ABSTRACT
Illustrations of the paper examine the revolution of a concept imbibed within the Income Tax Act of 1961, governing the Tax Deduction at Source (TDS) on commercial businesses incoming in India. It explores the legal framework governing TDS, analysing relevant sections of the Income Tax Act, of 1961, and key concepts like “resident,” “specified income,” and applicable rates. The study also examines the legislative framework governing TDS, interprets relevant sections of the Income Tax Act, and confers about payments concealed under the TDS mechanism and TDS rates, the slightest amount up to which TDS is not deductible, and TDS applicability to different payment methods. The paper thereby inquired into the effect of TDS on businesses and cash ow management, legal burdens, and other potential challenges. In addition, this paper may collate and contrast the TDS provision for different types of businesses or with countries. Provide exhortation for enhancing the efficiency and effectiveness of TDS application on commercial business income. Also, this paper focuses on various commercial incomes like homestay businesses that provide accommodations in their homes. recreational establishments, and how TDS is applicable in facilities like amusement parks, and sports clubs. Urban Companies’ requirements for considering premiums, commission, and other such transactions. It ensures that a portion of income is collected by the deductor and remitted to the government. The analysis covers the applicability, rates, compliance requirements, and impact of TDS on businesses and taxpayers. It explores the relevant sections of the Income Tax Act, delineates TDS rates and thresholds, elucidates compliance obligations for deductors, and examines the implications of TDS on cash own and tax planning for taxpayers. The findings underscore the importance of understanding and adhering to TDS provisions for fostering transparency and efficiency in the Indian tax regime. The methodology of the paper offers various recommendations for the improvement of the efficiency and effectiveness of the TDS application in the business revolves around the commercial business. This research aims to provide valuable insights for businesses and contribute to the ongoing dialogue on TDS in the Indian context.
KEYWORDS – TDS, House rent, Deduction, E-commerce, Income
INTRODUCTION
The “Tax deduction at source” (TDS) is a critical element of the Indian taxation framework, intended to certify efficient tax collection and compliance. Of the different types of income that are subjected to TDS commercial business income is of considerable consequence to the nation’s fiscal terrain. As the work captivates in commercial activities. They must withhold a predetermined portion of tax from specific disbursements to vendors, contractors, and service providers. TDS on Commercial Business Income is a pivotal system for the government’s preemptive accumulation of tax revenues, facilitating the simplification of the tax acquisition procedure.
This article will navigate through the complexities of Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) on commercial business revenue, examining its relevance, percentages, and protocols. Comprehending the subtleties of this fiscal stipulation enables enterprises to adhere to legal standards, circumvent possible sanctions, and uphold proficient fiscal governance.
Comprehending the inference of TDS on Homestays
In the dynamic terrain of a collaborative economy, homestays have loomed as a preference for travellers looking for more certain regional experiences. As a homeowner offering property for rent for a shorter period, it’s vital to apprehend the tax implications concerned, precisely the concept of Tax Deducted at sources (TDS).
♦ TDS and Homestays – when it advances to homestays if a homeowner attains income from renting out their property, TDS may apply, if it surpasses the limit, the TDS amount will get deducted before making payment to an individual
a. “Rent”, defined [Explanation (I) to s. 194-I] – “Rent refers to any payment, regardless of the terminology used, made under a lease, sub-lease, tenancy, or any other agreement for the utilization of tangible assets, either individually or collectively.”
“Under section 194-I, any non-individual or non-HUF entity making rent payments to a resident individual is required to deduct tax at source (TDS) at a rate of 10% if the annual rent exceeds Rs. 2.4 lakhs. Previously, the TDS limit for rent deduction was Rs. 1.8 lakhs, but it was raised to Rs. 2.4 lakhs starting from the financial year 2019-2020.”
b. Remittance made for facilities of lodgement grasp regularly will be like Rent made susceptible under section 194-I if such payment surpasses Rs 2,40,000 in a fiscal year if the amount does not surpass the threshold of Rs. 2,40,000 TDS rate will be 10% and will get deductible at the time of payment by way of rent. Tax will get deducted at the source under section 194-I For allocating a room and availing some facilities in homestays.
c. “Individuals and Hindu Undivided Families (HUFs), except those subject to tax audit under clauses (a) and (b) of section 44AB, are required to deduct TDS at 5% on monthly rent payments exceeding ₹ 50,000 to a resident Indian, as per section 194-IB.
