FCMA Sawinder Singh Chug

fcma-sawinder-singh-chug

Why black money is prevalent in Indian economy in such large scale that Govt has taken extreme step to defunct Rs 500/- and Rs. 1000/- note.

Govt. has taken strict action to control black money and determined to flush it out from our economy.

India is not rich country. Most residents here want to earn more and become rich. They want to become rich to have lavish life styles as followed by rich. Movies & media has played important role in changing mindset & lifestyle of Indians, which is once known as country of devtas (devbhoomi) and ‘sone ki chiria’.  Diminishing moral values, social values and religious values among us  has added more fuel to the problem.   So we all want to become rich in shortest possible time. It created the need of black money (avoiding different taxes).

Advantages of doing 2 number business

(1) It is primarily used for avoid indirect taxes & duties and lastly income tax.

(2) To compete with competitors so that less price can be offered to customers.

Disadvantages of doing 2 number business

(1) Logistic & transport cost increase more than double. Transporters charge many time more freight than normal one.

(2) Normally once or twice a year trucks carrying these goods are raided by govt. tax authorities. Then Transporters have to pay a lot as penalty etc. Transporters do not pay it from their pocket, they charge from their customers (dealers) again.. Thus increase further cost.

(3) Maintenance of accounts cost also get increased as businessman has to maintain separate books of accounts for this purpose.

(4) They sell goods without invoice, so there is always risk from their customer side not to make payment. The possibility of litigation always remains.

(5) Many time Vat deptt & income tax deptt raids their showroom, stores & houses further reducing the profit margin.

(6) Lastly they always remain stressed and under pressure. Their nature towards society & family normally remain bitter. They are more adhere to illness & health problems.

So Disadvantages supersede advantage.

If 2 number business is stopped then competitors can’t offer low price.so this advantage gets vanished. As far as advantages of tax avoidance is concerned, it is much less than disadvantages associated with it.

Agar bimar ho jayoge ja mar jayoge to paise ka kia kroge.

Our religion also warns against culprit activities. We have to face result of our actions in this world as well next.

Conclusion:

The extreme step of Govt. may have planned good strategy but they forget to upgrade the ATMs. This has caused a lot of pain to people especially poor ones. My suggestion is that –

All BPL families should be paid/transferred currency through social workers network at their home.

Where it will ease bankers, routine transactions can be done at banks in efficient manners.  Govt. should also compensate the sufferers during this revolution. Some social organizations (including our Institute of Cost Accountants of India) have opened help line outside banks to accommodate public. This is welcome step.

I met different type of businessmen, smaller to bigger ones. All are internally quite satisfied with step and feel happy.

So Let’s pledge that we will do business honesty.

(Author is a Practicing Cost Accountant and can be reached at  cma.sschug@gmail.com)

More Under Fema / RBI

Posted Under

Category : Fema / RBI (3549)
Type : Articles (18266) Featured (4581)
Tags : black money (740) Demonetization (479)

3 responses to “Advantage & disadvantage of unrecorded business transactions”

  1. R. K AHUJA says:

    Subziwala Se Lear gold seller, majority does not give proper receipt and we do not oppose. Are we all not a party to the present day situation? Govt or the police do not support because of their own reasons.that is why we believe in God.

  2. Narendra Prasad says:

    This step is very prudent to curb black money. With one action money advantages. It will control corruption terrorism, inflation & will bring repayment in practice. Citizen of India appreciated PM.

    • Mahedra Kumar Jain says:

      Number 2 business can be controlled only when every business men in Delhi starts giving authentic invoices for all the traded goods. Then number 2 business in other towns will come down automatically.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *