Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Income Tax

ITAT Kolkata Deletes ₹3.86 Crore Ad Hoc Additions Without Rejection of Books

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2026 taxguru.in 19044
Case Name
Himmayet Hossain Sheikh Vs ITO (ITAT Kolkata)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Related Assessment Year
2023-24
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Himmayet Hossain Sheikh Vs ITO (ITAT Kolkata)

Summary: The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Kolkata Bench, in Himmayet Hossain Sheikh Vs ITO, deleted two additions aggregating to ₹3,86,04,900 made by the Assessing Officer on an estimated basis for Assessment Year 2023-24. The additions comprised ₹3,75,07,806, representing 10% of purchases, and ₹10,97,094, representing an estimated percentage of sundry creditors. The Tribunal held that additions based merely on presumptions and conjectures could not be sustained when the Assessing Officer had neither rejected the books of account under Section 145(3) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 nor identified substantive evidence justifying the estimation. The ruling reinforces the principle that ad hoc disallowances without rejection of books of account cannot be sustained solely on suspicion.

The assessee operated two proprietary concerns, namely Himayet Service Station, engaged in operating a petrol pump, and Himayet Enterprise, engaged in wholesale trading of building materials. He filed his income-tax return on 6 October 2023 declaring total income of ₹27,67,250. The return was selected for scrutiny because of high creditor liabilities and business expenses. During assessment proceedings, the assessee furnished audited financial statements, bank statements, purchase and sales details and other accounting records. However, the Assessing Officer recorded that the assessee had not furnished complete particulars in response to subsequent statutory notices, including the notice dated 3 March 2025 issued under Section 142(1).

The Assessing Officer consequently disallowed 10% of total purchases of ₹37,50,78,064, resulting in an addition of ₹3,75,07,806. A further addition of ₹10,97,094 was made against sundry creditors stated at ₹1,07,70,942. Both additions were made on an estimated basis without rejecting the books of account. The assessment was completed on 20 March 2025 under Section 143(3) read with Section 144B. The Tribunal subsequently examined whether these percentage-based additions could survive without any demonstrated accounting defects, comparable cases or independent evidence.

The assessee challenged the assessment before the National Faceless Appeal Centre. The appellate authority dismissed the appeal without adjudicating the substantive issues on merits. The assessee pointed out that a notice issued under Section 250 had permitted submission of details up to 8 October 2025, whereas the appellate order was passed on 29 September 2025. This procedural circumstance was considered alongside the substantive weakness in the additions. Instead of remanding the matter, the Tribunal decided the controversy itself because the relevant records were available and the additions lacked an evidentiary foundation.

The Tribunal examined the assessee’s audited accounts and the documentary material placed in the paper book running from pages 1 to 402. The records included income-tax returns, audited profit and loss accounts, balance sheets, bank statements, purchase and sales registers and invoices from Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited, Captain Steel India Ltd. and Ambuja Cements Ltd. The Tribunal observed that the statutory auditors had not identified any defect or deficiency in the accounts and had issued a favourable audit report. Despite the available records, the Assessing Officer had not identified specific false purchases, inflated expenditure, unexplained liabilities or discrepancies capable of supporting the additions.

Emphasising the distinction between a properly supported disallowance and an arbitrary percentage-based estimate, the Tribunal found that the Assessing Officer had proceeded on presumptions and surmises. It relied upon the judicial principle discussed in Principal Commissioner of Income Tax Vs R.G. Buildwell Engineers Ltd., where estimated disallowances were considered in the context of books of account that had not been rejected. Similar reasoning concerning arbitrary expense disallowances where audited books remain accepted has also been discussed in other TaxGuru-reported decisions. The Tribunal concluded that the additions in the present case lacked the necessary factual foundation.

Accordingly, the Tribunal set aside the order of the Commissioner (Appeals) and directed the Assessing Officer to delete both additions of ₹3,75,07,806 and ₹10,97,094. The assessee’s appeal was allowed in full. The decision highlights that non-compliance with certain assessment notices does not, by itself, establish the correctness of an arbitrary percentage-based addition when the books remain unrejected and the record does not disclose substantive defects. The Tribunal’s conclusion was based on the particular documentary evidence and assessment circumstances before it.