The tax, at the rate of 5% or 3.75%, should be withheld from the rent paid to the landlord, lessor, or payee, with the specific rate dependent on the payment date. The payer of the rent is responsible for deducting this Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) from the rent due and remitting it to the government.”[1]
Challenges inebriated on homestays
(i) One major issue inebriated on homestays is the higher rate of GST constrained by the govt nearly up to 18% on having an annual income of 20 Lakh or more which has resulted in contingency for a lot of homestays.
(ii) Introduced enormous amounts of fines on homestays if they fail to introduce details of guests within a specified period of every five months, mainly to small and medium enterprises.
(iii) Will there be another liability imposed upon the homestay owners of paying the central taxes in addition to the tax paid from the income generated from the usage of the homestays?
Provision in other countries, Rate of Tax, Analysis Co Relation
| ENGLAND
Rental income earned in England is taxable at various rates depending on your total taxable income – If annual rental income is up to 12,570 euros, then no tax will be charged on rent. – If annual rental income is at the basic rate up to 12571 euros to 50,270 euros, then 20% tax will be deducted. – If annual rental income is at the higher rate up to 50,271 euros, to 1,25,140 euros, tax deduction will be 40%. – If annual rental income is at the additional rate over 1,25,140 euros, then tax deduction will be 45%. |
SCOTLAND
Rental income earned in Scotland is taxable at various rates depending on your taxable income – If annual rental income is up to 12,570 euros no tax will be charged on rental income. – If annual rental income is in the range of 12,571 to 14,732 euros, then 19% tax will be deducted on rental income. – If annual rental income is between 14,733 to 25,688 euros, then 20% tax will be deducted on rental income. – If annual rental income is in range of 25,689 to 43,622 euros, 21% tax will get deducted. – If at higher rate between 43,663 to 125,140 euros 42% tax will get deducted – If annual rental income is above 125,140 euros, net deductible tax will be 47% of rental income earned. |
AUSTRALIA
In Australia income earned from housing rental is taxable at a different marginal tax rate. – If annual rental income is $18200, then no tax (0%) will be deductible. – If annual rental income between $18,201 to $45,000 then 19% tax will be deductible. – If annual rental income between $45,001 to $1,20,000 then 32.5% tax will be deductible. – If annual rental income range between $1,20,000 to $1,80,000 tax deduction rate will be 37% – Annual rental income above $1,80,001 then 45% tax will get deducted.[2] |
The RBI influence Dynamics
(i) It inspires and facilitates emergent entrepreneurs to inculcate in establishing their homestays.
(ii) It is equipping the homestays which are operating with enhanced apparentness, availing them to fascinate the prospective customer and running homestays profitably.
(iii) Creating an additional job prospectus for the local residents.
(iv) It magnified the self-assurance of the younger people who are having difficulty in finding jobs.[3]
“Real-world Example of lodging provider dealing with TDS implication”
i. TDS deduction on income from Rent – Rahul a homestay provider having its lodge in Goa registered with Airbnb earned an income of Rs 3 lakhs from renting his property. Since his annual rent exceeds Rs 2.4 lakh Airbnb deducted his tax @ 10% (Rs 30000) this TDS provision applies to both Individuals and companies. The Airbnb will deposit the TDS with the government on behalf of Rahul. The credit amount on TDS can be claimed by Rahul when filing an income tax return.
ii. TDS on payment made through an online platform – several online platforms like Airbnb, Trivago, and booking.com, may diminish TDS @10% on commission and security fees charged. Eg; Priya, a homestay owner earned a rental income of Rs 2 lakh from listing on an online platform such as Airbnb, Trivago charged TDS @10% i.e. (Rs 20000) on these fees. The deferred payment can be claimed while filing the tax return. [4]
E-Commerce
Understanding the Implications of TDS in the E-commerce Industry
The ongoing revolution dynamically changes the E-commerce structure of the way we buy things or manage and demeanour business. With its geometric & advanced growth, it has spawned distinctive challenges in the branch of taxation. One similar facet is the Deduction of tax at Source (TDS), an integral component of income tax acquiescence that the e-commerce platform needs to steer.
TDS & E-commerce
In the framework of e-commerce, TDS is conferred in a considerable sequence of events. For instance, when a product gets sold through an e-commerce source the TDS gets deducted before making the payment to the seller for the product sold, and then the deduction of tax gets credited contrary to the seller’s final accountability of tax.
♦ PROVISION OF SECTION 194-O
“If an e-commerce operator facilitates the sale of goods or services by an e-commerce participant through its digital or economic platform, the operator is obligated to deduct tax at source under section 194-O.
The e-commerce operator is required to deduct the tax when the sale amount for goods or services is either credited to the e-commerce participant’s account or paid to them, whichever occurs first.
