In this guide, we explore the importance of timely action and the law of limitation within the context of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017, and the Central Goods and Services Tax Rules, 2017. We delve into specific rules and sections, including Rule 9(2) which addresses the issuance of notices and timelines for providing additional information during GST registration; Rule 9(3) pertaining to granting registration after satisfying the proper officer; Rule 9(5) indicating deemed approval if the officer fails to act; Rule 12(3) streamlining registration for entities involved in TDS and TCS; Rule 16(3) specifying timelines for transitioning from temporary to regular registration; Rule 19(1) governing amendments and approval timelines; Rule 19(2) allowing officers to issue notices if amendments are deemed unwarranted; Rule 19(3) requiring timely responses to show cause notices; and Rule 19(5) enabling deemed amendments when the officer doesn’t act, collectively providing a comprehensive framework for efficient GST registration and amendment processes.
Rule 9 (2) – If any further information is required, proper officer shall issue notice within seven working days from the date of submission of application. Applicant shall furnish the information within seven working days from the date of receipt of the notice. In the circumstances mentioned in the Proviso thereunder, time available to grant is thirty days.
Rule 9(2) of the Central Goods and Services Tax (CGST) Rules, 2017, pertains to the issuance of notices and the timeline for providing additional information during the GST registration process. This rule outlines the steps and timeframes when further information is required to process a registration application. Let’s break down and analyse Rule 9(2) step by step:
Rule 9(2):
If any further information is required, the proper officer shall issue a notice within seven working days from the date of submission of the application. The applicant shall furnish the information within seven working days from the date of receipt of the notice.
This rule outlines the process when the proper officer reviewing a GST registration application determines that additional information is needed. Here’s how it works:
1. If, during the initial review of the application, the proper officer identifies that further information is necessary for processing the application, they must issue a notice to the applicant within seven working days from the date of application submission. This notice will specify what information or documents are required.
Example: ABC Traders apply for GST registration on Monday, January 1, 2023. The proper officer reviews the application and realizes that additional documentation, like bank statements or proof of address, is needed. The officer must issue a notice to ABC Traders by Monday, January 9, 2023, specifying what additional information is required.
2. Upon receiving the notice, the applicant is required to furnish the requested information within seven working days from the date of receipt of the notice.
Example: ABC Traders receive the notice on Monday, January 9, 2023. They have until Monday, January 17, 2023, to provide the requested additional information to the proper officer.
Rule 9(2) Proviso:
In the circumstances mentioned in the Proviso thereunder, time available to grant is thirty days.
Similar to Rule 9(1), Rule 9(2) also has a proviso, which means there are exceptions to the general rule. In specific situations as mentioned in the proviso, where more time may be needed to process the application, the proper officer is given 30 days instead of seven days to grant the registration.
Example: If the proper officer encounters complexities or multiple rounds of information requests and reviews in the process, or if there are concerns about the accuracy of the provided information, they may use the extended 30-day timeframe to make a decision.
To summarize:
1. If additional information is needed, the proper officer must issue a notice to the applicant within seven working days from the date of application submission.
2. The applicant, upon receiving the notice, has seven working days to provide the requested information.
3. In certain specified situations mentioned in the proviso, the proper officer may take up to 30 days to grant the registration.
These rules are designed to ensure that the GST registration process is efficient and allows for adequate time to gather necessary information while preventing unnecessary delays. They provide a clear framework for communication between the tax authorities and the applicants during the registration process.
Rule 9 (3) – If the applicant furnished the information to the satisfaction of the proper officer, he shall grant registration within seven working days from the date of receipt of such information.
Rule 9(3) of the Central Goods and Services Tax (CGST) Rules, 2017, outlines the process for granting GST registration once the applicant has provided the requested information to the satisfaction of the proper officer. This rule specifies a timeline within which the registration should be granted under such circumstances. Let’s analyse Rule 9(3) step by step:
Rule 9(3):
If the applicant furnished the information to the satisfaction of the proper officer, he shall grant registration within seven working days from the date of receipt of such information.
This rule deals with the scenario where an applicant has received a notice for additional information or clarification (as discussed in Rule 9(2)) and has successfully provided the required information to the satisfaction of the proper officer. Here’s how the process works:
1. Satisfaction of the Proper Officer: The applicant must ensure that the information provided satisfies the requirements of the proper officer. The officer will review the furnished information and documents to confirm that they are complete, accurate, and meet the criteria for registration.
2. Timeline for Granting Registration: If the proper officer is satisfied with the information provided, they are required to grant registration within seven working days from the date of receipt of such information.