Cases Discussed:

1. Principal Commissioner of Income Tax Vs R.G. Buildwell Engineers Ltd. (Supreme Court); [2018] 99 taxmann.com 284 (SC); [2018] 259 Taxman 370 (SC); 01/10/2018; AY: 2010-11 (underlying proceedings). The Tribunal relied on this authority for the proposition that ad hoc expense disallowances cannot be justified merely by alleging insufficient supporting material where the books of account have not been rejected and the findings do not justify estimation. The judgment reproduces an extract concerning the underlying Delhi High Court appeals, ITA Nos. 1183 and 1187 of 2017.

FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF ITAT KOLKATA

This is an appeal preferred by the assessee against the order of the National Faceless Appeal Centre, Delhi (hereinafter referred to as the “Ld. CIT(A)”] dated 29.09.2025 for the AY 2023-24.

2. There are two effective issues raised by the assessee which are as under:

i. first, is against the order of ld. CIT (A) confirming the disallowance of ₹3,75,07,806/- as made by the ld. AO at the rate of 10% of the total purchases;

ii. second issue raised by the assessee is against the order of ld. CIT (A) confirming the addition of ₹10,97,094/- as made by the ld. AO by applying 10% on the sundry creditors.

3. The facts in brief are that the assessee filed the return of income on 06.10.2023, declaring total income at ₹27,67,250/-. The case of the assessee was selected for scrutiny for two reasons namely; high creditor liability and business expenses. Accordingly, the statutory notices along with questionnaire were issued and served upon the assessee. The ld. AO noted that the assessee made submission only once in response to the Centralized communication letter by NEFAC on 23.12.2024. The assessee submitted the Profit and Loss account A/c, Balance sheet, Bank statement, Purchase, sale of details, etc. before the ld. AO. Thereafter, there was no compliance. Finally, the ld. AO asked the specific details vide notice dated 03.03.2025, issued u/s 142(1) of the Act. The assessee did not furnished the specific details of purchases and accordingly, the ld. AO disallowed 10% of the total purchases of ₹37,50,78,064/- which worked out to ₹3,75,07,806/- and same was added to the income of the assessee. Similarly in the second issue, the ld. AO disallowed 10% of the total sundry creditors of ₹1,07,70,942/-, which comes to ₹10,97,094/-. The ld. AO while making this disallowance on estimation did not reject the books of account u/s 145(3) of the Act. Finally, the assessment was framed by the ld. AO u/s 143(3) read with section 144B of the Act dated 20.03.2025 by making the above additions

4. In the appellate proceedings, the ld. CIT (A) dismissed the appeal of the assessee without deciding the issue on merits. The ld. AR placed before us the notice issued u/s 250 of the Act by NFAC, calling upon the assessee to furnish the details/ submission on or before 08.10.2025. However the ld. CIT (A) proceeded to dispose off the appeal vide order dated 29.09.2025.