The “Tax Deducted at Source” (TDS) rate is 1% of the aggregate amount for the sale of goods or services expedited by an e-business operator. When a purchaser directly pays an e-commerce participant for such a sale, that remittance is deliberated analogous to the amount credited or paid by the e-commerce operator to the participant. This entire amount is included in the aggregate sale value for tax deduction purposes. If the receiver is inadequate to provide PAN (Permanent Account Number), the rate of tax deduction increased to 5%.”
Tax Deduction at Source (TDS) under section 194-O is not applicable in certain scenarios, including:
(a) The e-commerce participant is either an individual or a Hindu Undivided Family (HUF).
(b) The gross revenue from the sale of goods or services by an e-commerce participant via the e-commerce operator did not surpass Rs 5 Lakh in the previous year; and
(c) In cases where the e-commerce participant has provided their PAN or Aadhaar number to the e-commerce operator.
When tax is deducted under section 194-O, it precludes the deduction of tax under any other section of the Act However, this exclusion does not apply to amounts an e-commerce operator receives or is due to receive for hosting advertisements or for services unrelated to the aforementioned sales/services.
In case any challenges arise in implementing the provisions of this section, the board, with the central government’s approval, may issue guidelines to address such difficulties. These guidelines must be presented before both houses of parliament and will be binding on income tax authorities and e-commerce operators.”
> Meaning of certain terms
(i) An “e-commerce operator” is defined as an individual or entity that owns, operates, or manages a digital or electronic platform for conducting e-commerce activities. This operator may be either a resident or non-resident in India.
(ii) The term “E-commerce participant” refers to an individual residing in India who engages in the sale of goods or services, or both, which may include digital products, via a digital or electronic platform designed for e-commerce. Consequently, the provisions for Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) do not apply if the E-commerce participant is not a resident of India.
According to the clarification provided in Section 194-O, when a buyer of goods or services makes a direct payment to an e-commerce participant for transactions facilitated by an e-commerce operator, this payment is considered as if it were made by the e-commerce operator to the participant. Consequently, this amount should be included in the total gross sales or services amount for the purpose of calculating TDS.
Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) need not be subtracted if the total sales or services amount attributed to an e-commerce participant, who is an individual or a Hindu Undivided Family (HUF), does not exceed Rs 5 lakhs. This exemption does not apply to amounts related to hosting advertisements.
This provision applies even when the buyer of goods or service recipient is a non-resident; however, it does not extend to e-commerce activities conducted independently by the participant through their own website.[5]
♦ Law before 194-O
Earlier before the commencement of TDS on e-commerce participants under section 194-O income tax returns were being filed separately, which resulted in many small e-commerce members evading the tax liability by not filing income tax returns. Therefore section 194-O has been acquainted with the union budget and it came to applicability on 1st October 2020.
For eg; – Before section 194-O of the Income Tax Act came into force the supplier sale the product to the customer which cost around Rs 50000, on receiving the product the customer made the payment of Rs 50000 to the E-commerce operator, and the E-commerce operator pay Rs 40000 to the supplier by cutting its commission of Rs 10000. [6]
ISSUE
The major issues which arose in the E-commerce particulars in recent times are –
(i) With the onset of 194-O it commissioned an E-commerce operator to abate TDS at the rate of 1% on the aggregate amount of sales/services ease through their digital
(ii) Whether the convenience fees, commission, logistic charges delivery fees, should be comprised in the gross amount for TDS purposes?
(iii) Whether the GST and other Taxes should be incurred in deduction with TDS?
E-Commerce in China
According to an arithmetical disclosure on Internet development in China, it represents the number of Internet users has increased swiftly. The no of telephone internet users and broadband internet have coverage across major areas of the state which leads the people to have affable access to the E-Commerce Industry.
The E-Commerce law was set off effectual on 1st January 2019. It elucidates all business-related activities of goods or material sales or provision of services through Internet sources. There were many E-commerce regulatory vendors set off on principles and supplier over other accessible portals. The purpose of making this law come into effect is to regulate unfair competition, partake liability for policy, affirming consumer privacy and rights. It brings an impact on taxation, including abiding with tax regulations to listing as a taxpayer and to fulfill tax obligations.
China is being handout privileged tax treatment and mitigating administrative requirements to brace the development of CBEC. For products sold to Chinese customers through parallel trade or grey market transactions evaluated below RMB 5000 or total annual E-commerce transactions below RMB 26,000 are exempted from import taxes and can enjoy 30% of Value added Tax (VAT) or Consumption Tax depletion if pertinent.[7]
♦ Unrevealing Tax implications for Urban Companies:
Embark on a journey where convenience meets luxury with Urban Company, an absolute paragon of ease and sophistication, which stand as the stare of modernity in the field of home service with a multitude of unique options like embellishment, coiffure, manipulation, antisepsis, plumping, furniture making, appliance overhaul, portrayal etc. Urban Company is a true maestro of orchestrating personal luxury, where class meets practicality. Urban Company offers a service platform that facilitates connections between users seeking particular services and proficient, seasoned professionals.[8] So as per the context, it corresponds to the Income Tax Act, of 1961 accurately under the concept of Tax deduction at sources (TDS).
