Sumit Chhabra Vs Assessment Unit (ITAT Delhi)
Borrowed Satisfaction Vitiates Reassessment – ITAT Quashes Reopening in Case of Alleged Bogus Purchases
In cross appeals by Assessee & Revenue, Delhi ITAT dealt with reassessment initiated on the allegation that Assessee had taken accommodation entries of bogus purchases from M/s KB Enterprises amounting to ₹2.37 crore during FY 2017-18. The original return was filed declaring ₹18.15 lakh, which was already scrutinized & accepted u/s 143(3) by NFAC in April 2021. However, based on information from Investigation Wing regarding accommodation entries routed by one Aditya Jain through dummy concerns including M/s KB Enterprises, notice u/s 148A(b) was issued in March 2022, culminating in reassessment with addition u/s 69C.
CIT(A) restricted addition to 6% of alleged bogus purchases, prompting Revenue to appeal for full addition & Assessee to challenge validity of reopening.
Tribunal noted that AO had not conducted any independent inquiry & merely reproduced Investigation Wing report regarding search in case of M/s KK Spun India Ltd., where Aditya Jain had admitted to providing accommodation entries. Crucially, the AO ignored that Assessee’s case was already assessed u/s 143(3), where the same purchases were accepted. The reasons recorded reflected confusion between bogus sales & bogus purchases, showing non-application of mind. Relying on jurisdictional Delhi High Court ruling in Sanjay Kaul Vs. ITO (W.P.(C) 11198/2019, 30.05.2025), which held that “reason to believe” cannot be equated with “reason to suspect” & reopening cannot be based solely on general Investigation Wing reports, ITAT held that the reassessment was founded on borrowed satisfaction. Absence of tangible material, non-furnishing of Investigation Wing report to Assessee & failure to conduct inquiry rendered the reopening invalid. Accordingly, ITAT quashed reassessment proceedings, allowed Assessee’s appeal, & dismissed Revenue’s appeal as infructuous.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.




