Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Income Tax

Section 56(2)(vii)(b) Addition Not Applicable to Purchase of Leasehold Rights: ITAT Jaipur

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2026 taxguru.in 19085
Case Name
Shiv Kumar Soni Vs ACIT (ITAT Jaipur)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Related Assessment Year
2014-15
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Shiv Kumar Soni Vs ACIT (ITAT Jaipur)

Summary: The Jaipur Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, in Shiv Kumar Soni Vs ACIT, allowed the assessee’s appeal for Assessment Year 2014-15 and deleted an addition of ₹26,10,078 made under Section 56(2)(vii)(b) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The principal issue was whether acquisition of leasehold rights in an industrial plot, together with the building situated thereon, could be treated as acquisition of immovable property for the purpose of taxing the difference between the purchase consideration and the stamp duty valuation. The Tribunal held that the assessee had acquired leasehold rights rather than ownership of the underlying land and that the deeming provision could not be extended to such rights.

The assessee, engaged in the business of trading gold bullion and gold and silver items, filed his return of income on 29 November 2014 declaring ₹16,79,410. During the relevant year, he entered into an agreement dated 8 October 2013 with M/s Unique Impex for acquisition of an industrial plot situated at G1-14(A), EPIP, Sitapura, Jaipur, measuring 1,180 square metres, together with a building having a covered area of 6,858.42 square feet. The agreed consideration was ₹97,00,000, whereas the Sub-Registrar adopted a stamp duty value of ₹1,23,10,078. The Assessing Officer treated the difference of ₹26,10,078 as taxable income under Section 56(2)(vii)(b).

The assessee contended that the property belonged to Rajasthan State Industrial Development and Investment Corporation Ltd. (RIICO) and that the seller possessed leasehold rights under an allotment letter dated 8 July 2003 and a lease agreement dated 2 March 2005. These rights were transferred to the assessee under the agreement dated 8 October 2013. According to the assessee, the statutory definition of property under Section 56(2)(vii) referred to immovable property being land or building or both, and did not extend to rights permitting the use or enjoyment of such property. Consequently, the difference between stamp duty value and consideration could not be taxed by treating leasehold rights as outright ownership.

The Assessing Officer rejected this argument, reasoning that the expression immovable property was sufficiently wide to include rights in land or buildings. He accordingly added ₹26,10,078 to the assessee’s income. On appeal, the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)-2, Jaipur, upheld the addition. The CIT(A) distinguished the decision in Jaipur Times Industries Vs ITO, which concerned Section 50C and leasehold rights in land. According to the CIT(A), the present transaction included a building constructed by the seller, and the consideration for land and building could not be segregated. The transaction was therefore treated as purchase of land and building attracting Section 56(2)(vii)(b).

Before the Tribunal, the assessee relied on the terms governing RIICO’s permission to transfer the leasehold rights. RIICO’s letter dated 6 January 2014 permitted the transfer subject to conditions, including construction of a rainwater harvesting system, clearance of outstanding dues and plantation of trees. The assessee argued that these restrictions demonstrated that ownership of the land remained with RIICO and that the transferee acquired only a conditional right to use the property. The assessee further submitted that a deeming provision must be interpreted strictly and could not be extended beyond its statutory purpose.

In support of this position, the assessee cited Bhavna Shashikant Ghone Vs ITO, Khazan Singh Anand, Noida Cyber Park Pvt. Ltd. and Rajkot Nagrik Sahakari Bank Ltd. The Tribunal particularly examined the Pune Bench decision in Bhavna Shashikant Ghone Vs ITO, which held that leasehold rights were not covered by the expression land or building or both for the purposes of Section 56(2)(vii)(b). That decision drew support from judicial interpretations of the corresponding expression under Section 50C.

The Jaipur Bench accepted the reasoning of the coordinate Bench and placed particular reliance on RIICO’s letter dated 6 January 2014, which established that the assessee had acquired leasehold rights for 99 years. The Tribunal concluded that Section 56(2)(vii)(b) could not be applied to the transaction and disagreed with the CIT(A)’s conclusion that the assessee had purchased land and building outright. It accordingly directed deletion of the entire addition of ₹26,10,078 and allowed the assessee’s solitary ground of appeal.

The decision is significant for the distinction it draws between acquisition of ownership in immovable property and acquisition of leasehold rights. Its application must nevertheless be assessed with reference to the relevant statutory provision, assessment year and the actual nature of the rights transferred. The Tribunal’s ruling concerned Section 56(2)(vii)(b) as applicable to AY 2014-15; it should not automatically be treated as determining the application of subsequently introduced or amended provisions to every leasehold transaction.

