Tusharbhai Rajnikantbhai Shah Vs State of Gujarat & Ors. (Gujarat High Court)
Summary: The Gujarat High Court, in Tusharbhai Rajnikantbhai Shah Vs State of Gujarat & Ors., allowed a criminal revision application challenging the dismissal of a private complaint alleging custodial assault, threats and attempted extortion by police officers and another complainant. The revision arose from the order dated 6 January 2024 passed by the 6th Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Surat, dismissing Criminal Inquiry No. 280 of 2023 under Section 203 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. The principal issue was whether the Magistrate could dismiss the complaint without recording the statements of witnesses who, according to the applicant, were present pursuant to an earlier direction and without explaining why their statements had not been recorded. The High Court held that the applicant had not received a full opportunity to present his case and that the dismissal order was improper and perverse.
The dispute originated in FIR No. 11210068230266 of 2023 registered at Vesu Police Station, Surat, for offences under Sections 420 and 120-B of the Indian Penal Code. The applicant had unsuccessfully sought anticipatory bail before the Sessions Court in Criminal Miscellaneous Application No. 5922 of 2023. He thereafter approached the Gujarat High Court through Criminal Miscellaneous Application No. 15242 of 2023, which was disposed of on 5 October 2023 with directions concerning compliance with Section 41A CrPC. The applicant subsequently approached the Supreme Court through SLP (Criminal) No. 14489 of 2023, in which notice and ad-interim relief were granted on 8 December 2023. The revision order recounts these proceedings as part of the factual background to the applicant’s allegations.
According to the applicant’s submissions, he appeared before the Investigating Officer on 11 December 2023 and was arrested and released on bail after executing the requisite bond pursuant to the Supreme Court’s directions. On 12 December 2023, he again appeared before the investigating agency and was allegedly interrogated at the police station from 1 p.m. until 10.30 p.m. The investigating officer subsequently sought police remand, which the Magistrate granted until 16 December 2023. When the applicant was produced before the Magistrate at the conclusion of remand, he alleged that police officers had threatened and assaulted him in custody in the presence of the Deputy Commissioner of Police. He further alleged that the complainant in the original criminal case was present and that the threats and assault were intended to extort ₹1.65 crore from him.
The applicant maintained that the Magistrate had not followed the appropriate procedure upon receiving his allegations of custodial ill-treatment. He alleged that his complaint was not taken seriously because he was a builder and the Magistrate regarded the discomfort associated with police interrogation as unsurprising. The applicant thereafter filed a private complaint on 21 December 2023 under Sections 2(d) and 190 CrPC against the police officers and the original complainant. The in-charge Magistrate directed verification of the complaint and observed that sanction under Section 197 CrPC was unnecessary because the alleged offences were not committed in the discharge of official duties. The complaint was registered as Criminal Inquiry No. 280 of 2023.
The applicant’s central procedural grievance was that, although the complainant and witnesses had been directed to attend before the Magistrate, their statements were not recorded. According to the applicant, the complainant appeared with his witnesses on 3 January 2024, but the Magistrate recorded only the complainant’s verification. On 6 January 2024, the complaint was dismissed under Section 203 CrPC without examining the witnesses or providing reasons for not doing so. The applicant argued that this amounted to a mechanical exercise of judicial power and deprived him of the opportunity to place relevant evidence before the Court. The State opposed the revision and supported the Magistrate’s order.
The High Court examined the statutory framework governing dismissal of complaints. Sections 200, 202 and 203 CrPC address the examination of complainants and witnesses, inquiry before issuance of process and dismissal of complaints where sufficient grounds for proceeding are absent. Section 203 requires the Magistrate to consider the statement on oath, if any, of the complainant and witnesses and the result of any inquiry or investigation under Section 202, and briefly record reasons for dismissal. The importance of a reasoned judicial assessment at this stage is also discussed in Bhushan Steel Case: HC quashes summons issued to limited extent against PNB Executive Director, included here as related reading rather than as a precedent cited in the present order.
On examining the impugned order, the High Court found that the complainant had been directed to appear with his witnesses and that, according to the applicant’s submissions, the witnesses had attended. Their statements had nevertheless not been recorded, and the Magistrate had given no explanation for that omission. The High Court concluded that the applicant had not been afforded a full opportunity to present his case. It therefore set aside the dismissal order and directed the Magistrate to record the witness statements and thereafter apply judicial mind to determine whether sufficient grounds existed to proceed. The decision did not direct the Magistrate to issue process automatically or determine the truth of the allegations against the proposed accused.
The applicant also sought transfer or allotment of Criminal Inquiry No. 280 of 2023 to another Magistrate, stating that he had initiated contempt proceedings before the Supreme Court involving police officials and that the Magistrate who passed the impugned order was named as respondent No. 7 in those proceedings. The Gujarat High Court declined to order reassignment directly. Instead, it left the applicant free to approach the Principal District and Sessions Judge, Surat, with an appropriate application, to be decided in light of the grounds raised. Accordingly, the revision was allowed to the extent of restoring the complaint for reconsideration after witness examination, while the request for transfer was left to the competent administrative or judicial authority.
