Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Income Tax

Joint Flat Buyer Gets Relief From Section 69 and 115BBE Addition

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2026 taxguru.in 18892
Case Name
Impa Amishkumar Desai Vs ITO (ITAT Rajkot)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Related Assessment Year
: 2021-22
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Impa Amishkumar Desai Vs ITO (ITAT Rajkot)

Builder’s Excel Sheet Alone Cannot Prove On-Money Payment — Rajkot ITAT Deletes ₹34.71 Lakh Addition

Summary: The Rajkot ITAT deleted an addition of ₹34,71,000 under section 69 read with section 115BBE for alleged cash paid over and above the registered price of a flat. The Assessing Officer relied on an Excel sheet seized from a third party and a statement explaining how unaccounted cash receipts were recorded. The Tribunal followed its coordinate bench decisions requiring independent evidence linking the disputed entry to an actual payment by the buyer.

Search on builder group leads to reassessment of flat buyer

The assessee and her husband jointly purchased Flat B-201 in Trinity Towers, Rajkot, from Buildcon Creations LLP for a registered consideration of ₹30 lakh. According to the assessee, each held a 50% share, and the entire purchase consideration was paid through banking channels.

A search under section 132 on 24 August 2021 covered several builder groups, including the Gangdev Group. An Excel file titled “Trinity” was found in the possession of Praful Narendrabhai Gangdev, a partner of Neelratna Enterprise LLP. The file contained a worksheet named “Instalment” with flat-wise details. In his statement on oath, Gangdev stated that unaccounted cash receipts were recorded in Excel sheets.

The Assessing Officer read the entry relating to the flat as evidence that the assessee had paid ₹34.71 lakh in cash over and above the registered price. He added the entire amount in her hands as unexplained investment under section 69 and applied section 115BBE. The CIT(A) confirmed the addition.

Buyer denied cash payment and sought cross-examination

The assessee relied on the registered sale deed and banking records and specifically denied paying any on-money. She pointed out that the worksheet had been found with a third party and carried no acknowledgement from her. She also requested cross-examination of Gangdev, whose statement the Assessing Officer had relied on.

The assessee separately questioned why the entire alleged payment had been attributed to her when the flat was jointly owned. She also cited two Rajkot ITAT decisions concerning buyers in the same Trinity Towers project and additions based on the same Excel file. These were Chatrabhuj Narandas Vithlani, ITA No. 113/Rjt/2026, and Kaushik Jentibhai Rathod, ITA No. 940/Rjt/2026.

ITAT follows coordinate bench on uncorroborated third-party entries

The Tribunal principally followed M/s. RC Buildcon and M/s. RC Heights Pvt. Ltd., ITA No. 941/Rjt/2024 and ITA Nos. 3 and 4/Rjt/2025, decided on 13 April 2026. In that case, the coordinate bench held that unsigned spreadsheet entries found with a third party could not sustain an addition without material showing that the entries had translated into actual transactions. The Tribunal also reproduced the reasoning in Sidique Ibrahim Allana, ITA No. 73/Rjt/2025, where an addition based on an uncorroborated WhatsApp entry had been deleted.

The coordinate bench had drawn support from the Gujarat High Court’s ruling in PCIT v. Kaushik Nanubhai Majithia, Tax Appeal No. 20 of 2024, decided on 6 March 2024. In that case, even the developer’s payment of tax before the Settlement Commissioner did not establish that the particular buyer had made the payment shown in an unsigned spreadsheet. The High Court declined to interfere with the concurrent findings that corroborative material was absent.

In the present case, the Revenue produced no material warranting a departure from the coordinate bench precedent. The Tribunal allowed the assessee’s appeal and deleted the full addition. Its operative reasoning addressed the evidentiary basis of the addition. The order contains no separate ruling on the validity of the reopening or on how an established cash payment would be attributed between the co-owners.

Author’s Comments

The distinction that matters in a section 69 case is between an entry identifying a flat and evidence identifying the person who actually paid the cash. A flat number may connect a spreadsheet entry to a property. A general statement about how cash receipts were recorded may explain the worksheet. To sustain an addition in the buyer’s hands, the Department still has to establish the link between the specific entry, the alleged payment and that buyer.