Example: ABC Traders received a notice for additional information from the proper officer on Monday, January 9, 2023. They diligently gather all the requested documents and submit them to the officer. The proper officer reviews the information and is satisfied with the completeness and accuracy of the provided documents. Therefore, the officer must grant GST registration to ABC Traders by Monday, January 17, 2023, within seven working days from the date of receipt of the satisfactory information.
It’s important to note that Rule 9(3) operates under the assumption that the applicant has promptly and adequately responded to the notice, and the provided information aligns with the requirements. The seven-day timeline ensures that the process remains efficient and that businesses do not face unnecessary delays in obtaining GST registration once they have fulfilled the necessary obligations.
Rule 9 (5) – If the proper officer fails to take any action within the said 7 / 30 /7 days, application for grant of registration shall be deemed to have been approved.
Rule 9(5) of the Central Goods and Services Tax (CGST) Rules, 2017, deals with the situation where the proper officer responsible for processing a GST registration application fails to take any action within the specified timeframes. This rule provides for a deemed approval of the application in such circumstances. Let’s analyse Rule 9(5) step by step:
Rule 9(5):
If the proper officer fails to take any action within the said 7 / 30 / 7 days, the application for the grant of registration shall be deemed to have been approved.
This rule sets a clear consequence when the proper officer does not act within the specified timeframes for various actions during the GST registration process. Here’s how it works:
1. Specified Timeframes: As discussed in previous rules (Rule 9(1), Rule 9(2), and Rule 9(3)), there are different timeframes for the proper officer to take specific actions, such as approving the registration within seven working days (Rule 9(1)), requesting additional information within seven working days (Rule 9(2)), and granting registration within seven working days from the receipt of satisfactory information (Rule 9(3)). Additionally, there’s a 30-day timeframe as a proviso under Rule 9(1) and Rule 9(2).
2. Deemed Approval: If the proper officer fails to take any action within the specified timeframes, the application for the grant of registration shall be deemed to have been approved. This means that the application is treated as if it has been approved automatically.
Example 1 (Rule 9(1)): Suppose XYZ Enterprises applied for GST registration on Monday, January 1, 2023. As per Rule 9(1), the proper officer should approve or reject the application within seven working days. If the proper officer doesn’t take any action by Monday, January 9, 2023, the application is deemed to have been approved.
Example 2 (Rule 9(2)): ABC Traders received a notice for additional information on Monday, January 9, 2023, as per Rule 9(2). They promptly submitted the requested documents. If the proper officer fails to take any further action by Monday, January 17, 2023 (within seven working days), the application is deemed to have been approved.
Example 3 (Rule 9(3)): DEF Corporation submitted satisfactory information to the proper officer on Monday, January 9, 2023, as per Rule 9(3). If the officer doesn’t grant registration by Monday, January 17, 2023 (within seven working days), the application is deemed to have been approved.
This rule is designed to ensure that the GST registration process remains efficient and does not get unnecessarily delayed due to inaction on the part of the proper officer. It provides businesses with a safeguard against undue delays and allows them to proceed with their operations if the tax authorities do not take the required action within the prescribed timeframes.
Rule 12 (3) – In respect of applications from the persons making TDS and TCS, proper officer may grant registration after due verification within a period of three working days from the date of submission of application.
Rule 12(3) of the Central Goods and Services Tax (CGST) Rules, 2017, addresses a specific provision regarding the timeline for granting GST registration to persons who are making Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) and Tax Collected at Source (TCS). This rule allows for a faster approval process for such applicants. Let’s analyse Rule 12(3) step by step:
Rule 12(3):
In respect of applications from the persons making TDS and TCS, the proper officer may grant registration after due verification within a period of three working days from the date of submission of the application.
This rule pertains to applicants who are required to make TDS or TCS as part of their business operations. When these entities apply for GST registration, the proper officer has the discretion to grant the registration after verifying the application, and this must be done within a shorter timeframe than the general application approval timelines. Here’s how it works:
1. Eligible Applicants: This provision applies to applicants who are involved in TDS and TCS. These are entities that are mandated to deduct tax at source when making certain payments (TDS) or collect tax at source when receiving payments (TCS).
2. Due Verification: Before granting the registration, the proper officer will conduct a verification of the application to ensure that it complies with all relevant requirements.
3. Timeline for Granting Registration: In this specific case, the proper officer may grant registration within a period of three working days from the date of submission of the application.
Example: XYZ Ltd., a company involved in TDS and TCS, submits its GST registration application on Monday, January 1, 2023. The proper officer reviews the application, conducts the necessary verification, and is satisfied that the application is in order. In such a scenario, the officer is allowed to grant GST registration to XYZ Ltd. by Thursday, January 4, 2023, which is within three working days from the date of application submission.
