Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Service Tax

CESTAT Delhi Sets Aside Service Tax on Reinsurance Premium Difference & Co-Insurance Charges

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2026 taxguru.in 18911
Case Name
Oriental Insurance Company Limited Vs Commissioner of Central Excise & Service Tax (CESTAT New Delhi)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Oriental Insurance Company Limited Vs Commissioner of Central Excise & Service Tax (CESTAT New Delhi)

Summary: The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), New Delhi, in Oriental Insurance Company Limited Vs Commissioner of Central Excise & Service Tax, LTU, New Delhi, examined the legality of service tax demands confirmed against the appellant, a public sector general insurance company, concerning reinsurance premiums ceded to foreign reinsurers and administrative charges collected from co-insurers. The dispute related to the periods 2008–09 and 2012–13 and arose from differences between figures reported in the balance sheet and ST-3 returns. Following an audit, the Department alleged short-payment of service tax on foreign reinsurance premiums, discrepancies in taxable income, non-payment of service tax on administrative charges and application of an incorrect service tax rate. The Commissioner confirmed the demands through an order dated 29 February 2016. The appellant challenged the order, contending that the Department had incorrectly relied upon provisional figures and failed to consider the reconciliation statements, supporting accounting records and explanations furnished before adjudication.

The Tribunal observed that the appellant had submitted a detailed reconciliation of foreign reinsurance premiums through its letter dated 25 April 2014, even before issuance of the show cause notice. The appellant had also clarified that the figures initially furnished during the audit were provisional and that the final figures established a taxable reinsurance premium of Rs.4,33,59,22,081, instead of Rs.4,80,63,38,385 adopted by the Department. The Tribunal found that the Commissioner had failed to properly examine the reconciliation, certified ledger accounts and supporting Chartered Accountant’s certificate dated 29 June 2016. Accordingly, the demand arising from the alleged difference in reinsurance premiums was held unsustainable. Regarding administrative charges collected from co-insurers, the Tribunal relied upon National Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs CST, Kolkata, reported in 2017 (47) S.T.R. 183 (Tri.-Kolkata), which held that a lead insurer does not render a separate taxable service to co-insurers under a co-insurance arrangement. The Tribunal also noted that two orders of the Commissioner (Appeals), which had dropped similar demands, had attained finality.

On the issue of penalty, the Tribunal observed that the appellant had deposited the amounts relating to the second and fourth allegations before issuance of the show cause notice and that these payments had already been appropriated by the Commissioner. Applying Section 73(3) of the Finance Act, 1994, the Tribunal held that the penalty imposed in respect of those amounts could not be sustained. Since the substantive demands and penalty were liable to be set aside, the Tribunal considered it unnecessary to examine the appellant’s contention regarding invocation of the extended period of limitation. Consequently, the CESTAT set aside the Commissioner’s order dated 29 February 2016 and allowed the appeal of Oriental Insurance Company Limited. The decision, pronounced on 25 May 2023 in Service Tax Appeal No. 51995 of 2016, Final Order No. 50761/2023, establishes that service tax demands cannot be sustained by disregarding material reconciliation evidence and that administrative charges received by a lead insurer from co-insurers do not constitute consideration for a separate taxable service in the circumstances examined.

Cases Discussed

National Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. CST, Kolkata — 2017 (47) S.T.R. 183 (Tri.-Kolkata). The Tribunal relied on this decision to hold that the lead insurer does not provide a separate taxable service to co-insurers in the relevant co-insurance arrangement.

FULL TEXT OF THE CESTAT DELHI ORDER

The order dated February 29, 2016 passed by the Commissioner confirming the demand of service tax, has led to the 1 filing of this appeal by M/s. Oriental Insurance Company Limited.

2. The period involved in this appeal is 2008 to 2009 and 2012 to 2013 and the issue is regarding the demand of service tax on ceded re-insurance premium basis the difference between the figures reported in the balance sheet and the ST-3 Returns, as also the demand of service tax on the administrative charges collected by the appellant from the co-insurers.

3. The appellant is a public sector undertaking and is engaged in the business of general insurance services and insurance auxiliary services.