The registered deed and banking trail gave the assessee a documented account of the purchase price and how it was paid. Where the Department alleges a further payment, the practical questions are whether a receipt, a contemporaneous ledger entry or other independent material confirms it, and whether the assessee had an opportunity to test any statement relied upon. In a joint purchase, attribution raises a further question of fact. The amount assessed in each buyer’s hands must follow the evidence of payment. Here, the Tribunal found the addition unsustainable at the earlier stage of proving the alleged payment itself.

Cases Discussed

FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF ITAT RAJKOT

Captioned appeal filed by the assessee, pertaining to assessment year 2021-22, is directed against the order passed under Section 250 of the Income-Tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’) dated 21.08.2026 by the National Faceless Appeal Centre (NFAC), Delhi/ Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) [in short ‘Ld. CIT(A)’], which in turn arises out of an assessment order passed by the Assessing Officer u/s.147 of the Act, dated 11.03.2026.

2. Grounds of appeal raised by the assessee are as follows:

1. The re-assessment order u/s. 147 of the Act is bad in law.

2. The reopening of the assessment u/s. 147 of the Act is bad in law.

3. The learned Assessing Officer has erred in law as well as on facts in making an addition an of Rs.34,71,000/- u/s 69 r.w.s. 115BBE of the Income Tax Act 1961 on account of unexplained investment. The learned CIT(A) has erred in law as well as on confirming the same.

3. Brief facts qua the issue are that the present appeal arises from the assessment order under section 147 dated 11.03.2026, passed by the Income Tax Officer, Ward-(2)(2)(1), Rajkot. The assessee is an individual deriving salary income and income from short-term and long-term capital gains on sales of shares and mutual funds and interest income from savings bank account during the year under consideration. The assessee filed her income tax return on 30.12.2021, declaring a total income of Rs.4,98,510/-. A search action under section 132 of the Act was carried out on 24.08.2021 on various groups of builders, including the Gangdev Group. During the search, the residential premises of Shri Praful Narendrabhai Gangdev, a partner of M/s. Neelratna Enterprise LLP of Gangdev Group was also covered. From his possession, certain incriminating digital data in the form of Excel file, namely, “Trinity”, was found. The Excel File contained a sheet named “Instalment” containing flat-wise details. Further, a statement of Shri Praful Narendrabhai Gangdev was recorded wherein he stated that the data pertaining to the cash receipts were recorded in Excel Sheets, which were unaccounted. On the basis of the above digital data and statement of Shri Praful Narendrabhai Gangdev recorded on oath, the learned AO had drawn an adverse inference that the appellant had paid on-money to the extent of Rs. 34,71,000/- during the year under consideration for the purchase of a residential immovable property bearing Flat No. B201 in Trinity Towers, developed by M/s. Buildcon Creations LLP. Consequently, the learned AO issued notice to the assessee to explain the transaction, on account of alleged on-money payment.

4. In response to the notice of assessing officer, the assessee clearly denied the allegation of any on-money payment for purchase of the residential property. Further, the entire consideration was paid through banking channels. The registered sale deed is always overwhelming evidence as compared to Excel sheets unilaterally created by any one party. Also, the aforesaid property was purchased with the assessee’s husband, Shri Amishkumar Desai, being the first owner of the property and the appellant being a co-owner of the property, each of them having 50% share. The appellant explained that the seized Excel Sheet has neither been found from her possession nor does it contain any approval of the assessee. The data found in digital form is always amenable to changes at the discretion of the possessor. Further, in the case of unilaterally created digital data and a general statement from the witness, cross-examination becomes an inevitable requirement of the law to ascertain the truth. Hence, the assessee requested to provide an opportunity to cross-examine Shri Praful Narendrabhai Gangiev. However, the learned Assessing Officer rejected the contention of the assessee and passed the assessment order by making an addition of the entire amount of Rs.34,71,000/- u/s 69 r.w.s. 115BBE of the Act in the hands of the assessee on account of unexplained investment.