This rule recognizes the importance of efficient registration processes for entities engaged in TDS and TCS. It streamlines the approval timeline to ensure that these entities can carry out their tax-related responsibilities promptly, as any delays in their registration could affect the collection and deduction of taxes at source.
Rule 16 (3) – Every person shall apply for registration within ninety days from the date of grant of temporary registration. In case of appeal filed against temporary registration, application for registration shall be filed within thirty days from the date of issuance of the order dismissing the appeal.
Rule 16(3) of the Central Goods and Services Tax (CGST) Rules, 2017, deals with the timeline for applying for regular GST registration after being granted temporary registration. This rule also provides specific timeframes for applying for registration in the event of an appeal filed against the temporary registration. Let’s break down and analyze Rule 16(3) step by step:
Rule 16(3):
Every person shall apply for registration within ninety days from the date of grant of temporary registration. In case of an appeal filed against temporary registration, the application for registration shall be filed within thirty days from the date of issuance of the order dismissing the appeal.
This rule outlines two distinct scenarios:
Scenario 1: Applying for Regular Registration after Temporary Registration
When a person is granted temporary registration under GST, they are required to apply for regular GST registration within ninety days from the date of the grant of temporary registration.
Example (Scenario 1): ABC Enterprises is provisionally granted temporary GST registration on January 1, 2023. ABC Enterprises must apply for regular GST registration by April 1, 2023, which is within ninety days from the date of the temporary registration grant.
Scenario 2: Applying for Registration after an Appeal against Temporary Registration
If an appeal is filed against the provisional or temporary registration, and the appeal is dismissed, the applicant must apply for regular GST registration within thirty days from the date of issuance of the order dismissing the appeal.
Example (Scenario 2): XYZ Corporation filed an appeal against the provisional GST registration granted to them. The appeal was dismissed on February 15, 2023. Following the dismissal, XYZ Corporation must apply for regular GST registration by March 17, 2023, which is within thirty days from the date of the order dismissing the appeal.
These timelines are set to ensure that businesses do not unnecessarily operate with temporary registration for an extended period and to expedite the transition to regular GST registration when applicable. The rule also ensures that businesses comply with the requirement to obtain regular GST registration within a reasonable timeframe after the grant of temporary registration.
Rule 19 (1) – In case of changes in the particulars of registration, application shall be submitted within fifteen days of such change. Where approval of amendments is required, proper officer shall approve within fifteen working days from the date of receipt of application.
Rule 19(1) of the Central Goods and Services Tax (CGST) Rules, 2017, pertains to the process of amending the particulars of GST registration in case of any changes. This rule establishes timelines for businesses to submit applications for amendments and for the proper officer to approve such amendments. Let’s break down and analyse Rule 19(1) step by step:
Rule 19(1):
In case of changes in the particulars of registration, the application shall be submitted within fifteen days of such change. Where the approval of amendments is required, the proper officer shall approve within fifteen working days from the date of receipt of the application.
This rule addresses two key aspects:
1. Timelines for Application Submission:
When there are changes in the particulars of a business’s GST registration (e.g., a change in the address, addition of a new place of business, or change in contact information), the business is required to submit an application for these amendments within fifteen days of the change.
Example (Timelines for Application Submission):
XYZ Traders moved to a new business address on January 15, 2023. They must submit an application for amending their GST registration with the new address by January 30, 2023, which is within fifteen days of the change.
2. Timelines for Approval of Amendments:
In cases where the proper officer’s approval is required for the requested amendments, the officer shall approve the amendments within fifteen working days from the date of receiving the application.
Example (Timelines for Approval of Amendments):
ABC Manufacturing applies for an amendment to their GST registration to include a new place of business on February 1, 2023. The proper officer, upon receiving the application, must approve or reject the amendment by February 16, 2023, which is within fifteen working days.
This rule is important as it ensures that the GST registration details are kept up to date and accurate. Timely submission and approval of amendments are crucial for compliance and maintaining the integrity of the GST system. It also provides businesses with clear timelines for making changes to their registration, thereby reducing any potential delays or uncertainties in their operations.
Rule 19 (2) – If the proper officer is of the opinion that the amendments are not warranted, he may within fifteen working days issue a notice.
Rule 19(2) of the Central Goods and Services Tax (CGST) Rules, 2017, pertains to the situation where the proper officer reviewing an application for amendments to a GST registration is of the opinion that the requested amendments are not warranted. This rule allows the officer to issue a notice within a specified timeframe to communicate their decision. Let’s analyse Rule 19(2) step by step:
Rule 19(2):
If the proper officer is of the opinion that the amendments are not warranted, he may within fifteen working days issue a notice.
