ACIT Vs Sharada Narayanan (ITAT Bangalore)
ITAT Bangalore: Sale of Jewellery Inherited Through Will – Addition u/s 56 Deleted
Background
Assessee, Smt. Sharada Narayanan, declared LTCG of ₹6.29 crore on sale of jewellery valued at ₹7.09 crore, claimed as inherited from her late mother-in-law Smt. Kasturi Shoury through a notarized Will (dated 28.06.2007, disclosed after 7 years). The jewellery was sold to M/s Navarathan Jewellers, Bangalore between June 2015 and February 2016. Assessee reinvested ₹6.45 crore in a residential house, claiming exemption u/s 54F.
AO’s Assessment
AO rejected the claim holding that:
- Assessee failed to prove existence of inherited jewellery in hands of mother-in-law.
- Original Will not produced; genuineness doubted.
- Weight discrepancy: Will showed 7,243 gms, whereas jewellery sold was 26,038 gms.
- Assessee did not furnish complete list/description of jewellery.
- AO concluded there was no LTCG, treated ₹7.12 crore received from jeweller as income from other sources u/s 56, and denied exemption u/s 54F.
NFAC’s Order (CIT(A))
NFAC deleted the addition and accepted assessee’s claim, holding:
- Registration of Will not compulsory; notarized Will valid.
- Inheritance disclosed in assessee’s Wealth Tax return (AY 2015-16) showing ₹3.79 crore worth jewellery.
- Navarathan Jewellers’ register confirmed purchases in assessee’s name; payment was by RTGS.
- AO’s comments on “unequal distribution in Will” irrelevant – succession terms not subject to AO’s judgment.
- Once jewellery inherited & sold, LTCG arises; reinvestment u/s 54F verified.
- Directed AO to delete addition u/s 56 and grant 54F deduction.
Tribunal’s Findings
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.