4. The appellant avails re-insurance services from foreign re- insurers, apart from Indian re-insurers. Re-insurance is an insurance of insured risk where the insurer retains a part and cedes the balance of the risk to the insurer. The said services fall within the scope of taxable services defined under section 65 (105)(d) of the Finance Act, 1994 and the appellant claims that service tax was discharged by it under reverse charge.

5. The appellant also entered into a co-insurance agreement dated February 20, 2009. Co-insurance is a type of insurance contract wherein the insurance to the policy holder is issued by more than one insurer who jointly share the risk as well as the premium under the insurance contract. In such co-insurance contracts, the insurers jointly provide insurance services to the insured.

6. An audit of the appellant was conducted in November 2013 for the period 2010-11 to 2012-13, wherein it was observed that the appellant had failed to pay/short-paid service tax in respect of various services provided/received by it and the observations made concerning the appellant are as follows:

“(i). Short payment of seivice tax on reinsurance premium ceded –

As per balance sheet for the year 2011-12, you have ceded Rs. 47587000001-. as reinsurance premium with the foreign insurers on which you were required to discharge the service tax liability but you have discharged service, tax liability only on Rs.4335922081/-. Thus, it appears you have short paid service tax amounting to Rs.43546126/- on the differential ceded premium with foreign insurers amounting to Rs.422777919/- (4758700000-4335922081).

(ii). Short payment of service tax including interest –

Reconciliation of gross premium income shown in the balance sheet and the ST-3 return for the year 2011-12, revealed that as per balance sheet your net taxable income is Rs.65163976959/- whereas in your ST-3 return for the concerned period you have shown your net taxable income as Rs.64110100157/- which has resulted in short payment of service tax amounting to Rs.108549311/- on the differential amount of Rs. 1053876802/-

(iii). Non-payment of service tax on administrative charges-

During the period 2010-11 to 2012-13 you have collected administrative charges of Rs.130986953/- from the co-insurer companies on which you have not paid service. Lax amounting to Rs.14434263/-,

(iv). Short payment of service tax-

Scrutiny of the ST-3 returns for the period 2012-13 revealed that you have discharged your service tax liability @ 10.3% instead of 12.36 % which has been raised w.e.f. 01.04.2012. This has resulted in short payment of Rs. 2951827/-.”

7. The appellant submitted a reply to the audit objection and the relevant portions are reproduced below:

“A.2 At the outset, we would like to submit that the figure of Rs. 4758700000/- arrived at by the audit party does not appear in our balance sheet for the period 2011-12 and does not even match with our calculations done on the basis of our financial statements for the relevant period. As à result, we are unable to arrive at the said figure. Hence, in this regard, we would request the audit party to give us a a basis for arriving at the amount of Rs. 4,75,87,00,000/- as claimed by them in their letter.

A.3 As per our balance sheet and reconciliation of the figures, we have ceded re-insurance premium only for an amount of Rs. 4,33,59,22,081/- to foreign re-insurers on which we have duly discharged our service tax liability under reverse charge. Details of calculations are attached as Annexure-I.

A.4 Hence, according to us there has been no short payment of service tax on re-insurance premium ceded to foreign insurers. As a result, we are not liable to pay any tax, interest and penalty on such amount.

xxxx xxxx xxxx

C.2 Under the co-insurance agreement, insurance policy is issued by more than one insurer who jointly share the risk as well as the premium under the contract. As per the arrangement, one of the r insurers assuming the maximum risk is appointed as lead insurer for the purposes of undertaking all the administrative activities such as issuing policy documents, collecting premium etc.

For the above activities, the lead insurer collects administrative fee from the co-insurers. It is submitted that such fee is collected only to compensate the expenditure incurred by the lead insurer.”

