Decoding Startup Valuation: Methods, Insights and Indian Context

Introduction: Navigating the intricate landscape of startup valuation is vital for entrepreneurs and investors. This article delves into the significance of startup valuation in the investment process, exploring methods like market comparables, DCF, scorecard, risk factor summation, First Chicago, and Berkus. Gain insights into assessing a startup’s value in the Indian context and make informed investment decisions.

Startup valuation is the process of estimating a startup company’s value while accounting for a number of variables, including revenue, market potential, and stage of the business. Making educated decisions is essential for entrepreneurs and investors alike. A crucial step in the investing process is startup valuation, which establishes a company’s early value. It is an essential component of investment decisions because it entails estimating a startup’s potential future worth. This Article offers a succinct summary of the several approaches that are used to assess the value of new businesses. Investigate the several techniques for determining a startup’s value and make wise investment choices.

1] Valuation Based on Market Comparable: Comparing the financial parameters and market values of comparable assets is a valuation technique called market-based valuation, or comparable analysis. This strategy is predicated on the idea that an asset’s price in a market with competition is the most accurate indication of its fair value. Three Methods or ways of Valuation based on Market Comparable are as follows:

1. Comparing the Markets: Using this approach, the worth of a company is assessed by contrasting it with similar businesses that have previously gone public or sold.

2. Data Analysis: To arrive at an accurate valuation, a thorough examination of the market, industry, and financial performance of similar companies must be conducted.

3. Accuracy and Relevance: Though helpful, this approach necessitates closely examining the comparable to make sure they fairly represent the startup’s distinctive qualities and potential.

For e.g. A mid-stage tech company’s valuation, for instance, is established by comparing its valuation to that of other tech businesses that are comparable in terms of size, scale, growth, profile, etc. Value Measure (such as Equity Value, Enterprise Value, etc.) Value Driver (e.g., EBITDA, EBIT, Net Income, and EPS)

2] Valuing Discounted Cash Flow (DCF): A valuation technique known as discounted cash flow (DCF) uses an investment’s anticipated future cash flows to estimate its value. Using estimates of the future cash flow that an investment will provide, DCF analysis aims to establish the investment’s current value.

1. Future Cash Flows: DCF valuation projects future cash flows and discounts them to present value to determine a company’s value.

2. Risk and Growth Considerations: It provides a thorough understanding of the startup’s inherent worth by accounting for both its growth potential and risk profile.

3. Long-Term Perspective: This approach highlights a startup’s long-term potential by emphasizing the stability and steady increase of cash flows over time.

Formula for Calculation of Discounted Cash Flow (DCF):

In a compounding environment, the time value of money is taken into account in DCF analysis. The following formula can be used to compute DCF if future cash flows have been predicted and the discount rate has been established:

DCF = CF₁/(1+r)¹ + CF₂/(1+r)²  + CF₃/(1+r)³ + CF_n/(1+r)ⁿ = ∑ⁿ_t=1 CF_t/(1+r)^t

In a compounding environment, the time value of money is taken into account in DCF analysis. The following formula can be used to compute DCF if future cash flows have been predicted and the discount rate has been established. Let’s understand with the following example:

An initial Rs150, 000 investment is needed by a corporation for a project that will likely bring in cash inflows over the following five years. Rs10,000 in the first two years, Rs15,000 in the third, Rs25,000 in the fourth, and Rs20,000 with a Rs100,000 terminal value in the fifth year are the expected earnings. With a 5% cost of capital and no additional investment needed over the project’s duration, the DCF can be computed as follows:

DCF = Rs 10,000/(1+5%)¹ + Rs 10,000/(1+5%)² + Rs 15,000/(1+5%)³ + Rs 25000/(1+5%)⁴ + Rs 120000/(1+5%)⁵ = Rs 1,46,142.

This project appears lucrative because, even without accounting for time value of money, it will generate a total cash return of Rs 180,000 after five years, which is more than the initial investment. Nevertheless, the present value of the return is less than the initial investment of 150,000, coming in at just Rs146,142 after discounting the cash flow of each year. It implies that the business shouldn’t fund the endeavor.

3] Scorecard Method: Angel investors tend to use the scorecard valuation method, which is sometimes referred to as the Bill Payne valuation method. This approach compares the target startup looking for funding against other financed startups that are comparable to it. These businesses are compared using the scorecard valuation model based on a number of variables, including stage, market, and geography. These elements directly affect how much the company is worth. Such factors also have an impact on the company’s typical valuation. Characteristics of scorecard are as follows:

1. Multiple Factors: The scorecard technique evaluates a startup’s staff, product, market, and competitive stance, among other things. This method offers a comprehensive assessment of the startup’s advantages and disadvantages.

2. Subjective Evaluation: It frequently entails the subjective assessment of specialists using a weighted scoring system to score the company according to predetermined standards. It facilitates the quantification of qualitative elements by granting scores to various factors.

