Sundaram Fasteners Ltd. Vs ACIT (Madras High Court)
Summary: The Madras High Court, in Sundaram Fasteners Ltd. Vs Additional Commissioner of Income Tax, examined whether an upfront payment of ₹5,96,80,000 made to Mahindra World City for the right to use land could qualify for depreciation under Section 32 of the Income-tax Act, 1961, on the basis that the assessee had acquired a commercial right for use in its business. The assessee had initially claimed the upfront amount as revenue expenditure under Section 37. However, the question concerning deductibility as revenue expenditure was rejected when the appeal was admitted on 22 January 2019. The appeal was admitted only on the alternative question of eligibility for depreciation. During the hearing, the assessee relied on Commissioner of Income Tax Vs Tamilnadu Road Development Company Ltd., T.C.A. Nos.220 to 225 of 2018, decided on 19 January 2021, while the Revenue relied on the Supreme Court’s decision in Commissioner of Income Tax Vs Alps Theatre, (1967) 65 ITR 377. The latter decision concerns the distinction between depreciable buildings and non-depreciable land, a principle also explained in the TaxGuru article Depreciation on Buildings as per Income Tax Law.
The Division Bench observed that the alternative claim for depreciation had not been raised in the appropriate form before the Assessing Officer, Commissioner (Appeals) or Tribunal. Although the foundational facts appeared to be available on record, the Assessing Officer had not been given an opportunity to examine the claim on its merits. Consequently, the High Court considered it premature to determine the applicability of the judicial precedents cited by either party. Instead, the Court remanded the factual issue relating to depreciation to the Assessing Officer for a fresh decision in accordance with law after considering the submissions of the assessee. The Tribunal’s order was upheld to the extent indicated in the judgment, while the substantial question of law concerning depreciation on the acquired commercial right was expressly left open. The Tax Case Appeal was allowed to that limited extent, without costs. Importantly, the judgment does not grant depreciation outright or finally determine whether the payment represents a depreciable intangible asset. The distinction between ownership of land and eligible depreciable assets is also considered in ITAT Delhi Allows Depreciation on Composite Cost of Leasehold Office Premises.
Cases Discussed:
- Commissioner of Income Tax Vs Alps Theatre (Supreme Court); (1967) 65 ITR 377 (SC) — Cited by the Revenue concerning depreciation. The High Court did not decide its applicability at this stage because the foundational factual issue required examination. The principle of this decision is discussed in Bifurcation of Consideration into Land and Building for Depreciation.
- Commissioner of Income Tax Vs Tamilnadu Road Development Company Ltd. (Madras High Court); T.C.A. Nos.220 to 225 of 2018; 19/01/2021 — Cited by the assessee in support of the depreciation claim. The High Court declined to examine its applicability before factual adjudication by the Assessing Officer.
FULL TEXT OF THE JUDGMENT OF MADRAS HIGH COURT
This appeal, filed by the assessee under Section 260A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, (‘the Act’ for brevity) is directed against the order dated 30.09.2016 made in ITA.No.591/Mds/2012 on the file of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, ‘D’ Bench, Chennai (‘the Tribunal’ for brevity) for the assessment year 2009-10.
2. The appeal was admitted on 22.01.2019 to decide the following substantial question of law:
“Whether Tribunal ought to have granted depreciation under Section 32 on the amount paid to SEZ as it had acquired commercial right for the use of the land for the purpose of business of the Assessee?”
3. We have elaborately heard Mr.R.Vijayaraghavan, appearing for M/s.Subbaraya Aiyar Padmanabhan, learned counsel for the appellant and Mr.J.Narayanasamy, learned Senior Standing Counsel appearing for the respondent-Revenue.
4. After elaborately hearing the submissions on either side and noting the substantial question of law on which the appeal was entertained, we find that this issue was not canvassed by the assessee before the Assessing Officer or the CIT(A) or for that matter at Tribunal and this is being raised as an alternate plea by the assessee. In fact, initially, the assessee had raised two substantial questions of law and the question on which this appeal was admitted was the 2nd question of law. So far as the 1st question of law was whether the Tribunal was right in law in holding that the upfront amount of Rs.5,96,80,000/- paid to Mahindra World city in consideration for the grant of use of land is not deductible as revenue expenditure under Section 37 of the Act.
5. The said issue was considered at the time of admission and by assigning reasons, the same was rejected and the appeal was admitted only on the aforementioned question of law.
6. The learned counsel for the appellant would place reliance on the decision of the Division Bench of this Court, to which one of us (TSSJ) was a party, in the case of Commissioner of Income Tax Vs. Tamilnadu Road Development Company Ltd. in T.C.A.Nos.220 to 225 of 2018, dated 19.01.2021.
7. Per contra, the learned Senior Standing Counsel for the respondent would place reliance on the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Commissioner of Income Tax Vs. Alps Theatre [(1967) 65 ITR 377].
8. In the considered view of this Court, these decisions cannot be looked into at this juncture, since foundational facts, though appear to have been on record, have not been canvassed by the assessee in the right form before the Assessing Officer to enable the Assessing Officer to take a decision in the matter. Nevertheless, this Court, having been satisfied that a issue arises for consideration in the assessee’s case, is of the view that the matter should be remanded back to the Assessing Officer for a decision to be taken on merits. Therefore, while upholding the order passed by the Tribunal to the extent indicated, insofar as the factual issue touching upon the question, which was framed for consideration, the matter stands remitted to the Assessing Officer for a decision to be taken on merits and in accordance with law, after taking note of the submissions that the assessee may make before the Assessing Officer.
9. In the result, the Tax Case Appeal is allowed to the extent indicated and matter stands remanded to the Assessing Officer and consequently, the substantial question of law is left open. No costs.