5. Aggrieved by the order of the Assessing Officer, the assessee carried the matter in appeal before the Ld. CIT(A), who has confirmed the action of the Assessing Officer, therefore, the assessee is in further appeal before this Tribunal.

6. At the outset, the Learned Counsel for the assessee submitted before me written submission, which are reproduced below:

1. It is submitted that Flat No. B-201 in the project named ‘TRINITY TOWERS’ was jointly purchased by the appellant along with her husband, Shri Amishkumar R. Desai, from M/s. Buildcon Creations LLP for a total consideration of Rs. 30,00,000/-. A copy of the purchase deed is enclosed herewith. [Page No. 1-37]

2. In the appellant’s case, the AO has made an addition of Rs. 34,71,000/- on the allegation that the appellant had made on-money payments for the purchase of the Flat No. B-201 in the project named ‘TRINITY TOWERS’. The above addition was made on the basis of the statement of Shri Praful Narendra Gangdev and the digital data in the form of an Excel Sheet (“Trinity”) found during the search.

3. The appellant’s case is directly covered by the Rajkot ITAT decision in the following identical cases wherein additions were made by the AO on the basis of the very same Excel Sheet titled “Trinity” in respect of purchases of properties in the same project, i.e. “TRINITY TOWERS”, from the same builder. The Hon’ble Tribunal deleted the addition of ‘on-money’ payment by holding that ne addition can be made merely on the basis of an unsigned and uncorroborated third-party material, without providing an opportunity of cross-examination and in the absence of any independent corroborative evidence:

    • Shri Chatrabhuj Narandas Vithlani (ITA No. 113/RJT/2026 decision dated 12.06.2026). [Page No. 38-43]
    • Kaushik Jentibhai Rathod (TA No. 940/RJT/2026 decision dated 09.09.2026)[Page No. 44-54]

4. Reliance is also placed on the decision of the Jurisdictional Rajkot ITAT in the case of M/s. RC Heights Pvt. Ltd. (ITA No. 3 & 4/RJT/2025) wherein an identical situation of unilateral material seized (Excel sheet) during the search in the case of RK Group and corresponding addition made in the case of a third party came up for consideration before the Hon’ble Tribunal. The Hon’ble ITAT held that no addition can be made merely on the basis of an unsigned and uncorroborated third-party material, without providing an opportunity of cross-examination and in the absence of any independent corroborative evidence. A copy of this decision is enclosed herewith. [Page No. 55-77] While holding so, the Rajkot ITAT has relied upon the judgment of Hon’ble Gujarat High Court in the case of PCIT v. Kaushik Nanubhai Majithia (Judgment dated 06.03.2024 in Tax Appeal No. 20 of 2024).

5. In view of the above, it is prayed that the addition of Rs. 34,71,000/- made by the AO are unsustainable in law. The same may please be deleted and oblige.

6. Further to the above, it is submitted that since the aforesaid flat was jointly purchased by the appellant along with her husband, the entire alleged amount of on-money payment cannot be made in the appellant’s hands only.

7. On the other hand, Ld. DR for the revenue relied on the findings of the Assessing Officer.

8. I have heard, both the parties and perused the material available on record. I note that the issue under consideration is squarely covered, in favour of the assessee, by the judgment of the Hon’ble ITAT Rajkot, in the case of M/s. RC Buildcon and M/s. RC Heights Pvt. Ltd in ITA No.941/RJT/2024 and 3 to 4/RJT/2025 order dated 13.04.2026, wherein it was held as follows:

