantially reinvested in agricultural land within two years despite the absence of a deposit under the scheme. The Revenue failed to distinguish the facts of the year under appeal. The Tribunal therefore upheld the CIT(A)’s decision allowing relief on the agricultural land purchases.

20% Ad Hoc Disallowance of Development Expenses Deleted

The Revenue questioned the cash payments and handwritten vouchers supporting the development expenditure. On examining the invoices, the Tribunal found that they contained addresses and mobile numbers. The authorities could have used those details to verify the service providers under Section 133(6).

Neither the AO nor the CIT(A) identified any specific expenditure unrelated to development of the land. The fact that the land had been developed after purchase was undisputed. The Tribunal therefore deleted the 20% disallowance and allowed the Section 54B claim in full.

Alleged ₹8.91 Lakh Land Sale Sent Back for Verification

The assessee denied selling land to Habib Ahmad for ₹8,91,000. The Tribunal observed that the AO had failed to verify the transaction with the land revenue authorities, including while giving effect to the CIT(A)’s order. It restored the issue to the AO and directed that the addition be dropped if verification showed that the assessee had made no such sale.

The Tribunal treated interest under Sections 234B and 234C as consequential and held that the challenge to initiation of penalty under Section 270A was premature. The Revenue’s appeal was dismissed, and the assessee’s appeal was partly allowed.

Cases Discussed

DCIT Vs Rajesh Jain — ITA No. 1/DDN/2026 (ITAT Dehradun, 2026)

Narayan Ravi Prakash Vs ITO — (2024) 167 taxmann.com 192 (Karnataka High Court)

ITO Vs Vinod Gugnani — (2022) 145 taxmann.com 314 (ITAT Delhi)

CIT Vs K. Ramachandra Rao — (2015) 56 taxmann.com 163 (Karnataka High Court)

Goetze (India) Ltd. Vs CIT — Supreme Court (2006)

FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF ITAT DEHRADUN

These cross appeals are filed by Assessee as well as Revenue against the order of Learned Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals), National Faceless Appeal Centre (NFAC) Delhi (‘the Ld. CIT(A)’ for short) dated 31.03.2026 for Assessment Year 2017-18.

2. Briefly stated the facts are that assessee is an individual and was engaged in the business of Real Estate and running Hotel. The return of income was filed on 30.03.2018 declaring total income at Rs. 32,75,400/-. The case was selected for complete scrutiny for the reasons that assessee had claimed, “Large deduction / exemption u/s 11(1A) of the Act”. The AO observed that assessee has claimed deduction u/s 54B & u/s 54F of the Act out of the long-term capital gains of Rs. 3,58,94,559/- arisen from the sale of property situated at Mauza Adhoiwala for a total consideration of Rs. 3,95,94,465/-. Besides this, the AO observed that the claim of the assessee u/s 54B is not correct as new agricultural land was purchased after the end of the Financial Year in the which the land was sold, and sale consideration was not deposited in the specified bank account. Besides this, the AO also doubted the nature of land purchased at Tuticorin, Tamil Nadu. Accordingly, he reduced the deduction u/s 54B claimed by the assessee to Rs.13,32,874/-. The AO further observed that the assessee has two residential house property and therefore, disallowed the deduction claimed u/s 54F also. The AO further observed that assessee has sold other properties and the capital gain was not disclosed and, accordingly, a sum of Rs.74,10,884/- being the sale consideration was added back to the total income of the assessee. Accordingly, the total income of the assessee was assessed at Rs. 4,52,47,965/-.

3. Against the said order, the assessee preferred an appeal before the Ld. CIT(A) who vide impugned order dated 31.03.2026 has partly allowed the appeal of the assessee wherein the deduction u/s 54B was allowed to the assessee as claimed by following the order of Ld. CIT(A) in immediately preceding year. However, has disallowed 20% of the land development expensed claimed of Rs. 2,34,42,444/- on ad-hoc basis. The Ld. CIT(A) has further allowed deduction u/s 54F of the Act.

However, the addition made as undisclosed capital gain of Rs.74,10,880/- was confirmed by observing that out of the total properties alleged as not included in the working of capital gain, six were already declared in the return of income and remaining was not disclosed, therefore, the Ld. CIT(A) has directed the AO to verify the claim of the assessee and to recompute the capital gain.

4. Aggrieved by the said order, both the Revenue and the assessee are in appeal before the Tribunal by taking following grounds of appeal:

ITA No.297/DDN/2026 (Revenue’s appeal)

“1 On facts and circumstances of the case and in law, whether the Ld. CIT (A) has erred in partly deleting the disallowance of deduction of Rs.3,45,61,685/- claimed under section 54B of the Income Tax Act. 1961 despite the assessee not complying with the statutory requirement as laid down under section 54B(2) of the Income Tax Act, 1961

2. On facts and circumstances of the case and in law, whether the Ld. CIT (A) is justified in ignoring the assessee’s statutory lapse of non-depositing the unutilized funds before due date of filing of return of income while allowing relief whereas allowing relief to him solely on the basis of decision of the learned CITIA) on this issue in the assessee’s case itself for the Assessment Year 2016- 17 wherein the learned CIT(A) in allowing deduction under section 54B of the I.T. Act. 1961 had placed reliance on the Hon’ble Karnataka High Court’s verdict in the case of CIT Vs. K. Ramchandra Rao |2015] 56 taxmmm.com 163 (Karnataka) which has not attained judicial finality.

3. On facts and circumstances of the case, whether the learned CIT(A) has caused perversity in allowing deduction under section 54B of the I.T. Act, 1961 on the entire land purchased by the assessee merely on the reasoning that it a part of the land was cultivable, the remaining land should also be treated as cultivable, ignoring the inquiry report as contained in the assessment order which stated that substantial portion of the land had not been put to agricultural use for past several years.

4. On facts and circumstances of the case, whether the Ld. CIT(A) has erred in allowing land development expenses as part of deduction under section 548 of the LT. Act. 1961 despite the inquiry report as well as the photographs of the relevant land parcel incorporated in the assessment order not indicating any such development activities as claimed by the assessed

5. On facts and circumstances of the case, whether the Ld. CT(A) is justified in allowing deduction under section 54F of I.T. Act 1961 be treating the property as commercial merely on the basis of photographs of the tenant’s dairy activities and its financials disclosing payment of rent to the assessee, without any enquiry regarding its legal and municipal character, ignoring that mere business usage by tenant does not alter the residential nature of the property

6. That, the appellant craves leave to add or amend any other more ground of appeal as stated above as and when needs for doing so may arise.”

ITA No.287/DDN/2026 (Assessee’s appeal)

“1. That on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the appellate order dated 31.03.2026 [‘the impugned order’] passed by the Hon’ble Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals)/National Faceless Appeal Centre [‘Hon’ble CIT(A)’] u/s 250 of the Act is bad in law, arbitrary, based upon conjectures, surmises, assuming incorrect facts and is liable to be quashed.

2. That on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the Hon’ble CIT(A) has erred in upholding the disallowance of Rs. 47,68,489, being 20% of the land development expenses inter alia because-

a. The disallowance made is purely ad hoc and arbitrary in nature, made merely on suspicion, without providing any cogent basis or reasonable justification

b. No material has been brought on record to doubt the genuineness or nexus of the expenditure

c. The disallowance is made basis facts and findings recorded in the assessment order, without giving any independent finding

d. Without appreciating the submissions and evidences in forms of bills and supporting documents as filed by the Appellant

3. That on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the Hon’ble CIT(A) has erred in not granting full relief against the addition of Rs. 74,10,880 made by the Ld. AO by treating certain sale considerations as undisclosed income, and in remanding the issue of the property sold to one Habib Ahmad (S. No. 46, consideration Rs. 8,91,000) back to the AO for verification.

a. The Hon’ble CIT(A) erred in remanding the matter for S. No. 46 to the Ld. AO, despite no evidence being produced by the Ld. AO and the Appellant consistently denying any such sale as non-traceable in its records either directly or through any PoA holder.

b. The addition of Rs. 8,91,000 ought to have been deleted as the Ld. AO failed to furnish any supporting evidence despite request from the Appellant, and the burden of proof lied on the AO.

c. In the absence of any documentary evidence of sale, the addition for S. No. 46 should be deleted rather than remanded, which unfairly prolongs proceedings, and causes continued harassment to the Appellant.

4. That on the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the action Hon’ble CIT(A) has erred in upholding the levy of interest u/s 234B and u/s 234C of the Act.

5. That on the facts and circumstance of the case and in law, the action of the Hon’ble CIT(A) in upholding the initiation of penalty proceedings u/s 270A of the Act is erroneous, unjustified and bad in law in as much as there has not been any under-reporting of income by the Appellant.

6. The above grounds are without prejudice to each other and the Appellant craves leave to add, to amend, to delete and/or to modify all or any of the fore going ground(s) of appeal.”

5. First, we taken up the Revenue’s appeal wherein the Revenue has challenged the action of the Ld. CIT(A) for allowing the deduction u/s 54B and u/s 54F of the Act to the assessee. In support of the Ld. Sr. DR vehemently supported the order of the AO and submits that in the return of income filed, assessee has claimed deduction u/s 54B and no deduction was claimed u/s 54F of the Act. He submits that as per the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Goetze (India) Ltd. vs. CIT (2006), AO has no power to entertain fresh claim as the assessee has made the claim of deduction u/s 54F of Rs. 66,91,220/- before the AO without filing revised return. He, therefore, requested that the same should not be allowed. On merits, ld. Sr. DR submits that assessee already has two residential properties, one was purchased in Vasant Vihar, New Delhi-57 in immediately preceding year for which deduction u/s 54F was claimed for AY 2016-17 and the other properties is situated at 14/3, Jakhan, Rajpur Road, Dehradun. The Ld. Sr. DR submits that the assessee had claimed that the property at Dehradun was in commercial use and was given on rent for running a dairy which is a commercial activity and thus the said property cannot be held as a residential house, however, the area where the dairy situated is purely a residential area and no commercial activities are allowed. He further submits that he has disclosed rental income as Income from house property and, therefore, the no deduction should be allowed u/s 54F for another property out of LTCG declared during the year.

6. Regarding the deduction u/s 54B of the Act, Ld. Sr. DR submits that assessee has not complied with the contentions laid down of deposit the sale consideration in the specified bank account before the due date of filing of return of income and, therefore, the deduction u/s 54B could not be allowed. Another argument placed by the Sr. DR that assessee purchased at Tuticorin, Tamil Nadu which is not an agricultural land for which all the details were brought on record by the AO, and therefore, he submits that the said property cannot be held as agricultural land. Regarding the land development expanses claimed, ld. Sr. DR submits that such expenses were mostly incurred in cash exceeding the limit allowable under the Act. Most of the expenses are against the handmade vouchers and no details of nature of expenses were given, therefore, the AO has rightly disallowed the same. He thus, requested that the deduction restricted by the AO u/s 54B and denial of deduction u/s 54F be sustained.

7. On the other hand, the Ld. AR for the assessee, at the outset submits that the deduction u/s 54B on the land was allowed in preceding assessment year by the Ld. CIT(A) which order was confirmed by the Co-ordinate Bench of the Tribunal in ITA 01/DDN/2026 vide its order dated 05.05.2026. He further submits that the facts of the preceding year are identical where the lands purchases was situated in the same area and Revenue has failed to distinguish the facts as existed in the preceding assessment year from the fact of the assessment year before us. He, therefore, requested for the confirmation of the order of Ld. CIT(A) in allowing the deduction u/s 54B of the Act.

8. In grounds of appeal No 2, assessee has challenged the action of Ld. CIT(A) in not allowing the deduction u/s 54B of the Act for Rs.47,68,489/- being 20% of the land development expenses. For this Ld. AR submits that the Ld. CIT(A) has disallowed 20% out of total land development expenses incurred on ad-hoc basis without bringing any contrary evidence on record that the expenses so incurred were not for the development of the subject land. He therefore, prayed that the deduction u/s 54B allowed as the claimed u/s 54F of the Act. The Ld. AR further made written submission which is reproduced as under:

“2. Submissions qua Revenue’s ground no.1 and 2

2.1. Vide Ground no. 1 and 2 of its appeal, the Revenue has raised an objection that deduction u/s 548 should have been denied to the Assessee as the amount of sale consideration was not invested in Capital Gains Account Scheme before the due date for filing of ITR.

2.2 At the outset, it is respectfully submitted that the said issue relating to the Capital Gains Account Scheme is now covered in Assessee’s favour by the Hon’ble ITAT, Dehradun Bench’s decision dated 15.5.2026 (ITA no. 1/DDN/2026) in Assessee’s own case for AY 2016-17. In Assessment Year 2016-17 also, the Revenue had challenged the Assessee’s claim under section 54B on the specific ground that the unutilised amount of sale consideration had not been deposited in the Capital Gains Account Scheme within the prescribed time. The Tribunal specifically recorded that the Assessee had not deposited the amount in the Capital Gains Account Scheme but had instead utilised the substantial amount for purchase of agricultural land within two years and accordingly held that there was no infirmity in Ld. CIT(AY’s order for the said year and dismissed Revenue’s appeal.

