Anil Kumar Batar Vs PCIT (ITAT Jaipur)
No Second Chance for Fishing Enquiry- AO’s Plausible View Cannot Be Replaced by PCIT’s Suspicion- PCIT Cannot Step into AO’s Shoes: Jaipur Tribunal Quashes Revision
Background
- Original assessment completed u/s 147 r.w.s. 144B on 18.03.2023 at returned income of ₹19,89,250.
- Issue: During survey, it was found that Matrix JEE Academy (tenant) had allegedly paid ₹75,00,000 cash advance to assessee for building construction.
- AO in reassessment proceedings (u/s 148) considered assessee’s replies, accepted declared income, & made no addition on this issue.
PCIT’s Action u/s 263
- On 10.03.2025, PCIT invoked revision jurisdiction u/s 263.
- Observed AO failed to properly verify the cash transaction of ₹75 lakh, even though it was the very reason for reopening u/s 148.
- Held assessment order erroneous & prejudicial to revenue for lack of enquiry.
- Directed AO to make fresh assessment after proper verification.
Assessee’s Arguments
- No jurisdiction: Both conditions of sec. 263 not satisfied—order not erroneous & prejudicial.
- AO had already examined this issue during reassessment with detailed queries & replies.
- Case was reopened only for this limited issue (alleged ₹75 lakh cash advance) → AO verified, tenant’s affidavit filed denying payment.
- PCIT ignored affidavit & evidence.
- Revision can’t be used just because PCIT thinks “deeper enquiry” was needed.
- Relied on case laws: Malabar Industrial Co. Ltd. (SC), Gabriel India (Bom HC), Software Consultants (Del HC), Palsana Gram Seva Sahakari Samiti (ITAT Jaipur), Sajjad Ali (ITAT Jaipur) etc.
- In faceless regime (NFAC), assessments are reviewed by multiple units, reducing chance of non-application of mind.
Tribunal’s Findings
- AO had specifically raised queries u/s 142(1) about the ₹75 lakh alleged cash advance.
- Assessee replied with details, bank statements, & tenant’s affidavit denying payment.
- AO, after considering material, took a plausible view & accepted returned income.
- Principle: When AO makes enquiries & adopts one possible view, order cannot be revised merely because PCIT feels further enquiry was required.
- Affidavit filed by tenant was not rebutted by PCIT; hence, facts stated therein must be accepted as true (supported by SC in Mehta Parikh & Co.).
- Revision u/s 263 cannot be used to conduct a “second round of fishing enquiry”.
Decision
- ITAT held PCIT’s order u/s 263 invalid.
- Assessment order was neither erroneous nor prejudicial to revenue.
- PCIT’s revision quashed.
- AO’s reassessment order dated 18.03.2023 restored.
When AO conducts enquiry on the very issue of reopening & takes a plausible view, PCIT cannot invoke sec. 263 just because he expects “deeper verification”. Mere suspicion or reliance on third-party information without rebutting assessee’s evidence (like affidavit) is insufficient.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.





