Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Income Tax

No Exempt Income, No Section 14A Disallowance: ITAT Bangalore

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2026 taxguru.in 19162
Case Name
Indus Valley Properties Private Limited Vs ITO (ITAT Bangalore)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Related Assessment Year
2017-18
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Indus Valley Properties Private Limited Vs ITO (ITAT Bangalore)

Summary: The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Bangalore SMC Bench, in Indus Valley Properties Private Limited Vs ITO, allowed the assessee’s appeal for Assessment Year 2017-18 and directed deletion of a disallowance of ₹17,70,833 made under Section 14A of the Income-tax Act, 1961, read with Rule 8D of the Income-tax Rules, 1962. The Tribunal held that where an assessee has not earned any exempt income during the relevant previous year, no disallowance under Section 14A can be sustained for the assessment year under consideration. It further relied on judicial precedents holding that the Explanation inserted in Section 14A by the Finance Act, 2022 applies prospectively.

The assessee, a private limited company, filed its return of income on 31 October 2017 declaring income of ₹2,81,233. Its case was selected for limited scrutiny concerning expenditure incurred for earning exempt income. During assessment proceedings, the Assessing Officer noticed that the assessee had invested ₹25 crore in India Build Villas Development Private Limited through India REIT Fund. The investment was financed through a loan from Axis Finance, described as “Axix Finance” in the assessment order as reproduced by the Tribunal. The Assessing Officer issued a show-cause notice proposing disallowance of expenditure under Section 14A.

The assessee maintained that it had not earned any exempt income during the relevant financial year and consequently the provisions of Section 14A were inapplicable. Nevertheless, the Assessing Officer computed a disallowance of ₹23,61,111 by applying 1% to the annual average investment under Rule 8D. The assessment order was passed under Section 143(3) on 31 October 2019.

Aggrieved, the assessee preferred an appeal before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals). It reiterated that the absence of exempt income was sufficient to invalidate the disallowance. However, the CIT(A), by order dated 30 December 2024, recomputed the amount and sustained a disallowance of ₹17,70,833. The assessee consequently approached the Tribunal, specifically raising Ground No. 4 that no disallowance could be made under Section 14A when no exempt income had been earned.

Before the Tribunal, the authorised representative repeated the assessee’s contention that Section 14A could not operate without exempt income. The Departmental Representative supported the lower authorities and argued that disallowance could be made even where exempt income had not arisen during the year. The Revenue referred to the CBDT circular and the statutory amendment concerning Section 14A.

After examining the rival submissions and the paper book, the Tribunal recorded that the assessee had not earned any exempt income during the year. It relied on several decisions of the Delhi High Court, including Cheminvest Ltd. v. CIT, PCIT v. Alchemist Ltd., PCIT v. Era Infrastructure (India) Ltd. and PCIT v. Sahara India Finance Corporation Ltd., supporting the proposition that Section 14A disallowance cannot be made in the absence of exempt income. The Tribunal also referred to the Karnataka High Court decision in Biocon Ltd. v. DCIT, which had adopted the same position.

The Tribunal separately considered the Explanation inserted in Section 14A by the Finance Act, 2022. It reproduced an extensive extract from a Gauhati High Court judgment reported at [2024] 166 taxmann.com 607, which examined the legislative memorandum accompanying the Finance Bill, 2022 and several judicial decisions on prospective operation. The quoted judgment considered the Delhi High Court’s ruling in Era Infrastructure (India) Ltd., the Supreme Court’s principles in Sedco Forex International Drill Inc. v. CIT and M.M. Aqua Technologies Ltd. v. CIT, and decisions of other High Courts. These authorities explained that an amendment described as clarificatory or introduced for removal of doubts cannot automatically be applied retrospectively where it changes the existing legal position.

