Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Company Law

Supreme Court Grants Bail in SFIO Fraud Case Due to Delay in Trial

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2026 taxguru.in 19128
Case Name
Jainam Rathod Vs State of Haryana & Anr (Supreme Court of India)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Jainam Rathod Vs State of Haryana & Another (Supreme Court)

Summary: The Supreme Court, in Jainam Rathod Vs State of Haryana & Another, allowed an appeal against the Punjab and Haryana High Court’s order dated 18 November 2021 refusing bail to an accused in a Serious Fraud Investigation Office (SFIO) prosecution under the Companies Act, 2013 and the Indian Penal Code. The case concerned alleged corporate fraud involving a large number of accused persons and offences including Section 447 of the Companies Act, 2013. The Supreme Court granted bail principally because the appellant had remained in custody since 28 August 2019 and there was no reasonable likelihood of completing the trial within a reasonable period. It emphasised that the stringent statutory conditions under Section 212(6) of the Companies Act must be considered alongside the constitutional right to an expeditious trial.

The SFIO filed Criminal Complaint No. 3 of 2019 before the Sessions Judge-cum-Special Judge at Gurugram on 18 May 2019, alleging offences under Section 447 of the Companies Act and various provisions of the IPC, including Sections 406, 417, 418, 420, 467, 468, 471, 474 and 477A. The appellant was arrested on 28 August 2019, after the complaint had already been filed. His first bail application was rejected by the trial court, and the Punjab and Haryana High Court dismissed his application under Section 439 of the Code of Criminal Procedure on 13 November 2019. The Supreme Court dismissed his special leave petition on 27 January 2020 but expressly left open the possibility of seeking bail afresh. The Special Judge rejected a subsequent application on 13 October 2020, and the High Court again refused bail on 18 November 2021.

In the second round of bail proceedings, the appellant argued before the High Court that nearly two years had elapsed since the earlier rejection and that the trial was unlikely to conclude soon. He pointed out that even the complainant had sought segregation of proceedings concerning accused persons in custody, but the trial court had rejected that request. The appellant also relied on interim bail granted to certain co-accused by the Supreme Court, submitting that his alleged role was comparatively limited and that he deserved similar treatment. The High Court, however, held that the earlier bail application had been dismissed through a detailed order on merits and that the passage of additional time in custody was insufficient, given the seriousness of the alleged offences.

The Punjab and Haryana High Court further declined to extend the benefit of parity. It observed that the Supreme Court orders relied upon by the appellant were interim in nature and did not finally determine entitlement to bail. The High Court considered that those interim orders did not disclose sufficient reasons to permit a meaningful comparison between the appellant’s role and those of the co-accused. Since the earlier decision on merits remained undisturbed, it declined to reopen the question merely to grant interim bail. Accordingly, both the substantive bail petition and the prayer for interim bail were dismissed.

Before the Supreme Court, senior counsel for the appellant submitted that he had appeared before the SFIO during investigation and was arrested only after the prosecution complaint had been filed. It was emphasised that he had been in custody for approximately two years and eight months and that the prosecution had named 187 accused persons, making early completion of trial improbable. The appellant also referred to bail granted to certain other accused, including Vivek Harivyasi, Priyanka Modi, Raj Kumar Modi and Surender Singh, while acknowledging that the principal accused, Mukesh Modi and Rahul Modi, remained in custody.

The SFIO opposed bail, arguing that the conditions under Section 212(6) of the Companies Act, 2013 had not been satisfied. The prosecution contended that the appellant could not claim parity because the investigation attributed to him a role in providing accommodation entries to the principal accused, besides receipt of approximately ₹22 lakh as commission. The SFIO also relied upon Serious Fraud Investigation Office Vs Nittin Johari, (2019) 9 SCC 165, concerning the statutory restrictions and principles applicable to bail in serious corporate fraud cases. As regards progress of the trial, the prosecution informed the Supreme Court that, out of 187 accused, all except 27 had appeared before the Special Court. Proclamation proceedings under Section 82(1) of the CrPC had been directed against 24 of the remaining accused by an order dated 25 March 2022.

The Supreme Court considered these circumstances and found that the large number of accused and the incomplete process of securing their appearance created substantial uncertainty regarding the trial’s completion. It held that courts must remain mindful of protecting personal liberty where the trial is unlikely to conclude within a reasonable period. Referring to Nittin Johari, the Court recognised that Section 212(6) imposes additional limitations on bail and that economic offences warrant careful scrutiny. Nevertheless, the Court emphasised that those statutory restrictions must be balanced against the constitutional right to an expeditious trial. It also considered it necessary to distinguish the appellant’s role from that of the principal accused.

Consequently, the Supreme Court allowed the appeal and directed that the appellant be released on bail, subject to terms and conditions imposed by the Special Judge in connection with Criminal Complaint No. 3 of 2019. The ruling did not decide the merits of the fraud allegations or declare the appellant innocent. Rather, it established that, in the circumstances of this prosecution, prolonged custody and the absence of a fair prospect of early trial completion justified bail notwithstanding the seriousness of the alleged corporate offences. The Supreme Court’s subsequent order superseded the High Court’s refusal of bail.

Cases Discussed

1. Serious Fraud Investigation Office Vs Nittin Johari (Supreme Court); (2019) 9 SCC 165. The Supreme Court considered this decision on the application of Section 212(6) and Section 212(7) of the Companies Act, 2013. The judgment recognises that statutory limitations on bail are additional to the principles governing bail under the Code of Criminal Procedure. The Supreme Court in the present case applied those principles while also protecting the appellant’s constitutional right to an expeditious trial.