“18. We note that the assessee has contended that the addition made by the assessing officer is just based on the excel file data found and seized from the third party. The addition cannot be made without rejecting the audited books of account u/s 145(3) of the Act. We note that no tangible documents, loose papers found during the course of search. So far, the excel sheet is concerned, there is no signature of the assessee as well as authorized partner of M/s Vivan Infraspace LLP. The Assessing Officer one side has observed that perusal of the excel sheet revealed that the assessee- company has not reported entire receipts, as appearing from the seized excel sheet. Matching of entries on the seized excel -sheet found from the third- party with those on the accounting ledger of the assessee and of M/s Titanium Buildcon LLP (developer of the project The City Centre) has no any nexus in the case since the assessee has worked with company, M/s Titanium Buildcon LLP and has no relevance with any document seized in the form of data/transactions recorded in the excel file from third-party. In absence of any instance of transactions being pointed out by the assessing officer, there is nothing for rebuttal by the person receiving such notice from the assessing officer. A person can offer rebuttal with evidence only where the department provides the details of the transactions which they consider to have led to cash receipt by the assessee. Merely comparing the excel sheet found from the third- party with the accounts of assessee- company, will not be an instance to prove that the assessee- company has received cash from the third- party. The well settled legal position is that a non- speaking document without any corroborative material, evidence on record and finding that such document has materialized into transactions giving rise to income of the assessee which had not been disclosed in regular books of account by such assessee, has to disregarded for the purposes of assessments to be framed pursuant to search and seizure action. From the search and seizure perspective, such non speaking seized documents are referred to as “Dump Documents”.

19. Therefore, we find that no arbitrary addition to the income of the assessee can be made by the Assessing Officer based on the dump documents, loose papers containing scribbling, rough/vague notings in the absence of any corroborative material, evidence recorded and finding that such dump documents had materialized into transactions giving rise to income of the assessee, which had not been disclosed in regular books of accounts by the assessee. For that reliance is placed on the judgement of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of K.P. Varghese vs. ITO [1981] 7 Taxman 13/131 ITR 597 held that the fictional receipt cannot be deemed to be receipt in the absence of any cogent material to support the factum of actual receipt. Moreover, the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in case of CIT vs. D.K. Gupta [2008] 174 Taxman 476 upheld the order of the Tribunal wherein it was held that Ad-hoc/Dumb Documents without any corroborative evidence and finding, that the alleged documents nave materialized into transactions cannot be deemed to be the income of the assessee. The Hon’ble Calcutta Bench of ITAT in case of T.S. Venkatesan v. Asstt. CIT [2000] 74 ITD 298 held that in the absence of corroborative evidence, addition of undisclosed income could not be made simply on the basis of entries on loose papers recovered from the residence of a third- party and certain general statements of said party. Therefore, the well settled legal position is that a non- speaking document referred to as a “Dump Document” without any corroborative material, evidence on record, has to disregarded for the purposes of assessments to be framed u/s 153A and 153C of the Act. The aforementioned legal position also gathers support from the Judgement of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of CBI v. V.C. Shukla 1998 taxmann.com 2155 popularly known as Jain Hawala Case wherein it was held that any presumption of transaction on some vague, tenuous and dubious entries in a sheet of paper is not rational and hence legal unless there is corroboration by corresponding entry in regular accounts of both the parties to the transaction. In this case it was held that entries in Jain Notebooks held on facts admissible under section 34, but file containing loose sheets of papers are not “book” and hence entries therein not admissible under section 34 of the evidence Act. Further it was also held in this case that entries in books of account shall not alone be sufficient evidence to charge any person with liability. The above view further gathers reinforcement from the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Common Cause v. Union of India [2017] 77 taxmann.com 245/245 Taxman 214/394 ITR 220 popularly known Sahara dairies and Aditya Birla diaries case. In this case, the Hon’ble Supreme Court, following the judgment rendered in case of V.C. Shukla (supra), laid down the following principles:

(i) Entries in loose papers/sheets are irrelevant and not admissible under section 34 of the Evidence Act. It is only where the entries are in the books of account regularly kept, depending on the nature of occupation, that those are admissible;

(ii) As to the value of entries in the books of account, such statement shall not alone be sufficient evidence to charge any person with liability, even if they are relevant and admissible, and that they are only corroborative evidence. Even then independent evidence is necessary as to trustworthiness of those entries which is a requirement to fasten the liability.

(iii) The meaning of account book would be spiral notebook/ped but not loose sheets.

