Summary: GST on real estate and Joint Development Agreements (JDAs) continues to be governed principally by the rate and exemption framework introduced on 1 April 2019, under which under-construction residential apartments attract an effective GST rate of 1% for affordable housing and 5% for other residential apartments without input tax credit (ITC), while sales after the completion certificate or first occupation fall outside GST. This article examines the statutory framework under the CGST Act, 2017, relevant notifications, CBIC FAQs and the treatment of development rights, Transferable Development Rights (TDR), Floor Space Index (FSI), long-term leases and construction services supplied to landowners. It explains the reverse charge mechanism applicable to promoters, the 80% registered-purchase requirement, valuation rules, the deemed one-third land deduction, ITC restrictions and transitional provisions for ongoing projects. The discussion also covers the September 2025 GST rate rationalisation, the retrospective amendment to Section 17(5)(d) by the Finance Act, 2025, and important judicial developments involving Safari Retreats, Munjaal Manishbhai Bhatt and Arham Infra Developers. Through practical illustrations, comparative tables and compliance checklists, the article highlights the tax implications for developers and landowners, including GST on area-sharing and revenue-sharing JDAs, unbooked flats, construction services and cancellation of bookings. It emphasises the importance of proper JDA drafting, project-wise accounting, accurate valuation, timely reverse charge compliance and documentation of ITC adjustments, while recognising that the taxability of development rights under JDAs remains subject to judicial consideration.
- Abstract and introduction
- Circular Master: Real Estate
- Statutory framework
- Notifications in the compilation
- Rate scheme from 01-04-19
- Key definitions (Notification 11/2017 para 4, as amended by 3/2019)
- Conditions for the 1% / 5% rates
- Joint Development Agreements
- The two supplies in an area-sharing JDA (development rights on or after 01-04-19)
- Valuation
- Other points from the FAQs
- Land, TDR, long-term lease and other special issues
- CBIC FAQs and clarifications
- Recent updates (2022 to November 2026)
- Key judicial decisions
- Worked illustrations
- Illustration 1: Area-sharing JDA
- Illustration 2: the 80% registered-purchase test (FY 2025-26)
- Illustration 3: is it an affordable flat?
- Compliance checklist
- Promoter / developer
- Landowner
- Both parties
- Conclusion
Abstract and introduction
The tax on a flat is set in a few places in the law. Constructing a residential apartment that is sold before completion carries an effective GST of 1% (affordable) or 5% (others) without input tax credit (ITC). Selling it after the completion certificate attracts no GST, because that is a sale of immovable property. Joint Development Agreements (JDAs) add a second supply: the landowner transfers development rights, and the developer constructs and hands over flats in return. The scheme of 29 March 2019 deals with both supplies through exemptions and reverse charge.
This paper is built on the
Circular Master: Real Estate
compilation provided. That compilation covers:
- the CBIC FAQs of 07-05-19 and 14-05-19
- Notifications 11/2017, 12/2017 and 4/2018 (Central Tax (Rate))
- Notifications 3/2019 to 8/2019 and 23/2019 (Central Tax (Rate))
- Notification 16/2019 (Central Tax), which amended Rules 42 and 43 for real estate
- the Scheme of Classification of Services
It adds the developments up to November 2026: the GST 2.0 rate rationalization, the Safari Retreats judgment and the Finance Act, 2025 amendment that followed, and court rulings on JDAs and the deemed land deduction.
Scope: CGST Act, 2017 and the rate notifications (with matching State notifications), as in force on 02-11-26.
Statutory framework
GST on real estate rests on three provisions of the CGST Act: Schedule II para 5(b), Schedule III para 5, and Section 148. On these sit a set of rate, exemption, reverse charge and time-of-supply notifications.
- Schedule II, para 5(b).Construction of a complex, building or civil structure intended for sale is a supply of service. This covers sale before the completion certificate or first occupation, where any consideration is received before that event.
- Schedule III, para 5.Sale of land, and of a building after the completion certificate or first occupation, is neither goods nor services. It is outside GST.
- Section 7 and “business”.Transfer of development rights by a landowner is a supply even by an individual, because “business” includes any adventure or similar activity (FAQ Part I, Q.39).