The legislative memorandum expressly stated that the amendment would take effect from 1 April 2022 and apply from Assessment Year 2022-23 onwards. Accordingly, the Tribunal accepted the judicial position that the Explanation could not be retrospectively applied to Assessment Year 2017-18. Since the assessee had earned no exempt income during that year, the disallowance sustained by the CIT(A) could not survive.

The Tribunal therefore reversed the orders of the lower authorities and directed the Assessing Officer to delete the entire disallowance of ₹17,70,833. Ground No. 4 was allowed, while the remaining grounds were treated as infructuous and were not separately adjudicated. The assessee’s appeal was allowed by the order pronounced on 9 June 2025.

Cases Discussed

  • Principal Commissioner of Income-tax v. Alchemist Ltd., [2024] 167 taxmann.com 284 (Delhi High Court). Cited by the Tribunal among the authorities supporting the proposition that disallowance under Section 14A is impermissible in the absence of exempt income.
  • Principal Commissioner of Income-tax v. Sahara India Finance Corporation Ltd., [2024] 168 taxmann.com 165 (Delhi High Court). Relied upon by the Tribunal in support of the principle that Section 14A disallowance cannot be sustained without exempt income.
  • Principal Commissioner of Income-tax v. Keti Construction Ltd., [2024] 162 taxmann.com 278 (Madhya Pradesh High Court). Referred to in the reproduced Gauhati High Court judgment as supporting prospective application of the Finance Act, 2022 amendment.
  • Principal Commissioner of Income-tax v. Avantha Realty Ltd., [2024] 164 taxmann.com 376 (Calcutta High Court). The reproduced judgment noted that the Calcutta High Court followed Era Infrastructure in holding that the Explanation inserted in Section 14A could not apply retrospectively.
  • Principal Commissioner of Income-tax v. Jas Toll Road Company Ltd., ITAT/7/2024, decided on 26/02/2024 (Calcutta High Court). The reproduced Gauhati High Court judgment discussed this authority concerning the prospective operation of the Section 14A amendment and the absence of exempt income.
  • Principal Commissioner of Income-tax v. Uniparts India Ltd., [2024] 160 taxmann.com 92 (Delhi High Court). Referred to in the reproduced judgment for the settled position concerning prospective application of the Finance Act, 2022 amendment.
  • Principal Commissioner of Income-tax (Central)-2 v. Era Infrastructure India Ltd., ITA No. 359/2024, order dated 16/07/2024 (Delhi High Court). The reproduced Gauhati High Court judgment noted that the Revenue’s appeal was dismissed following the earlier decision in Era Infrastructure.
  • Principal Commissioner of Income-tax v. Era Infrastructure (India) Ltd., [2022] 448 ITR 674; ITA No. 204/2022; 20/07/2022 (Delhi High Court). The Tribunal relied upon the principle that the amendment to Section 14A by the Finance Act, 2022 is prospective and applies from Assessment Year 2022-23.
  • M.M. Aqua Technologies Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income-tax, Delhi-III, [2021] SCC OnLine SC 575; [2021] 436 ITR 582 (Supreme Court). Quoted in the reproduced Gauhati High Court judgment concerning the interpretation of statutory Explanations and the principle that an amendment changing the law is not necessarily retrospective merely because it uses clarificatory language.
