Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Income Tax

Section 50C Could Not Apply to Relinquishment of Specific Performance Right: ITAT Chennai

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2026 taxguru.in 14177
Case Name
May Flower Enterprises Private Limited Vs ACIT (ITAT Chennai)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Related Assessment Year
2017-18
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

May Flower Enterprises Private Limited Vs ACIT (ITAT Chennai)

The central question

A purchaser paid for land under an agreement but never obtained a registered sale deed. Years later, the vendor paid the purchaser to give up its rights under that agreement. Was the purchaser transferring land, so that the stamp duty value could replace the agreed consideration under Section 50C? Or was it relinquishing only a contractual right to seek specific performance?

In May Flower Enterprises Pvt. Ltd. v. ACIT, the Chennai ITAT held that the company had transferred only its right under the sale agreement. Since it had never become the owner of the land, Section 50C could not be invoked. The Tribunal directed deletion of the addition arising from the Assessing Officer’s recomputation of long-term capital gain.

How the transaction unfolded

May Flower Enterprises Pvt. Ltd., a housing project developer, entered into an agreement with H. R. Ravichandra on 22 August 2005 to purchase a site. The agreement stated a total consideration of ₹1,40,40,000, divided into ₹32,40,000 towards the site and ₹1,08,00,000 towards development charges. The listed development work included drainage, sewerage, electricity, roads and other layout facilities.

The purchase did not result in a registered conveyance in the company’s favour. Under the agreement, if the vendor failed to execute a sale deed, the company’s remedy was to sue for specific performance. Subsequently, the company received ₹2 crore from the vendor in connection with giving up its rights. The receipts relied upon before the Tribunal described the payment as being towards cancellation of the 2005 agreement.

In its return for assessment year 2017–18, the company reported a long-term capital loss, after taking into account the ₹2 crore received and claiming indexed cost in relation to the amount originally paid.

Why the Assessing Officer invoked Section 50C

The Assessing Officer divided the ₹2 crore receipt into two parts. He treated ₹1.08 crore as a return of the development charges, reasoning that the contemplated development had not been carried out. That left ₹92 lakh as, in his view, consideration for the land. He also restricted the relevant acquisition cost to the ₹32.40 lakh site component.

The stamp duty value of the land was ₹2.16 crore. Applying Section 50C in place of the ₹92 lakh figure, the Assessing Officer recomputed the transaction as a long-term capital gain of ₹1,42,89,230 rather than the capital loss claimed by the company. The Commissioner (Appeals) upheld the assessment.

Before the ITAT, the company argued that this approach began with the wrong asset. It had no registered title to the site; its asset was the right acquired under the agreement to demand performance from the vendor. The ₹2 crore was received for relinquishing that right. The company also disputed the division of the receipt into land and refunded development charges, maintaining that the original agreement concerned a composite bundle of rights.

The Tribunal’s ruling: identify the asset first

The ITAT examined the agreement and found that no sale deed had ever been registered in May Flower’s favour. The vendor remained the owner throughout. Clause 4.7 of the agreement showed that, on the vendor’s default, the company could institute a suit for specific performance. What the company held, and later gave up for ₹2 crore, was therefore the right to seek specific performance, not the land itself.

The Tribunal relied on the Madras High Court decision in K. R. Srinath v. ACIT for the proposition that a right to specific performance is a capital asset, and that relinquishing it constitutes a transfer under Section 2(47). There was thus a transfer of an asset; the crucial point was which asset had been transferred.

Section 50C applies where the capital asset transferred is land or building or both. The Tribunal held that its deeming rule could not be extended to this relinquishment of a contractual right. It referred to Greenfield Hotels & Estates (P.) Ltd., which distinguished a right in land from the land itself for this purpose.

What about the contrary Bombay High Court ruling?

The Tribunal expressly considered Vidarbha Veneer Industries Ltd. v. ITO, in which the Bombay High Court had applied Section 50C to a leasehold right in land. It distinguished that decision on its facts. Vidarbha Veneer involved a registered leasehold interest, later assigned by a registered deed, that conferred possession and enjoyment. May Flower, by comparison, had an unregistered agreement and a contractual right to seek performance, which had never matured into a registered interest in the land.

On that distinction, the ITAT held that Section 50C did not apply and directed the Assessing Officer to delete the addition made by recomputing the long-term capital gain. It did not separately decide whether the ₹2 crore should have been divided between land and development charges, or whether the difference between ₹2 crore and ₹2.16 crore fell within a permissible tolerance limit. The company’s alternative argument about the year of transfer was also left open.

Author’s comments

The important step in this decision is to identify the asset that the assessee actually owned. An agreement to purchase land may give the purchaser a valuable capital asset, even before a sale deed is executed. But giving up that contractual right does not necessarily mean that the purchaser has transferred the land.

The decision also shows why cases concerning rights in immovable property require careful factual comparison. The Tribunal did not ignore Vidarbha Veneer; it distinguished a registered leasehold interest carrying possession and enjoyment from May Flower’s bare right to enforce an unregistered purchase agreement. The ruling should therefore be applied with attention to the deed, the nature of the right, and what was actually relinquished.

Finally, the outcome is specific to the Section 50C recomputation. The Tribunal removed the addition based on substituting the land’s stamp value. It did not decide the company’s alternative objection that the transfer belonged to an earlier year, despite payments having been received before assessment year 2017–18.

Want to Read the Complete Judgment?

You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.

Read on with Premium
Goes straight to payment. GST invoice included.

One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.

Advertisement

Author Info

CA Vijayakumar Shetty
Qualification: CA in Practice
Company: Shetty & Co, Chartered Accountants, Mangalore
Location: Mangalore, Karnataka
Articles Published: 7,785

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.