Cases Discussed

  • Rajkot Nagrik Sahakari Bank Ltd. – 2022 (7) TMI 333, dated 06/07/2022 (ITAT Rajkot). Cited by the assessee in support of the exclusion of leasehold rights from the scope of the deeming provision.
  • Bhavna Shashikant Ghone Vs ITO, Ward 12(2), Pune – 2022 (9) TMI 919, dated 20/06/2022 (ITAT Pune). The principal coordinate Bench decision followed by the Tribunal, holding that acquisition of leasehold rights does not attract Section 56(2)(vii)(b).
  • Khazan Singh Anand Vs ITO, Ward 40(5), New Delhi – 2020 (12) TMI 114, ITA No. 5837/Del/2019, dated 02/12/2020 (ITAT Delhi). Held that Section 50C does not apply to the transfer of leasehold rights in land.
  • Noida Cyber Park Pvt. Ltd. – 2020 (10) TMI 563, ITA No. 165/Del/2020, dated 12/10/2020 (ITAT Delhi). Cited by the assessee in support of the distinction between leasehold rights and ownership of immovable property.
  • Ritz Suppliers Pvt. Ltd. Vs ITO – 2020-TIOL-307-ITAT-KOL; 182 ITD 227 (ITAT Kolkata). Referred to in the reproduced coordinate Bench decision concerning the non-applicability of Section 50C to the transfer of leasehold rights.
  • CIT Vs Greenfield Hotels and Estates Pvt. Ltd. – [2017] 77 taxmann.com 308; 389 ITR 68 (Bombay High Court). Referred to in the reproduced Pune Bench decision regarding the applicability of Section 50C to leasehold rights.
  • Kancast Pvt. Ltd. Vs ITO – [2015] 55 taxmann.com 171; 68 SOT 110, ITA No. 1265/PN/2011, dated 19/01/2015 (ITAT Pune). Held that Section 50C does not extend to the transfer of leasehold rights in land or building.
  • Jaipur Times Industries Vs ITO, Ward 1(3), Jaipur – ITA No. 429/JP/2012, AY 2007-08, dated 26/02/2014 (ITAT Jaipur). Held that Section 50C cannot be invoked where leasehold rights, rather than ownership of land, are transferred. The CIT(A) distinguished this decision on facts.
  • GVK Industries Ltd. Vs ITO – (2011) 4 SCC 36 (Supreme Court). Appears among the authorities cited in the reproduced Pune Bench decision.

FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF ITAT JAIPUR

This appeal filed by the assessee is directed against order of the ld. CIT(A)-2, Jaipur dated 16-12-2019 for the assessment year 2014-15 wherein the solitary ground raised by the assessee is as under:-

“That on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the ld. CIT(A) is wrong, unjust and has erred while upholding AO’s decision and confirmed addition of Rs.26,10,078/- on account of invoking provisions u/s 56(2)(vii)(b) of the Income Tax Act, 1961.”

2.1 Brief facts of the case are that the asssessee filed the original return of income showing total income of Rs.16,79,410/- on 29-11-2014 which was processed u/s 143(1) of the Act. The case of the assessee was selected for scrutiny on the basis of CASS under complete scrutiny. The statutory notice u/s 143(2) of the Act was issued on 01-08-2015 which was duly served upon the assessee, however due to change of incumbent, the case was referred to transfer pricing officer u/s 92CA(1) on 16-09-2016 for approval of ld. Pr.CIT-2, Jaipur. In this case, the AO noticed that the assessee derives income from trading of bullion, purchase & sale of gold and silver items in wholesale. In this case, the AO while making the assessment during the year under consideration noticed that the assessee had purchased plot situated at G1-14(A), EPIP, Sitapura, Jaipur for a consideration of Rs.97.00 lacs. However, the stamp duty value of such lease hold rights of plot situated at G1-14(A), EPIP, Sitapura, Jaipur as adopted by Sub-Registrar, Jaipur-VI amounted to Rs.1,23,10,078/-. Therefore, vide note sheet entry dated 15-09-2017, the AO show caused the assessee as to why difference of Rs.26,10,078/- should not be added back to the total income of the assessee u/s 56(2)(vii)(b) of the Act for which the ld. AR of the assessee submitted the detailed reply before the AO mentioning therein that “5. As section 56(2)(vii)(b) applies only to a immovable property, being land or building or both, it cannot be made applicable to lease rights in a land. As the assessee purchase lease right for ninety years (90 years) in the plot and not land itself, the provisions of Section 56(2)(vii)(b) cannot be invoked.” However, the submission made by the assessee was considered by the AO and he did not find the same tenable due to the reason that, in the Section 56(2)(vii)(b), the phrase ‘land or building or both’ has never been used by the statute and wrongly stated by the assessee. According to the AO Explanation to Section 56(2)(vii) defines “property” inter alia to mean capital asset being (i) immovable property being land or building or both, (ii) shares and securities (iii) jewellery (iv) archaeological collections (v) drawings (vi) paintings (vii) sculptures (viii) any work of art or (ix) bullions. However, the definition of ‘property’ does not refer to rights in land or building or both. Hence, the lease rights in land under consideration can neither be classified as “any sum of money” or can it be classified as “property”. The AO thus observed that the term of ‘immovable property’ is a wider term and it has always included rights in land or building or both. The AO did not find the arguments raised by the assessee satisfactory and made the addition of Rs.26,10,078/- by taking the difference of stamp value of Rs.1,23,10,078 minus sales consideration of Rs.97,00,000/-. Thus the AO made addition of Rs.26,10,078/- u/s 56(2)(vii)(b) of the Act and added the same amount to the total income of the assessee.