The Assessee humbly submits that he had sold agricultural land over a period of three years and had correspondingly invested in agricultural land, inter alia, in Uttarakhand and Southern India and claimed deduction under section 54B in respect of such investments in each of these years. On the issue, the position over the preceding and the following assessment years is as under:

The Assessee humbly pleads that Revenue has not demonstrated any distinguishing features in the facts of the impugned year which would justify departure from the Tribunal decision in the Assessee’s own case for AY 2016-17. Also, it is pertinent to point out as stated above, that the Department itself has accepted the Assessee’s explanation regarding investement of sale proceeds of agricultural land towards purchase and development of new agricultural land in scrutiny proceedings for AY 2018-19 and therefore Rule of Consistency also supports Assessee’s contention,

In view of the above submissions, it is humbly pleaded that Revenue’s appeal on the issue of section 54B deduction deserves to be dismissed at the very threshold.

2.3. Without prejudice, on the merits of the case, the Assessee relies on its synopsis filed before the Hon’ble ITAT on the same issue in Department’s appeal for AY 2016-17, which for the sake of brevity are not being reproduced here. The Assessee had averred that when it is settled law that where substantive compliance has been made, deduction should not be denied for reasons of procedural lapses. A copy of the said synopsis dated 6.4.26 is placed at pages 859-860/PB-II.

2.4. The Assessee humbly pleads that even on merits, Ground no. 1 of the Department’s appeal deserves to be dismissed having regard to:

a) The Hon’ble Delhi Tribunal in ITO v Vinod Gugnani (2022) 145 Taxmann.com 314 wherein it has been held that a delay or procedural lapses in CGAS compliance does not defeat exemption, once the investment is made within the prescribed period.

b) The Hon’ble Karnataka High Court in CIT v K Ramachandra Rao 230 Taxmann.334

c) Since affirmed by the Hon’ble Karnataka High Court in Narayan Ravi Prakash v ITO (2024) 167 Taxmann.com 192

The Assessee humbly pleads that it is not in dispute that the statutory investment was ultimately made, but the contention of the Revenue is that the amount was not parked in CGAS within the prescribed time. This very objection has been considered and rejected by the Hon’ble ITAT in Assessee’s own case for AY 2016-17. In the absence of any material distinction in facts, the Hon’ble ITAT’s decision cited above deserves to be followed and the Revenue’s ground no. 1 and 2 deserve to be dismissed.

3. Submissions qua Revenue’s ground no. 3.

3.1. Vide Ground no. 3 the Revenue has challenged the relief granted by the Hon’ble CIT(A) in respect of allowance of the section 54B claim on entire 73.24 acres of land purchased by the Assessee. The Revenue has sought to sustain the restriction to approximately 27 acres on the sole reasoning that “substantial part of the land had not been put to agricultural use of past several years.” In the Assessment order, the Ld. AO had alleged that the Appellant purchased a land on which no agricultural activity was going on. Thereafter the Ld. AO called for a report from ITO Ward 3, 19A West Cotton Green Road, Tuticorin to ascertain “whether it was agricultural land…. Or residential land?” (Pls. refer top para of pg. 6 of assessment order).

On Ld. AO’s request, the land was duly physically inspected by the ADIT (Investigation), Tirunelveli who deputed the ITI to physically visit the site. The ITI inspected the site and got actual photographs of the site taken which form part of the assessment order. Based on the selective reading of the ADIT(Inv.)VITI’s report, the Ld. AO then goes on to aver “that most of the land is lying barren for the past fifteen years and only small part is used for agricultural purposes and that too for only three months in a year. Going by the above despite all the technical irregularities committed by the assessee the deduction u/s 54B is allowed to the extent of part of the land which was purchased before filing of return and payment made upto 5.8.2016 (i.e. due date for fling return u/s 139(1)) As the payment of land of 73.24 acres at Tuticorin was made on the due date le 5.8.2016 the same was allowed up to the extent of area of land used for agricultural purposes which is 27 acres as per the report.

The Ld. AO had fairly conceded on the basis of inspection report that the land in question was agricultural land and was being used for agricultural purposes and not residential land as was initially suspected by him. And yet the Ld. AO has come to a conclusion that only a part of the agricultural land i.e. 27 out of 73 acres was to be considered eligible for deduction u/s 548.

3.2. The Appellant humbly submits that Section 54B(1) allows deduction in case “the assessee has, within a period of two years after that date, purchased any other land for being used for agricultural purposes. The mandate of section 54B is for prospective use of the new asset for agricultural purposes and it does not say that the purchased land ought to have been used for agricultural purposes in the past. However, in the present case, the Ld. AO has substituted a test of existing physical cultivation for the statutory test of whether the land was purchased for being used for agricultural purposes.

3.3. The Assessing Officer relied upon the report of the ADIT(Inv.)/ITI in restricting the eligible area. The report is self-contradictory in as much as at opening para (reproduced at page 6 of the assessment order), it reproduces the version of the ITI wherein he observes that the entire area is under cultivation of rain fed crops including Maize, Black gram, Jowar etc. and then goes on to state that subsequently he inquired from the Village Administrative Officer (VAO) and it is according to VAO’s version only part of survey numbers are under cultivation of maize and the rest are under forest trees. If further records limitations regarding physical access to the property and the conditions prevailing at the relevant time. The Assessee’s submissions before the Ld. CIT(A) had specifically pointed out that the report had not resulted from a proper measurement/ demarcation of the entire 73.24 acres and that the figure of approximately 27 acres was based upon information stated to have been furnished by the VAO. In such circumstances, the Revenue has at best established the cultivation over approximately 27 acres. It has not established the converse proposition that the remaining 46.24 acres constituted non-agricultural land or that such remaining land was not purchased for agricultural use. Rather there is a definite finding that even the remaining land had standing forest trees thereon.

The Assessee pleads that the statutory test is the purpose for which the land was purchased, not merely the quantum of crop standing on the land on the date of an inspection. The fact remains that the Assessee purchased one identified agricultural parcel/holding on which he has performed agricultural activity. The investigation report itself does not establish through demarcation that the remaining acreage was incapable of agricultural use. It would be against the mandate of law to restrict the claim for exemption to an and incorrect estimation of proportion of land actually used for agricultural purposes.

3.4. The finding of the Ld. AO that approximately 27 acres were under agricultural use is without basis and based on conjectures. Be that as it may, even if for argument’s sake it is accepted though not admitted that only 27 acres were only being cultivated by the Assessee and the rest was only forest trees, it is nevertheless significant because it demonstrates that that land was not found to be inherently non-agricultural. The Revenue’s own inspection therefore does not establish that remaining land was non-agricultural or that it was acquired for any purpose other than agricultural use.