This rule outlines the following key points:
1. Officer’s Discretion: The proper officer, while reviewing an application for amendments to a GST registration, has the discretion to determine whether the requested amendments are necessary or justified.
2. Notice Issuance: If the proper officer, after evaluation, forms an opinion that the amendments are not warranted, they are authorized to issue a notice to communicate this decision.
3. Timeline for Notice: The notice must be issued within fifteen working days from the date of receiving the application for amendments.
Example: ABC Traders applied for an amendment to their GST registration on January 15, 2023, requesting a change in their business address. The proper officer received the application on the same day. After reviewing the application, the officer concluded that the change in address was not warranted, perhaps due to incorrect documentation or other reasons. In this case, the officer must issue a notice to ABC Traders communicating their opinion that the amendments are not justified by January 30, 2023, which is within fifteen working days from the date of receiving the application.
This rule is designed to ensure that there is a clear and specified timeframe within which the proper officer must communicate their opinion regarding the requested amendments. It allows businesses to be promptly informed if their amendment request is not going to be approved, allowing them to take appropriate actions or make necessary corrections to their application.
Rule 19 (3) — The registered person shall file reply to the show cause notice within seven working days.
Rule 19(3) of the Central Goods and Services Tax (CGST) Rules, 2017, outlines the requirement for a registered person to file a reply to a show cause notice within a specified time frame. This rule is an important part of the process when the tax authorities raise concerns or issues related to the GST registration. Let’s break down and analyse Rule 19(3) step by step:
Rule 19(3):
The registered person shall file a reply to the show cause notice within seven working days.
This rule deals with the following aspects:
1. Show Cause Notice: A show cause notice is a formal communication from the tax authorities, usually in response to issues or concerns regarding a registered person’s GST registration. The notice outlines the reasons or issues for which the registered person is required to provide a response.
2. Timeline for Filing Reply: As per Rule 19(3), the registered person who receives a show cause notice must file a reply within seven working days from the date of receipt of the notice.
Example: ABC Ltd., a registered business, receives a show cause notice from the tax authorities on Monday, January 1, 2023. The notice specifies certain discrepancies in their GST registration. As per Rule 19(3), ABC Ltd. is required to file a reply to the show cause notice by Monday, January 9, 2023, which is within seven working days from the date of receipt of the notice.
This rule is crucial for the efficiency and transparency of the GST registration process. It ensures that registered persons have a reasonable amount of time to respond to any concerns raised by the tax authorities and provide clarifications or corrections as necessary. Timely responses to show cause notices are essential for resolving issues and maintaining the integrity of the GST system.
Rule 19 (5) – Please see for deemed amendments to registration certificate, on failure to take action by the proper officer.
Rule 19(5) of the Central Goods and Services Tax (CGST) Rules, 2017, deals with the concept of deemed amendments to the registration certificate when the proper officer fails to take action. This rule addresses situations where the proper officer does not act within the specified timeframes, and as a result, certain changes to the registration certificate are deemed to have occurred. Let’s analyse Rule 19(5) step by step:
Rule 19(5):
Please see for deemed amendments to the registration certificate, on failure to take action by the proper officer.
This rule is somewhat succinct, and it suggests that amendments to the registration certificate can be deemed to have occurred when the proper officer fails to take action. The term “deemed” means that the change is considered to have happened by operation of law, even if the officer did not formally approve or process the amendment.
Examples of Deemed Amendments (on failure to take action):
1. Change in Address: Suppose ABC Traders applied for an amendment to change their business address, and they followed all the necessary procedures, but the proper officer failed to respond within the prescribed time frame. In this case, the change in the business address would be deemed to have occurred.
2. Addition of New Place of Business: XYZ Corporation requested an amendment to add a new place of business to their registration, and they submitted all the required documentation. If the proper officer did not respond within the stipulated time, the new place of business would be deemed to have been added.
3. Change in Legal Entity: DEF Manufacturing, after a merger, applied to update their registration to reflect the new legal entity. If the proper officer did not take action within the specified timeframe, the change in legal entity would be deemed to have occurred.
The purpose of Rule 19(5) is to prevent undue delays in the registration amendment process due to inaction on the part of the proper officer. It provides businesses with a safeguard, ensuring that necessary amendments are deemed to have occurred if the tax authorities fail to process these changes within the specified timeframes. This way, businesses can continue their operations without unnecessary interruptions. However, it’s important to note that the specifics of what amendments are deemed to have occurred may be defined in the related provisions or notifications issued by the tax authorities.
Author Bio