- Section 9(4).The promoter pays reverse charge on purchases from unregistered persons that make up the shortfall from the 80% registered-purchase requirement (Notification 7/2019).
- Section 148.This lets the Government set a special time of supply. Notifications 4/2018 and 6/2019 use it for JDAs.
- Section 17(5)(c) and (d).These block ITC on works contracts and on goods and services used to construct immovable property on one’s own account, other than plant and machinery.
Notifications in the compilation
| Notification | Date | What it does |
|---|---|---|
| 11/2017-CT(R), Sl. 3 and para 2 | 28-06-17 | Rate entries for construction services. Para 2 deems one-third of total consideration to be land value |
| 12/2017-CT(R), Entries 41A and 41B | inserted by 4/2019 | Exempts TDR/FSI and upfront long-term lease premium for residential flats booked before completion |
| 13/2017-CT(R), Entries 5B and 5C | inserted by 5/2019 | Promoter pays reverse charge on TDR/FSI and on long-term lease premium |
| 4/2018-CT(R) | 25-01-18 | JDA time of supply: on transfer of possession or right in the flats (conveyance or allotment letter) |
| 3/2019-CT(R) | 29-03-19 | New scheme: 1% / 5% without ITC, definitions, option for ongoing projects (Annexure IV) |
| 6/2019-CT(R) | 29-03-19 | Time of supply for TDR/FSI, lease premium and construction service to the landowner: completion certificate or first occupation, whichever is earlier |
| 7/2019-CT(R) | 29-03-19 | Reverse charge on the shortfall from 80%, on cement, and on capital goods bought from unregistered persons |
| 8/2019-CT(R) | 29-03-19 | 18% on goods bought from unregistered persons that fall under the shortfall (other than cement and capital goods) |
| 23/2019-CT(R) | 30-09-19 | Notification 4/2018 does not apply to development rights supplied on or after 01-04-19 |
| 16/2019-CT | 29-03-19 | Rules 42 and 43 amended for ITC reversal in real estate projects |
Rate scheme from 01-04-19
All rates below are effective rates after the deemed one-third land deduction. The nominal rate is 1.5% or 7.5% on two-thirds of the consideration. These residential rates were not changed by the GST 2.0 rationalisation of September 2025.
| Supply by promoter | Effective rate | ITC |
|---|---|---|
| Affordable residential apartment (new project, or ongoing project that opted for new rates) | 1% | No |
| Other residential apartment | 5% | No |
| Commercial apartment in an RREP (commercial carpet area ≤ 15%) | 5% | No |
| Commercial apartment in a REP other than an RREP | 12% | Yes |
| Ongoing project, old-rate option exercised by 10-05-19 | 8% (affordable) / 12% (others) | Yes |
| Flat sold after completion certificate or first occupation | Not a supply (Sch. III) | n/a |
| Works contract by a contractor to the promoter | 18% from 22-09-25 (12% for affordable housing earlier) | Yes, to the contractor |
Key definitions (Notification 11/2017 para 4, as amended by 3/2019)
- Affordable residential apartment.Carpet area up to 60 sq m in metropolitan cities, or 90 sq m elsewhere, with a gross amount of not more than Rs. 45 lakh. Metropolitan cities are Bengaluru, Chennai, Delhi NCR (limited to Delhi, Noida, Greater Noida, Ghaziabad, Gurgaon and Faridabad), Hyderabad, Kolkata and the whole of MMR. The gross amount includes preferential location, parking, amenity and legal charges, but not stamp duty or maintenance deposits (FAQ Part II, Q.4).
- RREP.A REP in which the commercial carpet area is not more than 15% of the total carpet area. Apartments are classed as declared to RERA (FAQ Part II, Q.3).
- Ongoing project.Commencement certificate issued and construction started on or before 31-03-19, completion certificate or first occupation not before that date, and some apartments booked by then. Each RERA registration is a separate project (FAQ Part I, Q.3, Q.30).
Conditions for the 1% / 5% rates
- Tax is paid in cash only. ITC cannot be used for it (FAQ Part II, Q.13).
- No ITC is taken. Credit attributable to the project is reversed under Rules 42 and 43.
- At least 80% of inputs and input services (by value) are bought from registered suppliers. TDR, FSI, long-term lease premium, electricity, HSD, motor spirit, natural gas and salaries are excluded from the base. Exempt purchases are counted as unregistered purchases (FAQ Part II, Q.15, Q.18, Q.19).