2.2 In first appeal, the ld. CIT(A) confirmed the action of the AO by observing as under:-

“2.3 I have perused the facts of the case, the assessment order and the submissions of the appellant. On perusal of overall facts, it is seen that during the year under consideration, assessee purchased a plot measuring 1180 Sq.mtr alongwith building with covered area of 6858.42 sq.ft. for Rs. 97,00,000/-. However, stamp authority took value of this land at Rs. 1,23,10,078/- for stamp duty purpose. The Assessing Officer treated the difference as income under section 56(2)(vii)(b) for Rs. 26,10,078/-

2.3.1 Ld. Authorized Representative argued that section 56(2)(vii)(b) is deeming fiction applicable only with respect to land and building or both and does not cover any right in land and building or both. For this he relied upon decision of Hon’ble ITAT, Jaipur bench in case of Jaipur Times Industries Vs. ITO.

2.3.2 On going through sale deed and order of Hon’ble ITAT, Jaipur bench, I find that as per sale deed the assessee has sold land and building thereon. The land is leasehold but the building thereon is not a leasehold building. In fact, the building is constructed by the seller and assessee purchased both land and building. Therefore, the claim of the appellant that assessee has sold any lease hold rights is incorrect.

2.3.3 So far as decision of Hon’ble ITAT is concerned, I find that Hon’ble ITAT in decision of Jaipur Times Industries held that section 50C cannot apply to leasehold rights in land and therefore, they deleted addition under section 50C. Thus, in that case, only leasehold right in land was sold. The facts of this case are different. Here, the assessee purchased the land allotted by RIICO to buyer alongwith building constructed thereon. The purchase consideration is for both and cannot be segregated. Thus this, constitutes, purchase of land and building by appellant, therefore, provisions of section 56(2)(vii)(b) are clearly applicable. Accordingly, addition made by the Assessing Officer is confirmed. This ground of appeal is dismissed.

3.In the result, the appeal is dismissed.”

2.3 During the course of hearing, the ld. AR of the assessee reiterated the same arguments as were raised by him before the ld. CIT(A).

