Laxman Kanaiyalal Dharmani Vs ITO (ITAT Mumbai)
ITAT Mumbai allowed the assessee’s appeal and deleted the addition under Sections 56(2)(vii)/56(2)(x) arising from redevelopment of his residential flat. The assessee and his wife had purchased a flat in 2001 and, under a redevelopment agreement dated 23.10.2010, surrendered their existing rights in exchange for a larger redeveloped flat.
A supplementary agreement also provided additional area, while the assessee separately acquired 159 sq. ft. by adjusting hardship allowance payable by the developer. The Assessing Officer treated the stamp duty value of the entire redeveloped flat as property received without consideration and made an addition. ITAT held that this approach ignored the fundamental fact that the assessee had surrendered his existing 623 sq. ft. flat as consideration for receiving 961 sq. ft. in the redeveloped property. Following Sashi Jain v. DCIT, the Tribunal further observed that the provisions applicable when the redevelopment agreement was entered into in AY 2011-12 covered receipt of immovable property without consideration, whereas taxation of property received for inadequate consideration was introduced only from AY 2014-15.
Therefore, even if the value of the surrendered old flat was lower than the value of the 961 sq. ft. received, the subsequently amended provision could not be applied. For the separately acquired 159 sq. ft., the Tribunal found that the consideration paid exceeded its ready-reckoner stamp duty value. Consequently, no addition was sustainable for either component and the CIT(A)’s directions to recompute the Section 56(2)(x) addition were set aside.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.