3.5 The Ld. CIT(A) has rightly held that when the consideration for entire land parcel of 73.24 acres was paid by 5.8.2017 (incorrectly mentioned as 05.08.2016 in the assessment order, and the same error crept into the CIT(A) order as well) and where some part of the land is cultivatable, logically the remaining part of land is also cultivatable and therefore after considering totality of the evidence has held that deduction u/s 54B should be allowed on consideration paid for entire 73.24 acres.

In light of the aforesaid, Ground no. 3 of the Revenue’s appeal deserves to be dismissed.

4. Submissions qua Revenue’s ground no. 4.

4.1. Vide Ground No. 4 of its appeal, the Revenue’s appeal challenges the action of the Id. CIT(A) in allowing the Assessee’s claim under section 54B of the Act in respect of land development expenditure on the ground that the inquiry report as well as the photographs of the land parcel incorporated in assessment order does not indicate development activity.

4.2. At the outset, the Appellant wishes to submit that he incurred land development cost of Rs. 2,38,42,444 in respect of agricultural land purchased by him before filing of ITR for AY 2017-18 on 30.3.2018. The details of total investment made towards purchase of new agricultural land along with copy of bills substantiating the land development cost incurred by the Appellant were filed with the Ld. AO vide our submissions dated 03.12.2019, which are placed herewith at pages 371-481/PB-L. These also contain the details of expenses incurred by the Appellant towards development of land.

4.3 The Assessee had submitted before the Ld. AO that he had entered into oral agreements for purchase of new agricultural land basis the terms that first the land development will be done to make it fit for agricultural use and only then the transfer deeds shall be executed. The land development expenses are a part and parcel of the total amount invested by the Appellant towards purchase of new agricultural land since incurring the said expenses was a part of the contract entered into by the Appellant with the sellers of the new agricultural land as the

land was to be purchased by the Appellant only after the same was made fit for agricultural use. It was also humbly submitted that the land development expenses cannot be given a separate recognition other than being a part of cost of acquisition of new agricultural land. Accordingly, the total amount of land development expenses as was incurred by the Appellant before filing his ITR are a part of cost of new agricultural land and hence, eligible for exemption u/s 54B of the Act.

4.4. It is reiterated that the investments made towards development of land to be purchased by the Appellant were a part of oral agreement entered into by the Appellant with villagers as the land was required to be made fit for agricultural use. For the aforesaid purpose, the Appellant has expended on land development which, as a part of oral agreement, was to be treated advance paid for the purchase of land, and hence, was a part of the cost price of the land.

4.5. It is humbly submitted that the Ground raised by the Revenue is against the facts of the case. In fact, the report of the ITI/ADIT extract reproduced at page 6 of the assessment order dated 23.12.2019 at page no. 45-68/PB-1 fairly states that the land belonging to Shri Rajesh Jain is demarcated by placing 8 ft concrete posts in a distance of some 4-5ft apart without wire fencing in the eat and north directions only le, upto the land under cultivation of Maize crop (Approximately 27 Acres- survey numbers already cited above).

Thus, the inspection report itself records physical demarcation of the Assessee’s land by pillars of approximately eight feet in height placed at intervals of about four to t four to five feet. Even though in the said report, it is fairly stated that 27 acres of the land had been demarcated on two sides, the IT/ADIT expressed inability to survey entire land holding due to adverse climate conditions prevailing at that time.

4.6 Details of land development expenditure had been duly furnished by the Assessee before the Ld. AO and also before the Hon’ble CIT(A). The Ld. AO has not demonstrated, by reference to any particular bill, payment, vendor or item of expenditure, that the expenditure was fictitious or unrelated to the agricultural land purchased.

More importantly, the Hon’ble CIT(A), after considering the material on record, expressly recorded that there was no dispute that the Assessee had incurred expenditure for development of agricultural land and held that the claim could not be denied completely.

4.7. Nextly, it is is pertinent to note that the Assessee has sold his agricultural land situated in Dehradun over a period of 3 years, Le., FYs 2015-16, FY 2016-17 (relevant to the impugned AY) and FY 2017-18. He has also purchased certain properties, inter alia, agricultural land over the course of these 3 years. The investment in land was made by the Assessee in agricultural lands situated in

Southern part of India on materially identical terms. On that basis he has claimed deduction u/s 548 over the course of these three years. That neither in preceding assessment year Le. AY 2016-17 nor in subsequent assessment year has the Ld. AO made any such disallowance on account of development expenditure. In fact, after due inquiry from the Assessee during AY 2018-19 the Ld. AO allowed development expense himself. Relevant extract is at written submissions dated 5.6.2025 filed before the Hon’ble CIT(A)

4.8. Further, the Assessee relies on the following judicial pronouncements:

-S Rajarajan v CIT, Chennai (Mad.) 275 Taxman 196 wherein it has been held that where the Assessee received 3 acres of land under a settlement deed out of total land of 11.53 acres belonging to various family members from his grandmother, ‘SA’-However entire land was earlier mortgaged by various joint owners of property including ‘SA’ with Bank and upon default in payment matter went to DRT and subsequently settled land in an OTS before DRT and land was sold Assessee claimed deduction of proportionate part of OTS amount paid to bank as cost of acquisition under section 55 Assessing Officer as well as Tribunal rejected claim of deduction-Whether encumbrance by way of mortgage whether by way of direct mortgage or as collateral security, had to be cleared off by legal heir or person in whose favour property had been settled like assessee and thus, amount paid by assessee to clear that encumbrance had to be treated as part of cost of acquisition or cost of improvement under section 48/49-Held, yes [Paras 14 and 17] [In favour of assessee]

In Rashmi Mahendra Dhanani TS 630 ITAT 2020 (Mum) the Hon’ble ITAT has held that Revenue should have allowed assessee’s claim of amenities charges as part of cost of acquisition of the asset; Finds that assessee had paid amenity charges which was reflected in the assessee’s balance sheet, Holds that veracity of assessee’s claim regarding payment of amenity charges was established by the amenities agreement between the assessee and the builder that was accepted by Revenue; ITAT, earlier, had held that if amenities works were actually been undertaken by the builder as per amenities agreement, the same would certainly need to be included in the cost of acquisition; Merely because the amenities agreement is not registered does not deprive the assessee the benefit of the amount paid when she has actually paid such amount;

-In Aditya Kumar Jajodia TS-446-HC-2018 (Cal.) In this case Hon’ble Calcutta HC rules that the cost of getting rid of the encumbrances in any immovable property has to be accepted as a part of the cost of acquisition of the property, subject, however, to the assessment as to the genuineness and validity of such encumbrances’, Notes that the encumbrances to the property in this case were created by the Will and the conduct of the assessee’s predecessor-in-interest, these encumbrances were got rid of by the assessee by payment and better title to the property was acquired by the assessee and transferred to the assessee’s transferee;

Relies on SC ruling in R.M. Arunachalam to hold that the discharge of a mortgage debt created by the predecessor-in-interest of the assessee had to be regarded as a part of the cost of acquisition; Further rules that the perfection of the title from perpetual leasehold rights to complete ownership had to be regarded as a cost of acquisition within the meaning under Sections 48 and 55 of the Act.