5. After hearing the rival contentions and perusing the materials available on record, we find that in this case the assessee is engaged in the business with two proprietary concerns, namely; (i) Himayet Service Station wherein he operates petrol pump service and (ii) Himayet Enterprise, wherein he is engaged in wholesale trade of building materials. We note that during the year the assessee’s books of account were audited by Chartered Accountant as the turnover of the assessee exceeds the specified limit as mentioned u/s 44AB of the Act. The assessee filed the audited balance sheet, audited profit and loss account, bank statement, details of purchase and sales, etc. before the ld. AO during the course of assessment proceeding. However, thereafter the assessee not reply to the show cause notices issued by the AO and the ld. AO disallowed 10% of the purchases which comes to ₹3,75,07,806/- as well as 10% of the sundry creditors which comes to ₹10,97,094/- on the ground of non reply and absence of complete details being furnished by the assessee by holding that it would be fair to make the disallowance on estimation basis as such. The ld. AO did not reject the books of account while making these s disallowances on estimation basis and the ld. CIT (A) simply confirmed the order of the ld. AO by disposing of the appellate order even before the date which was fixed by the ld. CIT (A) himself on 08.01.2025 for furnishing reply by the assessee. We note that the appeal was disposed off on 21.09.202. Since this is a case of additions/ disallowances on estimation basis without even rejecting the books of account and without there being brought on record any substantiate evidences or comparable cases justifying the additions in such cases, we are therefore not inclined to restore this appeal to the file of the ld. AO and the ld. CIT (A) and the same is being adjudicated at this level. We note that the ld. AO has made the disallowance on the presumption and surmises basis and this disallowed 10% of the total purchase. Similarly the 10% of the total sundry creditors was also disallowed. In our opinion any disallowance on the basis of junctures and surmises is not sustainable in the eyes of law. We also find from the documents placed before us from paging number 1 to 402, which comprised of copies of ITR, audited profit and loss accounts, balance sheets of two concerns, copy of the banks, statements of account no. 097501000004122 & 09750210000656, purchase and sale register of Himayet Enterprises, purchase invoices of the Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited, Purchase invoices from captain steel India Ltd. (Himayet Enterprise), purchase invoice from Ambuja Cements Ltd. (Himayet Enterprise). These are available at page no.1 to 402 of the Paper Book. We even note that the auditors have not pointed out any defect or deficiency in the books of accounts and had given a fair report on the books of accounts maintained by the assessee. Therefore, under these circumstances, we are not in a position to sustain any disallowance made by the ld. Assessing Officer. The case of the assessee is squarely covered by the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Principal Commissioner of Income Tax vs. R.G. Buildwell Engineers Ltd. [2018] 99 taxmann.com 284 (SC)/[2018] 259 Taxman 370 (SC)[01-10-2018], wherein the Hon’ble Court has held as under:-

“CM No.47025/2017(exemption)

Allowed, subject to all just exceptions.

ITA No.1183/2017 & CM Nos.47024/2017(u/S.5 of Limitation Act) ITA No.1187/2017 & CM No.47029/2017

1. The Revenue is aggrieved by the findings of the Commissioner of Income-Tax (Appeals) and Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), whereby disallowances and consequent additions made on two counts, i.e. expenses claimed towards the bricks, machinery repair, cartage etc. (Rs.1.1. crores) and labour expenses (Rs.2.3 crores) were set aside.

2. The Assessing Officer (A.O.) made the additions in respect of the return of the Assessee’s income of the Assessment Year 2010-2011.

3. In respect of the first item, i.e. expenses for bricks, machinery repair, cartage etc., the A.O. concluded that insufficient evidence was adduced. He, therefore, disallowed 10% of the claim. This was reduced by half by the C.I.T.(Appeals). The ITAT gave two reasons to set aside the findings of the A.O. – C.I.T.(Appeals). Firstly, that the books of account were not rejected and secondly, that in the past, consistently such expenses were allowed in scrutiny assessments. Likewise, in the case of labour cases too, identical reasons were adduced by the A.O. to bring to tax a sum of Rs.2.2 crores. The same were set aside ultimately by the ITAT.

4. This Court is of the opinion that the principal reasoning of the ITAT, i.e. omission to reject the books of account, in which event the adhoc disallowance could have been adjusted and also the historical treatment of such expenses, cannot be termed as unreasonable; in support of its ultimate conclusion.

5. In these circumstances, no substantial question of law arises.

6. The Appeals are, therefore, dismissed.”

6. We, therefore respectfully following the order of Hon’ble Apex Court, set aside the order of ld. CIT (A) and direct the ld. AO to delete both the additions of Rs. ₹3,75,07,806/- as well as of ₹10,97,094/-.

7. In the result, the appeal of the assessee is allowed.

Order pronounced on 27.03.2026.

Advertisement

Author Info

CA Sandeep Kanoi
Qualification: Graduate, CA in Job / Business, DD
Company: Taxguru Consultancy
Location: Mumbai, Maharashtra
Articles Published: 24,697

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.