Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs Lakshmavva Alias Lakshmi (Karnataka High Court)
Summary: The Karnataka High Court, Dharwad Bench, in Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs Lakshmavva Alias Lakshmi, dismissed a writ petition filed by an insurance company challenging an executing court’s direction to deposit ₹35,399 deducted as Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) from interest awarded on motor accident compensation. The dispute arose from a fatal road accident on 8 February 2009 involving Nagesh, whose wife and son filed a claim under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. By an award dated 1 August 2014, the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal granted compensation of ₹5,49,000 with interest at 6% per annum from the date of the petition until realisation. When the award remained unsatisfied, the claimants initiated Execution Petition No. 3 of 2015. The insurer deposited ₹6,90,596 towards satisfaction of the award but deducted ₹35,399 from the interest component as TDS. The executing court directed the insurer to deposit the deducted amount, prompting the insurer to invoke the High Court’s jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution.
The insurance company contended that deduction of tax was mandatory under Section 194A of the Income-tax Act, 1961, because the interest exceeded the prescribed monetary threshold. It further argued that the claimants had not furnished their Permanent Account Numbers (PAN), requiring deduction at a higher rate. According to the insurer, it had merely discharged a statutory obligation and had remitted the deducted amount to the Income-tax Department. In support of its position, the insurer relied upon Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs Union of India, W.P. (Civil) No. 534 of 2020, before the Supreme Court. The claimants opposed the petition, maintaining that motor accident compensation and the interest awarded on it were compensatory receipts rather than taxable income. They relied upon the Himachal Pradesh High Court’s decision in New India Assurance Co. Ltd. Vs Hari Narayan. The central issue was whether an insurance company could lawfully deduct TDS from interest awarded by a Motor Accident Claims Tribunal on compensation determined under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act.
The High Court explained that compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act is intended to provide just recompense for pecuniary and non-pecuniary losses suffered by accident victims or their dependants. Such compensation is not a source of profit or gain but a form of restitution for losses resulting from the accident. The Court held that interest awarded on compensation is not independent income generated by the claimant; rather, it compensates for the delay in determining and paying an amount that ought to have been available following the accident. The Court relied upon the Bombay High Court’s Division Bench decision in Shri Rupesh Rashmikant Shah Vs Union of India and Others, W.P. No. 2902 of 2016, which held that interest awarded from the filing of a motor accident claim until the date of the award is incidental to compensation and does not constitute taxable income. It also agreed with the Himachal Pradesh High Court’s decision in New India Assurance Company Limited Vs Hari Narayan, which treated interest awarded on motor accident compensation as part of the compensatory amount itself.
Addressing the statutory arguments, the High Court held that Section 194A is a mechanism for deduction of tax at source and cannot enlarge the charging provisions of the Income-tax Act. Unless the underlying receipt constitutes taxable income, the provision cannot independently authorise TDS. The Court further observed that the amendments to Section 194A referred to in the judgment, including enhancement of the monetary threshold by the Finance Act, 2026, did not change the fundamental legal character of motor accident compensation or interest awarded thereon. The amendments merely modified the applicable threshold wherever Section 194A otherwise operated. The insurer’s reliance on the claimants’ failure to furnish PAN was also rejected. The Court reasoned that the requirement to deduct tax at a higher rate for non-furnishing of PAN presupposes an existing obligation to deduct tax. Where the receipt itself is not taxable, the absence of PAN particulars cannot create a TDS liability.
The High Court concluded that no deduction towards TDS was permissible from either the compensation awarded by the MACT or the interest awarded thereon under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act. It held that the executing court had correctly treated the deduction as unauthorised and contrary to law. The direction to deposit ₹35,399 merely ensured that the claimants received the compensation awarded by the Tribunal and did not involve any jurisdictional error warranting interference. Accordingly, the writ petition was dismissed, and the executing court’s order dated 25 April 2015 was affirmed. The insurance company was directed to deposit ₹35,399 within four weeks from receipt of a certified copy of the High Court’s order, if not already deposited. The executing court was directed to release the amount immediately to the claimants in accordance with law. Pending interlocutory applications were disposed of without costs. The judgment reinforces the distinction between compensatory receipts and taxable income, while rejecting the proposition that a TDS threshold or absence of PAN can independently make a non-taxable payment subject to deduction.