  • Biocon Ltd. v. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, [2021] 125 taxmann.com 164 (Karnataka High Court). Directly relied upon by the Tribunal for the proposition that where no exempt income accrued during the relevant year, disallowance under Section 14A cannot be made.
  • Cheminvest Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income-tax, [2015] 378 ITR 33 (Delhi High Court). Cited directly by the Tribunal for the principle that Section 14A does not apply where no exempt income is received or receivable during the relevant previous year.
  • Sedco Forex International Drill Inc. v. Commissioner of Income-tax, [2005] 279 ITR 310; (2005) 12 SCC 717 (Supreme Court). Discussed within the reproduced judicial extract concerning the prospective operation of amendments that alter existing law notwithstanding the use of expressions such as “for removal of doubts”.
  • Commissioner of Income-tax v. Goslino Mario, [2000] 241 ITR 312; (2000) 10 SCC 165 (Supreme Court). Referred to in the reproduced Supreme Court reasoning concerning application of the law in force during the relevant assessment year.
  • Shyam Sunder v. Ram Kumar, (2001) 8 SCC 24 (Supreme Court). Cited within the reproduced Supreme Court extract on the distinction between clarificatory provisions and amendments changing substantive law.
  • Commissioner of Income-tax v. S.R. Patton, (1998) 8 SCC 608 (Supreme Court). Referred to in the legislative-history discussion reproduced from Sedco Forex.
  • Brij Mohan Das Laxman Das v. Commissioner of Income-tax, (1997) 1 SCC 352 (Supreme Court). Cited within the reproduced judgment on principles governing statutory Explanations.
  • Commissioner of Income-tax v. Podar Cement (P.) Ltd., (1997) 5 SCC 482 (Supreme Court). Referred to in the reproduced discussion on the interpretative operation of clarificatory amendments.
  • Commissioner of Income-tax v. Patel Bros. & Co. Ltd., (1995) 4 SCC 485 (Supreme Court). Cited in the reproduced Sedco Forex extract concerning legislative intent and prospective application.
  • Commissioner of Income-tax v. S.R. Patton, [1992] 193 ITR 49 (Kerala High Court). Discussed within the reproduced Supreme Court extract regarding the scope and commencement of an Explanation to Section 9(1)(ii).
  • Sonia Bhatia v. State of Uttar Pradesh, (1981) 2 SCC 585 (Supreme Court). Referred to in the reproduced discussion distinguishing Explanations that clarify existing provisions from those that expand their scope.
  • Reliance Jute and Industries Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income-tax, (1980) 1 SCC 139 (Supreme Court). Cited for the principle that the law applicable to an assessment ordinarily is the law in force during the relevant assessment year.
  • Commissioner of Income-tax v. S.G. Pgnatale, [1980] 124 ITR 391 (Gujarat High Court). Discussed in the reproduced Sedco Forex judgment concerning the historical interpretation of Section 9(1)(ii).
  • Commissioner of Income-tax v. Goslino Mario, [2000] 241 ITR 314 (Gauhati High Court). Discussed in the reproduced Supreme Court extract regarding the prospective operation of statutory amendments affecting earlier assessment years.
  • Commissioner of Income-tax v. Chettinad Logistics Pvt. Ltd., [2018] 95 taxmann.com 250 (Supreme Court). Mentioned within the reproduced Calcutta High Court decision concerning disallowance under Section 14A in the absence of exempt income.
  • Principal Commissioner of Income-tax v. Oil Industries Development Board, SLP (Civil) Diary No. 2755/2019 (Supreme Court). Mentioned in the reproduced Calcutta High Court judgment as an authority noted in the proceedings.

FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF ITAT BANGALORE

1. This appeal is filed by Indus Valley Properties Pvt. Ltd., (the assessee/appellant) for the assessment year 2017-18 against the appellate order passed by the CIT(Appeals)-1, Noida [ld. CIT(A)] dated 30.12.2024 for AY 2017-18 wherein the appeal filed by the assessee against the assessment order passed u/s. 143(3) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 [the Act] dated 31.10.2019 wherein disallowance of Rs.23,61,111 was made u/s. 14A r.w. Rule 8D was reduced to Rs.17,70,833 and the appeal of the assessee was partly allowed. Thus assessee is in appeal stating that the disallowance made by the ld. AO and confirmed by the ld. CIT(A) is not correct.

2. Various grounds of appeal are raised against the disallowance, but ground No.4 is that the assessee has not earned any exempt income and therefore there should not be any disallowance u/s 14 A of the Act.

3. The brief facts of the case show that assessee is a company, filed its return of income for AY 2017-18 on 31.10.2017 declaring returned income of Rs.2,81,233. The case of the assessee was taken up for limited scrutiny with respect to examination of the expenses incurred for earning exempt income.

4. During the examination, the ld. AO found that the assessee made investment of Rs. 25 crores in India Build Villas Development Pvt. Ltd. through India REIT fund. The above investment was made out of the loan from Axix Finance. Therefore, assessee was issued show cause notice that why expenditure incurred for earning exempt income should not be disallowed.

5. The assessee submitted that provisions of section 14A of the Act does not apply to the assessee as it has no exempt income earned during the year and therefore no disallowance can be made.

6. The ld. AO despite the above fact computed the disallowance taking 1% of annual average of investment and worked out the disallowance of Rs. 23,61,111 u/s. 14A of the Act r.w. Rule 8D. Assessment order u/s. 143(3) of the Act was passed on 31.10.2019.

7. The assessee preferred appeal before the ld. CIT(Appeals) wherein amongst other submissions, assessee submitted that it has earned no exempt income and therefore provisions of section 14A of the Act does not apply. The ld. CIT(A) ignored the above submission and after recomputation, confirmed the disallowance of Rs.17,70,833. The assessee is in appeal before us on the same issue.

8. The ld. AR reiterated the submissions made before the lower authorities that assessee has not earned any exempt income during the year and therefore the disallowance u/s. 14A of the Act cannot be made.

9. The ld. DR vehemently supported the order of the ld. lower authorities stating that even if there is no exempt income earned during the year, disallowance u/s. 14A can be made. He referred to the Circular as well as amendment to the I.T. Act.

10. We have carefully considered the rival contentions and perused the orders of ld. lower authorities. According to the paperbook submitted before us, it is apparent that assessee has not earned any exempt income during the year. It has been held by several judicial precedents that if there is no exempt income earned during the year, no disallowance u/s. 14A of the Act can be made. We find that if there is no exempt income, there cannot be any disallowance u/s. 14A of the Act, as has been held so by the Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of:-

  • Cheminvest Ltd. v. CIT [2015] 378 ITR 33 (Del)
  • PCIT v. Alchemist Ltd., 167 taxmann.com 284
  • PCIT v. Era Infrastructure Ltd., 448 ITR 674 (Del)
  • PCIT v. Sahara India Finance Corporation Ltd., 168 taxmann.com 165

11. Further the Hon’ble Karnataka High Court in the case of Biocon Ltd. v. DCIT in 125 taxmann.com 164 has also categorically held that where there was no exempt income accrued to the assessee during the year, no disallowance can be made u/s. 14A of the Act.

12. Regarding retrospective applicability of explanation introduced u/s 14 A of the Act with effect from 1/4/2022, honourable Gauhati High court in [2024] 166 taxmann.com 607 (Gauhati) where in it is held that such explanation is prospective in nature as under :-

13. Heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and also perused the material placed on record.

The Explanation to Section 14A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 is inserted vide Finance Bill, 2022. The Ministry of Finance, Union of India, issued Memorandum Explaining the Provisions in the Finance Bill, 2022.

The relevant extract of the said Memorandum reads as under:

“Clarification in respect of disallowance under Section 14A in absence of any exempt income during an assessment year.

Section 14A of the Act provides that no deduction shall be allowed in respect of expenditure incurred by the assessee in relation to income that does not form part of the total income as per the provisions of the Act (exempt income).

2. Over the years, disputes have arisen in respect of the issue whether disallowance under section 14A of the Act can be made in cases where no exempt income has accrued, arisen or received by the assessee during an assessment year.