-In Ravi Kumar Tirupati Parthasarathy [TS-862-ITAT-2022(Bang)] Hon’ble ITAT directs revenue to consider cost of acquisition basis ‘unregistered assignment agreement and re-compute the capital gains, after verifying the bills and documents with regard to cost incurred towards brokerage, interiors and other costs of improvement, Opines that “merely for the reason that the assignment agreement is not registered, the actual outflow from the hands of the assessee towards acquisition of the property cannot be ignored for computing the capital gains”;

In light of the afore mentioned facts, the Assessee submits that land development expenditure deserves to be allowed in totality and that Revenue’s ground no. 4 deserves to be dismissed.

5. Submissions qua Revenue’s ground no. 5.

5.1. Vide Ground no. 5 the Revenue has challenged the deduction claimed by the Assessee under section 54F of the Act.

5.2. The Assessee had purchased a residential flat for Rs. 66,91,200 and claimed deduction u/s 54F. The Assessee also owned a commercial property at 14/3, Jakhan, Rajpur Road, Dehradun which had been let out for being used as a diary farm to Narendra Gauseva Society. Detailed written submissions made before the Ld. AO were made vide reply dated 13.12.2019 which are at pages 482 to 500/PB-4.

However, the Ld. AO in complete disregard of the said submission, wrongly treated the Dehradun property as second residential house property and also stated that the Assessee had himself shown rental income from the commercial property as income from house property. For these reasonings he denied the deduction u/s 54F.

5.3. Before the Ld. CIT(A) the Assessee furnished detailed written submissions at para 2.26 to 2.34 of submissions dated 27.6.2024 (copy placed at pages 560-599/PB-II) including photographs of the diary farm. Further, to substantiate the fact that the said property had been let out and was being as a Gaushala, the Assessee vide his submissions dated 30.12.2025 (copy placed at pages 689-693/PB-II) filed before the Ld. CIT(A) filed copies of ITR and audited financial statements of Narendra Gauseva Society for AYs 2016-17 and 2017-18 as additional evidences under Rule 46A.

At para 6.4.4 of the Appellate order it is stated that a remand report was called from the Ld. AO however despite several reminders there has been no reply from the Ld. AO regarding applicability of section 54F. The Revenue cannot now contend that the Ld. CIT(A) ought to have rejected the Assessee’s claim when the Assessing Officer himself failed to furnish the requested response during the remand proceedings.

5.4. The Assessee further submits that it is the actual use of the property that is material and not the head of income under which the rental income is disclosed. In the present case, the actual use is supported by contemporaneous evidence. The property was being used for dairy activity by the tenant. The fact that rental income was assessed under the head “Income from House Property” is therefore not determinative of whether the property was a “residential house” for the specific purpose of section 54F.

Relying on the judicial precedents cited and the factual matrix before him the Ld. CIT(A) has rightly held that the Assessee is entitled to deduction u/s 54F and therefore it is humbly pleaded that Revenue’s Ground no 5 deserves to be deleted.

6. Submissions qua Assessee’s Appeal Qua Ground no. 2.

6.1. Vide the said ground the Assessee has challenged the adhoc disallowance of 20% of land development expenditure made by the Hon’ble CIT(A).

6.2. The Assessee respectfully submits that the said disallowance is wholly unsustainable both on facts and in law and deserves to be deleted in full.

6.3. The Hon’ble CIT(A), after considering the material available on record, recorded his observation that there was no dispute regarding the fact that the Assessee had incurred expenditure towards development of agricultural land. Having recorded the aforesaid finding, the Hon’ble CIT(A) nevertheless proceeded to disallow 20% of the expenditure by observing that there was a possibility that the genuineness and relevance of the land development expenses might not be fully correct and that 20% was being disallowed in order to meet ends of justice.

6.4. It is respectfully submitted that an assessment of taxable income cannot be founded upon a mere possibility or apprehension. If the Hon’ble CIT(A) considered any particular item of expenditure to be non-genuine, excessive or unrelated to the agricultural land, the proper course was to identify such expenditure and record a specific finding supported by material. No such item-wise finding has been recorded.

6.5. There is no finding in the appellate order identifying (a) any particular bill as bogus; (b) any particular payment as not having been made; (c) any particular payee as non-existent or unrelated; (d) any particular item of expenditure as unrelated to the agricultural land purchased; or (e) any specific amount which, on the basis of evidence, could legitimately be regarded as non-genuine.

In the absence of such a finding, the adoption of an across-the-board percentage of 20% as a blanked disallowance is purely ad hoc and arbitrary.

6.6. It is respectfully submitted that the learned CIT(A) has, in effect, accepted the expenditure but simultaneously made an estimate against the assessee without identifying the factual basis for such estimate. The two findings are mutually inconsistent: if the expenditure has been accepted as having actually been incurred, a further disallowance requires a specific finding as to why a particular part thereof is not allowable.

The assessee therefore respectfully submits that the entire disallowance of deserves to be deleted

9. Heard both the parties and perused the material available on record. At this outset, it is observed that identical issue of deduction u/s 54B of the Act was decided by the Co-ordinate Bench of Tribunal in assessee’s own case vide its order dated 15.05.2026 wherein deduction u/s 54B of the Act was allowed to the assessee. The relevant observations of Co-ordinate Bench are as under.

“6. We have heard both the parties and perused the material available on record. The solitary issue to be considered in the present Appeal is the deletion of the disallowance of deduction of Rs.2,78,84,118/- claimed under Section 54B of the Act. The Ld. A.O. while made the disallowance on the ground that the Assessee has not deposited the amounts in Capital Gain Account Scheme and held that the same is violation of Section 54B (1) of the Act. Admittedly the Assessee has purchased new agriculture land from the sale proceeds of another agriculture land. The said fact has not been disputed by the A.O. however, the Assessee has not deposited the amount in the capital gain account, but spent the substantial amount to purchases the new agriculture lands within the period of two years from the date of original transfer of land. The Ld. CIT(A) deleted the addition by relying on the Judgment of Hon’ble High Court in the case of CIT(A) vs. Ramchandra Rao (2015) 56 Taxmann.com163(Karnataka).

7. The Revenue has not disputed the fact that the Assessee has spent the amount within the period of two years on purchase of agriculture lands. The total accumulative sale consideration received by the Assessee in the sale of agriculture land was Rs. 2,92,01,133/- and spent total sum of Rs. 2,89,94,871/ which is within the span of two years. However, the amount has not been deposited in capital gain account. The Hon’ble High Court of Karnataka in the case of K. Ramchandra Rao (supra), held that Assessee having invested entire sale consideration in construction of a residential house within three years from date of transfer, he could not be denied exemption under Section 54F on ground that he did not deposit said amount in capital gains account scheme before due date prescribed under Section 139(1) of the Act and decided the issue in favour of the Assessee in following manners:-

“3. The two substantial questions of law which arise for consideration in these batch of appeals are as under:-

1) Whether the assessee is entitled to the benefit conferred under Section 54F when the sale consideration is utilized for construction of a residential house on a site which is owned by him within one year from the date of transfer?

2) When the assessee invests the entire sale consideration in construction of a residential house within three years from the date of transfer can he be denied exemption under Section 54F on the ground that he did not deposit the said amount in capital gains account scheme before the due date prescribed under Section 139(1) of the IT Act?

3. Re. Point No.1 Section 54(F) deals with capital gains on transfer of certain capital assets not to be charged in case of investment on house. It reads as under.

54F. (1) [Subject to the provisions of sub-section (4), where, in the case of an assessee being an individual or a Hindu undivided family), the capital gain arises from the transfer of any long-term capital asset, not being a residential house (hereafter in this section referred to as the original asset), and the assessee has, within a period of one year before or two years) after the date on which the transfer took place purchased, or has within a period of three years after that date constructed, a residential house (hereafter in this section referred to as the new asset), the capital gain shall be dealt with in accordance with the following provisions of this section, that is to say,-

(a) if the cost of the new asset is not less than the net consideration in respect of the original asset, the whole of such capital gain shall not be charged under section 45;

(b) if the cost of the new asset is less than the net consideration in respect of the original asset, so much of the capital gain as bears to the whole of the capital gain the same proportion as the cost of the new asset bears to the net consideration, shall not be charged under section 45: Provided that nothing contained in this sub- section shall apply where-

(a) the assessee,–

(i) owns more than one residential house, other than the new asset, on the date of transfer of the original asset; or purchases any residential house, other than the new asset, within a period of one year after the date of transfer of the original asset; or constructs any residential house, other than the new asset, within a period of three years after the date of transfer of the original asset; and

(b) the income from such residential house, other than the one residential house owned on the date of transfer of the original asset, is chargeable under the head “Income from house property”.) Explanation.-For the purposes of this section, [***] [***]” net consideration”, in relation to the transfer of a capital asset, means the full value of the consideration received or accruingas a result of the transfer of the capital asset as reduced by any expenditure incurred wholly and exclusively in connection with such transfer.

(2) Where the assessee purchases, within the period of (two years) after the date of the transfer of the original asset, or constructs, within the period of three years after such date, any residential house, the income from which is chargeable under the head “Income from house property”, other than the new asset, the amount of capital gain arising from the transfer of the original asset not charged under section 45 on the basis of the cost of such new asset as provided in clause (a), or, as the case may be, clause (b), of subsection (1), shall be deemed to be income chargeable under the head “Capital gains” relating to long-term capital assets of the previous year in which such residential house is purchased or constructed.

(3) Where the new asset is transferred within a period of three years from the date of its purchase or, as the case may be, its construction, the amount of capital gain arising from the transfer of the original asset not charged under section 45 on the basis of the cost of such new asset as provided in clause (a) or, as the case may be, clause (b), of sub-section (1) shall be deemed to be income chargeable under the head “Capital gains” relating to long-term capital assets of the previous year in which such new asset is transferred.]

[(4)] The amount of the net consideration which is not appropriated by the assessee towards the purchased of the new asset made within one year before the date on which the transfer of the original asset took place, or which is not utilised by him for the purchase or construction under section 139, shall be deposited by him before furnishing such return /such deposit being made in any case not later than the due of the new asset before the date of furnishing the return of income date applicable in the case of the assessee for furnishing the return of income under sub- section (1) of section 139 in an account in any such bank or institution as may be specified in, and utilized in accordance in the Official Gazette, frame in this behalf and such return shall be with any scheme which the Central Government may, bu notification accompanied by proof of such deposit; and, for the purposes of sub- section (1), the amount, if any, already utilised by the assessee for the purchase or construction of the new asset together with the amount so deposited shall be deemed to be the cost of the new asset:

Provided that if the amount deposited under this sub-section is not utilised wholly or partly for the purchase or construction of the new asset within the period specified in sub- section (1), then, 7 ITA No. 607/Del/2020 ITO Vs. Vinod Gugnani.

(i) the amount by which- (a) the amount of capital gain arising from the transfer of the original asset not charged under section 45 on the basis of the cost of the new asset as provided in clause (a) or, as the case may be, clause (b) of sub-section (1), exceeds (b)the amount that would not have been so charged had the amount actually utilised by the assessee for the purchase or construction of the new asset within the period specified in sub-section (1) been the cost of the new asset, shall be charged under section 45 as income of the previous year in which the period of three years from the date of the transfer of the original asset expires; and (ii) the assessee shall be entitled to withdraw the unutilised amount in accordance with the scheme aforesaid.

Section 54F(1) provides, in the case of an assessee being an individual or a Hindu undivided family, the capital gain arises from the transfer of any long term capital asset, not being a residential house and the assessee within a period of one year before or two years after the date on which the transfer took place, purchased or has within a period of three years after that date constructed a residential house, the capital gain shall be dealt with in accordance with the said provision. This is subject to the provisions of Sub Section (4)

Sub Section (4) stipulates if the amount of net consideration which is not appropriated by the assessee towards the purchase of the new asset made within one year before the date on which transfer of the original asset took place or which is not utilized by him for the purchase or construction of the new asset before the date of furnishing the return of income under Section 139 of the Act shall be deposited by him before furnishing such return in any case not later than the due date applicable in the case of the assessee for furnishing the return of income under Section 139(1) of the Act in an account in any such bank or institution as specified and utilized in accordance with any scheme which the Central Government may, by notification in the official gazette framed in this behalf. Sub Section (4) is attracted only to a case where the sale consideration is not utilized either for purchase or for construction of a residential house. It has no application to a case where the assessee invests the sale consideration derived from the transfer either in purchasing the property or constructing theresidential house within the period stipulated in Section 54F(1). The proviso to Section 54F puts an embargo on the application of Section 54F to cases which are mentioned in the said proviso. That is to be eligible for the benefit under Section 54F(1) the assessee should not be owning more than one residential house other than the new asset acquired or he should not purchase any residential house other than the new asset within a period of one year after the date of transfer of residential asset or constructs any residential house other than the new asset within a period of three years after the date of transfer of the residential asset. In the entire scheme there is no prohibition for the assessee putting up construction out of sale construction received by such transfer of a site which is owned by him as is clear from the language used. It is open for the assessee to put up a residential construction or to purchase a residential house. It is not the requirement of law that he should purchase a residential site and then put-up construction. Therefore, in the instant case admittedly the assessee has purchased a vacant site on 31.3.2001. He sold the original asset on 27.8.2003 on which date he was already owning a site. In fact even before sale of the original asset he had started construction on such site by availing loan from the Bank. In terms of Section 54F(1) all investments made in the construction of the residential house of the said site within a period of one year prior to 27.8.2003 would be eligible for exemption under Section 54F(1). Similarly all investments in the said construction after 27.8.2003 within a period of three years there from is also eligible for such investment in a residential construction cannot be made on a site owned by him to be eligible for exemption is without any substance. Both the Appellate Authorities have rightly extended the benefit to the assessee and there is no error committed by them which calls for interference,”