3. Determining Factors: The next stage is to use the scorecard valuation approach to compare the target firm to similar agreements completed in your location in order to calculate the pre-money valuation of pre-revenue businesses. The most widely used technique for determining a pre-money value is the scorecard method. These are the primary requirements for the scorecard technique in order:

• • 25% go to the board, the owner, and the management group.
  • Opportunity size: 20%
  • Product/Technology – 18%
  • Sales and marketing: 15%
  • 10% of projects require additional funding.
  • Others: 10%

The startup’s potential is what matters most, but these percentages can be changed to suit the investor’s tastes. The aforementioned factors are ranked in a subjective manner; this is the usual order in which investors evaluate new enterprises. Investors put the technology and product lower than the magnitude of the opportunity and the management team, which is a fact that frequently takes people off guard.

Let’s Calculate the Valuation of company through an example:

It is not difficult to determine a company’s valuation. Let’s look at an example to help you better comprehend it.

ABC Ltd. is trying to find angel investors in order to raise money for the business. For the target company, the prospective investor creates a scorecard company valuation.

Assuming YMB Ltd. possesses:

• • Substantial market potential (100%)
  • A robust group (180% of the norm)
  • A mediocre product and technology (100%)

At 80%, YMB Ltd.’s strength of market competitiveness is lower than that of its competitors. Customers’ initial comments on the offered goods are very positive.

Consequently:

• • Other (100%)

Conversely, the management was having issues with their channels of sales. They must concentrate on creating more effective sales channels and strengthening their alliances (80%). A table containing all of this data will be created, providing a brief overview of the business.

We may determine the company’s pre-money valuation by using the YMB Ltd.  Data:

Using the earlier example, we can calculate the pre-value of the target company by multiplying the median of the pre-money valuation by the total of the elements.

= 1.1205 times Rs 7,000,000 is

= Rs 7,843,500

YMB Ltd., the target company, has a Rs 7.843 million pre-money valuation. This valuation is used to determine the share value of the firm in addition to being the current value of the business prior to revenue and investment.

4] Risk Factor Summation Method: The Risk Factor Summation Method incorporates additional risk management and governance considerations into the pre-money valuation due to its somewhat more quantitative workings on certain risk variables. For comparison, I prefer using this valuation approach in conjunction with the Scorecard Valuation approach.

1. Risk Identification: This approach entails recognizing and evaluating a range of startup-related risks, including financial, operational, and market risks.

2. Risk Quantification: It measures these risks and compiles them into a thorough risk factor that should be taken into account during the appraisal procedure.

3. Impact on Valuation: By combining the effects of several risk variables on the startup’s total value, the risk factor summation approach affects the valuation.

5] First Chicago Method: The Venture Capital Method is another name for the First Chicago Method. Investors in venture capital and private equity adopt this method of business valuation. A multiple-based valuation and the discounted cash flow are combined in the first Chicago technique. First proposed in 1987, the First Chicago technique of valuation was created by and named after the First Chicago bank. The companies Madison Dearborn Partners and GTCR were founded by the Chicago bank. Characteristics of First Chicago Method are as follows:

1. Financial Metrics: The focus of this approach is on financial measures, such as capital expenditures, cost structures, and revenue projections.

2. Complex Calculations: Precise financial modeling and intricate computations are needed to estimate future revenue and evaluate the startup.

3. Investment Decision Support: The First Chicago technique thoroughly evaluates financial data to offer insightful information to help investment decisions.

6] Berkus Method: The Berkus technique determines a company’s worth prior to its first earnings. This technique was initially created by Dave Berkus in the 1990s. In the US, he is a well-known venture capitalist and angel investor. Let’s learn more about the Berkus method appraisal and gain a thorough understanding of it.

1. Five Criteria: Five primary criteria are used by the Berkus approach to assess startups: a strong concept, a working prototype, a quality management team, strategic partnerships, and the launch or sale of the product.

2. Quantified Milestones: It offers an organized method for valuing startups by giving each criterion a set of quantifiable milestones.

Conclusion and Key Takeaways:

1. Startup Valuation: Different approaches provide different insights into how much startups are worth. These approaches consider a range of elements, including market comparisons, risk evaluations, and financial projections.

2. Investment Decisions: Making wise investment decisions and evaluating the potential of early-stage companies depend on having a solid understanding of these valuation techniques.

3. Continual Evaluation and Adaptation: Since valuation is a continuous process, accurate and pertinent startup valuation depends on the ability to adjust to changing market conditions and industry trends.

4. Adaptability: The distinct qualities of the startup should be taken into consideration when assessing each method’s applicability in the Indian environment.

Conclusion: As the Indian startup ecosystem flourishes, understanding diverse valuation methods becomes paramount. From market-based approaches to risk factor summation, each method offers unique insights. Continuous evaluation and adaptability are key as the startup landscape evolves. For investors and entrepreneurs alike, mastering these valuation techniques is crucial for making informed and strategic decisions in the dynamic Indian market.

*****

The above article is written by Mr. Yash Bagadi ([email protected]) and reviewed by Mr. Suyash Tripathi ([email protected]).