3. The CBDT issued Circular No.5 of 2014, dated 11/02/2014, clarifying that rule 8D read with Section 14A of the Act provides for disallowance of the expenditure even where tax payer in a particular year has not earned any exempt income. However, still some courts have taken a view that if there is no exempt income during a year, no disallowance under section 14A of the Act can be made for that year. Such an interpretation is not in line with the intention of the Legislature. To illustrate, if during a previous year, an assessee incurs an expense of Rs. 1 lakh to earn non-exempt income of Rs. 1.5 lakh and also incurs an expense of Rs. 20,000 to earn exempt income which may or may not have accrued/received during the year. By holding that provisions of section 14A of the Act does not apply in this year as the exempt income was not accrued/received during the year, it amounts to holding that Rs.20,000 would be allowed as deduction against non-exempt income of Rs.1.5 lakh even though this expense was not incurred wholly and exclusively for the purpose of earning non-exempt income. Such an interpretation defeats the legislative intent of both Section 14A as well as Section 37of the Act.

4. In order to make the intention of the legislation clear and to make it free from any misinterpretation, it is proposed to insert an Explanation to section 14A of the Act to clarify that notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in this Act, the provisions of this section shall apply and shall be deemed to have always applied in a case where exempt income has not accrued or arisen or has not been received during the previous year relevant to an assessment year and the expenditure has been incurred during the said previous year in relation to such exempt income.

5. This amendment will take effect from 1st April, 2022.

6. It is also proposed to amend sub-section (1) of the said section, so as to include a non-obstante clause in respect of other provisions of the Income-tax act and provide that no deduction shall be allowed in relation to exempt income, notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in this Act.

7. This amendment will take effect from 1st April, 2022 and will accordingly apply in relation to the assessment year 2022-23 and subsequent assessment years.”

14. Taking note of above, the Division Bench of Delhi High Court in “Era Infrastructure (India) Ltd., Judgment dated 20.07.2022” (supra), considering the question whether the Explanation inserted to Section 14A of Act of 1961 is retrospective or prospective in nature, has held as under:

“However a perusal of the Memorandum of the Finance Bill, 2022 ([2022]440 ITR (St.) 226) reveals that it explicitly stipulates that the amendment made to Section 14A will take effect from 1st April, 2022 and will apply in relation to the assessment year 2022-23 and subsequent assessment years. The relevant extract of Clauses 4, 5, 6 & 7 of the Memorandum of Finance Bill, 2022 are reproduced hereinbelow:

“4. In order to make the intention of the legislation clear and to make it free from any misinterpretation, it is proposed to insert an Explanation to section 14A of the Act to clarify that notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in this Act, the provisions of this section shall apply and shall be deemed to have always applied in a case where exempt income has not accrued or arisen or has not been received during the previous year relevant to an assessment year and the expenditure has been incurred during the said previous year in relation to such exempt income.

5. This amendment will take effect from 1st April, 2022.

6. It is also proposed to amend sub-section (1) of the said section, so as to include a non-obstante clause in respect of other provisions of the Incometax Act and provide that no deduction shall be allowed in relation to exempt income, notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in this Act.

7. This amendment will take effect from 1st April, 2022 and will accordingly apply in relation to the assessment year 2022-23 and subsequent assessment years.”

(emphasis supplied)

Furthermore, the Supreme Court in Sedco Forex International Drill. Inc. v. CIT, (2005) 12 SCC 717 has held that a retrospective provision in a tax act which is “for the removal of doubts” cannot be presumed to be retrospective, even where such language is used, if it alters or changes the law as it earlier stood. The relevant extract of the said judgment is reproduced herein below (page 316 of 279 ITR)

“The High Court did not refer to the 1999 Explanation in upholding the inclusion of salary for the field break periods in the assessable income of the employees of the appellant. However, the respondents have urged the point before us.

In our view the 1999 Explanation could not apply to assessment years for the simple reason that it had not come into effect then. Prior to introducing the 1999 Explanation, the decision in CIT v. S.G. Pgnatale [[1980] 4 Taxman 79/124 ITR 391 (Gujarat)] was followed in 1989 by a Division Bench of the Gauhati High Court in CIT v. Goslino Mario [[2000] 241 ITR 314 (Gauhati)]. It found that the 1983 Explanation had been given effect from 1-4-1979 whereas the year in question in that case was 1976-77 and said (page 318) :

‘……It is settled law that assessment has to be made with reference to the law which is in existence at the relevant time. The mere fact that the assessments in question had somehow remained pending on 1-4-1979, cannot be cogent reason to make the Explanation applicable to the cases of the present assessees. This fortuitous circumstance cannot take away the vested rights of the assessees at hand.’