8. Considering the fact that the Ld. CIT(A) after apprehension of the above facts and circumstances and by relying on the Judgment of the Karnataka High Court in the case of Ramchandra Rao (supra), deleted the addition. In the absence of any contrary judicial precedent and also in the absence of any contrary material brought on record by the Revenue to controvert the finding and the conclusion of the Ld. CIT(A), no error or infirmity in the order of the Ld. CIT(A) in deleting the disallowance made by the A.O. Thus, we dismiss the Grounds of Appeal we find of the Revenue which is devoid of merit. Accordingly, Appeal of the Revenue is dismissed.”

10. Before us, the Revenue has failed to controvert the findings given by the Co- ordinate Bench in preceding assessment year in assessee’s own case. It is also a matter fact that the Ld. CIT(A) while allowing the deduction u/s 54B of the Act has followed the order of Ld. CIT(A) in preceding assessment year which was upheld by the Co-ordinate Bench of the Tribunal. Under these circumstances and further considering that the facts are identical, we find no reason to deviate from the decision taken by the coordinate bench in preceding assessment year in assessee’s own case accordingly, we uphold the order of Ld. CIT(A) in allowing the deduction u/s 54B of the Act towards the purchase of agricultural land out of the Long-term capital gains declared by the assessee.

11. Now coming to the issue of adhoc disallowance @ 20% confirmed out of land development expenses by the Ld. CIT(A), it is observed that neither the AO nor the CIT(A) has pointed out any specific instance of any expenses being incurred not for the purpose of land development. The Ld. Sr. DR in its submissions has referred certain bills and vouchers which were handmade or do not contain complete address and it was alleged that most of the expenses were incurred in cash and identity of the service provider was doubtful. From the perusal of the said invoices, it is observed that the same contained the complete addresses and mobile number of the person and if the AO had any doubts with respect to the identity of any of the service provider, he could have made necessary verification directly by issuing summons u/s 133(6) of the Act which has not been done by the AO nor by ld. CIT(A). Merely on assumptions and presumptions disallowance was made out of the genuine expenses claimed by the assessee. It is also a matter of fact that the lower authorities had not doubted the fact that assessee has developed the land after purchases. Considering the entirety of the facts, we find no reason to make any ad-hoc disallowance out of land development expenses genuinely incurred by the assessee. Accordingly, the disallowance confirmed by the Ld. CIT(A) is hereby deleted and allowed the deduction u/s 54B as claimed by the assessee. The grounds of appeal No.1 to 4 of the Revenue are dismissed and grounds of appeal No.2 of assessee is allowed.

12. Coming to grounds of appeal No.5 of the Revenue with respect to the deduction u/s 54F, the Ld. CIT(A) has discussed this issue at length and made following observations while allowing the appeal of the assessee.

“6.4.4. With respect to the property located in Dahradun let out to Narendra Gauseva Society, remand report has been called from the AO to furnish his comments on the applicability of 54F. Several remainders have been issued to the AO in this regard and even last reminder was also issued however, there has been no reply from the A regarding applicability of 54F, although assessee had submitted detailed reply to AO on 10.03.2026, which he has submitted to undersigned also, during appellate proceedings. Hence, the issue is adjudicated based on the information available on record. To substantiate his claim that the property is a commercial property, the appellant has furnished the following documents

(i) Photographs of the dairy farm,

(ii) Copies of the ITRs and the audited financial statements of the Narendra Gauseva Society for the AY 2016-17 evidencing payment of rent during AY 2016-17

Further assessee has put reliance on following judicial pronouncements.

“4. In support of the contention that it is the end usage of the property that is considered for determining the eligibility for claiming exemption u/s 54F of the Act, the Appellant wishes to place reliance on the following judicial precedents –

-Judgment of the Hon’ble High Court of Karnataka in the case of Navin Jolly vs ITO as reported in [2020] 424 ITR 462 (Karnataka)[18-06-2020], wherein the Hon’ble Court has held as under –

“10. In the backdrop of aforesaid well settled legal principles, the facts of the case in hand may be examined. Learned counsel for the revenue have fairly submitted that out of nine apartments, seven flats have been sanctioned for commercial purposes. Therefore, the dispute only survives in respect of two apartments, which have been sanctioned for residential purposes and are being used for commercial purposes as serviced apartments. The usage of the property has to be considered for determining whether the property in question is a residential property or a commercial property. It is not in dispute that the aforesaid two apartments are being put to commercial use and therefore, the aforesaid apartments cannot be treated as residential apartments. The contention of the revenue that the apartments cannot be taxed on the basis of the usage does not deserve acceptance in view of decisions of Kerala, Delhi, Allahabad, Calcutta and Hyderabad High Courts with which we respectfully concur.”

-Judgement of the Hon’ble Delhi ITAT in the case of Sanjeev Puri v. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle-37(1), New Delhi as reported in [2016] 160 ITD 213 (Delhi – Trib.), wherein it has been held that –

“8.7 There is no dispute on fact that the property E-575A, GK-II, New Delhi owned by the assessee was being used as his office during the relevant period but only dispute between the assessee and Revenue remained about the entitlement of deduction of sec. 54F of the Act on the basis of actual user of the property i.e. office use and not merely on the basis of the municipal showing the property meant for residential use or in the sale deed shown as residential type. The ratios laid down in  the above cited decisions, support the stand of the assessee that for availing deduction under sec. 54F of the Act, the property though shown as residential on the record of the municipality but the test will be actual user of the premises by the assessee during the relevant period. In other words, it does not make difference whether the property has been shown as residential house on the record of the government authority but actual user thereof by the assessee will be considered while adjudicating upon the eligibility of deduction under sec. 54F of the Act claimed by the assessee. In the present case, for denial of the claimed deduction under sec. 54F of the Act, the Assessing Officer should not have considered the property E-575A, G.K.II, New Delhi as residential on the basis of municipal record ignoring the actual user thereof, as held in the above cited decisions. The authorities below were thus not justified in denying and upholding the denial of the claimed benefit to the assessee by way of deduction under sec. 54F of the Act on the basis that the assessee was owning more than one residential house (i.e. inclusion of E- 575A, GK-II, New Delhi) on the date of transfer of the original assets. We thus setting aside the orders of the authorities below in this regard direct the Assessing Officer to allow the claimed deduction under sec. 54F of the Act. The ground No.1 is accordingly allowed.