Section 194 J Tax deduction at sources on fee for professional or technical services
Any person who pays for the professional, technical services and royalty is subjected for tax deduction. Regardless an individual/ HUF is responsible for deduction if its turnover exceeds 1 crore in case of business and 50 lakh for profession during the financial year is appraised as Deduction under this section and a resident person is appraised to be deductee. The amount under TDS is deducted at time of credit or payment whichever is earlier. Rate on which deduction is made is 2% in cases of royalty and 10% in case of other payments made like professional and technical services. If the fee for technical and professional services is 30000 or less than 30000 than no TDS to be deducted.
Tangled within the maze-like web of tax laws is Section 194J, its sphere of comprises an important direction that goes beyond mere financial transactions to establish a story of complete compliance to the law and solid financial judgement for Urban Company and similar entities. Within the sacred sphere of this clause, it is the responsibility of the authorities for businesses to conduct an accounting symphony, especially when it comes to paying for the valuable technical and professional services provided. This is the crucial part: if the total sum of individuals as well Hindu Undivided Families (HUFs) residing in our India exceeds thirty thousand rupees, we are obligated to adhere to with the duty of Deduction of tax at Source (TDS) of 10% and 2% respectively.
Taxing Amusement Facilities:
The concept of Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) typically wouldn’t apply to individual purchases at amusement parks, like entrance fees or ride tickets.[9] TDS involves a business withholding a portion of tax from payments made to another business or individual, and depositing it with the government. However, amusement parks might need to consider TDS if they make certain bulk payments to vendors or contractors. TDS rules might come into play depending on the nature and amount of the payment.[10]
[(a-1) An “amusement park” is defined as a venue that consistently offers a variety of amusements, such as games and rides (excluding cinematograph and video exhibitions), which are accessible upon payment for entry;[11]
As per the definition-
a) An amusement park is a permanent establishment
b) Offering various types of entertainment options
c) With an entrance fee
Individual purchase at amusement park is considered as final consumption and not falls under basket of TDS. TDS applies to the situation where a company withholds tax payment made to another business or individual and deposit it with the government.
Section 194-C of the Income Tax Act, 1961, prescribes the rules for withholding tax at the source (TDS) for payments related to contractual work. This section is applicable to anyone tasked with remunerating a resident contractor for any type of work, which also encompasses labor provision. the annual remuneration to a resident contractor not surpass Rs. 30,000 (or Rs. 1,00,000 in the case of individuals and HUFs), TDS is not mandated. The scope of “work” under this section extends to activities such as advertising, broadcasting, transporting goods or passengers, catering, and the production of goods according to the customer’s requirements.
The intent behind Section 194-C is to secure tax collection at the source for payments on contracts, thereby fostering tax adherence and broadening the tax collection base. Compliance with this section is crucial for both the party deducting the tax and the recipient to circumvent any penalties or interest charges due to non-adherence
Effect of tax rates on amusement park operator
a) General expenses and net margins – imposing tax at higher rates abruptly simulates the operating cost for amusement parks. A considerable amount must be administered to pay the taxes, compressing their profit margins. This may induce challenges in affirming and improving infrastructures, and additional resources.
b) Pricing of tickets and reasonableness – the ticket price of the amusement park gets enhanced as the liability falls on the customer increases prices making consumers have to spend more to enjoy the same amount as before.
c) Growth of corporations and rising competition – Imposing higher tax rates can obstruct the development of the amusement park industry. Due to the higher cost of tax, the contestant finds difficulty in establishing it & causing difficulty to expand and innovate.
d) Attendance and revenue – deduction of higher tax rate may be disdaining the visitors and other traveller. And reducing the number of visitors impacts on the overall revenue, and maintainability of the park. “Park operators need to assess the responsiveness of demand to change in ticket prices.”
Addressing to the effectivity of TDS applicability on Amusement Park, also adhere to may criticisms affecting to it:
1. Compliance Burden: Other requirement to the deduction of TDS and the compliance in regards with various reporting and filing obligations are significantly administrative and the financial burden for the amusement park operators, in the smaller entities.
