Manikandan Vs Inspector of Police (Madras High Court)
Summary: The Madras High Court, in Manikandan Vs Inspector of Police, granted bail to an accused arrested in a case involving the alleged possession of methamphetamine under Sections 8(c), 22(c) and 29(1) of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985. Justice L. Victoria Gowri, by order dated 7 May 2026, examined whether separate recoveries of 30 grams each from two accused could be aggregated to invoke the commercial-quantity restrictions under Section 37 of the NDPS Act. The Court also considered allegations of prior illegal custody, non-communication of grounds of arrest under Section 47 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, procedural irregularities during seizure, the absence of the Forensic Science Laboratory report and the petitioner’s personal circumstances. On a cumulative assessment, the Court granted conditional bail while expressly reserving the merits of the allegations for investigation and trial.
The prosecution alleged that, on 31 January 2026 at approximately 10.00 p.m., the Gummidipoondi police received secret information that two persons would arrive from Chennai by train carrying methamphetamine for sale. The information was reduced into writing and communicated to the Inspector of Police. A police team proceeded to Gummidipoondi Railway Station and, at approximately 11.35 p.m., identified two persons as Manikandan and Mohammad Neman. According to the prosecution, a search conducted shortly thereafter resulted in the recovery of 30 grams of methamphetamine from Manikandan and another 30 grams from the second accused. Both persons were allegedly arrested at approximately 11.55 p.m. The contraband was seized under a seizure mahazar, and mobile phones were also recovered during the investigation.
The police further alleged that the accused had obtained the contraband from Hari Krishna, identified as the third accused, and an unidentified foreign national described as the fourth accused. According to the prosecution, these persons supplied the substance for sale and financial gain. The State contended that the total quantity involved was 60 grams of methamphetamine, constituting commercial quantity under the NDPS framework. It consequently invoked the stringent restrictions on bail under Section 37 of the NDPS Act. The Government Advocate also submitted that the Forensic Science Laboratory report was awaited, the investigation remained incomplete and the alleged suppliers were absconding.
The petitioner disputed the prosecution’s account of his arrest. His counsel submitted that police personnel had forcibly taken him from his residence at Ayanambakkam on 29 January 2026 at approximately 5.00 p.m., whereas the official arrest was shown only on 31 January 2026. According to the defence, the petitioner had remained in unlawful police custody during the intervening period. Counsel referred to complaints lodged by the petitioner’s father before H2 Puzhal Police Station and the Commissioner of Police, Chennai, on 31 January 2026, reporting that his son was missing. The petitioner also relied on alleged CCTV footage showing police personnel taking him into custody on 29 January 2026. These matters were advanced as circumstances casting doubt on the prosecution’s version of the arrest and subsequent recovery.
A principal legal contention concerned the aggregation of the quantities recovered from two different accused persons. The petitioner argued that only 30 grams had allegedly been recovered from his possession and that this quantity did not constitute commercial quantity. According to the defence, the police could not automatically combine the separate recoveries to reach 60 grams without prima facie evidence of conscious joint possession, conspiracy or common design. The petitioner maintained that the prosecution had not produced independent material establishing the necessary connection between the separate possessions for the purpose of applying Section 29 of the NDPS Act.
The defence additionally challenged the search and arrest procedures. It submitted that no independent public witness had participated in the search and seizure and that representative samples had not been drawn at the place of seizure in accordance with the prescribed procedure. More importantly, the petitioner alleged that he had not been furnished with the grounds of arrest in writing in a language known to him. Counsel argued that issuing an arrest memo under Section 36 of the BNSS did not, by itself, establish compliance with Section 47 of the BNSS or Article 22 of the Constitution. The petitioner also pointed out that he was an MBA graduate, was employed, had a permanent residence and had no previous criminal antecedents. His earlier bail application had been dismissed by the Special Court on 16 March 2026, principally because the investigation was at an initial stage.
The State opposed bail on the grounds that the alleged total recovery involved commercial quantity and that Section 37 of the NDPS Act therefore applied. The prosecution asserted that the seizure had been conducted lawfully and that the accused had been produced before the Judicial Magistrate, Ponneri, on 1 February 2026 and remanded to judicial custody. It submitted that samples had been sent to the Forensic Science Laboratory, Chennai, on 25 February 2026 and that the report remained pending. The State also expressed apprehension that the petitioner might abscond, tamper with evidence or threaten witnesses if released, particularly because the alleged suppliers had not been apprehended.
