Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Income Tax

BSNL Ex Gratia Exemption Under Section 10(10B) Allowed in Rectification Appeals: ITAT Delhi

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2026 taxguru.in 19219
Case Name
Sanjeev Kumar Vs ITO (ITAT Delhi)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Related Assessment Year
2020-21& 2021-22
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Sanjeev Kumar Vs ITO (ITAT Delhi)

BSNL Ex Gratia Is Eligible for Section 10(10B) Relief in Appeals Arising From Section 154 Rectification

Delhi ITAT Allows Both Appeals on BSNL Ex Gratia

The Delhi ITAT held that Sanjeev Kumar’s claim for exemption on ex gratia received from BSNL was covered by coordinate Bench decisions in favour of employees. The appeals arose from orders under section 154 of the Income-tax Act, 1961. The Tribunal allowed both appeals and restored the issues to the Assessing Officer with a direction to consider its findings and the decisions it had relied on and extend the benefit to the assessee. The operative order leaves implementation of that relief for the two assessment years to the Assessing Officer.

Dispute Over Taxability of ₹7,96,275

The Tribunal identified the principal issue as the taxability of ₹7,96,275 received as ex gratia from BSNL, the assessee’s employer. The assessee had sought rectification of his tax liability on the ground that the compensation qualified for relief. The Assessing Officer passed orders under section 154 on 16 February 2026 for both years. The Additional or Joint Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals), Thiruvananthapuram, dismissed the first appeals by orders dated 5 May 2026.

Before the Tribunal, the Revenue relied on CBDT instructions and argued that the receipt was taxable and fell outside the second proviso to section 10(10B). The assessee contended that the appellate authority could entertain the claim and relied on CIT v. Jai Parabolic Springs Ltd. (2008) 306 ITR 42 (Delhi). The appeals thus raised both the substantive exemption claim and the question of obtaining relief in proceedings originating from rectification.

Section 10(10B) and the Compensation Precedents

The Tribunal considered the issue covered on facts and law by the Chandigarh Bench decision in Dayal Singh v. ITO (2024) 169 taxmann.com 539. That decision dealt with compensation received following closure of the employer company under a decision of the Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs. The Chandigarh Bench accepted the claim under section 10(10B) and, in the passage reproduced in the Delhi order, directed relief on the whole compensation in the case before it.

The Delhi Bench also referred to Bijender Singh Dhankhar, ITA No. 222/Chd/2025, and Ananga Mohan Das v. ITO, ITA Nos. 1452 and 1453/Kol/2026, decided on 5 August 2026. In Ananga Mohan Das, the Kolkata Bench directed the Assessing Officer to grant exemption for retrenchment compensation and accumulated leave encashment, as applicable in the respective appeals. The Delhi Bench treated these authorities as part of a consistent line of decisions favouring employees on comparable compensation claims.

Rectification Can Address Taxable Income Overstated on the Record

The Tribunal reproduced the reasoning in Shamik Pankajbhai Parikh (2024) 158 taxmann.com 283 (Ahmedabad ITAT). The Ahmedabad Bench discussed severance compensation and the power to rectify an intimation under section 143(1). It referred to Pawan Kumar Aggarwal v. CIT, IT Appeal No. 199/2014 (Delhi HC), on the scope of section 154, and Zen Tobacco Pvt. Ltd. v. ACIT (2016) 65 taxmann.com 320 (Ahmedabad ITAT), where rectification was allowed for an overstatement of taxable income apparent from the record.

The significance of this discussion is procedural. Sanjeev Kumar reached the Tribunal through appeals against rectification orders. The Delhi Bench treated the favourable authorities as applicable to his claim and directed the Assessing Officer to give effect to the benefit. Whether a particular error is apparent from the record remains central when relief is sought under section 154.

Bangalore and Delhi Bench Decisions Also Noted

Among the decisions noted were Narasimha Bhat Nandavara, ITA No. 660/Bang/2026 and connected appeals, Renuka Narasimha Prabhu, ITA No. 992/Bang/2026 and connected appeals, and Vinod Kumar Madan, ITA Nos. 4698 and 4699/Del/2026. The Tribunal also referred to Nizamuddin Gooty, ITA Nos. 903 and 904/Hyd/2026 and connected appeals, which arose against an intimation under section 143(1). The Delhi Bench concluded that the lower authorities had failed to appreciate the facts and the favourable decisions.

Author’s Comments

The order is particularly relevant to BSNL employees whose exemption claims were rejected in section 154 proceedings. Its substantive reasoning rests on the Bench’s finding that the compensation claim was covered by earlier decisions. Its procedural significance lies in the direction to extend the benefit even though the appeals arose from rectification orders.