The decision reinforces the requirement that a Magistrate should undertake a meaningful assessment of the material relevant to a private complaint before dismissing it. Where witnesses have been directed to attend and are stated to be available, their omission from the inquiry without explanation may undermine the fairness of the process. At the same time, the ruling does not mean that every private complaint must result in prosecution. The Magistrate retains the statutory responsibility to determine whether sufficient grounds exist for proceeding after considering the relevant material. Related discussions of dismissal of complaints under Section 203 CrPC and the examination of witnesses before proceeding on a complaint provide further context, but were not relied upon by the Gujarat High Court in this order.
FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF GUJARAT HIGH COURT
1. By way of the present application, the applicant has prayed for the following main reliefs.
“(B) This Hon’ble Court be pleased to set aside the impugned order dated 6.1.2024 passed by the Ld.6th Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Surat annexed to the present petition at ANNEXURE – A and further be pleased to restore the Criminal Inquiry No.280 of 2023 upon the file of the Ld. Magistrate;
(C) This Hon’ble Court be pleased to direct the Ld. Magistrate to proceed with the Criminal Inquiry No.280 of 2023 in accordance with law;
2. Heard learned senior advocate Mr.I.H.Saiyed for the applicant and learned APP Ms.Jirga Jhaveri for the respondent State.
3. Learned senior advocate for the applicant has drawn the attention of this Court that the applicant has preferred the private complaint on 21.12.2023 under section 2(d) of the Code of Criminal Procedure 1973 (hereinafter referred for the sake of convenience and brevity as “the Code”) against the police officers and the complainant for threatening him and beating him up in police custody. The said private complaint came to be registered as Criminal Inquiry No.280 of 2023. Learned senior advocate for the applicant has also drawn the attention of this Court that on 22.12.2023, the learned Magistrate was not available and hence, the in-charge learned Magistrate took cognizance upon the private complaint preferred by the applicant and ordered verification of the same and while passing the said order, learned Magistrate has observed that no sanction under section 197 of the Code is required since the accused Police Officers therein have not committed the offence while discharging their official duty. Learned senior advocate for the applicant has further drawn the attention of this Court that on 6.1.2024, the learned Magistrate has resumed the office and passed the impugned order dated 6.1.2024 below Exh.1 whereby Criminal Inquiry No.280 of 2023 came to be dismissed under section 203 of the Code without allowing the witnesses to be examined.
4. Being aggrieved, the applicant has preferred the present Criminal Revision Application.
5. Learned senior advocate for the applicant has vehemently contended that the impugned order dated 6.1.2024 below Exh.1 has been passed by the learned Magistrate is the result of mechanical exercise of powers and suffers from complete lack of application of mind. Learned senior advocate for the applicant has further submitted that the power under section 203 of the Code for dismissing the complaint can be exercised after considering the statements on oath of the complainant and witnesses and result of inquiry/investigation under section 202 of the Code. Lastly, learned senior advocate for the applicant has requested this Court to allow the present revision application.
6. On the other-hand, learned APP Ms.Jirga Jhaveri has opposed the present revision application and supported the order passed by the learned Magistrate.
7. Considered the submissions made by the learned advocates for the respective parties and also perused the material made available to this Court. At this stage it would be fruitful to refer to the provisions of section 203 of the Code which read as under.
“Section 203 : Dismissal of complaint.- If, after considering the statement on oath (if any) of the complainant and of the witnesses and the result of the inquiry or investigation (if any) under section 202, the Magistrate is of opinion that there is no sufficient ground for proceeding, he shall dismiss the complaint, and in every such case he shall briefly record his reasons for so doing.”
8. It is required to be noted that the applicant was arraigned as an accused in FIR bearing No.11210068230266 of 2023 registered with Vesu Police Station, Surat for the offences under sections 420 and 120-B of IPC. Against the said FIR, the applicant preferred an application for anticipatory bail being Criminal Misc. Application No.5922 of 2023 before the learned Sessions Judge, Surat which came to be rejected vide order dated 1.8.2023. Being aggrieved, the applicant preferred Criminal Misc. Application No.15242 of 2023 before the coordinate bench of this Court. The said application came to be disposed of vide order dated 5.10.2023 with a direction to the Investigating Agency to comply with the provisions of Section 41A of the Code. Against which, the applicant preferred Special Leave Petition (Criminal) No.14489 of 2023 before the Honourable Apex Court and the Honourable Apex Court vide order dated 8.12.2023 was pleased to issue notice and granted ad-interim relief. Therefore, as per the order of the Honourable Apex Court, the applicant remained present before the Investigating Officer on 11.12.2023. The Investigating Officer arrested the applicant and thereafter released him on bail after execution of the requisite bond as per the directions issued by the Honourable Apex Court. Learned senior advocate for the applicant has drawn the attention of this Court that the notice under section 41A dated 11.12.2023 was served upon the applicant and as per the order of the Honourable Apex Court, the applicant was to remain present on 12.12.2023 for recording of his further statement. Accordingly, the applicant remained present before the Investigating Officer on 12.12.2023 and he was interrogated and kept in the police station from 1 pm to 10.30 pm. Thereafter, the applicant was served with the notice to remain present before the court of learned Magistrate for the purpose of seeking his police remand.