Examining the material, the High Court observed that the recovery attributed to the petitioner was 30 grams of methamphetamine, while a separate quantity of 30 grams had allegedly been recovered from the second accused. The Court held that whether these quantities could be aggregated depended on the existence of prima facie material establishing conspiracy, conscious joint possession or common design. At the bail stage, the prosecution had relied principally on the alleged confession statements and the claim that both accused had procured the substance from other persons. The Court found no independent material demonstrating a larger conspiracy. As the alleged recoveries were separately attributed to the individual pockets of the accused, the petitioner’s argument against aggregation could not be brushed aside.
The High Court also considered the alleged earlier custody and the statutory safeguards governing arrest. It noted that the petitioner’s father had reportedly made contemporaneous complaints concerning his disappearance and that the prosecution had not produced convincing material at that stage to completely dispel the allegation. Although the Court did not conclusively determine that the petitioner had been illegally detained, it considered the circumstances sufficient to raise a debatable issue about the manner in which police custody had commenced. The Court further emphasised that Section 47 of the BNSS embodies the constitutional requirement to communicate the grounds of arrest. Preparation of an arrest memo could not invariably be treated as sufficient compliance with that substantive safeguard.
Regarding Section 37 of the NDPS Act, the Court acknowledged that commercial-quantity offences attract stringent restrictions and that bail cannot be granted mechanically. However, the present case involved a serious dispute over whether separate recoveries could legally be aggregated. On the material then available, the Court found that conscious joint possession or conspiracy had not been prima facie established with sufficient clarity to attract the full rigour of Section 37 at that stage. The Court considered the absence of the FSL report, the alleged procedural deficiencies, the disputed arrest circumstances and the petitioner’s lack of previous criminal antecedents. It concluded, for the limited purpose of bail, that reasonable grounds existed to believe that the petitioner might not be guilty of an offence involving commercial quantity and that he was unlikely to commit an offence while on bail.
Accordingly, the Madras High Court allowed the bail petition and directed the release of Manikandan on executing a bond of ₹25,000 with two sureties of the same amount each. The Court imposed conditions requiring daily reporting before the respondent police at 10.30 a.m. until further orders, surrender of the passport or filing of an affidavit if no passport was held, restriction on leaving Tamil Nadu without permission, cooperation with the investigation and prohibition against influencing witnesses or committing further offences. The petitioner was also directed to furnish his mobile number and residential address and to make a non-refundable deposit of ₹50,000 to Manolaya, Home for Mentally Ill Destitute, within two weeks of receiving the order. The Court clarified that its observations were confined to the bail proceedings and would not influence the investigation or trial.
FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF MADRAS HIGH COURT
This Criminal Original Petition has been filed seeking to enlarge the petitioner/A1 on bail in Crime No.30 of 2026 on the file of the respondent police, registered for the offences punishable under Section 8(c) read with Sections 22(c) and 29(1) of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (NDPS) Act, 1985.
Case of the Prosecution:
2. The case of the prosecution is that on 31.01.2026 at about 22.00 hours, the respondent police received reliable secret information that two persons would arrive from Chennai to Gummidipoondi by train carrying methamphetamine for sale. The information was reduced into writing at 22.30 hours and communicated to the Inspector of Police, F1 Gummidipoondi Police Station, and necessary instructions were obtained at about 22.45 hours.
3. Thereafter, the Special Sub-Inspector, along with his police party, proceeded to Gummidipoondi Railway Station with necessary materials. At about 23.35 hours, two persons coming out of the railway station were identified by the informant. On enquiry, they disclosed their identities as Manikandan and Mohammad Neman.
4. After obtaining their consent for search and in the presence of police witnesses, the accused were searched at about 23.45 hours. During the search, 30 grams of methamphetamine was allegedly recovered from the pant pocket of the petitioner/A1 and another 30 grams of methamphetamine was allegedly recovered from the pant pocket of A2. The contraband was seized and marked as P1 and P2 respectively under seizure mahazar. Both the accused were arrested at about 23.55 hours on 31.01.2026.
5. It is further alleged that pursuant to the voluntary confessions of A1 and A2, one iPhone 13 Pro mobile phone from the petitioner/A1 and one iPhone 16 mobile phone from A2 were seized. The prosecution further claims that the accused disclosed that they had procured the contraband from Hari Krishna/A3 and one unknown person/A4, stated to be a foreign national belonging to an African country, for the purpose of sale and personal gain.
6. The learned Government Advocate would submit that the total quantity involved is 60 grams of methamphetamine, which is commercial quantity in terms of the NDPS Schedule, and that the Forensic Science Laboratory report is yet to be received. It is also submitted that A3 and A4 are absconding and that the investigation is still pending.