- On any shortfall from 80%, the promoter pays tax under reverse charge at 18%. Cement shortfall was taxed at 28%, now 18% after GST 2.0. Capital goods bought from unregistered persons are taxed under reverse charge at the applicable rate (Notification 7/2019).
- Project-wise accounts are kept, and ITC not availed is reported in GSTR-3B.
Joint Development Agreements
An area-sharing JDA is a barter of two services. The landowner supplies development rights to the developer, and the developer supplies construction service of the landowner’s flats in return. From 01-04-19, the right is exempt for residential flats booked before completion. The construction service is taxed at the flat rate. Both fall due on the completion certificate or first occupation.
The two supplies in an area-sharing JDA (development rights on or after 01-04-19)
| Supply | By → to | Treatment | Who pays | When |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Development rights / FSI for residential flats | Landowner → developer | Exempt (Entry 41A, 12/2017) for flats booked before completion. Taxable at 18% for flats unbooked on completion, capped at 1% / 5% of their value | Developer, reverse charge (Entry 5B, 13/2017) | Completion or first occupation (6/2019) |
| Development rights / FSI for commercial flats | Landowner → developer | 18% | Developer, reverse charge | Completion (FSI against flats); immediately where money is paid for commercial FSI |
| Construction of the landowner’s flats | Developer → landowner | 1% / 5% without ITC (residential); 5% or 12% (commercial) | Developer, forward charge | Completion or first occupation (6/2019) |
| Sale of flats by the landowner before completion | Landowner → buyer | 1% / 5%. ITC only for the tax charged by the developer (FAQ Part II, Q.2) | Landowner-promoter | Ordinary time of supply |
| Sale of flats by the landowner after completion | Landowner → buyer | Not a supply (Sch. III) | n/a | n/a |
Valuation
- Development rights.Valued at the price the promoter charges independent buyers for similar flats, on the booking date nearest to the date the right is transferred (Notification 12/2017 para 1A; FAQ Part II, Q.6).
- Construction service to the landowner.Valued the same way, less the deemed one-third land value under para 2 of Notification 11/2017 (FAQ Part II, Q.26).
- TDR / FSI tax on unbooked flats.Computed as GST on TDR × unbooked residential carpet area ÷ total residential carpet area. It is capped at 0.5% (affordable) or 2.5% (others) of the value of unbooked flats, per side (CGST and SGST together give the 1% / 5% caps).
Other points from the FAQs
- Landowner-promoter and developer-promoter must make the same option (old or new rates) for an ongoing project (FAQ Part II, Q.1).
- The landowner does not have to reverse ITC under the 180-day rule. Its “payment” (the development rights) is made before the service is received (FAQ Part II, Q.24).
- The developer pays reverse charge on TDR whether the landowner is registered or not (FAQ Part II, Q.12).
- For development rights transferred before 01-04-19, Notification 4/2018 still applies, even where flats are allotted later. Tax arises when possession or allotment is given (FAQ Part I, Q.27 and Q.38).
- In redevelopment and slum rehabilitation, flats given free to existing occupants are taxable supplies. The consideration is the TDR or FSI (FAQ Part II, Q.8, Q.9).
Revenue-sharing JDAs. Here the landowner receives a share of sale proceeds, not flats. The development right is still a supply, and the 18% reverse charge rule applies on the portion for unbooked or commercial flats. There is no barter construction service. The developer pays 1% / 5% on all sales. Some commentators argue that the landowner here is a co-venturer selling its own share, not a supplier of rights; the issue is open (see Arham Infra, below).
Land, TDR, long-term lease and other special issues
Deemed land deduction (para 2, Notification 11/2017). Where land or an undivided share of land is transferred along with construction, the land value is deemed to be one-third of the total amount charged. The FAQs say the actual land value cannot be used instead (FAQ Part I, Q.36). In Munjaal Manishbhai Bhatt v. UoI (Gujarat HC, 2022), the court held that the mandatory deeming is not valid where the actual land value is known, and read the provision down. In those cases, the actual land value may be deducted. Outside Gujarat, departments still apply one-third, and the issue is being litigated.