-Judgement of the Hon’ble High Court of Madras in the case of Commissioner of Income-tax, Chennal v. I. Ifthiqar Ashiq as reported in [2016] 68 taxmann.com 25 (Madras), wherein the Hon’ble Court has held as under-

14. It is not a case of the Department that the case of the assessee would fall under any one of the three sub clauses of clause (a) together with clause (b). The case of the Department is that the assessee had income from a commercial property that was treated as income from house property. To be precise, the assessee had one residential house in Chennai, one commercial flat in Chennai, from out of both of which, he was deriving a total income of Rs.4,25,131/-. He also had a land in Neelankarai which was sold and a house property was purchased in Kodaikanal. 15. Under Section 22 of the Act, any income from any buildings, irrespective of which the use which has to be treated under the head “income from house property”. Therefore, the Revenue cannot take above all the terminology use in clause (b) under the proviso. This is a mistake into which the Revenue has fallen to treat the case of the assessee as falling within the purview of the proviso.

16. The facts of the case as narrated in the order of assessment would show that the assessee did not own more than one residential house other than the new asset on the date of transfer of the original asset so as to fall clause (a)(i) of the proviso. The assessee did not purchase any residential house other than the new asset within one year of the transfer of the original asset. Therefore, his case did not also fall within clause (a)(ii) of the proviso. The assessee did not construct any residential house other than the new asset, so as to fall under clause (a) (iii). Therefore, the assessee did not satisfy any of the three sub-clauses contained in clause (a). Hence, the question of applying clause (b) of the proviso independent of the clause (a) of the proviso did not arise.

-Recent judgement of Hon’ble Chennai ITAT in the case of Kesavan Vanithamani v. Income-tax Officer as reported in [2026] 183 taxmann.com 567 (Chennai Trib.) [10-02-2026], wherein following the judgement of Hon’ble Madras Court in the case of I. Ifthiqar Ashiq (supra), the Hon’ble Tribunal held as under –

“5.….The CIT(A) however denied the benefit Section 54F to the assessee stating that the assessee is owning more than one residential house. From the observations of the CIT(A), we notice that the ground for denying the benefit of Section 54F is that the assessee has offered the income from the tannery income under the head ‘income from house property’. An identical issue has been considered by the Hon’ble Jurisdictional high Court in the case of 1. Ifthiquar Ashiq, supra, and the relevant observations of the Hon’ble High Court is extracted in the earlier part of this order. From the above observations of the Hon’ble High Court, we notice that the ratio laid down is that offering of income under the head “Income from House Property” is not the determinative factor and that if the assessee does not own more that one “residential house” other than the new the new asset then he cannot be denied the deduction u/s.54F. In the given case it is an admitted position that the assessee is owning one residential house that is self-occupied and one tannery that is being let out. Considering the ground on which the revenue has denied the benefit u/s.54F to the assessee we are of the view that the ratio laid in the above case is applicable to the assessee’s case also. Accordingly we hold that the lower authorities are not correct in denying the deduction u/s.54F to the assessee and we direct the AO to allow the deduction in AY 2017-18 as claimed by the assessee.”

On perusal of the documents submitted by the appellant, it is noticed that the property was being used for dairy business and given on rent to Narendra Gouseva Society and rent received from that society has been offered to tax in the form of rent and hence it does not qualify as a residential property, as it was being used for commercial purposes. Even during assessment proceedings, same facts regarding society, alongwith photographs have been submitted to AO, which AO had conveniently avoid, which is not correct. Accordingly, considering the above factual matrix and judicial pronouncements, it is hereby held that the appellant has been eligible for the deduction u/s 54F since the property situated in Dehradun has been let out by the appellant and is being used by the tenant for running a dairy farm, i.e., the end use of the property is commercial in nature.

Accordingly, the contention of the appellant that the said property cannot be considered as a residential house property while evaluating the Appellant’s eligibility for exemption u/s 54F of the Act is accepted. Consequently, the AO is directed to allow the deduction claimed by the appellant to the tune of Rs.66,91,200 /- in this regard. Therefore, the grounds raised by the appellant are hereby allowed.”

13. Before us, the Revenue has not controverted the findings of the Ld. CIT(A) and alleged that the property situated at Dehradun is a residential property where dairy was running by the tenant thus the said property cannot be held as commercial property. Once the subject property was utilized for commercial purposes and cannot be used for residence, it cannot be said that the said property was residential and, therefore, we find no error in order of Ld. CIT(A) allowing the deduction u/s 54F on the purchases of new residential house property during the year under appeal. Accordingly, grounds of appeal No.5 of the Revenue is hereby dismissed.

14. Coming to the grounds of appeal No.3 of the assessee wherein the Ld. CIT(A) has directed the AO to verify whether the land sold for Rs. 8,91,000/- to Habib Ahmad was brought to tax or not.

15. Heard both the parties and perused the materials available on record. It was the claim of the assessee that he has never executed any such transactions of sale of land for Rs.8,91,000/- which fact can be verified from the land revenue authorities however, the AO has not made any efforts for making such verification. It is further observed that AO while giving effect to the order of Ld. CIT(A) has again failed to make any verification from the land revenue authorities. Under these transactions, we set aside the order of both the authorities and remand the issue back to the file of the Ld. AO for making verification whether assessee has actually entered into transactions of sale of property land Rs.8,91,000/- to Habib Ahmad and if it is found that no such transaction was ever carried out by the assessee, no addition be made otherwise decide the same in accordance with law. With these directions, ground of appeal No.3 of the assessee is allowed for statistical purposes.

16. Grounds of appeal No.4 of the assessee is for charging the interest u/s 234B and 234C which are consequential in nature and Ground of appeal No.5 is with respect to the initiation of penalty proceedings u/s 270A of the Act which is premature thus, is not decided at this stage.

17. In the result, the appeal of the assessee is partly allowed and appeal of the Revenue is dismissed.

Order pronounced in the open Court 18.11.2026.

Advertisement

Author Info

CA Vijayakumar Shetty
Qualification: CA in Practice
Company: Shetty & Co, Chartered Accountants, Mangalore
Location: Mangalore, Karnataka
Articles Published: 7,808

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.