Related Reading: Second Bail Plea in SFIO Fraud Case Dismissed by Punjab and Haryana HC.

FULL TEXT OF THE SUPREME COURT JUDGMENT/ORDER

1. Leave granted.

2. By the impugned order dated 18 November 2021 of a Single Judge of the High Court of Punjab and Haryana, an application for bail has been rejected. The Single Judge held that:

(i) An earlier application for bail was dismissed on merits; and

(ii) No ground was made out for the grant of bail on the ground of parity with the other accused who have been granted bail.

3. Briefly stated, a complaint1 was lodged on 18 May 2019 before the Sessions Judge-cum-Special Judge (under the Companies Act 2013) at Gurugram alleging violations of the provisions of Section 447 of the Companies Act 2013 and various provisions of the Indian Penal Code 1860, including Sections 406, 417, 418, 420, 467, 468, 471, 474 and 477A. After the complaint was submitted on 18 May 2019, the appellant was arrested on 28 August 2019. The first application for bail was rejected by the trial judge, following which an application under Section 439 of the Code of Criminal Procedure 1973 was rejected by the High Court on 13 November 2019. A Special Leave Petition2 was dismissed by this Court on 27 January 2020 with the observation that it was always open for the appellant to move a fresh application for bail. Following this, the appellant applied for bail which was denied by the Special Judge on 13 October 2020. The High Court declined to grant bail by the impugned judgment.

4. Mr Kapil Sibal, senior counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant, submitted that:

(i) The appellant appeared before the Serious Fraud Investigation Office3 during the course of the investigation;

(ii) The arrest was effected after the complaint was lodged;

(iii) The appellant has been in custody for nearly two years and eight months;

(iv) 187 persons are named as accused and there is no likelihood of the trial being completed at an early date; and

(v) While the main accused, Mukesh Modi and Rahul Modi, continue to remain in custody, applications for the grant of bail on the part of some of the other accused, including, Vivek Harivyasi, Priyanka Modi, Raj Kumar Modi and Surender Singh, have been entertained.

5. A counter affidavit has been filed in these proceedings by SFIO opposing bail.

6. Mr K M Nataraj, Additional Solicitor General appearing on behalf of SFIO, opposed the prayer for bail on the following grounds:

(i) The conditions which are spelt out under Section 212(6) of the Companies Act 2013 have not been fulfilled;

(ii) There can be no claim of parity having due regard to the fact that besides the receipt of a commission of an amount of Rs 22 lakhs, the appellant is, upon investigation, found to have been involved in a concerted course of action of granting accommodation entries to the main accused as a part of their business;

(iii) As regards the progress of the trial, it has been stated in the counter affidavit that a complaint was filed before the Special Court against 187 accused and that all the accused except 27 persons have appeared before the Special Court. Out of the remaining 27 persons, the Special Court has, in the case of 24 persons, by an order dated 25 March 2022, directed the initiation of proclamation proceedings under Section 82(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure 1973; and

(iv) The provisions of Section 212(6) of the Companies Act 2013 have been interpreted in a judgment of this Court in Serious Fraud Investigation Office Nittin Johari4.

7. The appellant is in custody since 28 August 2019. 187 accused are named in the criminal case by the prosecution. It is stated in the counter affidavit that all except 27 of them have appeared. It is evident that even as regards the balance, proclamation proceedings are intended to be initiated pursuant to the order of the Special judge dated 25 March 2022. The proceedings are now listed before the Special Judge in July 2022.

8. In this backdrop, in the absence of a fair likelihood of the trial being completed within a reasonable period, this Court must be mindful of the need to protect the personal liberty of the accused in the face of a delay in the conclusion of the trial. We are inclined to grant bail on the above ground having regard to the fact that the appellant has been in custody since 28 August 2019. In Nittin Johari (supra), this Court has held:

“24. At this juncture, it must be noted that even as per Section 212(7) of the Companies Act, the limitation under Section 212(6) with respect to grant of bail is in addition to those already provided in CrPC. Thus, it is necessary to advert to the principles governing the grant of bail under Section 439 of CrPC. Specifically, heed must be paid to the stringent view taken by this Court towards grant of bail with respect of economic offences.”

While the provisions of Section 212(6) of the Companies Act 2013 must be borne in mind, equally, it is necessary to protect the constitutional right to an expeditious trial in a situation where a large number of accused implicated in a criminal trial would necessarily result in a delay in its conclusion. The role of the appellant must be distinguished from the role of the main accused.

9. For the above reasons, we allow the appeal and direct that the appellant be released on bail, subject to such terms and conditions as may be imposed by the Special Judge in connection with Complaint No 3 of 2019.

10. Pending application, if any, stands disposed of.

1. Leave granted.

2. In terms of the signed order, we allow the appeal and direct that the appellant be released on bail, subject to such terms and conditions as may be imposed by the Special Judge in connection with Complaint No 3 of 2019.

3. Pending application, if any, stands disposed of.

Notes:

1 Criminal Complaint No. 3 of 2019

2 SLP (Crl) No. 11765 of 2019

3 “SFIO”

4 (2019) 9 SCC 165

Advertisement

Author Info

CA Sandeep Kanoi
Qualification: Graduate, CA in Job / Business, DD
Company: Taxguru Consultancy
Location: Mumbai, Maharashtra
Articles Published: 24,789

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.