2.4 On the contrary, the ld. DR supported the orders of the authorities below.

2.5 The Bench has heard both the parties and perused the materials available on record. Brief facts of the case are that the assessee is engaged in the business of trading of Gold Bullions. During the year under consideration, the assessee has filed his return of income on 29-11-2014 declaring total income at Rs.16,79,410/-. It is noted that the assessee had entered into the sale agreement dated 08.10.2013 with M/s Unique Impex (hereinafter referred to as seller) of the industrial plot [admeasuring 1180 sq. meters] alongwith the building thereon [admeasuring 6858.42 sq. feets] situated at G1-14(A), EPIP, Sitapura, Jaipur (herein after referred to as the said property). The ownership over the said property belongs to Rajasthan State Industrial Development Investment Corporation Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as RIICO) for a sum of Rs. 97,00,000/-. The seller had received the lease-hold rights for a fixed period of 99 years on the said property from RIICO vide allotment letter dated 08.07.2003 and lease agreement dated 02.03.2005 (Page 12-20, 21-25 of Paper Book). The seller transferred the lease hold rights over the said property to the assessee vide sale agreement dated 08.10.2013 for Rs 3,.97,00,000/-. Subsequently RIICO issued letter dated 06.01.2014 (at Page No. 10-11 of II Paper Book) to the seller granting permission to transfer the lease hold rights of the property subject to compliance of certain terms and condition which were to be complied with by the SELLER but he had not complied, such as construction of Rain Water Harvesting System (Condition No. 7), Clearance of Old Outstanding dues of the Seller to RIICO (Condition No. 8), plantation of trees (Condition No. 10). On perusal of terms and condition of the letter of permission for transfer of lease hold right in favor of the assessee, the assessee did not retain the exclusive right of ownership over the land. It is only the right to use the land subject to terms and conditions imposed by RIICO. The AO without considering the submission made by the assessee made an addition of Rs 26,10,078/- u/s 56(2)(vii)(b) of the Act. The ld. CIT(A) also confirmed the action of the AO. The ld. AR of the assessee prayed that AO and ld. CIT(A) grossly erred in invoking the provision of 56(2)(vii)(b) of the Act. He submitted that section 56(2)(vi)(b) is deeming fiction and it is settled preposition that deeming provision cannot be extended beyond the purposed for which it is enacted and section 56(2)(vii)(b) applies only in the cases of transfer of Immovable property takes place but not where the transfer of rights in the immovable property takes place. The definition of property does not refer to rights or transactions which may enable use or enjoyment of property and it appears that having regards to description context and objective, acquisition of such rights cannot be equated with immovable property. To this effect, the ld. AR of the assessee relied on following case laws

1. Bhavna Shashikant Ghone, 2022 (9) TMT 919 dated 20-06-2022, (ITAT Pune Bench.)

2. Khazan Singh Anand (2020) 12 TMI 114 dated 02-12-2020 (ITAT Delhi Bench)

3. Noida Cyer Park Pvt. Ltd (2020) (10) TMI 563 dated 12-10-2020 (ITAT Delhi Bench)

4. Rajkot Nagrik Sahakari Bank Ltd. (2022) (7) TMI 333 dated 06-07-2022 (ITAT Rajkot Bench)

The Bench has gone through the series of the case laws relied upon by the assessee. However, it is noted that the ITAT Pune Bench in the case of Bhavna Shashikant Ghone vs ITO Ward 12(2), Pune has very explicitly observed as under:-

“4. The first and foremost issue that arise for our apt adjudication in this backdrop herein is as whether such leasehold rights are covered under the statutory definition of “any immovable property” u/s 56(2)(vii)(b) as defined in Explanation (d)(i) as “being land or building or both”. We note that the legislature has used an identical express in Section 50C(1) of the Act wherein various judicial precedents (2017) 77 taxmann.com 308 (Bom), CIT vs Greenfields Hotels and Estates Pvt. Ltd. (2015), 55 taxmann.com (2017) (Pune) Kancast Pvt. Ltd. vs ITO, (2011) 4 SCC 36 (SC) GVK Industries Ltd. vs ITO and 2020-TIOL-307-Kolkata hold that such a lease hold right does not come under either of the twin specified categories of “land or building or both” as the case may be. We adopt the very reasoning herein as well to conclude that the learned lower authorities have erred in law and on facts in invoking section 56(2)((vii)(b) addition qua assessee’s acquisition of leasehold rights in issue. The impugned addition stands deleted in above terms, Ordered accordingly.

5. This assessee’s appeal is allowed in above terms.”

In view of the decision of Coordinate Bench of ITAT Pune in the case of Bhavna Shashikant Ghone, we are of the view that Section 56(2)((vii)(b) cannot be applied in assessee’s case. It is also noteworthy to mention that letter dated 6-01-2014 issued by RIICO in favour of M/s. Unique Impex is clear evidence that the assessee only received lease hold right for 99 years. Hence, in view of above deliberations and the case laws mentioned hereinabove, the Bench does not concur with the view of the ld. CIT(A) and the addition sustained by the ld. CIT(A) is directed to be deleted. Thus the solitary ground of the assessee is allowed.

3.0 In the result, the appeal filed by the assessee is allowed.

Order pronounced in the open court on 18/10/2022.

Advertisement

Author Info

CA Sandeep Kanoi
Qualification: Graduate, CA in Job / Business, DD
Company: Taxguru Consultancy
Location: Mumbai, Maharashtra
Articles Published: 24,740

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.