(iv) Entries in books of account are not by themselves sufficient to charge any person with liability, the reason being that a man cannot be allowed to make evidence for himself by what he chooses to write in his own books behind the back of the parties. There must be independent evidence of the transaction to which the entries relate and in absence of such evidence no relief can be given to the party who relies upon such entries to support his claim against another;

(v) Even if books of account are regularly kept in the ordinary course of business, the entries therein shall not alone be sufficient evidence to charge any person with liability. It is not enough merely to prove that the books have been regularly kept in the course of business and the entries therein are correct. It is further incumbent upon the person relying upon those entries to prove that they were in accordance with fact.

(vi) The Court has to be on guard while ordering investigation against any important Constitutional functionary, officers or any person in the absence of some cogent legally cognizable material. When the material on the basis of which investigation is sought is itself irrelevant to constitute evidence it is not admissible in evidence.

20. We note that apart from excel sheet, no evidence has been found to suggest that the assessee had actually received the said amount. In the absence of any documentary evidence to suggest the same, it could not be presumed that the amounts reflected in the excel sheet were the income of the assessee, received from RK Group. The Assessing Officer has not brought on record any evidence to suggest that RK Group has admitted that the amounts were paid to the assessee- company. Hence, simply rough noting on the excel file, which is not signed by any party, does not mean that the addition could be made in the hands of the assessee- company. Since no evidence was found relating to the existence of any transaction between the assessee-company and R K Group and in the absence of any corroborative evidence to suggest that the assessee- company had actually received the said amount, no addition could be made merely on the basis of noting excel file found during the search proceedings from third party.

21. We find that no tangible documents, any loose papers found during the courses of search, which contains the signature of the assessee as well as authorized partner of M/s Titanium Buildcon LLP. In Pankaj Dahyabhai Patel (HUF) Vs. ACIT (1999) 63 TT) (Ahm) 790-where papers were not seized from house of the assessee nor was in his handwriting, of the assessee, the inference of on-money receipt based on such paper was not justified. Additions based on loose papers without corroborative evidence, it was held, by Tribunal, to be not sustainable. Neither evidence to link the seized documents found in the premises of third party, that is, R K Group during the course of search, then the presumption u/s 132(4A) of the Act not applicable. The action of the Assessing Officer in making addition based on the searched person`s excel -sheet data, recording of third party, that the same belongs to the assessee, is incorrect, as the same would be clearly impermissible, as the seized data, admittedly, had no nexus with the assessee and there is no signature of assessee or third-party, on such excel sheet. In the case of Addl. CIT v. Miss Lata Mangeshkar [1974] 97 ITR 696 (Bom), the addition was made in the hands of the assessee on the basis of the entries in the books of third persons. Hon’ble Bombay High Court held that such addition could not be made only on the basis of the notings in the books of third persons. The entire addition revolving to the excel sheet found and seized from the third- party which is “dump documents” which has no legality in the eyes of the law and the addition exclusively based on such documents needs to be deleted.

22. We note that assessee’s issue under consideration is also covered by the judgement of the Hon’ble High Court of Gujarat in the case of PCIT vs. Kaushik Nanubhai Majithia R/Tax Appeal No. 20 of 2024 order dated 06.03.2024, while passing the order the Hon’ble Gujarat High Court has made the following observations:

“1. Having noted the findings of the facts returned by the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) (‘CITA’, in brief) and the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (‘ITAT’, herein after), we may record that, essentially, the proceedings under Section 153C of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (in short, ‘IT Act of 1961′) were initiated against the Respondent- assessee on the basis of an excel sheet found from the computer of a person, associated with the Company, namely Navratna Organizers and Developers Private Limited (in short as “the Developer’), in the premises of whom the search was conducted.

2. The excel sheet, according to the learned Counsel for the Revenue, contained the details of payment made by the assessee to the developer, with respect to which tax had been paid by the developer before the Settlement Commissioner. The findings returned by the CITA and ITAT on the issue is sought to be assailed on the ground that the payment of tax by the developer, in whose premises search was conducted, before the Settlement Commissioner, with respect to the amount entered in the excel sheet found from the possession of the assistant working with the developer, is sufficient proof of the transaction between the assessee and the developer.

