Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Corporate Law

GST ITC Denied for Failure to Prove Supplier Paid Tax: GSTAT Upholds Rs. 1.35 Lakh Demand

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2026 taxguru.in 19105
Case Name
Vintek Control Systems Vs Commissioner of Central Tax (GSTAT Bengaluru)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Courts
GSTAT
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Vintek Control Systems Vs Commissioner of Central Tax (GSTAT Bengaluru)

Summary: The Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal considered an appeal by Shri Kariyappa Alahalli Manjappa, proprietor of M/s Vintek Control Systems, concerning input tax credit claimed for financial year 2018-19. Scrutiny disclosed a difference between credit availed in GSTR-3B and credit appearing in GSTR-2A, comprising IGST of Rs. 1,32,655 and CGST and SGST of Rs. 1,288 each. The appellant attributed the mismatch to purchases from M/s Naveen’s and M/s Classic Power Company and contended that a genuine purchaser should not lose credit because of supplier default. The adjudicating authority confirmed tax, interest and penalty; the first appellate authority dismissed the challenge.

The Tribunal identified the central issue as whether the appellant had discharged the burden under Section 155 of proving compliance with Section 16(2)(c) of the CGST Act, including actual payment of tax by the suppliers. It examined the competing submissions concerning Suncraft Energy, Instakart Services, Bhandari Scrap Traders and other authorities discussed in the order. Applying its understanding of the Supreme Court’s later decision in Bhandari Scrap Traders, it held that Section 16(2)(c) remained applicable and could not be read down merely because the recipient claimed to be bona fide. It also acknowledged that a mismatch with GSTR-2A alone does not establish supplier non-payment for FY 2018-19.

Circular No. 183/15/2022-GST prescribed a mechanism for resolving mismatches for the relevant period, including supplier confirmation where the difference attributable to a supplier did not exceed Rs. 5 lakh. The appellant produced neither a supplier certificate nor a tax-payment confirmation, supplier GSTR-3B or other satisfactory evidence, despite repeated opportunities. Although the original adjudication did not apply the circular and the appellant missed the scheduled hearings, the first appellate authority identified the required certificate and the Tribunal afforded another opportunity. The Tribunal found no demonstrated prejudice warranting remand and concluded that the statutory burden had not been discharged.

The appellant also relied on a purchase order, supplier invoice, banking records and export documents to substantiate the alleged purchase and movement of a portable fire pump from Chennai. The Tribunal observed discrepancies between the supplier invoice and export documentation concerning classification and description, and the absence of e-way bills, transport receipts, freight evidence, goods-receipt records and stock entries. It did not find fraud or conclude that the exported goods were different; rather, it held that the documents did not establish the necessary connection between the claimed purchase and subsequent export. This discussion addressed the appellant’s own plea and was not treated as a fresh ground of demand.

Accordingly, the Tribunal upheld the ITC demand of Rs. 1,35,231 and penalty of Rs. 33,266. It sustained interest liability under Section 50(3) but directed the proper officer to calculate interest only on credit wrongly availed and utilised, in accordance with Rule 88B(3), and furnish the computation before recovery. The order preserved any entitlement to re-avail credit if suppliers subsequently discharged tax, subject to applicable law, and directed transmission of information to the authorities having jurisdiction over the suppliers. The appeal was dismissed without costs.

Cases Discussed

  • Bhandari Scrap Traders v. Union of India & Ors. — SLP (C) No. 23931 of 2026; order dated 24 July 2026. Discussed concerning Section 16(2)(c) and the effect of a reasoned dismissal of special leave petitions.
  • Maruti Enterprise v. Union of India — Gujarat High Court; case number not stated in supplied source. Discussed concerning the validity and operation of Section 16(2)(c).
  • Sumetco Alloys Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India — Civil Writ Petition No. 9323 of 2026; 13 August 2026. Discussed on the treatment of the later Supreme Court order.
  • Instakart Services Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India — W.P. No. 4917 of 2021; 9 February 2026. Cited for reading down Section 16(2)(c) and Rule 36(4).
  • Sahil Enterprises v. Union of India — Tripura High Court; 6 January 2026. Discussed as the precedent followed in Instakart Services.
  • Abhimaani Structures and Engineering Pvt. Ltd. v. Superintendent of Central Tax — W.P. No. 35021 of 2025; 28 November 2025. Discussed concerning failure to apply Circular No. 183/15/2022-GST.
  • Suncraft Energy Pvt. Ltd. v. Assistant Commissioner, State Tax — Calcutta High Court, M.A.T. No. 1218 of 2023; 2 August 2023. Relied on by appellant concerning supplier defaults and bona fide recipients.
  • State of Karnataka v. Ecom Gill Coffee Trading Pvt. Ltd. — Civil Appeal No. 230 of 2023; 13 March 2023; 2023 INSC 212. Discussed on evidentiary burden and proof of genuine transactions.
  • Union of India v. Bharti Airtel Ltd. — (2022) 4 SCC 328. Discussed on the nature of GSTR-2A.
  • Aastha Enterprises v. State of Bihar — Patna High Court; citation not stated in supplied source. Cited in first appellate order on ITC conditions.
  • Pinstar Automotive India Pvt. Ltd. — Madras High Court; full case title/citation not stated in supplied source. Cited in first appellate order.
  • ALD Automotive Pvt. Ltd. v. Commercial Tax Officer — (2019) 13 SCC 225. Discussed on the statutory nature of tax credit.
  • Jayam & Co. v. Assistant Commissioner — (2016) 15 SCC 125. Discussed on statutory conditions for tax credit.
  • Kunhayammed v. State of Kerala — (2000) 6 SCC 359. Discussed on the effect of reasoned SLP dismissal under Article 141.
  • State Bank of Patiala v. S.K. Sharma — (1996) 3 SCC 364. Discussed on procedural irregularity and prejudice.
  • D.Y. Beathel Enterprises — Citation not stated in supplied source. Relied on by appellant; full citation not provided.
  • Agarwal & Brothers — Citation not stated in supplied source. Relied on by appellant; full citation not provided.
  • Gopalakrishnan Pillai — Citation not stated in supplied source. Relied on by appellant; full citation not provided.

FULL TEXT OF THE ORIGINAL GSTAT ORDER
1. The Appellant purchased a fire pump from a supplier in Chennai fo r Rs. 14,00,000/-, tax included. According to the Appellant, the supplier did not report the sale in its returns. Nothing on record shows whether the supplier paid the tax to the Government. The Appellant nevertheless claims the input tax credit. Section 1 6(2)(c) of the CGST Act allows that credit only where the tax charged has actually been paid to the Government, and the Supreme Court has recently declined to interfere with a judgment upholding that provision. The question in this appeal is, therefore, es sentially one of fact: has the Appellant proved that the suppliers paid the tax?

2. This appeal is filed under Section 112 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (“the CGST Act”) against Order-in-Appeal No. 57/2025- 26 dated 30.05.2025 (DIN 20250557000000002E5A), passed in GST Appeal No. 117/2024-25 A-II (ADC) by the Joint Commiss ioner of Central Tax, GST Appeals-First Appellate Authority affirmed Order-in-Original No. 29/2024- 25 OIO SUPDT BNWD3 dated 24.04.2024 (DIN 20240457YX000000A146), passed under Section 73(9) by the Superintendent of Central Tax, BNWD- 3 Range, Bengaluru North-West Commissionerate (“the Adjudicating Authority”).

3. The Appellant, Shri Kariyappa Alahalli Manjappa, is the proprietor of M/s Vintek Control Systems, Plot No. 30P, 4/2, KIADB Industrial Area, 1st Phase, Dabaspet, Nelamangala Taluk, Bengaluru Rural – 562111 (GSTIN 29AJSPM4331K1ZN). The dispute relates to the financial year 2018-19. The authorities below invoked Sections 16(2)(c), 50(3), 73(1), 73(9) and 122(2)(a) of the CGST Act and of th e Karnataka Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (“the KGST Act”), read with Section 20 of the Integrated Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (“the IGST Act”) in respect of integrated tax.

4. The provisions of the KGST Act material to this appeal are identical to th ose of the CGST Act. A reference in this order to a provision of the CGST Act or of the Central Goods and Services Tax Rules, 2017 (“the CGST Rules”) shall include the corresponding provision of the KGST Act and the KGST Rules. By virtue of Section 20 of t he IGST Act, the same provisions govern integrated tax.

A. FACTS
5. On scrutiny of the returns for 2018- 19 under Section 61, the proper officer found that the input tax credit (“ITC”) availed in FORM GSTR- the credit reflected in FORM GSTR-2A. He communicated the discrepancy in FORM GST ASMT- 10 dated 03.10.2023. The Appellant replied in FORM GST ASMT-11 on 07.12.2023. The reply was not found acceptable.

6. A show cause notice in FORM GST DRC-01, No. 39/2023- 24 SUPDT BNWD3 dated 28.12.2023 (DIN 2023125 7YX000022222F), was thereupon issued under Section 73(1), proposing the following demand:

FY 2018-19 (Rs.) IGST CGST SGST
ITC availed as per GSTR-3B (a) 12,67,517 72,25,676 72,25,676
ITC in GSTR-2A as per GSTR-9 (b) 11,34,862 72,24,388 72,24,388
Difference (a − b) 1,32,655 1,288 1,288

7. The notice rested on a single ground, set out in its paragraphs 3.7 and 4.3: that the Appellant had availed credit on supplies on which the suppliers had not paid the tax to the Government, contrary to Section 16(2). The notice relied only on the Appellant’s own returns and the ASMT-10. It did not allege that the goods were not received, that any invoice was fictitious, or that there was fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression. By paragraph 8, the Appellant wa s called upon to “produce all the evidence which he intends to rely upon in support of his defence”.

8. The Appellant replied on 06.02.2024. He attributed the difference to two suppliers who had not filed FORM GSTR-Street, Royapuram, Chennai – 600013 (GSTIN 33ADHPN3168J1ZE), and M/s Classic Power Company, BSK 2nd Stage, Bengaluru. In respect of M/s Naveen’s, he took the tax of Rs. 1,50,000/- shown in the invoice, set off Rs. 17,345.46 of excess credit reflected in other months, a nd arrived at the IGST difference of Rs. 1,32,654.54. He stated that goods worth Rs. 14,00,000/- were purchased under Bill No. 1789N/2018 and paid for by net banking on 27.04.2018, 26.06.2018 and 27.06.2018. He contended that a bona fide purchaser cannot b e made to suffer for the default of the supplier, and relied on D.Y. Beathel Enterprises, Agarwal & Brothers, Suncraft Energy and Gopalakrishnan Pillai. No document was produced in respect of M/s Classic Power Company. In respect of M/s Naveen’s, no e-way bill, transport document or certificate from the supplier was produced.

9. The Adjudicating Authority fixed personal hearings on 16.02.2024, 20.03.2024 and 08.04.2024, and sent notices by speed post and by e-mail. The Appellant did not appear on any of those dates and did not seek an adjournment.

10. By the Order-in- Original dated 24.04.2024, the Adjudicating Authority held that the suppliers had not reported the invoices and “appear to have not paid the tax”, and that the Appellant had produced nothing to establi sh otherwise. It confirmed the demand of IGST Rs. 1,32,655/-, CGST Rs. 1,288/- and SGST Rs. 1,288/- under Section 73(9), ordered interest under Section 50(3), and imposed a penalty of Rs. 33,266/- (IGST Rs. 13,266/-, CGST Rs. 10,000/-SGST Rs. 10,000/-) u nder Section 122(2)(a) read with Section 73(9). The order does not refer to Circular No. 183/15/2022- GST, and does not record any verification of the suppliers’ returns.

11. The Appellant preferred a first appeal in FORM GST APL- 01 on 26.06.2024, within the time allowed, and made the pre- deposit under Section 107(6). At the hearing on 16.05.2025, the then Authorised Representative, Shri A. Ravish Rao, Chartered Accountant, submitted that M/s Naveen’s had not filed GSTR-1, that the Appellant had purchased a port able fire pump from that supplier and exported it, and that Suncraft Energy supported the Appellant’s case.

12. The First Appellate Authority dismissed the appeal on 30.05.2025. It applied paragraphs 4, 4.1.1 and 4.1.2 of Circular No. 183/15/2022- GST dated 27.12.2022, and also referred to Circular No. 193/05/2023- GST dated 17.07.2023. It held that, the difference for each supplier being below Rs. 5 lakh, the Appellant was required to produce a certificate from the supplier confirming payment of the tax, and had produced none. It held that the dismissal in limine of the Revenue’s special leave petition in Suncraft Energy did not declare any law, and relied on ALD Automotive Pvt. Ltd. v. Commercial Tax Officer, M/s Aastha Enterprises v. State of Bihar (Patna High Court) and M/s Pinstar Automotive India Pvt. Ltd. (Madras High Court). Circular No. 193/05/2023-31.12.2021; we record the reference only as part of the history and do not rely on it.

13. Two observations in that order call for clarification. Paragraph 3 describes the notice as proposing a demand “under section 74”. That appears to be a typographical error, since the notice was issued, and the demand confirmed, under Section 73, and the rest of the order proceeds on tha t footing. The order also observes in passing that the Appellant furnished “proof of payment and receipt of goods”. It does not identify the document evidencing receipt, and it does not examine any e- way bill, transport record, stock record or export docum ent. The observation is therefore not a finding on receipt reached upon appraisal of evidence. We examine that question independently under Issue (iii).

B. THE APPEAL BEFORE THIS TRIBUNAL
14. The appeal in FORM GST APL-05 was verified on 06.05.2026. The grounds state that the authorities erred in disallowing credit of Rs. 1,35,231/- and in levying a penalty of Rs. 33,266/-. The amount in dispute is stated as Rs. 1,68,497/-.

15. The date of communication of the Order-in- Appeal is shown as 30.05.2025 in the online form and as 02.06.2025 in the statement of facts. Both dates fall Section 112(1), permitted appeals against such orders to be filed up to 30.06.2026, a date later extended. The appeal is within time.

16. The Appellant has made a pre- deposit of Rs. 13,523.10 (IGST Rs. 13,265.50, CGST Rs. 128.80, SGST Rs. 128.80), which is ten per cent of the tax in dispute. This satisfies Section 112(8), which, after its amendment by the Finance (No. 2) A ct, 2024, requires ten per cent of the remaining amount of tax in dispute in addition to the amount paid under Section 107(6). The reference to twenty per cent in the printed format reflects the provision as it earlier stood and is of no consequence. The a ppeal is maintainable, and recovery of the balance remains stayed under Section 112(9).

17. Written submissions dated 16.09.2026 were filed with six annexures: the purchase order and the invoice of M/s Naveen’s; a statement of payments with extracts of the ban k statement; the export invoice, shipping bill and packing slip; and copies of the decisions in Suncraft Energy, Ecom Gill Coffee Trading and Instakart Services. The submissions assert that “e- way bills, transport records and stock records” establish the m ovement and receipt of the goods. None of those records is annexed.

18. The Appellant has not questioned the jurisdiction of the Adjudicating Authority, the service of the notice, or the period within which the notice was issued and the order passed. No claim has been made under Section 128A. These matters were not argued, and we express no view on them.

C. THE RECORD
The composition of the demand
19. The demand comprises IGST of Rs. 1,32,655/-, and CGST and SGST of Rs. 1,288/- each. On the Appellant’s own working (paragraph 8), the IGST represents the tax of Rs. 1,50,000/- charged in the invoice of M/s Naveen’s, less Rs. 17,345.46 of excess credit relating to other months, that is, Rs. 1,32,654.54, rounded to Rs. 1,32,655/-. M/s Classic Power Company is located in Bengaluru, and its supplies to Dabaspet would attract CGST and SGST, not IGST. On the Appellant’s own explanation, therefore, the CGST and SGST of Rs. 1,288/- each relate to M/s Classic Power Company. No document of any kind has been produced for that sup plier. The Appellant’s case, both below and before us, concerns only the purchase from M/s Naveen’s.

20. Section 73(9) prescribes a penalty of ten per cent of the tax or ten thousand rupees, whichever is higher. The Adjudicating Authority applied it separately under each enactment, as follows:

Head Tax (Rs.) 10% of tax (Rs.) Minimum (Rs.) Penalty (Rs.)
IGST 1,32,655 13,265.50 10,000 13,266
CGST 1,288 128.80 10,000 10,000
SGST 1,288 128.80 10,000 10,000
Total 1,35,231 33,266

The documents relied upon
21. The Appellant relies on the following documents, which we describe as they appear on the copies produced:

Document Particulars as they appear
Purchase order No. VINTEK/18-19/V843/3508 dated 23.04.2018 on M/s Naveen’s, against its quotation of 18.04.2018, for one Godiva GP17/10 portable fire pump; value Rs. 12,50,000/-; GST “extra at actuals”; delivery “by vehicle”.
Supplier’s invoice Bill No. 1789N/2018 dated 27.06.2018; value Rs. 12,50,000/- plus “GST 12%” of Rs. 1,50,000/-; total Rs. 14,00,000/-; a handwritten endorsement that appears to be a goods-receipt reference dated 27.06.2018.
Payments Rs. 3,75,025.00 (RTGS, 27.04.2018), Rs. 8,75,052.00 (RTGS, 26.06.2018) and Rs. 1,50,017.70 (NEFT, 27.06.2018): total Rs. 14,00,094.70. The bank extract shows the debit of Rs. 3,75,025/- to “NAVEENS” on 27.04.2018; the other pages are largely illegible.
Export invoice No. 00352 dated 09.07.2018 to PERG Electrical Trading LLC, Dubai; one “Govida GP17/10” portable fire pump, HSN 85371000, Rs. 12,50,000/-; “GST of Rs. 2,25,000/- is exempted vide LUT dt 13.06.2018”; “Purchased From Naveen’s”. The Appellant describes it as the “corrected” export invoice.
Shipping bill No. 6251496 dated 16.07.2018, ICD Sabarmati, Ahmedabad; let export order 19.07.2018; FOB Rs. 12,50,000/-; export under LUT; drawback Rs. 25,000/-. As far as legible, the item is a “CONTROL PANEL” under 85371000, and the State of origin is Gujarat.
Packing slip Dated 09.07.2018; one package, 150 kg; “Godiva make pump with prime mover control panel”.

22. Certain features of these documents bear upon the weight they can carry, and we note them for that limited purpose. We record no finding of fraud or collusion. None is alleged, and none can be made in proceedings under Section 73.

(a) The invoice of M/s Naveen’s bears HSN 61171030, a code for knitted clothing accessories, for a fire pump. It charges “GST 12%” without describing it as integrated tax, although the supply is inter- State. It carries also TIN and CST numbers of the pre-GST regime.

(b) The export invoice and the shipping bill classify the goods under 85371000 (control panels). The export invoice computes notional tax at 18%. The shipping bill shows Gujarat as the State of origin.

(c) No e-way bill, lorry receipt, freight bill, goods r eceipt note or stock register has been produced for the movement of the goods from Chennai to Dabaspet, or from Dabaspet to Ahmedabad.

(d) The export documents were first produced before the First Appellate Authority, whose order does not discuss them.

D. SUBMISSIONS
On behalf of the Appellant
23. Sri Shiva Rao Ajjavara, learned Authorised Representative, advanced four submissions. It was submitted, first, that the demand rests on nothing more than a comparison of GSTR-3B with GSTR- 2A, an approach which Circular No. 183/15/2022-GST was issued to pre vent. Secondly, it was urged that the purchase order, the invoice and the payments through the bank prove the purchase, and that the Customs export documents, being independent public records, prove receipt of the goods; the test laid down in State of Karn ataka v. Ecom Gill Coffee Trading Pvt. Ltd. is thus satisfied. Thirdly, it was contended that a bona fide purchaser cannot be denied credit for the default of the supplier. Reliance was placed on Suncraft Energy Pvt. Ltd. v. Assistant Commissioner, State Tax (Calcutta High Court, M.A.T. No. 1218 of 2023, decided on 02.08.2023), and principally on Instakart Services Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India (W.P. No. 4917 of 2021, decided on 09.02.2026), in which the jurisdictional High Court read down Section 16(2)(c) an d Rule 36(4). Lastly, it was submitted that the authorities never computed the interest, and that the penalty must fall with the tax.

On behalf of the Revenue
24. The learned Departmental Representative supported the orders below. It was submitted that the con ditions in Section 16(2) are cumulative, and that Section 155 casts the burden of proving eligibility on the person claiming the credit. An invoice and payment through the bank do not, by themselves, discharge that burden, as held in Ecom Gill Coffee Trading. It was further submitted that the Circular afforded the Appellant a simple course, namely a certificate from the supplier, which the Appellant never adopted. ITC, being a statutory concession, is available only on the terms of the statute as held in th e case of ALD Automotive Pvt. Ltd. v. The Commercial Tax Officer & Ors., (2019) 13 SCC 225. No interference, it was urged, is warranted.

E. ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION
25. We have heard both sides and perused the record. The following issues arise for determination:

(i). Whether, after the decision of the Supreme Court in Bhandari Scrap Traders v. Union of India, Section 16(2)(c) can be read down in favour of a bona fide purchaser.

(ii). Whether the Appellant has proved, as Section 155 requires, that the suppliers paid the tax; and whether the omission of the Adjudicating Authority to apply Circular No. 183/15/2022- GST avails the Appellant.

(iii). Whether the Appellant has established his plea that the goods actually moved from Chennai and were received by him.

(iv). What tax, interest and penalty are payable.

F. ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS 
Issue (i): The scope of Section 16(2)(c)
26. Section 16(1) confers the entitlement to credit; Section 16(2) conditions it. Sub- section (2) opens with a non obstante clause and provides that no registered person “shall be entitled” to credit “unless” each of the listed conditions is satisfied. The conditions are cumulative. Clause (c), as it stood in 2018- 19, required that, subject to Section 41 or Section 43A, “the tax charged in respect of such supply has been actually paid to the Government”. Section 155 places the burden of proving eligibility on the claimant. It is settled that credit is a creature of statute and is available only on the conditions the statute prescribes as held by the Honourable Suprem e Court in the cases of Jayam & Co. v. Assistant Commissioner, (2016) 15 SCC 125 and ALD Automotive Pvt. Ltd. v. Commercial Tax Officer, (2019) 13 SCC 225.

27. In Instakart Services, decided on 09.02.2026, the High Court of Karnataka, following the Tripura High Court in Sahil Enterprises v. Union of India (decided on 06.01.2026), read down Section 16(2)(c) so that it would not control. A decision of the jurisdictional High Court ordinar ily binds this Bench.

28. The question has since been considered by the Supreme Court. In Bhandari Scrap Traders v. Union of India & Ors., SLP (C) No. 23931 of 2026, decided on 24.07.2026 [2026 LiveLaw (SC) 725], the Supreme Court dismissed the special leave p etitions against the judgment of the Gujarat High Court in Maruti Enterprise v. Union of India, which had upheld Section 16(2)(c) and declined to read it down. The dismissal was accompanied by reasons. The Supreme Court held that the Delhi Value Added Tax Act, 2004 and the CGST Act rest on different statutory schemes, so that the decisions under the Delhi statute protecting bona fide purchasers cannot be carried over. It observed that Sections 41, 73 and 74 provide a framework under which a purchaser may re – avail credit once the supplier discharges the tax. It found no ground to hold Section 16(2)(c) unconstitutional, and agreed with the High Court, which had refused to read it down.

29. An order dismissing a special leave petition does not ordinarily declare th e law. Where, however, the Supreme Court gives reasons, the law stated in those reasons is a declaration under Article 141 and binds all courts and tribunals as held by the Supreme Court in the case of Kunhayammed v. State of Kerala, (2000) 6 SCC 359. The High Court of Rajasthan has so understood Bhandari Scrap Traders in Sumetco Alloys Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India Civil Writ Petition No. 9323 of 2026, decided on 13.08.2026), and declined to follow Sahil Enterprises and Instakart Services.

30. The High Court of Karnataka decided Instakart Services before the Supreme Court pronounced on the question, and did not have the benefit of that decision. The law declared by the Supreme Court now governs. With the utmost respect to the jurisdictional High Court, we a re bound by Article 141 to apply Section 16(2)(c) as enacted and upheld.

31. Suncraft Energy does not advance the Appellant’s case either. The Revenue’s special leave petition against that judgment was dismissed in limine. The view that a purchaser may be proc eeded against only in exceptional cases cannot be reconciled with the statutory scheme affirmed in Bhandari Scrap Traders. The same applies to the other decisions cited in the reply to the notice.

32. This does not leave an honest purchaser without remedy. For 2017- 18 and 2018-19, Circular No. 183/15/2022- GST enables the purchaser to establish the supplier’s payment by a certificate. The proviso to Section 41(2), in turn, permits the purchaser to re- avail the credit once the supplier pays the tax, subject to th e conditions and time limits prescribed by law. What the purchaser cannot do is retain the credit when nothing on record shows that the tax reached the Government.

33. Issue (i) is answered accordingly. Section 16(2)(c) applies as enacted and cannot be read do does not by itself satisfy the clause. The Appellant must prove that the suppliers paid the tax to the Government at least when the recipient was put on notice by the Revenue with the details of the supplier.

Issue (ii): Proof of payment of tax by the suppliers
34. We accept the Appellant’s submission that, for 2018-19, a shortfall in GSTR – 2A does not by itself establish that the supplier failed to pay the tax. FORM GSTR-2A is a facilitator for self- assessment and not an instrument of assessment as held by the Honourable Supreme Court in the case of Union of India v. Bharti Airtel Ltd., (2022) 4 SCC 328. Neither Section 16(2)(aa) nor Rule 36(4) was in force during that year. It is for this reason that the Board issued Circular No. 183/15/2022- GST. Under paragraph 4, the proper officer is to verify that the recipient holds a tax invoice, has received the goods or services, and has paid the supplier. The recipient must then establish that the suppli er paid the tax. Where the difference in respect of a supplier exceeds Rs. 5 lakh, a certificate from a Chartered Accountant or Cost Accountant is required (paragraph 4.1.1 of the Circular); where it does not, a certificate from the supplier suffices (paragraph 4.1.2 of the Circular). In the present case, the difference in respect of each supplier is well below Rs. 5 lakhs.

35. The Circular does not dispense with Section 16(2)(c). Nor does it shift to the Department the burden that Section 155 places on the cla imant. It prescribes the manner in which the recipient may discharge that burden. That is a with the supplier, and a purchaser who has paid a supplier in full through the bank may reasonably be expected to obtain from that supplier a certificate of payment of tax.

36. The Appellant had ample opportunity to produce that certificate. The ASMT – 10 of 03.10.2023 raised the mismatch. The notice of 28.12.2023 stated the ground plainly and called for all the evidence relied upon. The Adjudicating Authority fixed three dates of hearing, and the Appellant attended none. On 30.05.2025, the First Appellate Authority held in terms that the certificate was required and had not been produced. The pres ent appeal was filed about eleven months thereafter, and written submissions were filed in September 2026. At the hearing on 17-09-2026, the learned Authorised Representative was specifically asked whether a certificate from either supplier, or any other p roof of payment of tax, could be produced. None was produced, and no time was sought. To a specific question the Authorised Representative for the Appellant categorically submits that they could not reach out to the supplier even after repeated attempt.

37. At no stage, therefore, has the Appellant produced a certificate from either supplier, a certificate from an accountant, a copy of either supplier’s GSTR – 3B, or even a letter to either supplier seeking confirmation. Nothing on record explains why a supplie r who was paid in full through the bank could not be approached. Neither the grounds of appeal nor the written submissions address the finding of the First Appellate Authority on this point.

38. In State of Karnataka v. Ecom Gill Coffee Trading Pvt. Ltd. (Civi l Appeal No. 230 of 2023, decided on 13.03.2023; 2023 INSC 212), a decision on which the Appellant himself relies, the Supreme Court held that “the burden of proving that the ITC claim is correct lies upon the purchasing dealer claiming such ITC”, and that “mere production of the invoices or the payment made by cheques is not enough”. Those observations were made under Section 70 of the Karnataka Value Added Tax Act, 2003. Section 155 of the CGST Act states the same principle in express terms.

39. It was conten ded that the adjudication was mechanical. The contention is not without substance. The Order-in- Original does not refer to the Circular, and the Adjudicating Authority did not call for the supplier’s certificate. The Circular binds the Department. In Abhim aani Structures and Engineering Pvt. Ltd. v. Superintendent of Central Tax (W.P. No. 35021 of 2025, decided on 28.11.2025), the High Court of Karnataka set aside a demand confirmed on a bare comparison of GSTR-3B with GSTR- 2A, without following the Circular. We respectfully follow that principle.

40. The principle, however, does not avail the Appellant on the facts of this case, for three reasons. First, the Appellant remained absent on all three dates of hearing, although Section 75(4) and (5) secured to him a hearing and up to three adjournments. The Adjudicating Authority cannot fairly be faulted for not calling for documents at hearings which the Appellant chose not to attend. are co- extensive with those of the original authority, did apply the Circular and informed the Appellant precisely what was required. Thirdly, even at this stage of the entire proceedings before this Tribunal as the final fact- finding authority, the Appellant has still produced nothing. In Abhimaani Structures, the taxpayer had no opportunity to comply; this Appellant had it repeatedly. A party complaining of a procedural lapse must show real prejudice as held in the case of State Bank of Patiala v. S.K. Sharma, (1996) 3 SCC 364. No prejudice is shown.

41. Issue (ii) is, therefore, answered against the Appellant. He has not proved that M/s Naveen’s or M/s Classic Power Compan y paid the tax. The condition in Section 16(2)(c) is not satisfied, and the lapse at the first stage has caused no prejudice. This finding by itself sustains the demand. Issue (iii): The plea of genuine purchase

42. Our answer to Issue (ii) decides the appeal on the ground stated in the notice. We nonetheless examine this issue because the Appellant’s defence of good faith, and his reliance on Ecom Gill Coffee Trading, rest on the assertion that the goods moved from C hennai to Dabaspet and were received by him. Having raised that plea, the Appellant must establish it.

43. Section 68 empowers the Government to require documents to accompany goods in transit. Rule 138 of the CGST Rules, substituted by Notification No. 12/2018-Central Tax dated 07.03.2018, made the e- inter- State movement of goods from 01.04.2018, the date notified by Notification No. 15/2018- Central Tax dated 23.03.2018. As the rule stood in June 2018, a registered person causing moveme nt of goods of consignment value exceeding fifty thousand rupees, inclusive of tax, was required to generate the e- way bill on the common portal before the movement commenced. It could be generated by the supplier, the recipient or the transporter. Where t he supplier or the transporter generated it, the particulars were made available to the recipient on the portal, with the option to accept or reject them (sub- rules (11) and (12)). Rule 138A required the conveyance to carry the e-way bill, and Section 129 provided for detention of goods moving without it.

44. Every condition of Rule 138 is attracted here. The supply was inter- State. The invoice is dated 27.06.2018. The consignment value was Rs. 14,00,000/-. The purchase order stipulated delivery “by vehicle”. An e- way bill was, therefore, mandatory, and the Appellant’s own written submissions state that e- way bills exist. 45. The e- way bill records the GSTINs of the parties, the invoice, the value, the places of dispatch and delivery, and the vehicle number. It is g enerated before the goods move. It is the contemporaneous record that connects the invoice with a vehicle carrying the goods to a stated destination. In Ecom Gill Coffee Trading, the Supreme Court held that physical movement is to be proved by, among other payment of freight charges, acknowledgement of taking delivery of goods”. The Appellant has produced none of these, beyond an unexplained handwritten endorsement on his own copy of the invoice.

46. The e- way bill was within the Appellant’s reach. If the supplier generated one, its particulars were available to the Appellant on the portal. If the supplier did not, the Appellant could have generated it himself. The Appellant asserts that e-way bills exist, yet has not produced them at any of the three stages, and offers no explanation. That unexplained omission weighs against the claim that the goods moved as the invoice states.

47. The subsequent movement is equally unrecorded. The Appellant states that the goods were received at Dabaspet and then exported, but the shipping bill was filed at Ahmedabad. Movement of goods worth Rs. 12,50,000/- from Dabaspet to Ahmedabad would itself have required an e- way bill, and none is produced. If the goods instead tra velled directly from Chennai to Gujarat on the Appellant’s direction, an e- way bill for that movement would show it. None is produced either.

48. The export documents do not fill the gap. To prove that M/s Naveen’s supplied the goods that were exported, the Ap pellant must connect the two sets of documents. As noted in paragraph 22, the invoice of M/s Naveen’s describes a fire pump under an apparel code, taxed at 12%. The shipping bill describes a “control panel” under 85371000, of Gujarat origin. The “corrected ” export transport record links them, and no explanation has been offered. We do not hold that the exported goods were different goods. We hold only that these documents, in the absence of explanation, do not establish the link. Although no application was made under Rule 112, we have examined these documents under Section 113(1) in the interest of justice. Even if they proved receipt, receipt would go only to Section 16(2)(b); it cannot establish that the supplier paid the tax.

49. This finding does not confirm the demand on a new ground, which Section 75(7) forbids. The demand rests on Section 16(2)(c), the ground stated in the notice; this finding only answers the Appellant’s own plea. Par agraph 4 of the very Circular on which the Appellant relies requires the proper officer to verify that the recipient has received the goods or services. Nor do we hold that the absence of an e- way bill defeats credit in every case, for Section 16(2) does n ot make it a condition. We hold that where a recipient relies on the genuineness of an inter-State purchase above the threshold value, the e- way bill is the primary evidence of movement; and if it is not produced and its absence is not satisfactorily expla ined, movement must be proved by other reliable contemporaneous evidence, such as lorry receipts, freight payments, goods receipt notes and stock entries. None has been produced. The plea of genuine purchase fails.