Cases Discussed:
- Shri Rupesh Rashmikant Shah Vs Union of India and Others (Bombay High Court); W.P. No. 2902 of 2016; 08/08/2019. Relied upon by the High Court for the proposition that interest awarded on motor accident compensation from the filing of the claim until the award is incidental to compensation and does not constitute taxable income.
- New India Assurance Company Limited Vs Hari Narayan (Himachal Pradesh High Court); CMPMO No. 159 of 2021. Relied upon by the claimants and approved by the High Court. The decision treats interest on motor accident compensation as part of compensation rather than taxable income.
- Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs Union of India (Supreme Court); W.P. (Civil) No. 534 of 2020. Cited by the insurance company in support of its contention that tax must be deducted when the statutory conditions are fulfilled.
Five SEO Titles (5ST):
- No TDS on Motor Accident Compensation or Interest: Karnataka High Court
- Insurer Must Pay ₹35,399 Wrongly Deducted as TDS on MACT Interest
- Section 194A Cannot Make Accident Compensation Interest Taxable: HC
- Non-Furnishing of PAN Does Not Justify TDS on MACT Compensation
- Karnataka HC Upholds Recovery of TDS Deducted From Accident Award
FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT
1. The captioned writ petition is directed against the order dated 25.04.2015 passed by the I Additional Senior Civil Judge, Ballari, in Execution Petition No.3/2015, whereby the Executing Court directed the petitioner–Insurance Company to deposit a further sum of Rs.35,399/-, representing the amount deducted towards Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) from the interest component of the compensation awarded by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal(MACT).
2. The petitioner is the insurer of the offending vehicle. Respondent Nos.1 and 2, being the wife and son of deceased Nagesh, instituted MVC No.560/2009 under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act,1988 seeking compensation on account of the death of Nagesh in a motor vehicle accident that occurred on 08.02.2009. By judgment and award dated 01.08.2014, the MACT awarded compensation of Rs.5,49,000/- together with interest at 6% per annum from the date of petition till realization.
3. The award having remained unsatisfied, respondent Nos.1 and 2 initiated Execution Petition No.3/2015 seeking recovery of the decretal amount. Pursuant thereto, the petitioner deposited a sum of Rs.6,90,596/- towards satisfaction of the award. However, while depositing the amount, a sum of Rs.35,399/- was deducted towards TDS from the interest accrued on the compensation on the ground that the accrued interest exceeded the statutory threshold prescribed under Section 194A of the Income Tax Act and that the claimants had not furnished their Permanent Account Number (PAN). According to the petitioner, in the absence of PAN particulars, it was statutorily obliged to deduct tax at the higher rate and accordingly remitted the deducted amount to the Income Tax Department.
4. The decree-holders objected to such deduction by filing a memo of calculation contending that no deduction towards TDS was permissible in respect of interest awarded by the MACT. Accepting the said contention, the Executing Court, by the impugned order, directed the petitioner to deposit the deducted sum of Rs.35,399/-. Aggrieved thereby, the present writ petition is filed.
5. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner contended that deduction of tax at source was mandatory under Section 194A of the Income Tax Act once the interest component exceeded the prescribed monetary limit. It was argued that the Insurance Company merely discharged its statutory obligation under the Income Tax Act and could not be faulted for deducting TDS. Reliance was placed on the decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Union of India in W.P (Civil) 534/2020 to contend that the payer is obliged to deduct tax wherever the statutory conditions are fulfilled.
6. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondents supported the order passed by the Executing Court and submitted that compensation awarded under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 including interest awarded thereon, does not partake the character of taxable income. It was argued that the interest awarded by the Tribunal is merely an accretion to the compensation intended to offset the delay in determination and payment of just compensation and, therefore, cannot be subjected to deduction of tax at source. Reliance was placed on the judgment of the Himachal Pradesh High Court in New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Hari Narayan (CMPMO No.159 of 2021).
7. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties and on perusal of the records, the sole question that arises for consideration is:
“Whether the Insurance Company is justified in deducting tax at source from the interest awarded by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal on compensation determined under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act?”