The reasoning of the Gauhati High Court was expressly affirmed by this Court in CIT v. Goslino Mario [(2000) 10 SCC 165 : [2000] 241 ITR 312 (SC)]. These decisions are thus authorities for the proposition that the 1983 Explanation expressly introduced with effect from a particular date would not effect the earlier assessment years.

In this state of the law, on 27-2-1999 the Finance Bill, 1999 substituted the Explanation to Section 9(1)(ii) (or what has been referred to by us as the 1999 Explanation). Section 5 of the Bill expressly stated that with effect from 1-4-2000, the substituted Explanation would read:

‘Explanation.–For the removal of doubts, it is hereby declared that the income of the nature referred to in this clause payable for–

(a) service rendered in India; and

(b) the rest period or leave period which is preceded and succeeded by services rendered in India and forms part of the service contract of employment,

shall be regarded as income earned in India.”

The Finance Act, 1999 which followed the Bill incorporated the substituted Explanation to Section 9(1)(ii) without any change. The Explanation as introduced in 1983 was construed by the Kerala High Court in CIT v. S.R. Patton [(1992] [1991] 65 Taxman 472/193 ITR 49 (Kerala), while following the Gujarat High Court’s decision in CIT v. S.G. Pgnatale [[1980] 4 Taxman 79/124 ITR 391 (Gujarat)] to hold that the Explanation was not declaratory but widened the scope of Section 9(1)(ii). It was further held that even if it were assumed to be clarificatory or that it removed whatever ambiguity there was in Section 9(1)(ii) of the Act, it did not operate in respect of periods which were prior to 1-4-1979. It was held that since the Explanation came into force from 1-4-1979, it could not be relied on for any purpose for an anterior period.

In the appeal preferred from the decision by the Revenue before this Court, the Revenue did not question this reading of the Explanation by the Kerala High Court, but restricted itself to a question of fact viz. whether the Tribunal had correctly found that the salary of the assessee was paid by a foreign company. This Court dismissed the appeal holding that it was a question of fact. (CIT v. S.R. Patton [(1998) 8 SCC 608]). Given this legislative history of Section 9(1)(ii), we can only assume that it was deliberately introduced with effect from 1-4-2000 and therefore intended to apply prospectively [See CIT v. Patel Bros. & Co. Ltd., (1995) 4 SCC 485, 494. It was also understood as such by CBDT which issued Circular No. 779 dated 14-9-1999 containing Explanatory Notes on the provisions of the Finance Act, 1999 insofar as it related to direct taxes. It said in paras 5.2 and 5.3 :

‘5.2 The Act has expanded the existing Explanation which states that salary paid for services rendered in India shall be regarded as income earned in India, so as to specifically provide that any salary payable for the rest period or leave period which is both preceded and succeeded by service in India and forms part of the service contract of employment will also be regarded as income earned in India.

5.3 This amendment will take effect from 1-4-2000, and will accordingly, apply in relation to Assessment Year 2000-2001 and subsequent years.’

The departmental understanding of the effect of the 1999 Amendment even if it were assumed not to bind the respondents under Section 119 of the Act, nevertheless affords a reasonable construction of it, and there is no reason why we should not adopt it.

