St. Peters Church Vs CIT (ITAT Mumbai)
Summary: Can a long-established public charitable institution be denied renewal of section 12AB registration because it cannot produce a formal trust deed that never existed? The Mumbai ITAT has answered that question in favour of St. Peters Church, Bandra. It set aside the rejection of the Church’s Form 10AB application and directed the Commissioner (Exemptions) to grant renewal in accordance with law.
The distinction that decided the case lies in Rule 17A(2). The Rule addresses both institutions created under a written instrument and institutions established otherwise than under an instrument. Insisting on a trust deed in every case would leave the second category without effect.
Why the Commissioner rejected the application
St. Peters Church applied in Form 10AB on 25 September 2025 for renewal of its regular registration. It explained that it had not been constituted under a separate written trust deed or Memorandum of Association. It was governed by Canon Law and was registered as a public charitable trust under the Maharashtra Public Trusts Act, 1950. To support its application, it furnished the papers filed with the Charity Commissioner and the certificate of registration issued by that authority.
The Commissioner considered those documents insufficient. In his view, they showed that the Church had been registered as a public trust but did not constitute the instrument by which it had been created or established. He also noted that no scheme for its management settled by the Charity Commissioner or a competent court had been supplied. Without what he regarded as a foundational instrument, he said he could not verify the Church’s objects, beneficiaries, administration and use of income and property. He rejected the renewal application on 29 March 2026.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.


