Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Service Tax

Proportionate CENVAT Credit Reversal Valid Despite Procedural Lapses: CESTAT Delhi

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2026 taxguru.in 19202
Case Name
Star Agriwarehousing & Collateral Management Ltd. Vs Commissioner of Central Excise & Service Tax (CESTAT Delhi)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Star Agriwarehousing & Collateral Management Ltd. Vs Commissioner of Central Excise & Service Tax (CESTAT Delhi)

Summary: The Principal Bench of the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal, New Delhi, allowed the appeal filed by Star Agriwarehousing & Collateral Management Ltd. against an order confirming a demand of ₹4,87,28,002 under the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004. The dispute concerned the reversal of CENVAT credit attributable to exempted services where the appellant provided both taxable and exempted output services, including storage and warehousing, cargo handling and business auxiliary services relating to agricultural produce. The Department alleged that the appellant had failed to maintain separate accounts under Rule 6(2) and had not complied with the prescribed procedure under Rules 6(3) and 6(3A). The Tribunal held that where proportionate credit had actually been reversed and the Department had not disputed the correctness of that reversal, minor procedural omissions could not justify denial of the substantive credit benefit.

The proceedings covered the period October 2008 to June 2012. Following an audit, the Department issued a show-cause notice dated 24 April 2014 demanding ₹4.87 crore under Rule 14 of the CENVAT Credit Rules read with Section 73(1) of the Finance Act, 1994. The Commissioner confirmed the demand through Order-in-Original dated 29 January 2015 and imposed an equivalent penalty under Section 78 of the Finance Act read with Rule 15 of the CENVAT Credit Rules. The appellant maintained that it had already reversed the proportionate credit attributable to exempted services and had furnished the required declaration. Its omission to disclose exempted-service turnover in certain periodic service tax returns was described as an inadvertent procedural lapse that did not affect the amount of credit reversed.

Before the Tribunal, the appellant argued that Rule 6(3A) permitted proportionate reversal of common input-service credit and that the Department could not demand an additional amount calculated on the value of exempted services after such reversal had been made. It relied on Chandrapur Magnet Wires (P) Ltd. v. Collector of Central Excise, 1996 (81) ELT 3 (SC), for the principle that reversal of credit has the effect of non-availment. The appellant also cited several High Court and Tribunal decisions, including CCE v. Ashima Dyecot Ltd., Hello Minerals Water (P) Ltd. v. Union of India, The Oberoi Rajvilas v. CCE and Mercedes Benz India (P) Ltd. v. CCE. The Department supported the adjudication order.

The Tribunal examined the CENVAT credit register for April 2009 to June 2012 and found that the appellant had regularly reversed proportionate credit attributable to exempted output services. Significantly, the Department had not alleged that the amounts reversed were incorrect or disproportionate. The Tribunal held that omissions such as failure to disclose exempted turnover in periodic returns were minor procedural irregularities that could not defeat substantial compliance with Rule 6(3A). Following Chandrapur Magnet Wires and The Oberoi Rajvilas, it reiterated that proportionate reversal satisfies the requirement of non-availment of credit on inputs or input services attributable to exempted services. Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the Order-in-Original and allowed the appeal.