TDR / FSI bought from another developer. This is taxable at 18% with ITC under Sl. 16(iii) of 11/2017 (heading 9972), payable by the promoter under reverse charge (FAQ Part I, Q.28). The Entry 41A exemption applies only to TDR used by a promoter for residential flats (FAQ Part II, Q.25).
Long-term lease (30 years or more).
- The upfront premium (salami, development charges) for residential flats is exempt to the extent the flats are booked before completion (Entry 41B).
- The premium for unbooked flats is taxed under reverse charge on completion, within the 1% / 5% cap. The premium for commercial flats is taxed immediately.
- Annual or monthly lease rent is fully taxable (FAQ Part I, Q.15, Q.16).
ITC transition for ongoing projects (Rules 42 and 43, as amended by 16/2019). Where an ongoing project moved to 1% / 5%, the ITC already taken is apportioned on carpet area. ITC on flats booked after completion is reversed through GSTR-3B or DRC-03, by September following the year of completion. Flats cancelled after 01-04-19 and re-booked at new rates need reversal of the old ITC taken on them (FAQ Part I, Q.22).
Cancellation and credit notes. If a booking is cancelled and the full amount is refunded, the developer may adjust the GST paid through a Section 34 credit note (FAQ Part I, Q.22). The credit note is now subject to the deadline of 30 November after the year end and to the Section 34(2) proviso on ITC reversal by the recipient. That proviso does not bite where the buyer is an unregistered individual.
ITC on commercial buildings for letting. In Safari Retreats (SC, 03-10-24), the Supreme Court held that a mall built for letting could be a “plant” under a functionality test, and so outside the Section 17(5)(d) block. The Finance Act, 2025 then amended Section 17(5)(d) with retrospective effect from 01-07-17, substituting “plant and machinery” for “plant or machinery”. The amendment removes that route, so ITC on buildings constructed for letting stays blocked.
CBIC FAQs and clarifications
The two sets of TRU FAQs (F. No. 354/32/2019-TRU) are still the main official guidance on the 2019 scheme. They have no force of law, and the notifications prevail where the two conflict. The table groups the key answers by topic.
| Topic | Clarification | FAQ ref |
|---|---|---|
| Option for ongoing projects | One-time option per RERA project in Annexure IV, filed manually by 10-05-19. No form means new rates are deemed chosen. No amendment is allowed after filing | I: Q.4, Q.24, Q.41; II: Q.22 |
| Projects with bookings not started by 31-03-19 | Treated as new projects: 1% / 5% compulsorily | I: Q.40 |
| Part completion or occupation certificates | A project is not “completed” until the certificate covers the whole project. One commencement certificate for part of it is enough to count as “commenced” | I: Q.29, Q.33, Q.34 |
| Completion certificate before 01-04-19, money due later | Old rates apply, since time of supply was before 01-04-19 | II: Q.10, Q.27 |
| Buyer’s past instalments | No extra tax on instalments paid before 01-04-19 | II: Q.16 |
| ITC under 1% / 5% | Not usable against 1% / 5% output tax; that tax is paid in cash only | II: Q.13, Q.14 |
| 80% rule | Salaries, land, TDR and FSI excluded. Exempt purchases count as unregistered purchases. Mixed projects split by carpet area | II: Q.5, Q.15, Q.18, Q.19 |
| 80% rule under old-rate option | Does not apply | II: Q.17 |
| Works contract rate to the promoter | 12% (affordable) / 18% (others) in 2019, on the promoter’s declaration. Now 18% after GST 2.0 | I: Q.32; II: Q.23 |
| Individual landowner | Transfer of development rights is a supply even by an individual | I: Q.39 |
| Pre-01-04-19 JDAs | Old regime (Notification 4/2018) applies even if flats are allotted later | I: Q.27, Q.38 |
| Redevelopment / slum rehabilitation | Free flats to occupants are taxable. Bookings are deemed to exist for the “ongoing project” test | I: Q.35; II: Q.8, Q.9 |
Our search found no later CBIC circular dedicated to real estate or JDAs; confirm on the CBIC site before relying on this. Changes since then have come through rate notifications, the Finance Act, 2025, and the courts.
Recent updates (2022 to November 2026)
The 1% / 5% scheme is unchanged, but several things have changed since 2022:
- inputs are cheaper (cement is now at 18%)
- contractors charge 18%
- ITC on buildings built for letting is blocked retrospectively
- the taxability of JDA development rights is before the Supreme Court
| Date | Development | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| 13-10-25 | Supreme Court stays a GST demand on a JDA in Arham Infra Developers AOP v. UoI (SLP against Bombay HC) | Whether development rights under a JDA are taxable or a transfer of land (Sch. III) is now before the SC. The developers also argue double taxation |
| 01-10-25 | Sec 34(2) proviso in force (Notification 16/2025-CT) | Credit notes on cancellations need ITC reversal by a registered buyer before the developer’s tax comes down |
| 22-09-25 | GST 2.0 rate rationalisation (56th Council) | Cement 28% → 18%; works contracts at 12% (affordable housing, government works) move to 18%. Residential 1% / 5% unchanged |
| 05-05-25 | Patna HC: developer liable under reverse charge on construction service to the landowner under a JDA | Development rights are a taxable supply, not a sale of land. Handing over the landowner’s share after the completion certificate does not avoid tax |
| 08-04-25 | Bombay HC: a plot owner’s agreement giving money and flats, with no TDR or FSI transferred, is not covered by Entry 5B | Demand under reverse charge on “development rights” quashed. Drafting of the JDA is decisive |
| 2025 | Finance Act, 2025 amends Sec 17(5)(d) retrospectively from 01-07-17 (“plant and machinery”) | Overrides Safari Retreats. No ITC on buildings constructed for letting |
| 03-10-24 | Chief Commr. v. Safari Retreats (SC) | Functionality test: a building may be “plant” |
| 2022 | Munjaal Manishbhai Bhatt (Gujarat HC) | Mandatory one-third land deduction read down where actual land value is known |
Open points: the outcome in Arham Infra, and whether the Council will revisit the 1% / 5% scheme. Contractors now charge 18% while promoters still get no ITC, which raises the cost of construction.
Key judicial decisions
The High Courts are split on JDAs. Patna treats development rights as a taxable supply. Bombay looks at whether the agreement actually transfers TDR or FSI. The Supreme Court’s stay in Arham Infra means the final answer is pending.
| Case | Court / date | Issue | Holding |
|---|---|---|---|
| Arham Infra Developers AOP v. UoI | SC, 13-10-25 (SLP) | Is a JDA a supply of service or a transfer of land? | Assessment order of 27-01-25 (Nashik-I) stayed. Bombay HC had sent the developers to appeal under Sec 107 |
| Builder v. State | Patna HC, 05-05-25 | Reverse charge on construction for the landowner | Development rights are taxable, not Sch. III land. Builder liable; writ dismissed |
| Builder v. UoI | Bombay HC, 08-04-25 | Entry 5B reverse charge where no TDR or FSI is transferred | Not covered by Entry 5B. SCN of 14-08-23 and order of 10-12-24 quashed |
| Chief Commr. of CGST v. Safari Retreats Pvt. Ltd. | SC, 03-10-24; 2024 SCC OnLine SC 2456 | ITC on a mall built for letting | Functionality test; a building can be “plant”. Overridden by the Finance Act, 2025 |
| Munjaal Manishbhai Bhatt v. UoI | Gujarat HC, 2022; [2022] 138 taxmann.com 117 | Deemed one-third land deduction | Mandatory deeming is not valid where the land value is ascertainable; provision read down |
| Larsen & Toubro v. State of Karnataka | SC, 2013 (pre-GST) | Agreement to sell flats under construction | A works contract; only the construction element is taxable. This is the basis for Sch. II para 5(b) |
Advance rulings bind only the applicant and are not listed here. Before relying on any ruling above, check the full order for its facts.
Worked illustrations
All amounts are in rupees. The project is a new residential project (non-affordable, commenced after 01-04-19), intra-State.
Illustration 1: Area-sharing JDA
The facts:
- 100 flats of 100 sq m each, 10,000 sq m in all.
- The landowner gets 40 flats and the developer sells 60.
- Similar flats were sold to outside buyers at 50 lakh each on the date nearest to the JDA.
