ACIT Vs Ace Associates (ITAT Mumbai)
Summary: A completion certificate for a building in its original form did not prove that a later reconfigured commercial unit was ready to be let. That distinction led the Mumbai Tribunal to uphold deletion of a ₹16.84 lakh notional rent addition against real-estate developer Ace Associates. The Tribunal also rejected a ₹27.49 crore addition under section 68 for opening stock brought forward from earlier years. A third Revenue ground concerning ₹42 lakh failed because the amount was a lease security deposit, and had not been included as an addition in the Assessing Officer’s final computation.
Three Disputes from One Redevelopment Project
Ace Associates, a partnership firm, developed the Divyajyot redevelopment project at Goregaon West, Mumbai. It returned income of ₹88,30,660 for assessment year 2020–21. During scrutiny, the Assessing Officer examined commercial units held as stock-in-trade. One unit had been let out; another, measuring 5,167.04 sq. ft., was vacant.
The Assessing Officer invoked section 23(5) for the vacant unit. Using a monthly rent of ₹2,00,500 obtained from a NoBroker internet search, he calculated annual value of ₹24,06,000 and, after the deduction under section 24(a), added ₹16,84,200 as income from house property.
He also noticed opening stock of ₹27,49,50,173 in the firm’s trading account, while the immediately preceding year’s return did not show closing stock. He treated the opening stock as an unexplained credit under section 68. Finally, he discussed ₹42 lakh as a supposed property purchase from HDFC Bank Ltd. under section 69, although he did not include that amount in the final computation of assessed income.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.