As was affirmed by this Court in Goslino Mario [(2000) 10 SCC 165 : [2000] 241 ITR 312 (SC)] a cardinal principle of the tax law is that the law to be applied is that which is in force in the relevant assessment year unless otherwise provided expressly or by necessary implication. (See also Reliance Jute and Industries Ltd. v. CIT [(1980) 1 SCC 139 : 1980 SCC (Tax) 67]. An Explanation to a statutory provision may fulfil the purpose of clearing up an ambiguity in the main provision or an Explanation can add to and widen the scope of the main section [See Sonia Bhatia v. State of U.P., (1981) 2 SCC 585, 598 : AIR 1981 SC 1274, 1282 para 24]. If it is in its nature clarificatory then the Explanation must be read into the main provision with effect from the time that the main provision came into force [See Shyam Sunder v. Ram Kumar, (2001) 8 SCC 24 (para 44); Brij Mohan Das Laxman Das v. CIT, (1997) 1 SCC 352, 354; CIT v. Podar Cement (P) Ltd., (1997) 5 SCC 482, 506]. But if it changes the law it is not presumed to be retrospective, irrespective of the fact that the phrases used are “it is declared” or “for the removal of doubts”.

(emphasis supplied)

7. The aforesaid proposition of law has been reiterated by the Supreme Court in M.M Aqua Technologies Ltd. V. Commissioner of Income Tax, Delhi-III, [2021] SCC OnLine SC 575. The relevant portion of the said judgment is reproduced hereinbelow (page 597 OF 436 ITR):-

“Second, a retrospective provision in a tax act which is “for the removal of doubts” cannot be presumed to be retrospective, even where such language is used, if it alters or changes the law as it earlier stood. This was stated in Sedco Forex International Drill. Inc. v. CIT, (2005) 12 SCC 717 as follows (page 318 of 279 ITR):

’17. As was affirmed by this Court in Goslino Mario [(2000) 10 SCC 165] a cardinal principle of the tax law is that the law to be applied is that which is in force in the relevant assessment year unless otherwise provided expressly or by necessary implication. (See also Reliance Jute and Industries Ltd. v. CIT [(1980) 1 SCC 139].) An Explanation to a statutory provision may fulfil the purpose of clearing up an ambiguity in the main provision or an Explanation can add to and widen the scope of the main section [See Ku. Sonia Bhatia v. State of U.P., (1981) 2 SCC 585]. If it is in its nature clarificatory then the Explanation must be read into the main provision with effect from the time that the main provision came into force [See Shyam Sunder v. Ram Kumar, (2001) 8 SCC 24; Brij Mohan Das Laxman Das v. CIT, (1997) 1 SCC 352; CIT v. Podar Cement (P) Ltd., (1997) 5 SCC 482]. But if it changes the law it is not presumed to be retrospective, irrespective of the fact that the phrases used are “it is declared” or “for the removal of doubts”.

18. There was and is no ambiguity in the main provision of Section 9(1)(ii). It includes salaries in the total income of an assessee if the assessee has earned it in India. The word “earned” had been judicially defined in S.G. Pgnatale [[1980] 4 Taxman 79/124 ITR 391 (Gujarat)] by the High Court of Gujarat, in our view, correctly, to mean as income “arising or accruing in India”. The amendment to the section by way of an Explanation in 1983 effected a change in the scope of that judicial definition so as to include with effect from 1979, “income payable for service rendered in India”.

19. When the Explanation seeks to give an artificial meaning to “earned in India” and brings about a change effectively in the existing law and in addition is stated to come into force with effect from a future date, there is no principle of interpretation which would justify reading the Explanation as operating retrospectively.”

(emphasis supplied)

Consequently, this Court is of the view that the amendment of Section 14A, which is “for removal of doubts” cannot be presumed to be retrospective even where such language is used, if it alters or changes the law as it earlier stood.”

15. In Era Infrastructure India Ltd., order dated 16.07.2024 (supra), the Delhi High Court, relying on the decision rendered in “Era Infrastructure (India) Ltd., Judgment dated 20.07.2022” (supra), has dismissed the appeal preferred on behalf of the Revenue.