Cases Discussed

  • Chandrapur Magnet Wires (P) Ltd. Vs Collector of Central Excise, Nagpur — 1996 (81) E.L.T. 3 (SC) — Applied: reversal of credit is treated as non-availment.
  • Commissioner of Central Excise Vs Ashima Dyecot Ltd. — 2008 (232) E.L.T. 580 (Guj.); affirmed at 2009 (240) E.L.T. A41 (SC) — Cited by appellant.
  • Hello Minerals Water (P) Ltd. Vs Union of India — 2004 (174) E.L.T. 422 (All.) — Cited by appellant.
  • Oil India Limited Vs Commissioner of Central Excise, Jaipur — 2018 (6) TMI 1248 (CESTAT New Delhi) — Cited by appellant.
  • Beekay Engineering Corporation Vs Commissioner of Central Excise, Raipur — 2017 (11) TMI 1468 (CESTAT New Delhi) — Cited by appellant.
  • Hindustan Antibiotics Limited Vs Commissioner of Central Excise — 2015 (9) TMI 1581 (CESTAT Mumbai) — Cited by appellant.
  • Dr. Writer’s Food Products Pvt. Ltd. Vs Commissioner of Central Excise, Pune-II — 2009 (247) E.L.T. 391 (CESTAT Mumbai) — Cited by appellant.
  • Tiara Advertising Vs Union of India, Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue — 2019-VIL-540-AP-ST — Cited by appellant; citation normalized from PDF typography.
  • The Oberoi Rajvilas Vs Commissioner of Central Excise, Jaipur — 2018 (5) TMI 1715 (CESTAT New Delhi) — Applied: proportionate reversal satisfies Rule 6 requirements.
  • Nagpur Urban Corporation Bank Vs Commissioner of Customs, Central Excise & Service Tax — 2018 (3) TMI 273 (CESTAT Mumbai) — Cited by appellant; party name follows PDF.
  • Tata Technologies Vs Commissioner of Central Excise, Pune — 2016 (1) TMI 972 (CESTAT Mumbai) — Cited by appellant.
  • Mercedes Benz India (Private) Limited Vs Commissioner of Central Excise, Pune — 2015 (40) S.T.R. 381 (CESTAT Mumbai) — Cited by appellant.
  • Bhingar Urban Co-op Bank Limited Vs Commissioner of Central Excise, Customs and Service Tax, Aurangabad — 2016 (41) S.T.R. 673 (CESTAT Mumbai) — Cited by appellant.

FULL TEXT OF THE ORIGINAL JUDGMENT/ORDER

The brief facts of the matter are that the Department during the course of audit, noticed that the appellant provided taxable services namely Storage and Warehousing Service, Cargo Handling Service and Business Auxiliary Service in respect of agricultural produces and not reversed back the service tax credits of input services received on account of these services which fall under the category of exempted services. It was further contended by the Department that since the appellant provided both taxable and exempted services the Cenvat input and input service credit on common inputs need to be reversed on the input services going into the exempted services. It was further mentioned that the appellant neither maintained separate record in terms of Rule 6 (2) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 nor have paid the amount as per the conditions and procedure specified under Rule 6 (3) (i) and (ii) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 readwith sub-Rule (3A) of Rule 6 of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004. On the basis of above stand, the Department have issued a show cause notice dated 24 April 2014 whereunder the reversal of Cenvat credit amounting to Rs. 4,87,28,002/- have been demanded as per provisions of Rule 14 of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 readwith provisions of Section 73 (1) of the Finance Act, 1994. The interest and penal provisions have also been invoked. The detail of the service tax demanded are as given in the table below :-                

Year Value of exempted services (Rs.) Rate at which amount payable Amount payable (Rs.)
2008-09 (from Oct.) 2,89,38,816/- 8% 23,15,105/-
2009-10 11,42,78,989/- 8% 91,42,319/-
2010-11 20,96,89,250/- 6% 1,25,81,355/-
2011-12 36,18,07,371/- 5% 1,80,90,369/-
2012-13 (upto June) 10,99,80,901/- 6% 65,98,854/-
Total 82,46,95,327/-   4,87,28,002/-

The above referred show cause notice have been adjudicated by learned Commissioner vide his order-in-original No. JAI-EXCUS- 000-COM-80-14-15 dated 29 January 2015. The learned Commissioner vide above-mentioned impugned order-in-original has confirmed the demand of service tax as demanded in the show cause notice and penalty of equal amount has already been imposed under Section 78 of the Finance Act, 1994 readwith Rule 15 (3) and Rule 15 (4) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004. The appellant are before us against the impugned order-in-original dated 29 January 2015.

2. The learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the appellant has submitted that appellant had availed the Cenvat credit during the period October 2008 to June 2012 according to Rule 6 (3A) of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 by reversing the proportionate amount of Cenvat credit attributable to exempted services and utilized the remaining amount of the Cenvat credit for payment of the service tax against the taxable services. It has further been submitted that appellant have submitted a declaration to the Department as is required in terms of Rule 6 (3A) of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004.

