Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Corporate Law

Audit Objection Cannot Reopen Assessment on Issues Already Examined by AO: Bombay HC

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2026 taxguru.in 14589
Case Name
Asian Paints Ltd. Vs ACIT (Bombay High Court)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Asian Paints Ltd. Vs ACIT (Bombay High Court)

Summary: Bombay High Court quashed reassessment proceedings initiated against Asian Paints Ltd. for AY 2017-18, holding that the exercise was founded on an impermissible change of opinion and lacked new tangible material. The original assessment had been completed under Section 143(3) after detailed queries and replies concerning depreciation on computers and computer software, Section 80G deduction relating to CSR expenditure, depreciation on goodwill, short provision towards discount and additional depreciation on plant and machinery.

Subsequently, a Section 148 notice was issued on 27 March 2021 based substantially on audit objections. Applying the Supreme Court ruling in CIT v. Kelvinator of India Ltd. and Bombay High Court precedent in Aroni Commercials Ltd. v. DCIT, the Court reiterated that the AO has power to reassess but not to review a concluded assessment. Once a query is raised during original assessment and answered by the assessee, the issue must be regarded as having been considered even if the final assessment order contains no discussion about it. The Court examined all six recorded reasons separately and found that they either concerned matters specifically examined during original assessment or were contrary to the applicable statutory provisions.

It further held that audit objections expressing an opinion on matters already examined by the AO could not constitute tangible material permitting the AO to alter his earlier opinion. The Court accordingly quashed the Section 148 notice dated 27 March 2021 and the order dated 16 February 2022 rejecting Asian Paints’ objections, and made the Rule absolute without costs.

Cases Discussed

  • SLP arising from Castrol India Ltd., (2025) 173 taxmann.com 686 (Supreme Court) — The source records that the special leave petition against the Bombay High Court decision in Castrol India Ltd. was dismissed.
  • Castrol India Ltd. v. DCIT, (2024) 161 taxmann.com 75 (Bombay High Court) — Relied upon in support of the proposition that reopening based on audit objections concerning issues already examined in the original assessment cannot be sustained where it merely results in a change of opinion.
  • CIT v. Jet Speed Audio Pvt. Ltd., 372 ITR 762 (Bombay High Court) — Relied upon for the requirement of tangible material and for the legal position concerning the observations in Kalyanji Mavji & Co. after the Supreme Court decision in Indian and Eastern Newspaper Society.
  • Export Credit Guarantee Corporation of India Ltd. v. Additional Commissioner of Income-tax, 350 ITR 651 (Bombay High Court) — Relied upon by Revenue and distinguished. The Court accepted that tangible material need not necessarily be new where relevant material was plainly ignored, but found the decision inapplicable because the disputed issues in the present case had actually been examined during the original assessment.
  • Direct Information P. Ltd. v. ITO, 349 ITR 150 (Bombay High Court) — Relied upon while dealing with depreciation on goodwill and recurring claims. The Court referred to the principle that where entitlement has been examined in the initial year, a recurring consequential claim cannot ordinarily be disturbed in a subsequent year without validly disturbing the underlying entitlement.
  • CIT v. Usha International Ltd., 348 ITR 485 (Delhi High Court, Full Bench) — Relied upon for the principles governing change of opinion. The Full Bench held, inter alia, that where a query was raised and answered during the original assessment but no addition was ultimately made, the Assessing Officer is regarded as having formed an opinion on the issue.
  • Aroni Commercials Ltd. v. DCIT, 362 ITR 402 (Bombay High Court) — Relied upon and followed for the proposition that once a query has been raised during assessment and answered by the assessee, the issue is treated as having been considered by the Assessing Officer even if the assessment order does not expressly discuss it.
  • CIT v. Kelvinator of India Ltd., 320 ITR 561 (Supreme Court) — Relied upon and followed for the distinction between reassessment and review and for the principle that reopening cannot be based upon a mere change of opinion and requires tangible material having a live link with formation of the belief of escapement of income.
  • Consolidated Photo & Finvest Ltd. v. ACIT, 281 ITR 394 (Delhi High Court) — Relied upon by Revenue, but the Court noted that the relevant observations had subsequently been disapproved by the Full Bench of the Delhi High Court in Usha International Ltd.
  • Rajesh Jhaveri Stock Brokers (P.) Ltd. (Supreme Court) — Referred to in the passage reproduced from Usha International Ltd. while explaining the reassessment principles applicable where a return has merely been processed under Section 143(1).
  • KLM Royal Dutch Airlines v. ACIT, [2007] 292 ITR 49 / 159 Taxman 191 (Delhi High Court) — Referred to through the Full Bench decision in Usha International Ltd.. The reproduced passage records that the Full Bench did not express approval or disapproval of the other issues dealt with in that decision.
  • CIT v. Paul Bros., [1995] 216 ITR 548 / 79 Taxman 378 (Bombay High Court) — Referred to in the passage from Direct Information P. Ltd. as following the principle stated by the Gujarat High Court in Saurashtra Cement & Chemical Industries Ltd.
  • Saurashtra Cement & Chemical Industries Ltd. v. CIT, [1980] 123 ITR 669 (Gujarat High Court) — Referred to for the principle that relief granted in the initial year cannot ordinarily be withheld in a subsequent year without first disturbing the relief granted in the initial year on valid grounds.
  • Indian and Eastern Newspaper Society v. CIT, 119 ITR 996 (Supreme Court) — Relied upon for holding that the relevant observations in Kalyanji Mavji & Co., concerning escapement resulting from oversight, inadvertence or mistake, did not lay down the correct law.
  • Kalyanji Mavji & Co. v. CIT, 102 ITR 287 (Supreme Court) — Relied upon by Revenue. The Court held that the particular observations invoked by Revenue did not represent the correct legal position in view of the subsequent Supreme Court ruling in Indian and Eastern Newspaper Society.

FULL TEXT OF THE JUDGMENT/ORDER OF BOMBAY HIGH COURT

Want to Read the Complete Judgment?

You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.

Read on with Premium
Goes straight to payment. GST invoice included.

One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.

Advertisement

Author Info

CA Sandeep Kanoi
Qualification: Graduate, CA in Job / Business, DD
Company: Taxguru Consultancy
Location: Mumbai, Maharashtra
Articles Published: 24,562

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.