The order records ₹7,96,275 as the ex gratia receipt in dispute and restores the issues for both years. In giving effect to the order, the Assessing Officer must apply the Tribunal’s findings to the payment and tax computation for each assessment year. The precise relief will follow from that exercise.

Cases Discussed

  • CIT Vs Jai Parabolic Springs Ltd. (Delhi High Court), (2008) 306 ITR 42
  • Dayal Singh Vs ITO (ITAT Chandigarh), (2024) 169 taxmann.com 539
  • Bijender Singh Dhankhar Vs ITO (ITAT Chandigarh), ITA No. 222/Chd/2025
  • Shamik Pankajbhai Parikh Vs ITO (ITAT Ahmedabad), (2024) 158 taxmann.com 283
  • Dy. CIT Vs Justice Dilip Kumar Seth (ITAT Kolkata), (2006) 98 ITD 241
  • Pawan Kumar Aggarwal Vs CIT (Delhi High Court), IT Appeal No. 199/2014
  • Zen Tobacco Pvt. Ltd. Vs ACIT (ITAT Ahmedabad), (2016) 65 taxmann.com 320
  • Ananga Mohan Das Vs ITO (ITAT Kolkata), ITA Nos. 1452–1453/Kol/2026
  • Bajirao Shankar Jagdale (ITAT Mumbai), ITA No. 1389/Mum/2026
  • Harish Kumar (ITAT Chandigarh), (2025) 175 taxmann.com 379
  • Sudarsan Sarkar (ITAT Kolkata), ITA No. 1607/Kol/2026
  • Soma Purkayastha (ITAT Mumbai), ITA Nos. 7205–7206/Mum/2026
  • Jayeshkumar Tulsidas Sutaria (ITAT Ahmedabad), (2026) 183 taxmann.com 587
  • Ravikiran Damodar Kudade (ITAT Pune), (2026) 187 taxmann.com 857
  • Narasimha Bhat Nandavara (ITAT Bangalore), ITA No. 660/Bang/2026
  • Renuka Narasimha Prabhu (ITAT Bangalore), ITA No. 992/Bang/2026
  • Nizamuddin Gooty (ITAT Hyderabad), ITA Nos. 903–904/Hyd/2026
  • Vinod Kumar Madan (ITAT Delhi), ITA Nos. 4698–4699/Del/2026

FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF ITAT DELHI

These appeals preferred by the Assessee against the order of the Ld. Addl/JCIT(A) Thiruvananthpuram (hereinafter referred to as the First Appellate Authority or ‘the ld. FAA’ for short) in appeals filed before him against the orders of the ld. Assessing Officer (hereinafter referred to as the Ld. AO, for short) passed u/s 154of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (hereafter referred to as ‘the Act’). Further details of the orders of the lower authorities are as under: –

ITA No. & AY First Appellate Authority Appeal order Assessing Officer / Order date
6555/D/26; 2020–21 Addl/JCIT(A), Thiruvananthapuram DIN ITBA/APL/S/250/2026-27/1088835439(1); 05.05.2026 ITO, Ward 3(2)(4), Muzaffarnagar; 16.02.2026
6556/D/26; 2021–22 Addl/JCIT(A), Thiruvananthapuram DIN ITBA/APL/S/250/2026-27/1088835643(1); 05.05.2026 ITO, Ward 3(2)(4), Muzaffarnagar; 16.02.2026

2. On hearing both sides we find that primarily the issue involved is whether the ex-gratia receipt of Rs.7,96,275/- received by the assesse from its employer BSNL is taxable under the Act. Ld. DR has heavily relied the various instructions of the Board and submitted that this ex-gratia receipt is taxable and does not fall in the scope of second proviso to Section 10(10B) of the Act. The primary issue is that assesse had sought rectification of its tax liability on the basis that the compensation received from the employer is deductible. Ld. CIT(A) has dismissed the same and the assesse claims that such a claim can always be entertain by appellate authority and reliance in this regard is placed in the decision of Hon’ble Delhi High in CIT Vs. Jai Parabolic Springs Ltd. [2008] 306 ITR 42 (Delhi).