Submissions on behalf of the Petitioner:
7. The learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submitted that the petitioner was not arrested on 31.01.2026 as projected by the prosecution. According to him, the respondent police, claiming to be a special team, unlawfully entered the petitioner’s residence at Ayanambakkam on 29.01.2026 at about 17.00 hours and forcibly took him into custody. It is further submitted that the petitioner was kept in illegal custody and his arrest was formally shown only on 31.01.2026.
8. The learned counsel further submitted that the petitioner’s father lodged a complaint before H2 Puzhal Police Station and also before the Commissioner of Police, Chennai, on 31.01.2026 stating that his son was missing. Subsequently, the petitioner’s father received telephonic information from the respondent police stating that his son had been arrested in Tiruvallur. According to the learned counsel, this sequence of events probabilises the petitioner’s contention that he had been taken into custody prior to the officially recorded date of arrest.
9. It is also submitted that CCTV footage dated 29.01.2026 would demonstrate that the petitioner was taken into custody by police personnel in uniform. Placing reliance upon the order of this Court in Crl.O.P.No.19638 of 2025, the learned counsel submitted that where the earlier illegal custody of the accused is established through contemporaneous complaints by family members, the alleged subsequent recovery becomes doubtful at the stage of bail.
10. The learned counsel further submitted that the alleged recovery from the petitioner is only 30 grams of methamphetamine, which is not commercial quantity. According to him, the respondent police have clubbed the alleged recovery from A1 and A2 and have erroneously invoked Section 22(c) of the NDPS Act. It is contended that there is no prima facie material to show conscious joint possession, conspiracy or common design so as to aggregate the individual recoveries.
11. The learned counsel further contended that no independent public witness was examined at the time of search and seizure and the entire prosecution case rests only on police witnesses. It is also submitted that representative samples were not drawn at the place of seizure in accordance with the mandatory procedure prescribed under law.
12. The learned counsel also placed strong reliance on Section 47 of BNSS and submitted that the petitioner was not furnished with the grounds of arrest in writing in a language known to him. According to the petitioner, only an arrest memo under Section 36 of BNSS was issued and the constitutional mandate embodied under Article 22 of the Constitution of India and Section 47 of BNSS was not complied with.
13. The learned counsel finally submitted that the petitioner is an MBA graduate, employed in a reputed company, has no previous antecedents, has permanent residence and undertakes to abide by any condition imposed by this Court. It is further submitted that the earlier bail petition filed before the learned Principal Special Judge for EC and NDPS Act Cases, Chennai, was dismissed on 16.03.2026 mainly on the ground that the investigation was at the nascent stage.
Submissions on behalf of the Respondent:
14. Per contra, the learned Government Advocate strongly opposed the grant of bail. He submitted that the petitioner is the first accused and that the quantity involved is 60 grams of methamphetamine, which falls within commercial quantity. Therefore, according to the prosecution, the statutory bar under Section 37 of the NDPS Act is attracted.
15. The learned Government Advocate further submitted that the contraband was seized in accordance with law, that the accused were arrested and produced before the learned Judicial Magistrate, Ponneri, on 01.02.2026 and were remanded to judicial custody on the same day. It is further submitted that the samples were sent to the Forensic Science Laboratory, Chennai, on 25.02.2026 and the report is awaited.
16. It is also submitted that based on the confession statements of A1 and A2, the involvement of A3 Hari Krishna and A4, an unknown foreign national, has come to light and both of them are absconding. Therefore, if the petitioner is enlarged on bail, there is every likelihood of his absconding, tampering with evidence and threatening witnesses. Hence, the learned Government Advocate sought dismissal of the petition.
Discussion and Analysis:
17. The petitioner is alleged to have been found in possession of 30 grams of methamphetamine. The prosecution seeks to treat the case as one involving commercial quantity by clubbing the alleged recovery of 30 grams from A1 and 30 grams from A2. Whether such clubbing is legally sustainable would depend upon the existence of prima facie material indicating conspiracy, conscious joint possession or a common design attracting Section 29 of the NDPS Act.
18. At this stage, except the alleged confession statements of A1 and A2 and the prosecution version that the contraband was procured from A3 and A4, no independent material has been placed before this Court to prima facie demonstrate a larger conspiracy. The recovery is shown as distinct and separate from the individual pant pockets of A1 and A2. Therefore, for the limited purpose of considering bail, the contention of the petitioner that the individual recovery from him is 30 grams and not commercial quantity cannot be brushed aside.
19. The prosecution has also admitted that the Forensic Science Laboratory report is yet to be received. Though the absence of FSL report by itself may not automatically entitle an accused to bail in every NDPS case, in the present case, the petitioner has raised additional grounds touching upon the manner of arrest, alleged prior illegal custody, lack of independent witnesses, non-drawing of representative samples at the spot and non-communication of grounds of arrest.