3. We find Inherent fallacy in this submission, inasmuch as, there is no basis for conducting proceedings against the assessee merely for the fact that the developer had paid tax on the amount shown in the excel-sheet There is no adjudication with regard to the payment, which was shown in the excel-sheet to the effect that the same was actually paid by the assessee to the developer. Even otherwise, the concurrent findings written by the CITA and ITAT are that the document found from the premises of the third party namely excel-sheet, which is the basis the proceedings was without any signature and there is no corroborative material to substantia the said document. The nature of the document has not been explained by the Assessing Officer while proceeding against the assessee. The statements of the persons recorded during search with reference to the alleged, seized material, was not provided to the assessee and hence, the entire proceedings under Section 153C of the IT Act of 1961 stood vitiated.

4. Learned Counsel for the petitioner could not successfully demolish the facts, which ai recorded concurrently by the CITA and ITAT.

5. No question of law much less any substantial question of law arises to entertain this appeal. The same is accordingly, dismissed.”

23. The issue is also covered by the judgement of the Co-ordinate Bench of ITAT Rajkot, in the case of Sidique Ibrahim Allana, in ITA No.73/RJT/2025, wherein it was held as follows:

“Analysis and Conclusion:

18. We have heard both the parties and carefully gone through the submission put forth on behalf of the assessee along with the documents furnished and the case laws relied upon, and perused the fact of the case including the findings of the ld CIT(A) and other materials brought on record. We note that assessing officer initiated the reassessment proceedings against the assessee, with the approval of Principal Commissioner that the books of accounts or documents, seized or requisitioned under section 132 of the Act, in case of Shri Mansur Mehta Group, pertains or relates to the assessee under consideration. Therefore, we note that there was no search on the assessee. We find that the figure mentioned in the WhatsApp chat at 550/-, has been interpreted by the Assessing Officer by adding five zeros, as if, it is at Rs. 5,50,00,000/- without any basis. We find that what is the basis, to add five more zeros, has not been explained by the Assessing Officer in his assessment order. As per learned DR for the revenue, the assessing officer added five zero, after the figure at 550/-, by applying common sense, is not acceptable. The addition made by the Assessing Officer (AO), is based purely on his own assumption, such as arbitrarily adding five zeroes to Rs. 550/-, found in a WhatsApp chat, is not legally sustainable, in the eyes of law, as, it is not corroborated by any further evidence. Such five zeroes were not even corroborated by a clear statement taken during the search proceedings. Neither the assessee stated nor the third-party stated, in his statement that five zeroes to Rs. 550/- may be added.

19. We note that the addition made by the assessing officer, must be based on concrete evidence and not on mere suspicion, conjecture, or assumptions. No addition can be made on the basis of assumptions and presumptions without corroborative evidence. A WhatsApp chat showing a reference to Rs. 550/- alone does not prove that the assessee, made investment in India of Rs. 550 x 100,000 (that is, Rs.5,50,00,000). The evidentiary value of a WhatsApp message must be corroborated with supporting evidence such as bank statements, ledger entries, cash flow statement, or statements from the sender/receiver etc. Any arbitrary enhancement in the figure of WhatsApp chat, by the assessing officer (like adding 5 zeroes) without giving the assessee a chance to rebut would violate the principles of natural justice, also. If the assessing officer wants to treat the figure at 550/- equivalent to Rs.5,50,00,000/-, by his own assumption and presumption, then in that circumstances, the onus is on the assessing officer to prove that the amount of Rs.5,50,00,000/-, is the investment made by the assessee in any movable and immovable property, in India, which he has failed to prove with corroborative evidence. That is, the assessing officer must prove that the Rs. 550 refers to undisclosed investment of assessee, and if claiming it is Rs. 5,50,00,000/-, then assessing officer must produce valid evidence before the assessee, for his rebuttal, which the assessing officer has failed to do so. Thus, addition of 5 zeroes to Rs. 550 is based purely on assumption by the Assessing Officer, which is unjustified, and therefore, needs to be deleted.