2. Cash flow issues: Theme Park valuation has a complexity process that involves assessing various aspects in the business to arrive at an accurate value. One of the key components in strategizing the overall value of the entitled theme park. Valuation Methods and the enterprises should incorporate the impact of seasonality on the revenue implemented potential. Analysing historical data, marketing trends, consumer habitat, and park-specific location, the valuation experts on tax deduction at source is impacting over the cash flow, particularly during the peak seasons or when they are making large payments or issuing a tender to the contractors or the service providers.
3. Inconsistent application: Theme Parks across the world, pertinently in India are gaining an unwanted reputation for teen bawls and melees following in surging fights over the past years as unsafe heavens of violence chaos and panic. There have been concerning issues over the inconsistent applicability of TDS provisions across different regions and the authoritative businesses, leading to the confusion and potentiality and political disputes.
4. Impact on small business: Small Amusement parks operators and other vendors are facing issues and other challenges to comply with the provision of the income tax, as deduction of tax is not directly applicable to the amusement park facilitates unless payment in bulk to carry out contractual agreements works as an operation to the field. Comparing the ginormous theme park with the smaller enterprises face difficulty with the TDS provisions as a requirement, vendering discouragement to entrepreneurship and investment in the this certain sectoral sector.
5. The Cascading Effect: The cascading effect of taxation occurs when taxation are levied at different multiple stages of production or distribution, leading tot he accumulation of other tax. Resulting in such increased cost of business and ultimate impactful consumers. The goal of the taxation system, is to prevents “tax on tax” or “cascading effect”. Governmental policies have been successful in the achievement of the taxation the GDP ration of 12.8%, revised to 6% in the light of the slowdown. It encourages the assessee for the voluntarily compliance. Present situation, the ambiguity in the Indian tax laws, the amusement has spend time on tax compliance. There are some cases, where TDS has been deducted multiple times on the similar income, and not been disintegrated over heads, leading to a cascading effect and higher tax incidence.
CONCLUSION
Compliance with TDS mandates on commercial business revenue transcends mere legal requirements; it embodies a conscientious corporate ethic that bolsters the country’s fiscal development. Enterprises must remain alert and conform to the dynamic TDS standards to eschew fines, interest dues, and judicial consequences. Enlisting the expertise of tax consultants or utilizing dependable digital references can aid in demystifying the intricacies of TDS adherence. Moreover, businesses ought to cultivate a culture of tax compliance and prudent financial stewardship, thereby nurturing trust among stakeholders and bolstering their reputation. By adhering to TDS regulations, businesses not only meet their tax responsibilities but also play a role in establishing a fair and transparent taxation framework, benefiting both the company and the nation at large.
Note:-
[1] Section 194i | how to calculate TDS on rent? (n.d.). https://www.canarahsbclife.com/blog/tax-saving/how-to-calculate-tds-on-rent
[2] Tax on rent income: 2024 Landlord’s Guide to UK property tax. Baron & Cabot. (n.d.). https://baroncabot.com/blog/tax-on-rent-income
[3] Homestays of India. (2024, January 26). Impact. https://www.homestaysofindia.com/impact
[4] Homestays of India. (2023, October 8). About Us. https://www.homestaysofindia.com/about-us/
[5] publisher, tax guruFollow this. (2022, February 4). Taxation of e-commerce transactions in Income Tax & GST with examples. Issuu. https://issuu.com/taxguru21/docs/taxguru.in-taxation_of_e-commerce_transactions_in_
[6] Tax implications on e-commerce operators. (n.d.-b). https://icmai.in/TaxationPortal/upload/DT/Article/90.pdf
[7] Mazars. (n.d.). May 2019 – China adopts E-commerce law – its tax implications – mazars – china. https://www.mazars.cn/insights/our-publications/tax-publications/china-tax-newsletter/may-2019-china-adopts-e-commerce-law
[8] Urban Company – Get Expert Professional Services at Home. (n.d.). Urban Company. https://www.urbancompany.com/about
[9] Individual purchases at amusement parks are generally considered final consumption and not subject to TDS
[10] The applicability of TDS on business-to-business transactions depends on the specific provisions of the tax code in your jurisdiction.
[11] Section 2 (a-1) The Maharashtra Entertainments Duty Act – India … (n.d.). https://www.indiacode.nic.in/bitstream/123456789/16215/1/the_maharashtra_entertainments_duty_act.pdf
****
Author Information:
Author Name: Shubham Kumar, Rajkishore Agrawal, Rajduhita Nandy.
Affiliation: Student KIIT SCHOOL OF LAW.
Email: 2182088@kls.ac.in, 2182069@kls.ac.in, 2182066@kls.ac.in
Author Bio