16. The High Court of Kolkata in Jas Toll Road Company Ltd. (supra) has dismissed the appeal filed by the Revenue while relying on the decision of the Delhi High Court rendered in “Era Infrastructure (India) Ltd., Judgment dated 20.07.2022” (supra) and held that the explanation inserted to Section 14A by Finance Act, 2022 will be applicable prospectively.

The operative portion of the decision rendered in M/s Jas Toll Road Company Ltd. (supra) is reproduced hereunder:

“Upon careful consideration and going through the materials on record we find that the learned tribunal was fully justified in dismissing the appeal filed by the revenue affirming the order passed by the Commissioner of Income Tax [Appeals], Kolkata-20. The issue involved in the case is that whether disallowance under Section 14A of the Act can be made even if the assessee has not earned any exempt income, the issue is no longer res integra and there are several decisions to the effect that amendment made under Section 14A of the Act by Finance Act, 2022 will be applicable prospectively and disallowance should not exceed the exempt income earned by the assessee during the year.

The PCIT has also noted the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in CIT v. Chettinad Logistics Pvt. Ltd [2018] 95 taxmann.com 250/257 Taxman 2 (SC) and PCIT-18 v. Oil Industrices Development Board, SLP (Civil) Diary No.2755/2019.

Thus, we find no ground to interfere with the order passed by the learned tribunal.

Accordingly, the appeal is dismissed and the substantial questions of law are answered against the revenue.”

17. In Avantha Realty Ltd. (supra), the High Court of Calcutta, relying on the decision of Delhi High Court, rendered in “Era Infrastructure (India) Ltd., Judgment dated 20.07.2022” (supra), has dismissed the appeal filed by the Revenue and held that the Explanation inserted to Section 14A by Finance Act, 2022 will be applicable prospectively.

The operative portion of the decision in Avantha Realty Ltd. (supra) reads as under:

“Substantial questions Nos. D & E pertain to the deletion of the disallowance made under Section 14A of the Act. The learned Tribunal took note of the decision of the High Court of Delhi in Era Infrastructure (India) Ltd. (supra), which had taken note of the decision in the case of Cheminvest Ltd. (supra), wherein it was held that amendment by the Finance Act, 2022 of Section 14 A of the Act by inserting a non-obstante clause and explanation we take effect from 01.04.22 and cannot be presumed to have retrospective effect and, therefore, on facts the amendment cannot be applied to the assessment year under consideration. We find no error in such conclusion arrived at by the learned Tribunal.

Accordingly, substantial questions of law No.D & E are decided against the revenue.”

18. Later on, the Delhi High Court, in Uniparts India Ltd. (supra), has made a specific statement that so far as the applicability of Explanation inserted to Section 14A by Finance Bill, 2022 is concerned, it is settled that the same will apply prospectively.

19. The High Court of Madhya Pradesh has also followed the same view in Principal Commissioner of Income-tax (Central) v. Keti Construction Ltd. [2024] 162 taxmann.com 278 (Madhya Pradesh).

20. In view of the Memorandum Explaining the Provisions in the Finance Bill, 2022 and various decisions rendered by the different High Courts, we also hold that the Explanation inserted to Section 14A vide Finance Act, 2022 is applicable prospectively.”

13. Accordingly, respectfully following the decisions of the Hon’ble High Courts, we reverse the orders of the ld. lower authorities and direct the ld. AO to delete the disallowance u/s. 14A of the Act of Rs.17,70,833. Thus, ground No.4 of the appeal is allowed.

14. In view of our decision in ground No.4, all other grounds of appeal become infructuous and therefore do not require any adjudication.

15. In the result, the appeal filed by the assessee is allowed.

Pronounced in the open court on this 09th day of June, 2025.

Advertisement

Author Info

CA Sandeep Kanoi
Qualification: Graduate, CA in Job / Business, DD
Company: Taxguru Consultancy
Location: Mumbai, Maharashtra
Articles Published: 24,816

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.