3. The learned Advocate has further submitted that the benefit of the option available under Rule 6 (3A) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 for payment of the service tax cannot be denied to the appellant merely on the ground that the turnover figures of the exempted services were not filed by the appellant in the monthly service tax returns. The appellant in ignorance have failed to mention the turnover of exempted services in their monthly service tax returns, however, this does not make any difference in the amount of the Cenvat credit utilized by the appellant as they have already reversed back the Cenvat credit which were attributable to the common inputs which have gone into exempted services.

4. The learned Advocate has further submitted that any shortcoming in the declaration or intimation by the appellant to the Department is purely a procedural lapse and for such a procedural lapse substantial benefit of the Cenvat credit cannot be denied to the appellant. It has further been stressed that even if for sake of argument, it is taken that the appellant had availed full Cenvat credit on input services used for providing both exempted and taxable services they are only required to pay service tax under Rule 6 (3) (i) of the Cenvat Credit Rules and same in any circumstances cannot be more than the amount of the Cenvat credit which have been availed by them. Since, they have already reversed back the proportionate input credits which have gone into the exempted services and, therefore, same cannot be demanded twice from the appellant.

5. It has also vehemently opposed by the learned Advocate that in the facts and circumstances of the matter the provisions of willful suppression with an intention to evade payment of service tax or to avail wrong Cenvat credit on the part of the appellant cannot be invoked for applying extended period of limitation under Section 73 (1) of the Finance Act, 1994 and it was blatantly wrong on the part of the Commissioner to impose penalty on the appellant by invoking the provisions of Rule 15 of the Cenvat Credit Rules 2004 readwith Section 78 of the Finance Act, 1994 as element of any fraud, mis-declaration, suppression of facts etc. are not present in this matter and the appellant have already made a declaration to the Department that proportionate Cenvat credit of the inputs which are going into exempted services are being reversed by them on their own. The learned Advocate has relied on the Hon’ble Supreme Court decision in the case of Chandrapur Magnets Pvt. Ltd. versus Commissioner of Central Excise – 1996 (81) E.L.T. 3 (S.C.). In this judgment the Hon’ble Apex court has held that once the Cenvat credit taken has been reversed back by the assessee, it amounts to as if no Cenvat credit was availed. The learned Advocate further stressed that decision of Chandrapur Magnets Pvt. Ltd. (supra) is regularly being followed by this Tribunal and some of the case laws cited by the learned Advocate are as follows :-

(i) Commissioner of Central Excise versus Ashima Dyecot Ltd. – 2008 (232) E.L.T. 580 (Guj.) (affirmed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in 2009 (240) E.L.T. A41 (S.C.)

(ii) Hello Minerals Water (P) LOtd. Versus Union of India – 2004 (174) E.L.T. 422 (All.)

(iii) Oil India Limited versus Commissioner of Central Excise, Jaipur – 2018 (6) TMI 1248 – CESTAT New Delhi (iv) Beekay Engineering Corporation versus Commissioner of Central Excise, Raipur – 2017 (11) TMI 1468 – CESTAT New Delhi (v) Hindustan Antibiotics Limited versus Commissioner of Central Excise – 2015 (9) TMI 1581 – CESTAT Mumbai

(vi) Dr. Writer’s Food Products Pvt. Ltd. versus Commissioner of Central Excise, Pune – II – 2009 (247) E.L.T. 391 (Tri. – Mumbai).

6. The learned Advocate has further stressed that as per Rule 6 (3) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 every appellant in similar circumstances have three options which also include the payment in terms of Rule 6 (3A) of the Cenvat Credit Rules which provides that the assessee is providing an output service is entitled to reverse back the Cenvat credit for every month equivalent to amount of Cenvat credit attributable to input used in or in relation to exempted services. Since the appellant have already reversed back the proportionate Cenvat credit it is wrong on the part of Department to demand Cenvat credit calculating on the basis of the value of the exempted services. The learned Advocate in support of his argument has relied on following decisions in this regard :-