Findings on point for consideration:
8. The compensation awarded under the Motor Vehicles Act,1988 is intended to provide just recompense to the victims of road accidents or their dependants for the loss suffered on account of the wrongful act of the tortfeasor. The compensation awarded by the Tribunal is not a source of profit or gain; rather, it is restitution for the pecuniary and non-pecuniary losses occasioned by the accident. Interest awarded on such compensation is not independent income generated by the claimant but is awarded only to compensate for the delay in determination and payment of compensation which ought to have been made available immediately upon occurrence of the accident.
9. The Division Bench of the Bombay High Court, in W.P No. 2902/2016 while examining the very issue, has authoritatively held that interest awarded in motor accident claim cases from the date of presentation of the claim petition till the date of the award is merely incidental to the compensation and does not constitute “income” liable to tax. The Division Bench observed that the provisions relating to deduction of tax at source under Section 194A do not determine the taxability of a receipt and that deduction of tax at source can arise only if the payment itself is in the nature of taxable income. The Court concluded that interest awarded by the Claims Tribunal for delayed determination of compensation cannot be treated as income attracting TDS.
10. Similar is the view taken by the Himachal Pradesh High Court in New India Assurance Company Limited v. Hari Narayan, (CMPMO No. 159/2021) wherein it was held that the interest awarded on motor accident compensation forms part of the compensation itself and is not eligible to income tax. The Court reiterated the earlier Division Bench view that compensation together with interest awarded thereon cannot be treated as taxable income.
11. This Court finds itself in respectful agreement with the aforesaid view taken by the Himachal Pradesh High court and Division bench of Bombay High court. The consistent judicial opinion emerging from these decisions is that compensation awarded under the Motor Vehicles Act, together with the interest granted thereon, is compensatory in character and does not answer the description of taxable income.
12. Though learned counsel for the petitioner sought to place reliance upon the provisions of Section 194A of the Income Tax Act, the said provision merely prescribes the mechanism for deduction of tax at source where the payment represents income chargeable to tax. The provision cannot enlarge the charging provisions of the Act. Unless the receipt itself is taxable income, Section 194A cannot be invoked to authorize deduction of tax at source.
13. The subsequent amendments made to Section 194A of the Income Tax Act, including the enhancement of the monetary threshold by the Finance Act, 2026, do not alter the fundamental legal position. The amendment merely modifies the threshold for deduction of tax at source wherever Section 194A otherwise applies. It does not convert compensation or the interest awarded by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal into taxable income. The charging provisions remain unaltered and, therefore, the amendment has no bearing on the present controversy.
14. The contention of the petitioner that the absence of PAN particulars compelled deduction of tax at the higher rate is equally untenable. The obligation to deduct tax at source presupposes that the payment is otherwise liable to tax. Where the receipt itself is not taxable, the question of applying a higher rate of deduction for non-furnishing of PAN does not arise.
15. The Executing Court has therefore rightly held that the deduction made by the petitioner was unauthorized and contrary to law. The direction issued requiring the petitioner to deposit the deducted amount merely ensures that the decree holders receive the full compensation awarded by the Tribunal and does not suffer from any jurisdictional error warranting interference under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India. Accordingly, the point for consideration is answered in the ‘negative’.
16. Consequently, this Court holds that no deduction towards TDS is permissible either from the compensation awarded by the MACT or from the interest awarded thereon under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, the interest being an integral component of just compensation and not taxable income.
17. For the forgoing reasons, this Court proceeds to pass the following:
ORDER
(i) The writ petition is dismissed.
(ii) The order dated 25.04.2015 passed by the I Additional Senior Civil Judge, Ballari, in Execution Petition No.3/2015 is affirmed.
(iii) The petitioner–Insurance Company shall deposit the deducted sum of Rs.35,399/-, if not already deposited, before the Executing Court within four weeks from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order.
(iv) On such deposit, the Executing Court shall release the amount forthwith in favour of respondent Nos.1 and 2 in accordance with law.
(v) Pending interlocutory applications, if any, stand disposed of.
No order as to costs.


