Hemraj Prabhudas Chandel Vs ITO (ITAT Ahmedabad)
Assessee filed return declaring Rs.3,11,410/-. Case was selected for limited scrutiny to verify credit-card payments & demonetisation-period cash deposits. No compliance was made before AO despite eight opportunities, leading to best-judgment assessment u/s 144. AO added Rs.11,73,620 as unexplained cash expenditure towards credit-card payments u/s 69C & Rs.3,12,500 as unexplained cash deposit. Before Addl. CIT(A), assessee again made no appearance; however, the first appellate authority deleted the addition relating to cash deposit but sustained the Rs.11.73 lakh credit-card expenditure addition.
In second appeal, assessee explained delay of 435 days—frequent overseas travel as tour manager & reliance on previous counsel—supported by affidavit; delay was condoned. Assessee submitted that cash payments against the credit-card were sourced from cash withdrawals & some expenses were incurred for clients in the travel business. He sought one more opportunity to produce evidence.
Tribunal observed persistent non-compliance before both authorities, finding the explanation of “continuous travel” unconvincing. Once appeal was filed, it was assessee’s duty to track proceedings & ensure compliance; the blame cannot be shifted to counsel. Tribunal therefore imposed a cost of ₹5,000 to PMNRF as a condition. Subject to payment of cost, matter was remanded to the jurisdictional AO to allow the assessee one final opportunity to substantiate credit-card cash payments with proper evidence. AO may decide based on available records if assessee again defaults. Appeal allowed for statistical purposes.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.