(a) M/s Tiara Advertising versus Union of India Ministry of Finance Department of Revenue – 2019 – VII. – 540 – AP – ST (b) The Oberoi Rajvillas versus Commissioner of Central Excise, Jaipur – 2018 (5) TMI 1715 – CESTAT New Delhi (c) Nagpur Urban Corporation Bank versus Commissioner of Customs, Central Excise & Service Tax – 2018 (3) TMI 273 – CESTAT Mumbai (d) Tata Technologies versus Commissioner of Central Excise, Pune – 2016 (1) TMI 972 – CESTAT Mumbai (e) Mercedes Benz India (Private) Limited versus Commissioner of Central Excise, Pune – 2015 (40) S.T.R. 381 (Tribunal – Mumbai) (f) Bhingar Urban Co-op Bank Limited versus Commissioner of Central Excise, Customs and Service Tax, Aurangabad – 2016 (41) S.T.R. 673 (Tribunal – Mumbai).

7. We have also heard learned Departmental Representative who has generally supported the findings given in the order-in- original.

8. We have heard the rival contentions and are of the view that it is a matter of record that the appellant have been providing both taxable and exempted output services in respect of which they have been availing credit of common input services. It is also a matter of record that the appellant have fulfilled the requirement of Rule 6 (3) (ii) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 readwith Rule 6 (3A) and have been reversing the amount of common Cenvat credits, proportionate to value of exempted output services. In this regard we take note of the fact that appellant have furnished Cenvat credit register for the period April 2009 to June 2012 which indicate that they have regularly been reversing the proportionate amount of the Cenvat credit taken on the common inputs which have gone into exempted output services. In this regard, we are of the view once the appropriate reversal have been made under Rule 6 (3A) of the Cenvat Credit Rules any procedural violations of minor nature would be of in-consequential nature and will not dis-entitle the assessee from availing the Cenvat credit of the common inputs for which they have already been making a regular reversal of proportionate credits. We also take note of the fact that the Department has nowhere mentioned in entire proceedings that the amount of Cenvat credit reversed is not proportionate to the value of exempted services or not proper otherwise. The only ground that the appellant have not followed the laid down procedure of availing the option of Rule 6 (3A) like not declaring value of turnover of exempted services in their periodic service tax return etc. can be minor procedural lapses, but same cannot become ground for denying a substantial benefit to the appellant.

9. We are also of the view that once the proportionate reversal of the Cenvat credit has taken place, that tentamount to not availing of the input services credit of the common inputs which are going into the exempted services. While holding this view we take shelter of the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Chandrapur Magnet Wires (P) Ltd. versus Collector of Central Excise, Nagpur – 1996 (81) E.L.T. 3 (S.C.).

10. We also take note of this Tribunal’s decision on the same issue in case of M/s The Oberoi Rajvilas versus Commissioner of Central Excise, Jaipur reported under 2018 (5) TMI 1715 – CESTAT New Delhi, the relevant extract of same are reproduced here below :-

“9. From the above, we note that the appellant has followed the proportionate method for availment of credit on common input services. It cannot be said that the appellant has availed any credit on input services used in providing exempted service. The reversal of credit as above satisfies the requirement of non availment of credit laid down in the Notification No. 1/2006-ST ibid.

10. It is a settled position of law that proportionate reversal at a later date will satisfy the requirement of non availment of Cenvat credit. This view is supported by various decisions of the Supreme Court/ High Courts and Tribunal, some of which have been cited by the appellant.

11. The procedure prescribed in Rule 6(3A) of the Credit Rules is only to make the provisions of Rule 3 workable. By means of proportionate reversal the requirement of Rule 6(3) has been substantially satisfied. This is also provided in Rule 6(3D) of the Cenvat Credit Rules which was introduced at a later date”.

11. In view of above discussion, we find no merit in the order- in-original. Accordingly, we set aside the same and allow the appeal.

(Operative part of order pronounced in open court.)

Advertisement

Author Info

CA Sandeep Kanoi
Qualification: Graduate, CA in Job / Business, DD
Company: Taxguru Consultancy
Location: Mumbai, Maharashtra
Articles Published: 24,847

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.