Issue (iv): Tax, interest and penalty
50. Tax. The IGST of Rs. 1,32,655/- represents, on the Appellant’s own working, the tax charged in the invoice of M/s Naveen’s, less the excess credit relating to other months (paragraph 19). It is sustained for the reasons recorded under Issue (ii). No material has been produced in respect of M/s Classic Power Company, and the CGST and SGST of Rs. 1,288/- each are likewise sustained. The tax sustained is, therefore, IGST Rs. 1,32,655/-, CGST Rs. 1,288/- and SGST Rs. 1,288/-, in all Rs. 1,35,231/-.

51. Interest. Inte rest is compensatory and follows the tax. Section 50(3), substituted by the Finance Act, 2022 with effect from 01.07.2017, levies interest on credit wrongly availed and utilised, at eighteen per cent per annum (Notification No. 13/2017-Central Tax, as amen ded by Notification No. 9/2022- Central Tax). Rule 88B(3) prescribes the method of computation: interest runs from the date of utilisation to the date of reversal or payment, and credit is treated as utilised when, and to the extent that, the balance in the electronic credit ledger falls below the amount wrongly availed. The liability to interest is upheld. The Appellant’s grievance about its computation is, however, well founded. The Order-in- Original directs recovery “at applicable rates” without any working, and records no finding on utilisation. The proper officer shall compute the interest under Rule 88B(3) and furnish the working to the Appellant before recovery.

52. Penalty. Section 73(9) mandates a penalty of ten per cent of the tax or ten thousand rupees, whichever is higher, and Section 122(2)(a) is to the same effect. This penalty does not depend on fraud or intent to evade, which are the province of Section 74. The absence of any such finding, therefore, does not assist the Appellant. The table in para graph 20 shows that the Adjudicating Authority imposed the statutory minimum under each enactment. The penalty of Rs. 33,266/- is upheld.

G. A WORD BEFORE WE PART
53. In upholding Section 16(2)(c), the Gujarat High Court in Maruti Enterprise was conscious of the predicament of an honest purchaser who pays the price and the tax, and then loses the credit through a default he can neither see nor prevent. The High Court observed that the Government should consider a technology-driven mechanism enabling recipients to verify, invoice by invoice and in real time, whether their suppliers have paid the tax. The Revenue may also recover the tax from the defaulting supplier under Sections 73 and 74, whereupon the purchaser may re-avail the credit.

54. In 2018, the Appellant could not see his suppliers’ GSTR- 3B or their payments of tax; the proper officer can. Nothing said here lightens the burden under Section 155, and our decision does not rest on this paragraph. Good administration, however, requires that the proper officer examine the the defaulting supplier with equal diligence. M/s Naveen’s is registered in Tamil Nadu, and M/s Classic Power Company may not fall within the Respondent’s jurisdictio n. We expect the Department to pass this information to the officers having jurisdiction over those suppliers, so that they may proceed in accordance with law. If the tax is recovered, the Appellant’s right to re-avail the credit under Section 41 as reaffirmed in Maruti Enterprise may then be exercised in accordance with law.

H. ORDER
55. In the result, the appeal is dismissed, with the following directions:

(a) Order-in-Appeal No. 57/2025-26 dated 30.05.2025 and Order-in -Original No. 29/2024-25 OIO SUPDT BNWD3 dated 24.04.2024 are upheld, subject to clause (d).

(b) The demand of tax, namely IGST Rs. 1,32,655/-, CGST Rs. 1,288/- and SGST Rs. 1,288/- (in all Rs. 1,35,231/-), is upheld.

(c) The penalty of Rs. 33,266/- (IGST Rs. 13,266/-, CGST Rs. 10,000/ -SGST Rs. 10,000/-) imposed under Section 73(9) read with Section 122(2)(a) is upheld. (d) Interest under Section 50(3) is payable on the credit wrongly availed and utilised. The proper officer shall compute it in accordance with Rule 88B(3) of the CGST Rules and communicate the working to the Appellant before recovery.

(e) Nothing in this order shall preclude the Appellant from re- availing the credit, to the extent the suppliers pay the tax, under the proviso to Section 41(2) of the CGST Act, subject to the applicable conditions and time limits; nor shall it preclude the Department from proceeding against the suppliers in accordance with law. (f) The Registry shall forward a copy of this order to the Principal Commissioner of Central Tax, Bengaluru North- West Commissionerate, for appropr iate action in the light of paragraphs 53 and 54, including passing the relevant information to the authorities having jurisdiction over the suppliers.

(g) There shall be no order as to costs.

56. The appeal is disposed of in the above terms.

Pronounced in Open Tribunal on this the 8th day of October 2026.

Advertisement

Author Info

CA Sandeep Kanoi
Qualification: Graduate, CA in Job / Business, DD
Company: Taxguru Consultancy
Location: Mumbai, Maharashtra
Articles Published: 24,760

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.