3. After taking into consideration all the facts and circumstances and the rival submissions as reflected in the impugned order we are of the considered view that the case of assesse seems to be squarely covered on facts and in law by Coordinate Bench decision and nothing is required to be determined on first principle any further. Coordinate Bench Chandigarh Bench in the case of Dayal Singh Vs. ITO (2024) 169 Taxmann.com 539 order dated 03.12.2024 has examined similar claim of an employee and observed in para 4.9 as follows:

“4.9 In view of the above, the appellant’s plea that the compensation received subsequent to the closure of the employer company, based on the decision of the Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs, Government of India, is eligible for exemption under section 10(10 B) of the Act, is accepted. The addition made by the Assessing Officer of Rs. 23,13,096/- is deleted. Appeal on this ground is allowed.” 23. We are therefore intrigued by the fact that where the ldCIT(A) in other cases under identical fact pattern are consistently holding that the employees who have received similar compensation from HMT are eligible for exemption u/s 10(10B) of the Act and these cases are brought to the notice of the ld CIT(A) in the instant case, the ld CIT(A) has failed to take cognizance of these decisions. It is not even a case where the aforesaid decisions so rendered in other cases have been challenged by the Revenue or any distinguishing facts and circumstances are available on record and/or pointed out by the ldCIT(A). Therefore, under the identical set of facts and circumstances of the case, where the matters have been decided and the Revenue is not in appeal, following the principle of consistency as well, the matter TANVI deserve to be decided in favour of the assessee at the first appellate level itself which unfortunately has not happened in the instant case. 24. In light of aforesaid discussion and in the entirety of facts and circumstances of the case, the assessee is held eligible for exemption u/s 10(10B) on whole of the amount received of voluntary retirement compensation amounting to Rs.36,07,576/- and the AO is directed to allow necessary relief to the assessee. In the result, the ground no. 3 of the assessee’s appeal is allowed.”

4. Similar has been the fate in the case of Bijender Singh Dhankhar in ITA No. 222/Chd/2025 and Ahmedabad Bench in case of ShamikPankajbhai Parikh (2024) 158 taxmann.com 283 (Ahmedabad Trib) has observed as follows:

“7.3 Accordingly, in our considered view, the case of the assessee is directly covered by the afore said decisions, which have on identical set of facts held that the severance compensation received by the assesseeon voluntary basis towards termination of employment from his employers is a “capital receipt” and, hence ,not taxable in the hands of the assessee. Further, even the Department has not contested the claim of the assessee that the aforesaid amount is not taxable in the hands of the assessee as his income.

In the case of Dy. CIT v. Justice Dilip Kumar Seth [2006] 98 ITD 241/101 TTJ 90 (Kol), the ITAT held that the Assessing Officer is well competent to rectify any mistake in the intimation u/s.143(1) of the Act which was brought tohis notice by the assessee. Further, the Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of Pawan Kumar Aggarwal v.CIT [IT Appeal No. 199/2014] has held that from bare reading of section 154 of the Act, it is apparent that the power of rectification extends to amendment of an intimation or deemed intimation u/s.143(1) of the Act. The Hon’ble High Court further held that this power of rectification enures even after the matter has been considered and decided in any proceedings by way of appeal or revision. It was held that necessarily this power extends even at the stage of the appeal and further appeal to the ITAT. In the case of Zen Tobacco (P.)Ltd. v. Asstt.CIT [2016] 65 taxmann.com 320 (Ahd. – Trib.), the assessee had filed its return of income declaring certain income and the same was processed under section 143(1). Subsequently, on verification of assessee’s record, it was noticed that the provision of deferred tax assets of certain amount, which ought to have been deducted from total income, was not deducted but added back to amount of profit and, thus, taxable income was overstated. Therefore, the assessee filed an application under section 154 seeking for rectification of mistake along with the revised statement of income and claimed a refund. The Assessing Officer rejected the application observing that the assessee should have filed a revised return rather than taking recourse to section 154, which was not permissible under the Act. On appeal, the Commissioner (Appeals) dismissed the appeal. On second appeal, the Ahmedabad ITAT held that from the provisions of sections 139(1), 139(5) and143(1) it is evident that it is not the case that revenue authorities have to accept whatever stated in the return and compute the taxable income mechanically. As per provisions of section 143(1), the concerned revenue authority has to examine whether any claim as made by the assessee is correct or not. This includes understatement and overstatement of the income. If the revenue authority failed to take note of any incorrect claim with regard to total income of the assessee, such failure would necessarily mean mistake apparent from the record. Therefore, following the judgment of the Delhi High Court in Pawan Kumar Aggarwal’s case(supra) and the decision of the Co-ordinate Bench in the case of Justice Dilip Kumar Seth (supra) the order of the Commissioner (Appeals) was directed to be set aside and the Assessing Officer was directed by ITAT to allow the application of the assessee made under section 154 and grant refund amount.”