20. The allegation of prior illegal custody is supported, according to the petitioner, by complaints made by his father before H2 Puzhal Police Station and the Commissioner of Police, Chennai, on 31.01.2026. The prosecution has not placed convincing materials at this stage to completely dispel the said contention. This circumstance, though not conclusive, creates a debatable issue regarding the manner in which the petitioner came into the custody of the respondent police.
21. The petitioner has also raised a serious contention that Section 47 of BNSS was not complied with. Section 47 of BNSS embodies the constitutional requirement that an arrested person must be informed of the grounds of arrest. The mere preparation of an arrest memo cannot, in all cases, be treated as compliance with the statutory mandate to communicate the grounds of arrest. The judgments relied upon by the learned counsel for the petitioner emphasise that communication of grounds of arrest is a substantive safeguard and not an empty formality.
22. In an offence under the NDPS Act, where stringent consequences follow and the liberty of the accused is subjected to special statutory restrictions, procedural safeguards assume greater importance. The Court cannot ignore serious allegations of non-compliance with arrest safeguards, particularly when the petitioner has produced circumstances suggesting prior custody and delayed formal arrest.
23. The respondent has expressed apprehension that the petitioner may abscond, tamper with evidence or threaten witnesses. Such apprehension can be sufficiently addressed by imposing stringent conditions. The petitioner is stated to have no previous antecedents, is a graduate and is having a permanent place of residence. He has also undertaken to cooperate with investigation.
24. Insofar as Section 37 of the NDPS Act is concerned, this Court is conscious that bail cannot be granted in a mechanical manner where commercial quantity is involved. However, in the present case, there is a serious dispute as to whether the quantity allegedly recovered from the petitioner can be treated as commercial quantity by aggregation. The material presently available does not prima facie establish conscious joint possession or conspiracy with such clarity as to attract the full rigour of Section 37 at this stage.
25. Therefore, on a cumulative consideration of the alleged individual recovery of 30 grams, the absence of FSL report as on date, the disputed aggregation of quantity, the allegation of prior illegal custody supported by contemporaneous complaints, the alleged non-compliance of Section 47 of BNSS and the absence of previous antecedents, this Court is satisfied, for the limited purpose of bail, that there are reasonable grounds to believe that the petitioner may not be guilty of the offence involving commercial quantity and that he is not likely to commit any offence while on bail.
26. It is made clear that the observations made herein are only for the purpose of deciding this bail petition and shall not influence the investigation or trial.
27. In the facts and circumstances of the case, this Court is inclined to enlarge the petitioner on bail, subject to stringent conditions.
28. Accordingly, this Criminal Original Petition is allowed and the petitioner/A1 is ordered to be enlarged on bail on executing a bond for a sum of Rs.25,000/- (Rupees Twenty Five Thousand only) with two sureties, each for a like sum to the satisfaction of the learned Principal Special Judge for EC and NDPS Act Cases, Chennai / concerned jurisdictional Court, subject to the following conditions:
(i) The sureties shall affix their photographs and Left Thumb Impression in the Application for Surety ship [Judicial Form No.46 annexed to ‘The Criminal Rules of Practice, 2019’]. The learned Magistrate shall obtain a copy of any one of the identity proofs to ensure their identity;
(ii) The petitioner shall report before the respondent police daily at 10.30 a.m. until further orders.
(iii) The petitioner shall surrender his passport, if any, before the concerned Court. If he does not possess a passport, he shall file an affidavit to that effect.
(iv) The petitioner shall not leave the State of Tamil Nadu without prior permission of the concerned Court.
(v) The petitioner shall cooperate with the investigation and shall appear before the respondent police as and when required.
(vi) The petitioner shall not tamper with evidence or influence, threaten or contact any prosecution witness.
(vii) The petitioner shall not indulge in any offence, particularly any offence under the NDPS Act, while on bail.
(viii) The petitioner shall furnish his mobile number and residential address to the respondent police and shall keep the same active. Any change of address shall be intimated forthwith to the respondent police and to the concerned Court.
(ix) In the event of breach of any of the above conditions, the respondent police is at liberty to move the concerned Court for cancellation of bail.
(x) The petitioner shall make a non-refundable deposit of Rs.50,000/- (Rupees Fifty Thousand only) to the credit of Manolaya, Home for Mentally Ill Destitute, Bank Name: Indian Overseas Bank, Branch: Kottaram, IFSC Code: IOBA0000253, Account Name: Manolaya, Account No.025302000000284, UPI ID: 6379484925@okbizicici, Gpay:9443307196, within a period of two weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order and shall produce the said receipt before the concerned Court.
29. Consequently, connected miscellaneous petitions, if any, are closed.