8. However, a show cause notice dated May 21, 2014 was issued to the appellant containing the following allegations:

(i) There is a difference between the figures of ceded reinsurance premium paid to foreign re-insurers reported in the STR-3 Returns and the balance sheet during the year 2011-12 thereby resulting in short-payment of service tax of Rs.4,35,46,126/- on the differential value;

(ii) There is a difference in the value of net taxable income shown in the balance sheet and the ST-3 returns during the year 2011-12 and thus, there is a short-payment of service tax to the tune of Rs. 10,85,49,311/-;

(iii) The appellant has failed to pay service tax of Rs.2,09,15,202/- on the administrative charges received from the co-insurers during the period 2008-09 to 2012-13;

(iv) There is a short payment of service tax of Rs.29,51,827/- as service tax liability was discharged at a lower rate of 10.3% instead of 12.36% during the months of May 2012, July 2012 and November 2012; and

(v) The appellant had intentionally and willfully suppressed the fact of provision and receipt of taxable services from the Department. Thus, the extended period was invokable in the case.

9. The appellant filed a detailed reply to the aforesaid show cause notice. The Commissioner adjudicated the show cause notice by order dated February 29, 2016, which order has been impugned in this appeal.

10. The relevant portion of the order so far as short payment of service tax on amount ceded as reinsurance premium is reproduced below:

“17.2 On perusal of the reconciliation and balance sheet, it is seen that the sub-total of foreign insurance premium ceded is Rs. 480,63,38,385/- whereas they have paid service tax on Rs. 433,59,22,081/-. The reconciliation submitted by the Noticee was also submitted in reply to audit objection and after considering the same the value was taken as Rs. 475,87,00,000/-. The Noticee has not provided anything in addition to their earlier submissions which were examined by the department during the course of audit and subsequent investigations thereto and demand was issued as the Noticee failed to properly explain the reconciliation. Even in the reconciliation submitted by the Noticee at this juncture, the differences are apparent. It is needless to emphasize here that the onus lies upon the Noticee to clarify the requisites, especially, when the issue has been raised by the audit as well as vide the impugned SCN. I find that the Noticee had merely passed on the reconciliation record without explaining as to why the amount of Rs. 433,59,22,081/- only should be considered as ceded foreign insurance premium as against the sub-total of Rs. 480,63,38,385/- said to be “reconciliation of premium figures for Service Tax purposes (with foreign premium) as on 31.03.2012. 17.3 As noted above, due to material distortions not explained appropriately and also by the fact that all the figures were provided by Noticee to the audit, were duly scrutinized, I, thus, find no reason to accept the contentions of the Noticee. In view of the above, I confirm the demand of Rs. Rs.4,35,66,126/- proposed in the show cause notice. This assertion, based on the allegations of the impugned show cause notice, is restricted to the value in question i.e. Rs. 475,87,00,000/; and not on the amount of Rs. 480,63,38,385/- as stated in the reconciliation figure provided by the Noticee, which incidentally is in excess of the amount of Rs. 475,87,00,000/- specified in the show cause notice.”

11. In regard to the liability of service tax on administrative charges, the Commissioner observed:

“19.12 Thus, I hold that the Noticee, as lead insurer, is deemed to be an agent for other co-insurers, for provisions of insurances services representing all the co-insurers against the consideration in the form of administrative expenses. Thus, the Notice is a service provider and co-insurers are the service recipients for the provision of BAS as taxable services against gross value of such taxable services in the form of administrative expenses. It is also pertinent to mention, here that the nomenclature is not relevant to understand the taxability and the consideration as the nature of the services provided against the consideration matters for falling in the ambit of provisions of the Finance Act, 1994. Hence, the term “administrative expenses” per se does not mean that the same is not towards taxability under the provisions of the Act ibid

Having observed so, I hold that the Service Tax demand under this issue is sustained.”

12. Shri B.L.Narasimhan, learned counsel for the appellant assisted by Ms. Purvi Asati made the following submissions:

(i) There is no short-payment of service tax by the appellant on the foreign reinsurance premium ceded. The impugned order has confirmed the demand on the alleged differential ceded reinsurance premium paid to the foreign re-insurers on the ground that the appellant merely provided the reconciliation without any explanation as to why the amount of Rs. 433,59,22,081/- shown in the ST-3 returns be only considered as ceded foreign reinsurance premium. It also held that due to material distortions, unexplained amounts and also due to the provision of the figures by the appellant itself during the course of audit, the demand has been confirmed. The appellant had provided the re-conciliation between the figures of ceded reinsurance premium given in the balance sheet and ST-3 Returns by letter dated 25.4.2014 even before the issuance of the show cause notice. The appellant, by letter dated 17.10.2014, also informed the Department that the figures provided by it during the course of audit were provisional figures and the final figures those provided by letter dated 25.4.2014. However, these facts have not been considered in the impugned order and the impugned order has proceeded to confirm the demand on the basis that the said reconciliation does not explain the amount of Rs. 433,59,22,081/- shown in the ST-3 returns as the ceded foreign reinsurance premium; and