20. We also note that ld. DRP mentioned in its order that figure of 550/-, is apparently at Rs.550 lakhs, which is again without any base. The learned DRP did not mention that how the figure of 550/- is apparently at Rs.550 lakhs. By following arbitrary method, the said figure, could be apparently be presumed at Rs.5500 lakhs or Rs.55,000/- lakhs also. Thus, the findings of the Ld DRP, is also based on surmise and conjuncture, so far adding five zeroes are concerned.

21. We also note that the provision of Section 132(4A) and Section 292C of the Act creates deeming fiction on the assessee subjected to search or survey, wherein it may be presumed that any such document found during the course of search / survey from the possession or control of person searched / surveyed belongs to such person and contents of such documents are true. However, in the assessee`s case under consideration, it is an undisputed fact that the impugned loose papers- WhatsApp chat, was not found from the possession of assessee, but the same was found from the possession of third party. Therefore, noting made in such loose papers do not present a preponderance of probabilities, so as to support the allegation of unexplained investment. It is well settled position of law that a non-speaking document referred to as a “Dump Document” without any corroborative material or evidence on record has to disregarded for the purposes of assessments to be framed under the Income Tax Act. This view gathers support from the landmark judgement of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of CBI v. V. C. Shukla 1998 taxmann.com 2155 (SC) popularly, known as Jain Hawala Case, wherein it was held that any presumption of transaction on some vague, tenuous and dubious entries in a sheet of paper, is not rational and hence legal, unless there is corroboration by corresponding entry in regular accounts of both the parties to the transaction. In this case it was held that entries in Jain Notebooks held on facts admissible under Section 34 of Evidence Act, but file containing loose sheets of papers are not “book” and hence entries therein not admissible under Section 34 of Evidence Act. Further it was also held in this case that entries in books of account shall not alone be sufficient evidence to charge any person with liability. Entries even if relevant are only corroborative evidence. Independent evidence as to trustworthiness of those entries is necessary to fasten the liability. In view of these facts, it was held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court that entries made in the Jain Hawala diaries are under Section 34 of the Evidence Act, but truthfulness thereof not proved by any independent evidence. It was also held in this case that “books” ordinarily mean a collection of sheets of paper or other material, blank, written, printed, fastened or bound together so as to form a material whole. Loose sheets or scraps of paper cannot be termed as “book” for they can be easily detached and replaced. The Supreme Court further went on to state that even correct and authentic entries in books of account cannot without independent evidence of their trustworthiness fix a liability upon a person.

22. The above view further gathers reinforcement from another recent and landmark judgement of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Common Cause v. UOI [2017] 77 taxmann.com 245 popularly known Sahara dairies and Aditya Birla diaries case. In view of the above rulings laid down by Hon’ble Apex Court, we find that the figure 550/- reflected in the WhatsApp chat, is without any head or tail and such figure does not consist complete breakup of transactions and hence, no adverse inference could have been drawn solely on the basis of such WhatsApp chat. We also place reliance on the decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of K. P. Varghese v. ITO [1981] 131 ITR 597 (SC), wherein, it is held that the fictional receipt cannot be deemed to be a receipt in the absence of any cogent material to support the factum of actual receipt.