5. Coordinate Bench Kolkata in case of Ananga Mohan Das Vs. ITO, Ward- 42(1) Murshidabad vide ITA No. 1452 & 1453/Kokl/2026 dated 05.08.2026 held as follows:

“Further, with respect to compensation on retrenchment and accumulate leave encashment, as decided in ITA No.1452/KOL/2026 in the case of Ananga Mohan Das Vs. ITO Ward 42(1), Murshidabad, we direct to grant exemption on of retrenchment compensation and also in respect of accumulated leave encashment as the case may be in respective Appeals filed by the different Assessee. Thus, the captioned Appeals are allowed and the Assessing Officer is directed to grant exemption accordingly.”

6. Apart from that our attention is drawn to decisions in ITAT MUMBAI BENCH H in case of Bajirao Shankar Jagdale [ITA 1389/Mum/2026]; ITAT CHANDIGARH BENCH in case of HARISH KUMAR [175 taxmann.com 379]; ITAT KOLKATA BENCH in case of SUDARSAN SARKAR [ITA 1607/KOL/2026] and others; ITAT MUMBAI BENCH in case of SOMA PURKAYASTHA [7205&7206/MUM/2026]; ITAT AHMEDABAD SMC BENCH in case of Jayeshkumar Tulsidas Sutaria [183 taxmann.com 587]; ITAT PUNE SMC BENCH in case of Ravikiran Damodar Kudade [187 taxmann.com 857]; ITAT KOLKATA SMC BENCH in case of Ananga Mohan Das [ITA Nos 1452 & 1453/KOL/2026] and 20 others; ITAT BANGALORE SMC BENCH in case of Shri Narasimha Bhat Nandavara [ITA/660/BANG/2026] and 6 others; ITAT AHMEDABAD SMC BENCH in case of Chhaganlal Bhimabhai [ITA Nos.2547 & 2548/Ahd/2025]; ITAT PUNE SMC BENCH in case of Meghmala Sudhir Pathak [ITA Nos.290 and 293/PUN/2026] and 11 others; ITAT PUNE SMC BENCH in case of Prathibha Jgadish Unawane [ITA/1117/Pun/2026 & ITA 1118/Pun/2026] and 101 others; ITAT CHANDIGARH BENCH A in case of Shri Suresh Pal Chauhan and others [ITA NO. 83/Chd/2023]; ITAT PUNE SMC BENCH in case of Sanjay Bajarang Todali [ITA 2090/PUN/2026] and 35 others; ITAT AHMEDABAD BENCH A in case of Nehaben Vimalkumar Shah [ITA Nos. 789 & 790/Ahd/2026]; ITAT PUNE SMC BENCH in case of Ravikiran Damodar Kudade& others [ITA 1785/PUN/2026] and 34 others; ITAT AHMEDABAD SMC BENCH in case of Chhaganlal Bhimabhai Dangodara [ITA Nos.2547 & 2548/Ahd/2025]; ITAT AHMEDABAD SMC BENCH in case of Jayendra Bipinchandra Patel [ITA Nos. 189-190/Ahd/2026]; ITAT AHMEDABAD SMC BENCH in case of Suman Nandlal Raval [ITA Nos.2389 & 2390/Ahd/2025]; ITAT CHENNAI BENCH C in case of Shri Sekar Gnanaprakasam [ITA 1608 & 1609/CHNY/2026]; ITAT BANGALORE in case of RENUKA NARASIMHA PRABHU & 6 others [ITA 992/BANG/2026]; ITAT Hyderabad against Intimation U/s 143(1) vide latest order dated 3-7- 2026 in case of Nizamuddin Gooty [903 & 904/Hyd/2026] & 12 others; ITAT INDORE in case of Narendra Kumar Mishra Vs ITO. ITA No.233 / Ind/20 25 dt. 27-02-2026, for the asst. year. 2020-21; ITAT PANAJI SMC BENCH in case of Shivnandan Narendra Sanvordekar [ITA No.141 and 142/PAN/2026]; ITAT GUWAHATI BENCH in case of Kanauj Kanti Chaudhuri [ITA 258/GTY/2026]; ITAT DELHI SMC BENCH in case of Vinod Kumar Madan [ITA. Nos. 4698 & 4699/Del/2026] wherein all the benches across India have decided the issue in favour of assesse employee.

7. In the light of aforesaid we are of the considered view that ld. tax authorities have failed to appreciate the facts and the settled law in favour of assesse. In the light of aforesaid the appeals are allowed and issues are restored to the files of AO to take into consideration the aforesaid findings of this Bench and the decision we have relied and extend the benefit to the assessee. The appeals are allowed. Order pronounced in the open court on 18.11.2026

Order pronounced in the open court on 18.11.2026

Advertisement

Author Info

CA Vijayakumar Shetty
Qualification: CA in Practice
Company: Shetty & Co, Chartered Accountants, Mangalore
Location: Mangalore, Karnataka
Articles Published: 7,828

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.