(ii) No service tax can be levied on administrative charges collected from the co-insurers. The administrative charges collected by the appellant (lead insurer) from the co-insurers is not towards any service and in this connection, reliance has been placed on the decision of the Tribunal in National 3 Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. CST, Kolkata, wherein it has been held that there is no service being rendered by the lead insurer to the co-insurers in terms of the non-insurance agreement.

13. Shri Sanjay Kumar Singh, learned authorized representative appearing for the Department has, however, supported the impugned order.

14. The submissions advanced by the learned counsel for the appellant and the learned authorized representative appearing for the Department have been considered.

15. The impugned order has confirmed the demand of service tax on the alleged differential ceded reinsurance premium paid to the foreign re-insurers on the ground that the appellant merely provided the reconciliation without providing any explanation as to why the amount of Rs. 433,59,22,081/- shown in the ST-3 returns should only be considered as ceded foreign reinsurance premium. It is seen that the appellant had provided the re-conciliation between the figures of ceded reinsurance premium given in the balance sheet and the ST-3 Returns by a letter dated April 25, 2014 even before the issuance of the show cause notice, as is evident from the Relied Upon document-III to the show cause notice. The appellant, by a letter dated October 17, 2014, also informed the Department that the figures provided during the course of audit were provisional figures and the final figures would be the one provided by the letter dated April 25, 2014. However, this explanation not been considered in the impugned order and it has proceeded to confirm the demand on the basis that the said reconciliation does not explain the amount of Rs. 433,59,22,081/- shown in the ST-3 Returns as the ceded foreign reinsurance premium. Only a bald statement has been made, while confirming the demand, that the appellant had not provided anything in addition to the submissions earlier made by the appellant to the audit objection which were examined by the Department during the course of audit and as the appellant had failed to submit a proper reply, the show cause notice was issued. In other words, what has been observed is that since the Commissioner concluded that the reply submitted by the appellant to the objection raised by the audit was examined and thereafter the show cause notice was issued, it would mean that the reply submitted by the appellant to the audit objections had been examined and considered and since no further submissions had been made by the appellant in reply to the show cause notice, there is no necessity to examine the reply filed by the appellant to the show cause.

16. This approach of the Commissioner is enough for setting aside the findings recorded by the Commissioner. The least the Commissioner could have done was to have examined the reply filed by the appellant that explained the reconciliation by pointing out that earlier only a provisional figure was provided during the course of audit and it was only later that final figures were provided. Adequate and proper explanation had been provided by the appellant with details. The appellant had supplied a certified copy of the ledger of reinsurance account to prove the claim made by the appellant in the letter date February 4, 2014 and this clearly explains that service tax would be leviable on Rs.4,33,59,22,081/- and not on Rs.4,80,63,38,385/- as contended by the Department. The said document is reproduced below:

“THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED
RI Account, Head Office, New Delhi
Conciliation of Premium figures for service tax purpose(with foreign premium)
Premium only 31.03.2012

Type Particulars Amount
Indian Premium as per Trial Balance (Indian) 19656122214
Premium as per Trial Balance (foreign) 167071329
pjv
Premium ceded by foreign offices 236963144.3
Portfolio premium -1550687
Total cessions 20058606000
Total service tax advised to ho 6671152651
Motor Dr Pool (9months paid)
Less Advised for previous year 1675936357
Add service tax advised in October 1818582209
Add service tax advised December 603652286
Terrorism pool not paid yet 660831907
Motor Dr pool (4th quarter to be paid) 6767777408
Pjv
Add service tax not paid yet 318572940
Exempted 87634571
Sub total 15252267615
Foreign Total service tax advised to ho 4335922081
Less Advised for previous year- 30055026
Add service tax advised in Oct/November 368483044
Add service tax not paid yet 0
Premium as per Trial Balances (foreign) 167071329
Premium ceded by foreign offices 236963144.3
Difference in booking 0
Portfolio premium -1550687
Sub total 4806338385
Grand total 20058606000