23. Our view is further fortified by the judgement of the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in case of CIT v. D.K. Gupta [2008] 174 Taxman 476 (Delhi), wherein, Hon’ble High Court had upheld the order of the lower court (ITAT), wherein, it was held that Ad-Hoc / Dumb Documents without any corroborative evidence/finding that the alleged documents have materialized into transactions cannot be deemed to be the income of the assessee. We also find that Co-ordinate Bench of ITAT Mumbai, in case of Amarjit Singh Bakshi (HUF) v. ACIT [2003] 86 ITD 13 (Delhi) (TM) held that any noting in the loose sheet is no evidence by itself. An entry in the books of account maintained in the regular course of business is relevant for purposes of considering the nature and impact of a transaction, but notings on slips of paper or loose sheets of paper cannot fall in this category. Thus, we find that in assessee`s case under consideration, the basis for addition is only WhatsApp chat. The WhatsApp chats are unsigned documents. The Assessing Officer has not established nexus between the WhatsApp chat with actual investment in India by the assessee, if any. Such WhatsApp chat, seized during the course of search, is a dumb document having no evidentiary value, hence no addition can be made, in the hands of the assessee, in the absence of corroborative material. In the instant case, undoubtedly no statement from the parties whose names found in the WhatsApp chat, has been brought to the notice and as such entire addition in the hands of the assessee, on the basis of uncorroborated, WhatsApp chat, in the loose paper form, is not possible.

24. Besides, the assessee under consideration, is a non-resident, therefore no any income has accrued or arisen in India, by way of WhatsApp chat, which contains figure at 550/-.The assessee stated that he lived in the UAE, since 1995, and as per section 5(2) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, an income of a non-resident, is not taxable, if such income, is not received or accrued or arised in India. Since, assessee had no income that is received or accrued or arose in India, hence he is not liable for payment of any taxes in India. Besides, no any investment was made by the assessee, in India, which is mentioned in the WhatsApp chat at Rs.550/-. At the cost of repetition, the provisions of section 5(2) of the Act, is reproduced below:

“(2) Subject to the provisions of this Act, the total income of any previous year of a person, who is a non-resident, includes all income from whatever source derived which-

(a) is received or is deemed to be received in India in such year by or on behalf of such person or

(b) accrues or arises or is deemed to accrue or arise to him in India during such year.”

The assessee submitted, a copy of his passport, before the assessing officer, to demonstrate that he was non-resident in India, therefore, we note that since, the assessee is a non-resident in India, therefore, he is not liable to tax in India, on the basis of WhatsApp chat, which contains the figure at 550/-, as the said amount has neither accrued in India nor arisen in India. In addition to this, figure in WhatsApp chat, is an arbitrary figure, without any corroborative evidence, therefore, it is not a real income of the assessee. Under the Income Tax Act, only real income is to be taxed, not the imaginary figure or arbitrary figure, which does not have any support with corroborative evidence. Therefore, in absence of any external evidence, addition cannot be resorted to only on the basis of WhatsApp chat. The department had not brought on record any evidence to prove conclusively that the WhatsApp chat contained details of secreted profits which were chargeable to tax in India. Hence, we are not inclined to accept the contention of the Assessing Officer/ DRP in any manner and hence the addition so made is deleted. Hence ground No.3 raised by the assessee, on merit, is allowed.”

9. As the issue is squarely covered in favour of the assessee by the decision of the Coordinate Bench(supra) and there is no change in facts and law and the Revenue is unable to produce any material to controvert the aforesaid findings of the Coordinate Bench (supra). In this case, the Coordinate Bench(supra), has observed that addition should not be made based on the excel sheet, which was neither signed by the seller nor purchaser, hence, based on the dump document, the addition should not be made.

10. As the issue is squarely covered in favour of the assessee by the judgment of the Coordinate Bench of ITAT Rajkot, in the case of M/s. RC Buildcon and M/s. RC Heights Pvt. Ltd. (supra) and there is no change in facts and law and the revenue has failed to point out any infirmity in the decision of the Coordinate Bench in the case of M/s. RC Buildcon and M/s. RC Heights Pvt. Ltd. (supra), therefore, respectfully following the binding precedent of the Coordinate Bench of ITAT Rajkot, in the case of M/s. RC Buildcon and M/s. RC Heights Pvt. Ltd. (supra), I allow the appeal of the assessee.

11. In the result, appeal filed by the assessee, is allowed.

Order is pronounced in the open Court Today on 17/11/2026.

Advertisement

Author Info

CA Vijayakumar Shetty
Qualification: CA in Practice
Company: Shetty & Co, Chartered Accountants, Mangalore
Location: Mangalore, Karnataka
Articles Published: 7,778

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.