9. Learned senior advocate for the applicant has further drawn the attention of this Court that an application seeking remand was preferred by the Investigating Officer before the learned Magistrate and the learned Magistrate vide order dated 13.12.2023 heard the remand application preferred by the Investigating Officer and granted police remand of the applicant till 16.12.2023. It is pointed out by learned senior advocate for the applicant that when the remand got over, the applicant was produced before the learned Magistrate on 16.12.2023 and upon production before the learned Magistrate, the applicant made a complaint before the learned Magistrate that while the applicant was in police custody, he was threatened and beaten by the police in the presence of the Deputy Commissioner of Police. The applicant also stated that the complainant was also present at the Vesu Police Station and all the police officers and the complainant threatened and beat up the applicant to extort a sum of Rs.1.65 crores from the applicant. That the learned Magistrate did not follow the procedure established by law and even though specific complaint of ill-treatment was made noted that the applicant is a builder and it was natural that he being interrogated in police custody was against the comfortable situation that he was in and hence, the allegations made against the police could not be taken seriously. That besides this, no other procedure for the ill-treatment was undertaken by the learned Magistrate. Thereafter, on the insistence of the learned Magistrate, the applicant preferred Criminal Misc. Application No.15153 of 2023 for being released on regular bail which came to be allowed by the learned Magistrate and the applicant was released on bail and made to execute another bond on certain conditions.
10. Learned senior advocate for the applicant submitted that the applicant had preferred a private complaint under section 2(d) read with section 190 of the Code against the Police Officers and the complainant for threatening him and beating him up in the police custody on 21.12.2023. On that day, in-charge 6th Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate passed an order below the complaint that there was no necessity for procedure under section 197 of the Code as the offence was committed by the public servants, not as public servants and the complaint was registered as Criminal Inquiry Case and the complainant was directed to remain present with his witnesses on 3.1.2024. Learned senior advocate for the applicant submits that on 3.1.2024, the complainant was present before the learned Magistrate along with his witnesses, but the learned Magistrate merely recorded verification of the complainant and did not record the statements of the witnesses. That, thereafter, by order dated 6.1.2024, entire case was dismissed under section 203 of the Code.
11. As per Section 203 of the Code, the learned Magistrate ought to have recorded the statement on oath of the complainant and of the witnesses and when in-charge Magistrate has directed the complainant to remain present with his witnesses and the witnesses were present before the learned Magistrate, learned Magistrate without giving any reasons for not recording the statements of the witnesses has dismissed the complaint which is illegal and improper. That if the statements of the witnesses were recorded, learned Magistrate could have applied her mind and form the judgment whether there is sufficient ground for proceeding against the accused or not. That learned Magistrate has acted erroneously and has passed the impugned order which is illegal and improper and hence, the same is required to be set aside.
12. On perusal of the impugned order, it appears that the complainant was directed to remain present with his witnesses and as per the submission of the learned senior advocate for the applicant, witnesses were present before the learned Magistrate, but their statements have not been recorded. No reasons have been given by the learned Magistrate for non-recording of the statements of the witnesses and hence, the applicant – original complainant has not been given full opportunity for putting up his case before the learned Magistrate. That the impugned order is improper and perverse and is required to be set aside. Learned
13. Under the circumstances, the application is allowed. The impugned order dated 6.1.2024 passed below Exh.1 in Criminal Inquiry No.280 of 2023 is quashed and set aside. The learned Magistrate is directed to record the statements of the witnesses and then after applying judicial mind to the material placed before the Court, form the judgment whether or not, there is sufficient ground to proceed.
14. At this stage, learned senior advocate for the applicant urged this Court to direct the learned Principal Sessions Judge, Surat to allot Criminal Inquiry Case No.280 of 2023 to some other Magistrate as the applicant has filed the petition before the Honourable Apex Court for contempt against the police officials and learned Magistrate who has passed the impugned order is respondent No.7 in the said matter.
15. So far as request made by learned senior advocate for the applicant for allotment of the criminal inquiry case to some other Magistrate is concerned, this Court is not inclined to pass any such order, but it would be open for the applicant to file an application before the learned Principal District & Sessions Judge, Surat and the same shall be decided in light of the contents of the request made by the applicant.