17. The appellant had also produced a certificate dated June 29, 2016 issued by the Chartered Accountant that premium liability for service tax is actually Rs.4,33,59,22,081/-, and not Rs.4,80,63,38,385/-.

18. A bare perusal of the aforesaid documents filed by the appellant would make it clear that service tax was to be paid only on Rs.4,33,59,22,081/- and had these two documents been examined by the Commissioner, the demand would not have been confirmed.

19. The aforesaid demand, therefore, cannot be sustained and is liable to be set aside.

ADMINISTRATIVE CHARGES

20. The contention of the learned counsel for the appellant is that service tax cannot be levied on administrative charges collected from co-insurers, for the reason that administrative charges collected by the appellant as a lead insurer from the co- insurers is not towards any service. In this connection, reliance has been placed on the decision of the Tribunal in National Insurance Co., wherein it has been held that no service is rendered by the lead insurer to the co-insurers in terms of the co-insurance agreement.

21. The contention advanced by the learned counsel for the appellant deserves to be accepted as this issue has been settled in favour of the appellant by the Tribunal in National Insurance Co. and the relevant portion of the decision is reproduced below:

“5. From the above discussions we observe that there is no separate service rendered by the lead insurer to the co-insurer or otherwise relating to insurance business, except for certain administrative matters. The only service rendered is between the co-insurers and the policy holder. For this service, the insurance premium is received in full by the lead insurer and after payment of service tax on the entire amount, the rest is distributed among the co-insurer on the basis of their agreed shares. The co-insurers and their shares of risk are decided by the policy holder at the time of entering into the policy agreement itself, who only selects the co-insurer. The co-insurance agreement is only in the nature of general regulation for sharing the risk and premium involved in a insurance policy and the entire insurance premium has already suffered tax at the time of its receipt in the hands of the lead insurer.”

22. It has also been contended by the learned counsel for the appellant that the Commissioner (Appeals), in a different order dated February 31, 2017, had also examined this issue at length and the demand was dropped. According to the learned counsel for the appellant, this order attained finality as no appeal was filed by the Department. Learned counsel also pointed out that the Commissioner (Appeals), in another appeal, by order dated April 09, 2018 had examined this issue and dropped the demand and this order has also attained finality.

23. In view of the aforesaid decision of the Tribunal in National Insurance Co. and the two decisions of the Commissioner (Appeals) which have attained finality, it has to be held that service tax cannot be levied on the administrative charges collected by the appellant from the co-insurers.

IMPOSITION OF PENALTY

24. Learned counsel for the appellant also submitted that in so far as the second and fourth charges contained in the show cause notice are concerned, the appellant had deposited the entire amount before the issuance of the show cause notice and therefore, the show cause notice for these two changes could not have been issued nor penalty could have been imposed.

25. This contention advanced by the learned counsel for the appellant deserves to be accepted. The amount deposited by the appellant before the issuance of the show cause is noted in the order passed by the Commissioner and it has been appropriated. In such circumstances, the imposition of penalty on the said amount cannot be sustained in view of the provisions of section 73(3) of the Finance Act and is set aside.

26. In view of the aforesaid discussion, it is not necessary to examine the contention raised by the learned counsel for the appellant that the extended period of limitation could not have been invoked.

27. The impugned order dated February 29, 2016, for all the reasons stated above, is set aside and the appeal is allowed

Notes:-

1 the appellant

2 the Finance Act

3 2017(47) STR 183 (Tri.-Kolkata)

Advertisement

Author Info

CA Sandeep Kanoi
Qualification: Graduate, CA in Job / Business, DD
Company: Taxguru Consultancy
Location: Mumbai, Maharashtra
Articles Published: 24,571

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.