Viney Kumar Sharma Vs Improvement Trust, Ludhiana and Another (Punjab & Haryana High Court)
Summary: The Punjab and Haryana High Court, in Viney Kumar Sharma Vs The Improvement Trust, Ludhiana and Another, dismissed a writ petition seeking execution of a conveyance deed for a residential plot purchased through a public auction, holding that such a direction could not be issued while civil suits concerning the property remained pending. The petitioner had purchased Plot No. 22-F, measuring 300 square yards, in Maharishi Balmiki Nagar, Ludhiana, through an auction conducted on 28 May 2021. After being declared the highest bidder, he received an allotment letter dated 21 June 2021, paid the entire sale consideration after obtaining a bank loan, and entered into an agreement with the Improvement Trust on 14 July 2021. Physical possession was delivered on 29 July 2021, following which he raised construction and obtained an occupation certificate on 29 December 2021. However, he subsequently discovered that the property was already involved in litigation initiated by Sushma Lata, who had obtained an interim injunction against forcible dispossession.
The petitioner had earlier approached the High Court through CWP No. 19955 of 2024, seeking a refund of ₹1,55,47,450 with 12% interest from 21 June 2021 and compensation of ₹10 lakh towards construction expenditure. He contended that he was a bona fide purchaser without notice of the pending litigation and had invested his life savings in the property. During those proceedings, the Improvement Trust disputed Sushma Lata’s ownership claims and alleged that her supporting documents were forged or fabricated. However, its counsel acknowledged a serious lapse and lack of due diligence in auctioning the property despite the pending civil suit. Since the competing claims were being adjudicated in two civil suits, the petitioner ultimately sought their expeditious disposal. Accordingly, by order dated 21 August 2024, the High Court requested the trial court to conclude the proceedings preferably within six months from receipt of a certified copy of its order, without expressing any opinion on the merits of the parties’ claims.
In the subsequent writ petition, the petitioner sought a mandamus compelling the Improvement Trust to execute the conveyance deed notwithstanding the pending litigation. The Division Bench comprising Justice Arun Palli and Justice Vikram Aggarwal observed that the earlier writ petition had already been disposed of with directions for expeditious adjudication of the civil suits. The Court held that seeking execution of the conveyance deed during the pendency of those proceedings was totally misconceived. When specifically questioned about the legal basis for issuing such a direction, the petitioner’s counsel was unable to provide an answer. The High Court therefore found no justification for entertaining another writ petition or directing execution of the conveyance deed while the property disputes remained unresolved. Accordingly, CWP No. 32947 of 2024 was dismissed as devoid of merit. The judgment did not determine the competing ownership claims or the petitioner’s ultimate entitlement to the property, leaving those issues for adjudication in the pending civil proceedings.
Cases Discussed
Viney Kumar Sharma Vs The Improvement Trust, Ludhiana and Another, CWP No. 19955 of 2024, decided on 21/08/2024 (Punjab & Haryana High Court). The earlier writ petition concerning the same property was reproduced and considered by the Court. In that proceeding, the High Court requested the civil court to decide the pending suits expeditiously, preferably within six months. The earlier order was central to the dismissal of the subsequent petition seeking execution of the conveyance deed.
FULL TEXT OF THE JUDGMENT/ORDER OF PUNJAB & HARYANA HIGH COURT
1. The petitioner (Viney Kumar Sharma) prays for the issuance of a writ of mandamus directing the respondents to execute conveyance deed of Plot No.22-F, measuring 300 sq. yards situated in Development of Maharishi Balmiki Nagar, Ludhiana (hereinafter referred to as ‘the plot’) which had been sold to the petitioner in an open auction conducted on 28.05.2021 and for which the entire sale consideration was paid by the petitioner after raising loan from the Bank.
2. Concededly, the petitioner had earlier also approached this Court by way of CWP No.19955 of 2024 which was disposed of on 21.08.2024 (Annexure P-12). The facts, as set out in the instant writ petition, are reflected in the order dated 21.08.2024;
“The petitioner (Viney Kumar Sharma) has prayed for the following substantive relief:
“Civil Writ Petition under Article 226/227 of the Constitution of India for issuance of an appropriate writ in the nature of mandamus directing the respondent No.1 to refund a sum of Rs.1,55,47,450/- along with interest at the rate of 12% with effect from 21.06.2021 (Annexure P-2) till the date of actual realization of the said amount. Further prayed for issuance of writ in the nature of mandamus directing the respondent No.1 to compensate the petitioner for the construction raised by the petitioner on the said plot after spent an amount of an amount of Rs.10,00,000/-.”