- At the completion certificate, 10 of the developer’s flats are unbooked.
| Step | Working | Tax |
|---|---|---|
| Construction service to landowner (value) | 40 × 50 lakh = 20 crore | |
| Less deemed land (1/3) | 20 crore − 6.67 crore = 13.33 crore | |
| GST at 7.5% on 13.33 crore (= 5% effective) | Payable by developer on CC date | 1.00 crore |
| TDR value | Same as the flats given: 20 crore | |
| GST on TDR but for exemption | 20 crore × 18% = 3.60 crore | |
| Attributable to unbooked flats | 3.60 crore × 1,000 ÷ 10,000 = 36 lakh | |
| Cap: 5% of value of unbooked flats | 10 × 50 lakh × 5% = 25 lakh | |
| Reverse charge payable on TDR (lower of the two) | Paid in cash on CC date | 25 lakh |
The landowner sells 20 of its flats before the completion certificate at 55 lakh each. GST is 5% of 11 crore = 55 lakh. Against this, the landowner may use ITC of the developer’s tax on those 20 flats: 1 crore × 20/40 = 50 lakh (FAQ Part II, Q.2). The net cash payable is 5 lakh. If it sells its flats after the completion certificate instead, no GST arises, and the 50 lakh credit is lost.
Illustration 2: the 80% registered-purchase test (FY 2025-26)
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Inputs and input services (excluding TDR, lease premium, fuel, electricity, salaries) | 10.00 crore |
| Required from registered suppliers (80%) | 8.00 crore |
| Actually bought from registered suppliers | 7.00 crore |
| Shortfall taxed under reverse charge | 1.00 crore |
| GST at 18% (cement included at 18% after 22-09-25) | 18.00 lakh |
The test is applied for each financial year (or up to the completion certificate). The tax is paid by June of the next year. It cannot be paid using ITC.
Illustration 3: is it an affordable flat?
A flat in Guwahati (not a metro city) has a carpet area of 85 sq m. The base price is 44 lakh, and parking and amenity charges are 1.5 lakh. The gross amount is 45.5 lakh, which is above the 45 lakh limit, so the flat is taxed at 5%, not 1%. Stamp duty and the maintenance deposit are left out of the gross amount.
Compliance checklist
Promoter / developer
- Classify each RERA project: RREP or REP (commercial carpet area ≤ 15%?), and affordable or other, flat by flat (carpet area and Rs. 45 lakh gross amount)
- Pay 1% / 5% output tax in cash; take no ITC on project inputs
- Keep project-wise accounts and report ITC not availed in GSTR-3B
- Track the 80% registered-purchase test each financial year; pay reverse charge on any shortfall (18%) by June of the next year
- Pay reverse charge on capital goods bought from unregistered persons
- On the completion certificate or first occupation: pay tax on construction for the landowner; compute reverse charge on TDR / FSI / lease premium for unbooked flats (with the 1% / 5% cap)
- Pay reverse charge immediately on TDR / FSI or lease premium for commercial flats
- Value the landowner’s flats at the price charged to independent buyers nearest to the JDA date; keep the comparable booking on file
- On cancellations, issue credit notes within the Sec 34(2) deadline and refund the buyer in full
- Keep the RERA registration, commencement certificate, architect’s certificate and completion certificate on file
Landowner
- Register if the flats you receive will be sold before the completion certificate (you become a landowner-promoter)
- Charge 1% / 5% on such sales; take ITC only for the developer’s tax on your flats
- Choose the same old/new rate option as the developer for an ongoing project
- For JDAs signed before 01-04-19, check tax under Notification 4/2018 at allotment or possession
Both parties
- Draft the JDA to state clearly what is transferred (land, development rights, TDR / FSI), the sharing ratio, and who bears GST
- Watch Arham Infra (SC) and keep a protective position on notices about JDA development rights
Conclusion
The 2019 scheme still governs residential real estate in November 2026. Flats sold before completion pay 1% or 5% without ITC, and flats sold after completion pay nothing. In a JDA, the developer’s construction for the landowner and its reverse charge on unbooked TDR both fall due at the completion certificate. The pressure points have moved elsewhere:
- contractors now charge 18% that promoters cannot recover
- ITC on rental buildings is blocked retrospectively
- whether a JDA is a supply at all is pending before the Supreme Court in Arham Infra
Until that is decided, draft JDAs carefully, document valuations, and keep protective positions on notices.