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner participated in the E-auction conducted by the respondent-trust for allotment of residential/commercial properties. And, upon being adjudged H-1, vide letter of allotment dated June 21, 2021 (P-2), he was allotted a residential plot no.22, Block-F, measuring 300 sq. yards, Maharishi Balmiki Nagar (256 Acre) Scheme, Ludhiana. Accordingly, he submits that the petitioner remitted the entire sale consideration. And, an agreement dated July 14, 2021 (P-3) was also entered into between the parties. On July 29, 2021 (P-5), the petitioner was delivered the actual physical possession of the site. Whereafter, he constructed the site and obtained the occupation certificate on December 29, 2021 (P-10). However, subsequently he learnt that a Civil Suit No.6609 of 2020, for injunction similicitor, filed by one Sushma Lata against the respondent-trust qua the subject site was pending before the Civil Judge (Junior Division), Ludhiana. And, vide interim order dated November 04, 2022 (P-15), the trial court had even restrained the respondent-trust from causing forcible dispossession of the plaintiff. Accordingly, an application under Order 1 Rule 10 of CPC was moved by the petitioner, to be arrayed as a party to the suit which, however, was dismissed on October 20, 2023 (P-19). Against which, Civil Revision No.7376 of 2023, preferred by the petitioner is pending before this Court and is posted for January 13, 2025. And, in the meanwhile, he submits that Sushma Lata (Plaintiff), alleging violation of the interim injunction granted by the trial court, has even initiated the contempt proceedings not only against the respondent-trust but also the petitioner. It is submitted that subsequently she had even moved an application seeking police help for restoration of possession which, however, was dismissed by the trial court on July 19, 2024. Accordingly, it is urged that the said suit is now posted for September 30, 2024 and, whereas the contempt proceedings are pending for September 10, 2024. Further, yet another suit has been filed by Sushma Lata (C.S. NO. 3503 of 2023) against the respondent-trust as also the petitioner, which is also pending for September 10, 2024. And, upon an application moved by the petitioner, both the suits have since been clubbed and are being heard by the same Court.
It is submitted that petitioner is a bonafide purchaser, without notice, for a valuable consideration, and had no clue that the subject property, which was put to auction by the respondent-trust was a subject matter of dispute in a suit filed by Sushma Lata. It is urged that petitioner is a senior citizen, who has invested his life savings on acquiring and constructing the site. And, he is not a litigant by choice but a victim of apparent negligence and insensitivity of the respondent-trust. However, having argued the matter at some length, learned counsel for the petitioner, as always, fairly submits that as the rights of the plaintiff (Sushma Lata), respondent trust as also of the petitioner, are being determined in the pending suit(s), for the present, the petitioner would be satisfied if the trial court, is directed to expedite the proceedings and decide the said suit(s) at the earliest.
Served with the advance copy of the petition, Mr. Sandeep Khunger, Advocate with Mr. Saksham Khunger, Advocate is present in Court on behalf of the respondent-Trust. He submits that in the written statement filed on behalf of the respondent-trust to the suit filed by Sushma Lata, not only her right, title and interest in the subject site is disputed, but the stand set out by the trust is that the documents, upon which her claim is predicated, are forged/fabricated. He submits that the matter is being pursued by the respondent trust in the right earnest. Though, he concedes that owing to a serious lapse and lack of due diligence, at the end of the respondent-trust, despite the site being a subject matter of pending suit, was put to auction. Be that as it may, he submits that every possible endeavour shall be made by the respondent trust to ensure that proceedings before trial court are not unduly delayed.
In the wake of the position sketched out above, and in terms of the statement made by learned counsel for the parties, this petition is accordingly disposed of with a request to the learned Presiding Officer, who, as indicated above, is in seisin of both the suits to try and conclude the trial, expeditiously, and decide the suit(s) preferably within six months from the receipt of certified copy of this order.
Needless to assert that this order shall not constitute an expression of opinion on the merits of the case of any of the parties to the suit(s), for, the trial court, would decide the matter strictly in accordance with law.”
3. A perusal of the aforesaid order shows that this Court had already disposed of CWP No.19955 of 2024 with a request to the learned Presiding Officer in whose Court both suits referred to in the said order were pending to try and conclude the trial expeditiously and decide the suits preferably within six months from the receipt of a certified copy of the said order. Once the aforesaid direction had been passed, the instant writ petition seeking the issuance of a mandamus directing the respondents to execute the conveyance deed of the plot in question during the pendency of the said civil suits is totally misconceived.
4. On a specific query put to learned counsel representing the petitioner as to how such a direction could be issued to the respondents, learned counsel for the petitioner is at a loss to respond.
5. Keeping in view the fact that CWP No.19955 of 2024 titled as Viney Kumar Sharma Vs. The Improvement Trust Ludhiana and another has already been disposed of by this Court in the aforestated terms, we do not find any reason to entertain the present writ petition and issue any kind of direction as regards the execution of a conveyance deed qua the plot.
Accordingly, the writ petition is found to be devoid of merit and is hereby dismissed.





